thank you KaraokeLiederPianist, I just tried to sing this piece accompanied by you and I think your tempo is quite nice. And yes, in the end the singer has to work hard to keep up the speedy tempo but the spinning wheel is not slowing down at all but it needn't too. You play beautifully and this is a nice opportunity to rehearse this song without a "live"pianist available!
Thanks for your comments everyone. I know some of you think the accel is too fast to sing at the end; however, this is the genuine tempo I have leart from the soprano with whom I have most performed this song. It won't work for you if you have very wide vibrato though. Incidentally I think the spinning wheel is definitely metaphorical at that point; if you've known true despair then you know what I mean.
Brava it;s very helpfull but if you just went a bit slower in the end it would be better. Its not cantabile at the tempo you play in the end. It's supposed to be agitated but it's a little to much! You play wonderfully by the way!
Thank you very much for this! Is very appreciate, not only for us,the people that wish to learn that piece, but because you are a very nice pianist and is great to listen.
thank you KaraokeLiederPianist, I just tried to sing this piece accompanied by you and I think your tempo is quite nice. And yes, in the end the singer has to work hard to keep up the speedy tempo but the spinning wheel is not slowing down at all but it needn't too. You play beautifully and this is a nice opportunity to rehearse this song without a "live"pianist available!
feetje2008 1 year ago 2
Thank you so much for putting this up! It has been a life saver!
vexdgrl 1 year ago
Very useful. Thank you very much.
Any chance we could get you to do Erlkonig?
courthousedoc 2 years ago
muchas gracias por su viedeo. Usted me ayuda a estudiar...
tristaneisolda2001 2 years ago
Perfect tempo! Brava!
CatalinaDM56 2 years ago
Thank you! Its beautifull! Thank you! Sugestion : Im wunderschönen Monat Mai , Schumann
areadene 2 years ago
Thanks for your comments everyone. I know some of you think the accel is too fast to sing at the end; however, this is the genuine tempo I have leart from the soprano with whom I have most performed this song. It won't work for you if you have very wide vibrato though. Incidentally I think the spinning wheel is definitely metaphorical at that point; if you've known true despair then you know what I mean.
KaraokeLiederPianist 2 years ago 4
Thanks perfect exept the tempo is a little to fast for singing.
Schubert has written -Nicht so geschwind and the spinning weel has it´s limits ,though you seem to have non. Looking forward to more from you.
lovecp11 2 years ago
nice exercise!
But the title this lied is "Gretchen at the spinning wheel", not "Gretchen at the sewing-machine" ...
mlkoln 2 years ago
@mlkoln: Maybe you would like to give it a try and post it on Youtube? It is so easy to make those comments........and so cheap.....
lekkerbekje 1 year ago
:-* Thank you so much!
elegie84 2 years ago
thank yououou!!!very helpfull
merianaki1 2 years ago
I really enjoyed your video! Sorry, I accidentally clicked on two stars when I was trying to press play. :( I love the piano part of this song.
htjester 2 years ago
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR POSTING THIS YOU ARE AMAZING!!! Same note as juliapetr tempo-wise. You really do a very nice job! Thank you!
DarkKitten22 2 years ago
I can't thank you enough for your work.
It is very helpful and brilliantly played.
eeryness 3 years ago
Brava it;s very helpfull but if you just went a bit slower in the end it would be better. Its not cantabile at the tempo you play in the end. It's supposed to be agitated but it's a little to much! You play wonderfully by the way!
juliapetr 3 years ago
thank you so much !
just piano is wonderful !
merlinhelene 3 years ago
That's a cool idea, indeed! Thank you so much. I'd like to suggest something: why don't you "erlkönigfy" us a little?
rmelofranco 3 years ago
Oh, thank you!, your songs are really useful! You're a really talented pianist.
Could you make a video playing Nachtviolen someday?
Thank you!
Dameeis 3 years ago
Thank you very much for this! Is very appreciate, not only for us,the people that wish to learn that piece, but because you are a very nice pianist and is great to listen.
Thanks <3
DestinyRage 3 years ago
Blah I'm so glad you put just the piano. I'm trying to learn the piano.
ChibiKawaii3 3 years ago
Oh wow, THANK you. Have to sing this for my jury... it's also great to hear the accompaniment by itself so I can follow the nuances better...
currymuttonpizza 3 years ago
thank you so much for posting htis up! I was looking for just the piano cause it's brillant! thank you!
mrbrightsideazer 3 years ago
Thank you for your comments. I will post Lascia ch'io pianga when I have a chance.
KaraokeLiederPianist 3 years ago
Thank you so much for doing this - I have to sing this song and you have just made my life so much easier.
Wonderful - you are very talented!
bellapagan 3 years ago
thank you
nicosupersex 4 years ago
Gracias por tu trabajo tan útil y desinteresado. Si no fuese mucho pedir me gustaría pedirte que hicieras un video de "Lascia ch'io pianga". GRACIAS
mesirvecualquiera 4 years ago