Added: 3 years ago
From: carollaw21
Views: 14,318
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (88)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Im sorry but....

    a) Matt Smith failed at living up to Tennant

    b) Martha was rubbish- she was a wannabe Rose. Amy is also rubbish-treats Rory terribly & is the reason the Doctor is in trouble 97% of the time.

    c) Rose was his love, & his equal- she was brilliant & kept him in check. Donna was hilarious & understood that he missed Rose terribly and also kept him in check. Jack was well Jack

    The show became predictable & not as good after David Tennant, Julie Gardner & Russel T Davies left.

  • I LOVE DAVID TENNANT!!!

    Nice video!:)

  • Nice song to go w/David! :)Fits him jusr right.

    11th doctor is good and kinda funny at times but 10 is WAY WAY better :)....just sayin' :)

  • The amount of passion that David Tennant put into his time as the Doctor simply can't be tooped. I like Eleven,but I still miss Ten....

  • who is the author of the song?

  • i cant believe 3 people didnt like thius! lunatics

  • I watch it almost everyday. I love it, it's just perfect! Thank you for making this :)

  • This was an amazing vid! Thanks for putting it together for those of us who are not thechno inclined.

  • Still my favorite Doctor Who fan vid which is really saying a lot :) Fantastic in every way; I love David Tennant and miss him. Went and bought the song too bc i found myself singing it over and over again.

  • I'm always wondering about Doctor and his cruel way of life. This video with the music come to my heart and sing me about it very clearly. Davies had created something more than fictional character of old english show, isn't he? And Rose was just more than a companion. Eccleston, Tennant, Piper, Tate lived on screen. And it was so stunning that I fell in love with show. People are creative and that so gorgeous. That why I watched it and write it now. Thank you for video ;)

  • What is the episode that the clip at 1:37 - 1:40? Thanks!

  • @Whovian93 That is from the beginning of "Army of Ghosts"

  • @Whovian93 i've seen every episode of doctor who ever made, ask me anything.

  • @13doctorwho okay, on the very first doctor who episode, what creature was trying to kill, the doctor, and his grand daughter, and the 2 humans he had with him.

  • @nisteven haaha. I think whovian93 just went to tardis wiki.

  • Comment removed

  • Oooooooh, Whumpy! Loved it!

  • it was good

  • "It's not on purpose, in the darkness" Where in the series did Dona say that again?

  • @ToudaHell Donna doesn't say that. That line was said by the plasmavore from Season 3 episode 1 "Smith and Jones"

  • @carollaw21 thanks

  • @ToudaHell and the line is "and yet i think, laughing on perpose. At the darkness"

  • @ToudaHell And it's: 'But I think, laughing on purpose, at the darkness'

  • Comment removed

  • Holy hell that was amazing!!! really really fantastic!  it brought into focus all the reasons David Tennant will always be my Doctor. For all time. Thank you so much for posting!

  • Fab vid... very intense.. very Tenth Doctor!

    *applauds* thanks for sharing it!

  • Loved this, especially the bits where The Doctor and Rose were holding out their hands to the camera. Found it hard, however, to hear soem quotes during.

  • Well done! Good song and great clips you chose as well.

  • aw, this was so good! i love david tennant, im gonna miss him so much! Great video, tho, loved it!

  • That was fantastic! I'm really going to miss him as the Doctor. 11 has a lot to live up to!

  • yes, yes he does. i will soooo miss david but i'm also almost looking forward to the new guy. just to see what happens..... i guess i'll find out tonight at 8:30.

  • I love this video. What eps is at 1:13 seconds? I haven't seen all the TEN eps yet.

  • it's the "Runaway Bride", Christmas special before the third season

  • Thanks! Can't wait to get the DVDs with this special on it. I have series 2 and 4.

    Allons-y!

    stlouisphile

  • This song is perfect

  • Fantastic video. The song fits perfectly.

  • i so lvoe thsi video it so cool and so sweet

  • That was fantastic! You hit just the right note with those quotes and clips, and used very few special effects to do so. Nice job. :)

  • Wow, this video is the best!!!

    Tennant really had to go through a lot to be the Doctor. I hope the new guy is up for the roll.

  • Seriously. This new guy has some HUGE shoes to fill. lol.

  • (Insert inappropriate joke about ten inches here.) lol

  • This video is awesome!! The song just fits so perfectly!!

  • oh i love this sooo so much. thank you for making this, it is heartbreaking....and if you really think about it...The Doctor's life, despite all the wonderful and good things, is ultimately a tragedy.

  • meh. its not that bad. besides the battling of daleks and traveling the universe I have a pretty similar attitude. I like keeping people at a distance and not getting attached but unfortunately there are the few exceptions that get to me cause theyre no longer here. lol. I dont even know you and i've just done something that would cost me £100 in a psychiatric office

  • You know what's beautiful. At 1.55 (and afterwards) Rose reaches out to the doctor.

    As if she wants him to grab her hand.

    And it's like at 2.00 the doctor TRIES to do that, but he's falling.

  • This video is fantastic, much better than anything I've ever done. Keep it up!

  • Wow, I loved this. I was never reminded of the Doctor when I listened to this song on its own, but with your video it makes perfect sense. And I loved your idea of the Doctor having lost that idea of "home" for good when he lost Rose(at least that how I interpret it).

  • Beautiful vid. The song fits perfectly!

    But if you don't mind, that clip of the planet being burned from 2:03 to 2:05, what eppy is that from?

  • That clip is from Season 1 Episode 2 "The End of the World" near the end.

  • 5 Stars!!!!! That was awesome!

  • It was beautiful, I loved it.

    *tries to stop crying*

    Ah, the song just fits perfectly.

  • So love your video !!!!!

  • Wow, I've just revisited this video with the intent of asking just what Chemicals and Romance asked. Would I be able to have a copy of this to watch on my mp3 player please? If it's not too much trouble that is. =3 The video is just that fantastic.

  • I'm glad you like my video, but I can't send it to you. I'm sorry.

  • Back again, sorry. You've got me hooked on this song and I was just wondering if you would be able/ willing send it to me? If not that's absolutely fine, just thought it'd be worth asking.

    And I didn't say it last time, but I love the flip effect you used at about 1:49, it's really nice and the clips from Doomsday and The Stolen Earth are just beautiful.

  • I'm glad you like my video, but I can't send it to you. I'm sorry.

  • That's fine, I thought so, most people don't send out their songs but you can't blame me for asking, well you can but I'd rather if you didnt :$. Doesn't matter, I'll scrounge around for the song somewhere, can't be that hard to find. Thanks anyhow =D

  • This is an amazing video! You got all the emotional scenes and it definitely fit the Doctor. Fantastic!

  • Brilliant, amazing! Just wonderful, really. The song and the clips worked really well together and you chose such great clips. I really like that bit at the end too, between him and Donna, it's a great line and it's so true. He always says he's alright but you can see in his eyes, it's never quite true.

    I love this video, I really do. Thank you for making it!

  • Gosh I want to cry. Doctor, I am so sorry. Genius video. The song is perfect :)

  • This was BRILLIANT! XD The audio, song and the Doctor's expressions mixing together were very good, and I love the beginning with Donna asking him if he was alright! I think you've done a wonderful job of showing the wounds the Doctor has endured, and how much some of it is still only slowly healing! (ooh.. saying that makes me feel so sorry for the Doctor.. T.T) The end.. ooh.. knowing the finale of season 4, it gives me the chills hearing Donna say that! Good job!! :D :D :D

  • brilliant aditing luv the end :)

  • great job =D

  • i love this video :D

  • I love this vid it so fits the doctor !!!

  • i love this video it so cool and sweet

  • wow... incredible. one of the best dr who vids ive seen!

    please make more!

  • Fantastic - this must have taken you a looong time to make.

    Seeing this made me miss regular Doctor Who Saturdays even more than I already do!

  • WOW! that was the best!!

  • omg i love it!!!!! that was so good, and different to a lot of other videos ive seen it was a breath of fresh Doctor who. =D

    thanks!

  • i did think the beginning and end could have used a bit more polish (ie: letting the doctor say "I'm always alright" before laying over the music and other footage, and ending with donna's question rather than answer in order to keep the focus on the doctor). I also didn't find all the soundclips to be audible or necessary but, hey, it is still definitely a fave for sure! :) *runs off to find more from you*

  • nicely done! absolutely BRILLIANT song choice as you so effectively demonstrated. i really did tear up for our "lonely angel". loved the connections to the tardis and earth and rose as his "home" now (the overlay at 1:05 was gorgeous) and all the clips of him noticeably breathing and in pain for the refrain.

  • wow. this was...brilliant. sheer brilliance at work here. The music, the scenes...everything just came together so perfectly...you are truly talented!! What a work of art!! Thank you so much for making this!

  • This vid makes me cry. Sadly, we know is far than all right.

    I think if I will be through all He has been I won't be all right too, so we can't blame him to be sad, and we can't blame him to pretend he's all right, we all do when we are sad... Sometimes he's really acting like a human! :S.. And David's acting just make it priceless!

  • still by far my most favortie scene of the entire series

  • Wonderful! Loved it! Instant fav!

  • possibly the best song choice ever for the doctor. and your editing is brilliant, very few people can use wmm (correct me if I'm wrong and you don't use that) and honestly produce a video just as good as or better than those with more advanced software, which is a testament to your editing. favourite :)

  • Wow! thanks for all the kind comments. I'm glad you like this video! :)

  • great use of clips! you sum it up perfectly for the doctor in this. love the song choice, as well.

  • Great use of the song and sound bites! Great work. 5*

  • I'm not kidding when I say that I am crying my eyes out Lol. Absolutely Fantastic! 5/5 and faved

  • EeeeeXCEeeLLEeeeeeNT.

  • Wow really well done, love the choice of song it fitted perfectly! Nicely edited!!

  • Really well done! I thought the song was AMAZING for the Doctor... as he is 'always alright' with so much pain and loss lying just under the surface. Brilliant. xx

  • this is so good!!

  • Again, you have done an awesome video. Put this one in my favorites and keep up the GREAT work.

  • I love this video! I find it funny that the song in the video was originally done by Melissa Etheridge! Lol!

  • THAT WAS AMAZING! I think I just cried.

  • That was great, 5 stars!

  • Wow, wonderful and powerful. I love it!

  • Wahou!!!

    Your videos are mazing!

    Well Done!

  • Love this vid!! Can't quite understand some of the dialogue you've added in though.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more