Added: 4 years ago
From: merkinsniffer
Views: 32,948
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (90)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I never could figure out how he got this sound on this song

  • I can imagine this being fucking difficult to perform live.

  • Nirvana's cool. But Elliott has better musicianship and songwriting than Kurt but there are like if you had 2 brothers, if both are good for different reasons you got to love them. I agree that Elliott needs more respect and notice.

  • 2:20 <3

  • Beautiful song and delivery. Oh what I would do to have an opportunity to see Elliott Smith live!

  • "deserves as much respect as nirvana."... don't even mention in the same breath

  • i can't believe i never saw this video before!!! thank you thank you thank you for posting this!!!!! xoxoxo!!!!!

  • I was a 5 year old boy totally clueless of the fact that my favorite musician of all time was playing one of my favorite songs of all time. I love you Elliott your missed...thanks

  • Even Elliott's false starts/fuck-ups are endearing LOL.

    Awesome performance of a haunting song. RIP Elliott - you are missed.

  • @candysays69 i seriously got goosebumps after reading your comment...no idea why

  • hahha i need to drink ,,, more beer elliott was a rare delicate creature that everybody let go of

  • i wish you could see his face and his emotions. there are hardly any live videos of this songs

  • definetly an acoustic rock star, deserves as much respect as nirvana.

  • @arexthetrex way more respect then nirvana

  • @dunks10304

    Indeed. 100x more

  • great harmony

  • @thewarfiles That song kill sucks to me. I don't see how someone listening to that crap would be listening to elliott.

  • He was such a sweet heart.

  • This is my favorite song of his. So sad and emotionally raw!

  • One of the best.

  • the flute melody? lol, yea and i love the trombone work in kiwi maddog 20/20.

  • @Gammarklar there is no trombone....are you dense?

  • @thefortress12 sarcasm, how does it work? look it up in a dictionary. its obvious theres no trombone in kiwi maddog, just like its obvious that there isnt a flute in roman candle... to anyone that has ears which work.

  • @thefortress12 sarcasm, how does it work? look it up in a dictionary. its obvious theres no trombone in kiwi maddog, just like its obvious that there isnt a flute in roman candle... to anyone that has ears which work.

  • @Gammarklar yup...alright...yup

  • Lmao i miss you so much Elliott, you were such a wonderful person and musician, almost criminally under-rated. <3 xo

  • "I need to drink more beer"

  • love.....

  • i love this song so much. and just learnt it off mark1800 a few comments below. thanks mark! =)

  • love you you elliott

    xo

  • I live in NYC on the same block as the Knitting Factory and walk past it every day to go to work. I think about Elliott walking around there- kind of an empty feeling

  • darkest hour? dude, he had some pretty dark hours...

  • My friend shot me in the face with a roman candle and all I could think about was this man

  • @Flipperdoodles Thank you. I just love hearing people talk about Elliott Smith so much.  I would be thinking the exact same thing.

  • @Flipperdoodles woah sorry about your face if the chicks still make out if ya still it's okay.. i bet so you got a great musical taste ;)

  • @Flipperdoodles ...ow?

  • i would have to agree: would have given anything to be there but i was 6, and it surely is his best song. I think the strumming and chord progressions in the song sum up what i believe to elliotts best attributes. and of course the way he sings around it all. the simple stuff is always the best.

    I wish i could figure it out to.. but that shit is hard. some site gave me their version. it goes... C#m,a#m, a... c#m, e ,f . it's probably not exact but it will get you feeling good.

  • tune your guitar to D-A-D-G-B-D first of all, and then play the following shapes as you would in standard: b minor 7th for the first chord, c sharp 7 for the second, then get a G power-chord by barring the E and A sterings at fret 5, and the last chord in the verse progression is an A7. chorus is the same chords but with a D and E minor thrown in there.

    good luck figuring out the picking pattern - you have to strum with your...

  • ...index/middle fingers on the higher straings and do an alternating picking pattern on the bass strings! but hopefully the chords/tuning will give you a starting point.

    i'm thinking about making a tutorial video for this song at some point, so subscribe!

    good luck

  • i would give anything to have been there.

    but i was 2 :P

  • i've never seen anyone play this song like elliott. the one of the most beautiful songs ever.

  • this is so amazing

  • Best Elliot Smith Song and Album

    rip elliot

  • best album i agree.

    the no names

    are amazing

  • maybe his darkest album?? not his best imo

  • all time favourite elliott song.

    miss him

    xo

  • heard this song a million times... but this mourning i was listening to it in my car.... and the lyrics just hit me like a ton of bricks..... such a powerful song.....

    such a shame he isnt with us anymore..... best song writer of my generation.... NO DOUBT

  • so true. the very best of my gerneration as well.

  • ps. does anyone know the tuning for this?

  • I think its a drop D.

  • It's gotta have some kinda downtuning on the higher strings to get that jangling thing going though.... hrrrm. I must figure it out

  • i think its standard with a capo on the 7th

  • way off...scroll up for tab

  • thanks so much for posting this, i love this song.

  • this video alone should make this guy more famous than he is now, let alone...

  • I'd have to say this is one of the most depressing songs I've ever heard. I love though.

  • I was at this show ... although this vid doesn't nearly capture that experience, I am so grateful for the posting :)

  • how the hell he did it?

    00:53

    pa pa pam

  • magic

  • i think it was maybe someone like beating on a table or something like who was sitting by the camera? idk

  • no... you can hear the strings...

    elliott was so amazing...:[

  • no like while he was playing, someone in the audience sitting near the guy recording like just tapping along to that part of the song cause it has a strange time signiture

  • he's using his thumb to slap the strings against the fretboard whilst flicking the higher strings

  • He was just unbelievable. It always sounds to me like there are two of him - two voices singing together.

  • and at the same time one piece

  • YES! It was incredible. You can hear it here on this live recording which proves it.

  • hahaha, typical Elliott. It is a really hard song to play anyways. Great song too.

    Thanks for posting it.

  • Thanks so much for posting this. One of my favorite ES songs.... I love that weird flute melody that comes in just after the first two lines or so on the record. Love that pause for gulp of beer. Thanks again!

  • I don't think I've ever noticed that flute melody...I'll check out the album version again. Thanks for mentioning it, I guess.

  • Well I just listened to it again...doesn't sound like a flute to me =S

    Sounds more electric...

  • damp sustained electric guit imo

  • imo as well, though not in so much detail haha.

    But yeah, it is an eargasmic sound.

  • Actually, it isn't a flute - it's just an electric guitar with the fuzz and the treble turned way down so that it has a warm and subdued/mysterious sound.

    Cheers!

  • Comment removed

  • you guys sure, i thought he played two real quiet piano keys during those parts, could be confusing it with something else though

  • Fucks up and jumps RIGHT back in....

    amazing

  • I love this song! Thanks so much for the upload.

    He was so masterful.

  • amazing video, thank you for posting

  • not many would be in this quality, but great vid. thanks

  • absolutely stunning

  • scares the sh out of me

  • Thanks, pretty rare him perfoming this one live..?

  • one of his best songs that no one knows about he did nto play it alot. its abotu his realtionship with his stepdad

  • Wow.

    :(

  • haunting, still a classic

  • nice

  • thanks for the post.. awesome!

  • Cute! I love you Elliott.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more