I read a lot of negativity toward this album, from fans, critics and the band members themselves. But I would just like to say, this album is very moving. I almost cried listening to this album. I love how it feels like a post script to The Wall. I love The Final Cut.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It wasn't the high command that took his daddy from him, it was the Germans! Roger Waters is a pathetic liberal and communist sympathizer but a great musician.
@jokersgotu If you read about the battle of Anzio the people who planned it made it a suicide mission. The infantry went in with little tank support or air support and tried to hold off a force that outnumbered them greatly and possessed many tiger tanks. When the commander realized this he asked to withdraw but they told him to sit tight. I mean 44,000 men sustained casualties because someone made a change in plans. It makes a great war story none the least.
As a veteran from a staged war, this really cuts down to the bone. We're never going to learn. We need to stand fucking face to face with our ruling elite and absolutely crush their skulls in. They started both world wars and they will be soaked in their own blood. I hate them and if anything is organised to find them....count me in.
@Dicedrum Utterly pretentious and self indulgent shit in my view.All about folk tales and theatrical sound effects.Very little to do with music at all
Well said, TheXenomorph1980. I couldn`t agree more.
ManFromMelbourne 2 months ago
I read a lot of negativity toward this album, from fans, critics and the band members themselves. But I would just like to say, this album is very moving. I almost cried listening to this album. I love how it feels like a post script to The Wall. I love The Final Cut.
jfitz1431 3 months ago
my favourite album!
niketmik 3 months ago
Wow, reading the history behind this song makes it a lot more powerful.
lronPriest0fMetal 4 months ago
this number is to in the wall
pinkfloydthewallfan 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It wasn't the high command that took his daddy from him, it was the Germans! Roger Waters is a pathetic liberal and communist sympathizer but a great musician.
jokersgotu 1 year ago
@jokersgotu If you read about the battle of Anzio the people who planned it made it a suicide mission. The infantry went in with little tank support or air support and tried to hold off a force that outnumbered them greatly and possessed many tiger tanks. When the commander realized this he asked to withdraw but they told him to sit tight. I mean 44,000 men sustained casualties because someone made a change in plans. It makes a great war story none the least.
Grunts4Hire 10 months ago 4
@jokersgotu and who do you think funded the germans and hitler? Only those of the high command.
katoness 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Does Richard Wright play on this?
scottbuster2000 1 year ago
10 that gave thumb up are really Pink Foyd fans
hamsteradorable 1 year ago
the orginal single version is better this sounds a bit close to the echoes version except the echoes version doesent have the drum roll
kingsergio128 1 year ago
As a veteran from a staged war, this really cuts down to the bone. We're never going to learn. We need to stand fucking face to face with our ruling elite and absolutely crush their skulls in. They started both world wars and they will be soaked in their own blood. I hate them and if anything is organised to find them....count me in.
TheXenomorph1980 1 year ago 10
@TheXenomorph1980 Hitler needed to be stopped, the World Wars were justified, more recent wars not so much.
bjames1812 1 month ago
Ich mag dieses Lied sehr obwohl es mich immer sehr betroffen und traurig macht.
sylvischatz 2 years ago
Good stuff
ilikefarts69 2 years ago 2
This has always one of my favorite songs. thank you so much for posting. The Final Cut is also my favorite Pink Floyd album. Rock on! Dice
Dicedrum 2 years ago 2
@Dicedrum Utterly pretentious and self indulgent shit in my view.All about folk tales and theatrical sound effects.Very little to do with music at all
kenfig 1 year ago
@kenfig that's cool too. Rock on! Dice
Dicedrum 1 year ago
@Dicedrum trully one of the best
njnivek 1 year ago
brilliant
kwstasfwtiou1 2 years ago