how can a vid like this get 17 dislikes ??? this song is perfect is the song im a ianist songwriter and singer and is this song i sing when i want to remember who im and why im living my life for music
okay so i am a HUGE fan of my chemical romance, and i heard Gerard (the singer) was really into the Dresden Dolls and he said it was a basically a woman who sang and played piano and a drummer, and i sing and play the piano so that really got me interested so this is the 3rd song i have listened to by them and im really impressed i like them i think i am going to listen to more haha
I usually have to be in a certain kind of mood for a song to make me cry, especially the first time I hear it. The first time I heard this song was just now. I was in a perfectly normal mood, eating breakfast and watching youtube videos. Then I listened to this. Now I'm crying into my cereal. In a good way though!
lol, paused the video so I could get the url and download the mp3 so I'm not doing too many things at once, and I totally got a good facial expression of Amanda at 2:35. xD
I am a fan of both MCR and Dresden Dolls. Dude, these are two completely different songs that happen to have the same title. It's not like singing is an obscure thing to sing about.
There's no way to say whether or not MCR, or any other band, stole lyrics from The Dresden Dolls. Unless you ask My Chem directly, you can't know definitely. So quit spreading rumors. Personally, I can't see MCR stealing anyone else's lyrics. That seems really out of character for them. But that's my opinion. What's done is done, so... Just enjoy the songs, 'kay? Both are amazing.
@strangeling354 I think it's unecessary for my chemical romance to blatantly steal the ideas of a GREAT song by the dresden dolls. They even used the same song title.
@strangeling354 what ever FUCK MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE!!! some one should go to their show and toss a razor blade up on stage and a note that says "JUST DO IT! SEVER THE VAIN!! YOU PUSSY!! YOU KEEP MISSING IT!! THOSE SCRATCHES AINT GONNA DO NOTHING!!"
@MechNIN I know the lyrics and both are also a little like the chores for Sing For The Moment by Eminem. But we have our opinions I guess. The only way for anyone to really know is to ask MCR themselves.
@IdiotsForObamaCom Why wouldn't you sing for someone who lacks the freedom of thought you so clearly have? Someone who has been so brainwashed by the lack of freedom in their homeland that they don't really have a choice?
xand- that "idiotsforobama" is an imposter, not me. I have several of them and all they do is use my name, advertise for me and create more traffic to my site. I have no idea who the Dresden Dolls are
you have to respect talent, simple as that. The dolls and Amanda Palmer herself have a thoughtful energy that few others seem to have. Long may her light shine in a sea of darkness.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't know whats more impressive, her tattooed eyebrows or those pearly white cock scratchers. Either way, they'd both look better covered with my semen
*person who was deeply moved by this song* Hey, dude, you gotta listen to this song! It's so amazing!....*person* WTF is this and who the hell are you? Why are you giving me a letter? POLICE!
This song is what lets me wakeup most mornings. Thank God she's free of Roadrunner. you can't cage that kind of beauty. And Brian and her got to hang out recently. I'm so happy for them. I hope to one day hear a new Dolls record.
@rockboy12346 Amanda Palmer is currently working on a collaborative project with singer/songwriter Jason Webley called Evelyn Evelyn, it's like this, but even more subversive.
I wish someone would do a fucking flash mob with this song instead of the songs that only have a fraction of the soul this one has. -sigh- Either way, I get chills with song every time I hear/sing it <3
how can a vid like this get 17 dislikes ??? this song is perfect is the song im a ianist songwriter and singer and is this song i sing when i want to remember who im and why im living my life for music
Lylahkirina 2 weeks ago
There is this thing that's like touching except you don't touch
LOLimmy123 2 weeks ago
I love her hair in this video. It's too short now.
69kumquat 2 weeks ago
sound is goosed on this......:(
Erbgrinder 3 weeks ago
LIFE IS NO CABARET.
kissyaaaaah 1 month ago
this is one song that will NEVER leave my ipod!
KaryK96 1 month ago
They've muted Amanda's swearing! Fucking hell! Motherfucking roadrunner
JackieTheCaveman 2 months ago 3
i love Amanda! xD
mastiloko 3 months ago
This song always makes me feel better.
SaryWalrus 3 months ago
Seriously, the build up. Phenomenal.
sneekz07 3 months ago
This song has just shot itself into my Top 10 favourites.
rhiskisnoir 3 months ago
how do rap songs get to swear as much as they want but a well placed swear word here get blurred, makes no fuckin sense
blazia6 4 months ago in playlist blazia6's favorites 12
@blazia6 Do you live in NA? any good R&B/rap/rock/bluegrass song WILL get bleeped if they swear.... idiot.
69iambecomedeath89 1 week ago
@blazia6 You're listening to the wrong rap song, yo!
DarkShadowMegadeth 4 days ago
okay so i am a HUGE fan of my chemical romance, and i heard Gerard (the singer) was really into the Dresden Dolls and he said it was a basically a woman who sang and played piano and a drummer, and i sing and play the piano so that really got me interested so this is the 3rd song i have listened to by them and im really impressed i like them i think i am going to listen to more haha
strawberryfrazel 4 months ago 6
@strawberryfrazel i also have to thank Gerard for bringing me to them! :D great great great :)))
sparkleMusic13 1 month ago
Siiiinnnngg!!!!
CrOssdone 4 months ago
The white statues remind anyone else of BioShock?
dhicks3 4 months ago
I DEDICATE TO OCCUPY! WE ARE FINALLY SINGING!
psychokillercrab 4 months ago in playlist mm
I usually have to be in a certain kind of mood for a song to make me cry, especially the first time I hear it. The first time I heard this song was just now. I was in a perfectly normal mood, eating breakfast and watching youtube videos. Then I listened to this. Now I'm crying into my cereal. In a good way though!
ryeguy48 4 months ago 2
I watched a young girl 16 or below just get arrested in NY..at the wall street protest...As I watched I thought of this song....
BAXT1975 5 months ago 2
Jacks Mannequin totally ripped off this song
stinknus 6 months ago
@stinknus how so
KadajusFunToy 5 months ago
so softspoken at the beginning. makes you pay attention.
bloody fantastic.
spotlessmindofmine 6 months ago
sing some fuckin'SLAYERRRRRRRR!!!!! hahaha
pentumplementgum 7 months ago
@pentumplementgum RAINING BLOOOOD!!! hahaha
200timwhite 6 months ago
Some of the most gorgeous, anthemic, heartwarming music ever.
Johnny123456789x 7 months ago
Boy, I sure do love censorship. Motherfuckers.
OfNumbersAndStrings 7 months ago 2
lol, paused the video so I could get the url and download the mp3 so I'm not doing too many things at once, and I totally got a good facial expression of Amanda at 2:35. xD
Sploggez 7 months ago
@Sploggez AHAHAHAHAHAHAH!
ilovefluffysheep 6 months ago
@Sploggez Buy the fucking album.
gardenguyvic 6 months ago
@gardenguyvic Why should I? I don't like many dresden doll songs, so it would be a waste of money.
Sploggez 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Sploggez you can get it at any price you want on Bandcamp, including for free
oldieXP 5 months ago
God Amanda is my inspiration! Again another fabulous piece of art. :) Thank you Amanda Palmer.
Sangoluvah5 8 months ago
This song is so beautiful, I started crying when I listened to it.
koryfail 8 months ago
The 16 dislikes were from people afraid to sing...
hounahou 8 months ago 34
@hounahou nah im sure its because they just cant sing :)
MrsTakumi 3 weeks ago
I am a fan of both MCR and Dresden Dolls. Dude, these are two completely different songs that happen to have the same title. It's not like singing is an obscure thing to sing about.
violetheatherbrown 8 months ago 4
@violetheatherbrown
funny story gerard's a dredsen dolls fan :LL
i like both vers :3
InvaderSkat 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There's no way to say whether or not MCR, or any other band, stole lyrics from The Dresden Dolls. Unless you ask My Chem directly, you can't know definitely. So quit spreading rumors. Personally, I can't see MCR stealing anyone else's lyrics. That seems really out of character for them. But that's my opinion. What's done is done, so... Just enjoy the songs, 'kay? Both are amazing.
BananaButterPickles 9 months ago
Comment removed
BananaButterPickles 9 months ago
Oh great MCR, I don't even like this song I think its really cheesy but for MCR to do a rendition of this makes me *facepalm
alotofcheese76 9 months ago
if mcr did 'steal' this song..i actually prefer mcr's version tbf..
bumblebee6074 9 months ago
to the 13 people who couldn't appreciate singing - i'd appreciate it if you'd shut the eff up.
milolovepie 9 months ago
Sing for my chemical romance raping the ideas of DD.
God I hate that band
MechNIN 10 months ago
@MechNIN that was unnecessary, bro :/ please don't use the comments section on a music video to criticize another band.
strangeling354 10 months ago 3
@strangeling354 I think it's unecessary for my chemical romance to blatantly steal the ideas of a GREAT song by the dresden dolls. They even used the same song title.
MechNIN 10 months ago
@strangeling354 what ever FUCK MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE!!! some one should go to their show and toss a razor blade up on stage and a note that says "JUST DO IT! SEVER THE VAIN!! YOU PUSSY!! YOU KEEP MISSING IT!! THOSE SCRATCHES AINT GONNA DO NOTHING!!"
MentalRecluse 10 months ago
@MentalRecluse dude, not cool. self harm jokes are never funny. that's such a cheap shot, you're letting the rest of dresden doll's fanbase down :/
strangeling354 10 months ago 4
@strangeling354 DUDE! YOU'RE RIGHT! I'M NOT COOL!!! CAUSE ALL MY COMMENTS ARE SHIT!!! so...I let fellow fans down .... 0.o Oh well?
MentalRecluse 10 months ago
@MentalRecluse Not cool.
PyroPrincess33 6 months ago
@PyroPrincess33 oh well.
MentalRecluse 6 months ago
@MechNIN Not looking to fight or whatever... I love DD and MCR.... But MCR hasn't stole anyones ideas
MCRisSOawesome 9 months ago
@MCRisSOawesome look at the lyrics of "sing" by both bands.
MechNIN 9 months ago
@MechNIN I know the lyrics and both are also a little like the chores for Sing For The Moment by Eminem. But we have our opinions I guess. The only way for anyone to really know is to ask MCR themselves.
MCRisSOawesome 9 months ago
@MCRisSOawesome agreed they didnt steal anything the lyrics music and style is different idk y ppl think they stole it both are good songs
NightWalker6690 8 months ago
Chills.
12akay 10 months ago
Love the song but still wont sing for the terrorist....Love the whistling of a bommb dropping on them..
IdiotsForObamaCom 10 months ago
@IdiotsForObamaCom Why wouldn't you sing for someone who lacks the freedom of thought you so clearly have? Someone who has been so brainwashed by the lack of freedom in their homeland that they don't really have a choice?
xandriathegreat 10 months ago
xand- that "idiotsforobama" is an imposter, not me. I have several of them and all they do is use my name, advertise for me and create more traffic to my site. I have no idea who the Dresden Dolls are
IdiotsForObamaCom 10 months ago
Twelve people are too busy playing with their phones to sing.
musicmydrugmrm 11 months ago 2
you have to respect talent, simple as that. The dolls and Amanda Palmer herself have a thoughtful energy that few others seem to have. Long may her light shine in a sea of darkness.
djchester10 11 months ago 3
ONE OF A KIND!LOVE HER & LOVE THE FUKING DRESDEN DOLLS!!
KrazyLu23 11 months ago
Sing for the APACHE helicopters who dont let the fuckin terrorist sing
ThePete65 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sing it for the boys, sing it for the girls, everytime that you lose it, sing it for the world. My chemical romance sing is better.
AgentJ11191998 1 year ago
@AgentJ11191998 mcr's sing is just a carbon copy of this song !
xXemosrockhardXx 1 year ago
@xXemosrockhardXx thank you
MechNIN 10 months ago
@AgentJ11191998 Wrong. I'm an MCR fan to the bone, but the two are completely different. and DD will always be better.
deadlylilee 1 year ago 5
Absolutely amazing message...
You can be who you want to be and express yourself however the fuck you want..
If anyone tells you other wise prove them wrong and shove it in their face.
Amanda Palmer is truly an inspiration <3
jennyyouwho 1 year ago
God, I can't watch this without crying! <3
ellie050394 1 year ago 4
@ellie050394 Wow, really? You must be a fucking mess. Would a mouth full of hot semen soup help?
It's Mmm Mmm Good.
rednoseroxy 1 year ago
@rednoseroxy
Funnily enough, no. No, that would not help. :s
ellie050394 1 year ago
desperatly in love with a.p.
cybercutealicious 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't know whats more impressive, her tattooed eyebrows or those pearly white cock scratchers. Either way, they'd both look better covered with my semen
rednoseroxy 1 year ago
@rednoseroxy
Her eyebrows are drawn on with liquid eyeliner, not tattooed on.
ellie050394 1 year ago 2
@rednoseroxy ewwwwww
binabear128 1 year ago
You motherfuckers, you'll sing someday.
xmisogyny 1 year ago 56
i love brian's last tom hit at the end, POP!
toribjork10 1 year ago 2
@pikajace yeah, but it's really really similar in theme and lyrcs. it's safe to say he was, ahem, "influenced" by the dolls' song...
toribjork10 1 year ago
I love the dresdon dolls but this song is beautiful nd deep. This video brings tears to your eyes. incredibly moving
PeaceLoveCassie 1 year ago
I like her "Kurt Weil" keyboard
whsonic 1 year ago
*person who was deeply moved by this song* Hey, dude, you gotta listen to this song! It's so amazing!....*person* WTF is this and who the hell are you? Why are you giving me a letter? POLICE!
doodleyyy 1 year ago
Isn't censoring the song doing exactly what the song is trying to get people not to do?
thenyctomancer 1 year ago 2
11 people refuse to sing
Goot2Boot 1 year ago 12
I love the flowers. :)
StrawberryGash 1 year ago
Great song!!!!
karinight01 1 year ago
@pikajace
Yes, MCR didn't really steal the idea, maybe they were inspired by it and put their new style on it. :) I love this song :D
WeBelongInTheSea 1 year ago
@WeBelongInTheSea Yes, it's true. Gerard Way is a serious fan of The Dresden Dolls.
Kalvet 1 year ago
I love her eyebrows lol. Well What she does.
123456789rs 1 year ago
the song is nice and all but I really can't dig the aesthetic of the eyebrow thing. I find it kinda repulsive.
piston22 1 year ago
man, I would hate to be the naked one! XD
Love this.Love Amanda.Love Brian.Love The Dresden Dolls.
MeggieMoodle1 1 year ago
brilliant!
mastiloko 1 year ago
god, this song brings tears to my eyes...
d34d23 1 year ago
Sing for the number of people who dislike this vid. Just sing.
captison 1 year ago
sing bitch
mbravo00 1 year ago
wow!!!!!
tect777 1 year ago
@yamara34 @dfishie mine too!!!
raysc0089 1 year ago
the scene with the statues reminds me of a scene in bioshock with the frozen dead people
shiphotel2 1 year ago 3
@dfishie Katherine F
yamara34 1 year ago
i like how amanda has pit hair n brian doesnt
punkkidbubbles 1 year ago 3
One world...... love, peace, empathy
RosaElefant82 1 year ago
my friend's in this video
yamara34 1 year ago
@yamara34 Mine too!
dfishie 1 year ago
Brian I love your drumming!!!!!!
embrassemoi04 1 year ago
Never heard of this band. A hell of a kind of Smashing Pumpkins-sounding duo! Fucking love it!
goenaeker666 1 year ago
Hey Whitney!
~Sumberg
lredelman 1 year ago
They bleeped out the bad word ha!
KristinKellyrose 1 year ago
"These is this thing like fucking except you don't touch". :) Good song.
blewj 1 year ago 3
Amanda Palmer is amazing! I love this song, it's so fucking good.
hauntedlyza 1 year ago
I find her magnificent! Voice, looks, and songwriting abilities.
lhiannon82 1 year ago
This song doesn't just make me want to sing; it makes me want to force my soul out via my throat. It doesn't get much better than this.
featheredskyblue 1 year ago 37
Beautiful lyrics. She's evilcute btw. hatewheel approves.
hatewheel 1 year ago
Comment removed
muhmuhmuhmonsterr 1 year ago
This is my favorite song in the world! AFP!!!
muhmuhmuhmonsterr 1 year ago
AMANDA FUCKING PALMER!
iLOVEthe80TWILIGHT13 1 year ago
My girlfriend likes this group. To me though, it's kinda meloncholy. I'm not raggin' on em thouhg, just giving my opinion. 1st amendment.
RockonDude92 1 year ago 2
I love that you can see that her nail polish is only still half on in the beginning.
RebeletteRose 1 year ago
thank god she's not with roadrunner records :DDD
twoyogurtpretzels 1 year ago
im in this!!!! i love u guys
JudyBallantine 1 year ago
What a beautiful song.
It would be awesome if Amanda and Brian got together again and released another record as the Dolls.
FlyingRedwood 1 year ago
dig the band but not the sexist asshole record company.
AFP for president ;)
insertafeckingname 1 year ago
This song is what lets me wakeup most mornings. Thank God she's free of Roadrunner. you can't cage that kind of beauty. And Brian and her got to hang out recently. I'm so happy for them. I hope to one day hear a new Dolls record.
dorion911217 1 year ago
@dorion911217 omg i thought brian and amanda split
66PixieOfDeath6 1 year ago
@66PixieOfDeath6 They did...sorta. But, the dynamic duo is back!!!! w00t w00t
takealookatme 1 year ago
Inspiring band!....it´s like a sudden flow of "something that I did not know yet" ....damn...and I KNEW them....hehehe...
santnamor2013 1 year ago 2
this makes me happy inside. :D
AnnieLives 1 year ago 2
I will meet her. Whenever. However. Whatever it takes. She's done so much for me.
waerfeles 1 year ago
Holy hell! I can't believe I'm just hearing about this band!! This was incredible!!! Instant Fan!!
gdbass 1 year ago
this video was posted on my birthday! lol
MsRagdoll14 1 year ago
Censors can lick my left nut! It's destroying art!
OceanicCactus 1 year ago 4
sing for the people who told you you can't sing
OpakeArawra2 2 years ago 7
I fucking love this song. I fucking love this band. I fucking love Amanda.
immaeighteen 2 years ago 103
@immaeighteen it's to fucking bad the band stopped!
rockboy12346 2 years ago
@rockboy12346 Amanda Palmer is currently working on a collaborative project with singer/songwriter Jason Webley called Evelyn Evelyn, it's like this, but even more subversive.
StevenLoos 2 years ago
i knew this still sad dresden dolls aren't together i really liked them.
april 28 evelyn evelyn is performing at Amsterdam my sister is going there.:P
rockboy12346 2 years ago
YOUR SISTER IS A LUCKY BITCH
If they perform in Michigan, I'm so going. I've loved Jason Webley for even longer than I've loved the Dresden Dolls, so him + APG = EPIC WIN
StevenLoos 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
YOUR SISTER IS A LUCKY BITCH
If they perform in Michigan, I'm so going. I've loved Jason Webley for even longer than I've loved the Dresden Dolls, so him + AFP = EPIC WIN
StevenLoos 2 years ago
@immaeighteen i would vote zilion thumbs up on this if i could :D
ardous 1 year ago
@immaeighteen I fucking agree!
twistedtick 11 months ago
@immaeighteen Fuck yeah
Lhene9 10 months ago
I wish someone would do a fucking flash mob with this song instead of the songs that only have a fraction of the soul this one has. -sigh- Either way, I get chills with song every time I hear/sing it <3
VivaLaHorror 2 years ago 2
@VivaLaHorror do it :)
ApocIndustries 1 year ago
Sing for the fucking record company who refuses to sing.
lilyampersand 2 years ago 129
@lilyampersand I think this is the best comment I have ever read on you tube, cheers to you!
psychokillercrab 1 year ago
one of my favorite songs
MFHshow 2 years ago
why can't roadrunner growup and realize that limitation is NOT the key to the future?
no embedding, oh that makes sense...
monkeyrocketsurgeon 2 years ago
sing for the children shooting the children, sing.
stardigan5 2 years ago
C'est laid.
Mexanne 2 years ago
@Mexanne C'est tres belle.
kremer08 2 years ago
more like c'est fucking awesome
OpakeArawra2 2 years ago 5
=) ....
Awesome415 2 years ago
sing
onlythebestguitars 2 years ago