All I Want For Christmas Is You (Live @ Disney World)

[DarkWolfyo]

you guys are like, derp just stop, its not bad, but still, you guys have to stop comparing people, if you need to compare someone to either

of them compare yourself, compare your singing to theirs. i do it all the time and compared to both of them im nothing.

[TheColores30]

wow!!!

S-P-E-C-T-A-C-U-L-A-R-!

[charmedone43]

@bibizoca1000 well If you let me add:

[tk090522]

It is very happy　！

[ubal]

when she finish the song the first time, it looks like she burns down in hell...

[afleitikh3]

beautiful and awesome!

[marts1233]

is this in paris??

[stormysky86]

@marts1233 No, this is Disneyworld in Orlando, Florida!

[liloleo]

@marts1233 no ! America

[jenst92]

@marts1233 you can see it's america because the castle is grey and in paris the castle is pink

[HiHikarii]

yeahh cool

[marts1233]

beauty

[juanitabful]

She is beautiful and has a lovely voice! I'm so happy for her that she is having twins! God Bless You Mariah.

[popsita]

im putting this on my profile, its too cute

[bibizoca1000]

Miley = Nothing

Mariah = Everything

Miley = Shit

Mariah = Amazing Singer

Shut up Miley fans!!!!

[veinivan7]

wow! mariah's dancers are not showing their flash or booty shaking ... must be the spirit of christmas

[DaoMingChoi]

Congratulations Mariah! More number 1 albums and more number 1 singles for you!!!!!!

[lizcorona408]

awesome perfomance

[hollabigT]

in a GIANT ASS WREATH HAHAHAHAH classic

[lafrank03]

Awesome performance! She looks hot!

[pixieislove101]

the ginger bread men are scary lookin to me

[Ihateeminem1985]

She's soooooooooo beautiful!

[MrACCE24]

Canta muy bien Mariah, pero definitivamente queda claro que los flacos se ven mejor, pues miren que linda está, ahora no es que está fea, pero está gordis, Eso me recuerda que debo bajar 20 libras antes de Navidad. Espero lograrlo. Saludos...

[sempredisi]

SIMPLY PERFECT



[drunkdivamariahcarey]

ONE OF THE BEST CHRISTMAS MARIAH HAS GIVEN

[drunkdivamariahcarey]

She 28 when she wore sexy clothes...

mild but sexy when she was 18

[slyx207]

Glad to see MARIAH in the DISNEY WORLD. "BABY ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS MIMI & HER MERRY CHRISTMAS II YOU CD." ;)

[DarKStalkeR19]

Merry Christmas II you!!! November 2...cant wait!

[CyprusHot]

SHE IS A LEGEND

[BabyG18]

mariah has amazing legs

beautiful song!

[mybodysayinletsgo]

@BabyG18 LOL! ditto :D

[WireDream]

This was apparently before her side trip to Ben & Jerry's. And plastic surgeon.

[mcdamian17]

@WireDream This was in 2004.

[initochanchan]

@WireDream This was 2004. She has always been the same. No craziness, she has just had a normal boob job hahaha, but she had it in 1999. She will be back with a christmas album in november and will blow people away!

[zakswife1]

omg people are stupid... miley and mariah carey are both amazing artists... quit comparing a kid to an adult... of course mariah is more experienced and all that but miley shouldnt be bagged on especially on mariahs video... and if you all hated miley so much as you say you do... then why did u even bother listening to her video? grow up, get a life. they are famouse and your not... so they must have done SOMETHING right...

[justbitme123]

this song is covered by shania, john mayer, miley...

which means this is such a worthy song to be revived...

but the original version is the really d best..

[PixieSticksRSweet]

what a dumb dress

[jrah22]

i like the gingerbread men.. too cute x

[mariahmoni]

Mariah is the best!!!!1 she is nr. 1

[SMVEMJ]

mariah was amazing here and i loved the ending where she was hanging onto the reef, and can you stop comparing mariah and miley

Mariah - One of the best singers in the world, has tons of singles and the biggest singing range ever!

Miley - fake

[MiMiFanx3]

=] mariah is the best

[FULLMETALALCHEMlST]

those nutcracker's hands looks like boobs :D

[tordiscool]

talk about bad recording i can barle hear it ..........

[lcklkul]

no one can ever do it better than her, with that flava!

[waltonmt]

She's still smoking hot

[Swordsfor200Alex]

Obviously, kids under the age of 17 are going to think the world of Miley. Anyone older will know the difference between a 3 yr teen sensation for Disney and a 20 yr career top selling female artist of ALL TIME in Mariah Carey. Before you start comparing Cyrus to Carey...lets see how long it takes to sell over 200 million records for Cyrus and then we can talk about which one is better. Little child...go to 30 other concerts by 30 other artists in the next 10 yrs and broaden your knowledge...

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

Oh no, c'mon i'm miley's biggest fan EVER, but mariah is way bigger than her (that doesn't mean i prefer mariah, i prefer miley --> freedom of choice and taste u can NOT say i'm wrong))

But when i first arrived here (on this video) I read that what ppl were talking about is miley's version of All i want for christmas, so i took part of the 'debate' of course, not saying that miley is better, but that miley is NOT bad, she may not be as good as MC but that does n't mean she's bad !!!!

[Siggyred]

One Most Influential, Unmatched, Undefeated, Undeniably Top Notched, One Powerhouse Ultimate World Pop/R&B Queen 200million Top Best Selling Legendary Iconic Superstar Diva MARIAH CAREY - from her #1 Top Best Selling 8million Copies Sold CHRISTMAS Album "MERRY CHRISTMAS" (1994 / 2005) One of her #1 Christmas Hit Singles "ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS" and "JOY TO THE WORLD" (Live at 2004 ABC Disney Christmas Special).

Buy a Copy tis Christmas! Its a Definite MUST HAVE Collection for Ages! ;op

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

I LOVE how almost everybody is talking about Miley on a video that has nothing to do with her

[MollerDoller]

I love this song and Mariah Carey is the best singer i will say that this is my Favorite CHRISTMAS song!

[barkleysound]

Mariah's version > Miley's version

[mundiman889]

well of course....Mariah wrote and composed this song (with Walter) her version will ALWAYS be better than everyone elses!

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

Your the idiot in the story, u say stuff that are OBVIOUS and u make it look like it was the smartest thing nobody has ever thought about before

--> Original versions are always the best !! why ? cus they ARE the ones who inspire others to sing them^^

so yeah mariah's version is the best, just like miley's version of the climb is better than anyone else (even if the guys from X Factor are good)

ohh yeah i had it all right about the "artist" thing ! i loved how u got complexed by it :)

[Ueberbacker]

I disagree, Mariah has recorded many songs from other artists and made them sound better... cause she's a hell of a vocalist, even though she writes many songs too.

Just the fact it's your song, doesnt mean you have the best version, but in case of great and famous artists like her, its difficult to come close

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

so maiah carey's version of All I want for christmas is not the best version ever for that song ?

Ok :)

[Ueberbacker]

It is the best version, but not just because its her song, but cause she's an amazing singer

Im just saying that being a composer doesnt make you the best performer.

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

I agree with u, composers are not "always" the best performers, and i also think that mariah's version will always be the best, cus i think she was the 1st too sung it, and nobody can make it better...

i mean if mariah wasn't a great singer, the song wouldn't be great, and miley wouldn't know it, so its because mariah was the original singer, that the song is now one of the most covered Christmas song of all time !

I still think original versions are the best, but i respect ur opinion..

[marisalander]

i remember watching this n crying cuz at that moment i knew she was gonna make a big comeback! n she did! i love herrr!

[Guille24Jun]

mariah , una cantate como nunca escuche ¡¡¡¡¡ unica e inigulable ¡¡¡ la MEJORRRRRRRRR¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ te adoro

[itsFRANCISsuckka]

the people red makes me laugh lol when they wave idk y its funny. Miley sucked in this song

[marvelucla]

I am so happy Mariah Carey is bringing in the new year at MSG in NY 2010!!!!

[Winterlove48]

first off.. why are we talking about miley cyrus on a mariah carey christmas video? obviously, no one can compare to mariah's high range of vocals. miley cyrus is just a little teenybopper that started off on disney. she's nothing special at ALL! my dog can sing better than her.

[iSh1n3]

never get tired of hearing this song, but only by Mariah, after hearning Miley try to sing it I wanted to throw up, it was so bad! Mariah Carey ftw :D

[Preeti619]

wat kinda christmas is that there with no snow!!

[212hal]

A good one:) No broken legs, hips or people being isolated because they can't go out of their homes and no one comes to visit.

[mmouse1999]

there is no snow in florida =[

hope that helped=]

[iimmm]

stop! comparing mariah and miley..... miley WHO?? come on people we are talking about mariah carey not your ordinary teenage "star"; MC is a real singer

[IMAGIRLism1]

wo so cool song

[michpasx]

THE BEST

[leivoj]

yeah... miley sings through her NOSE.. xD

[MRSrobbypattinson]

omg i thought i was d only 1 dat noticed dat lol

[Arundodonax]

Mariah Carey, 5 octave range, uses 2 of them (F#3 to F#5) here effortlessly. Miley Cyrus, unable to really even reach the D#5 in the bridge. Mariah Carey, sings with resonance and a naturally integrated vibrato throughtout (sic 2:09-2:11, 2:33-2:34). Miley Cyrus sings through her nose (sic "come true" lyric).

Need I go on? Any of you Miley Cyrus supporters care to actually substantiate your claims of her superiority of Mariah Carey with something other than "Miley rocks!"? We're waiting...

[Arundodonax]

Corrections: superiority "over" Mariah Carey (obviously).

Also, Miley is singing in G, so the note she doesn't reach is E5, not D#5. Still not hitting any D#5's either though :).

Thanks.

[moi28]

Whatevs...these days all Mariah does is lip sync. Even her studio recordings pale in comparison to the Mariah back in the day.

I think once she starting being more concerned about taking her clothes off, the talent came off as well....

Did you hear that awful remake she did of HERO? Yuk!

[xKATNEYx]

Most people know NOTHING when it comes to music . They like Miley because she's fun, mindless entertainment. There's just something about her that makes you want to watch her, no matter how good/bad she is.

Think of it this way, "The Madeleine" is said to be the best (and most expensive)chocolate in the world, but "Hersheys" is the most popular.

That said I like both versions of the song. This one is eaiser to listen to though, lol.

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

Sorry but if u want ppl to respect ur opinion, u have to respect theirs

and ++ there's no accounting for taste

I like Miley, and i have MY reasons... u have no right to say that i'm wrong, or to criticize me or even to judge me

P.S : unlike u, I act maturely and don't act like how u just did, and we're supposed to be the "immature" ones... -_-'

[xKATNEYx]

I never said you were wrong or immature.

I LIKE Miley, I like her music better than Mariah's. I feel she puts more of herself into her music.

Mariah has an AMAZING voice, but thats all she is (to me). Just a voice, no personality. Miley is the opposite.

So calm down, if you were really mature you would have taken my comment at face value and just left it at that.

"If you want people the respect your opinion, you have to respect theirs."

[radmanzhang]

how can you say miley cyrus puts more of herself into her music, when mariah carey was the one who wrote this song?

i don't see how you can put more of yourself into your music if you don't write your own songs, over someone who writes basically ALL their songs themselves

[xKATNEYx]

I said "HER" music.

Not THIS song. I know Carey wrote this song.

I should have been more specific. I didn't mean Miley put more into musc (I know she dosen't write most of her songs), I ment performance wise.

Miley is a performer, Mariah is an artist.

Get what I was trying to say now?

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

WHAT ?

--> an artist does artS with a big "S" -_-'

Miley is a singer, an all time LIVE performer, she's also a songwriter (she wrote 21 songs on her albums) she's a writer (she wrote a 200 pages autobiography at 15yo) a SUCCESSFUL fashion designer, she's a TV and MOVIE actress ! and was even a voice off in Bolt

that makes her an ARTIST not a performer..

carey is a better singer, but Miley is better than her in everything else :)

So miley is an artist, mariah carrey is a PERFORMER

[mundiman889]

you're an idiot

[BDMariianaa]

"So miley is an artist, mariah carrey is a PERFORMER..." Huh... more like "so Miley is a poor-talented-lypsyincher-who-­doesn't-even-sing-ok-fake-doll and Mariah Carrey an ARTIST" gurl admit it, you're a miley fan, but she covered a song just totally OUT OF HER LEAGUE... that's why she writes her own "songs" (if you can call them all that way), pretty much EVERY other artist's song is out of her league:)

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

Oh gosh, should I remind u, of WHAT the definition of "artist" means ???

--> that means a person who does different arts and succeed in them ?

--> not a person who's liked by "BBMariianaa"

she has 3 No1 movies, 1 best seller, 6 No1 albums, Ohh and one top rated TV Show !

the fact that MC's one of the best singers in the world, doesn't make her better than Miley in everything else :)

Ps : I don't admit being a Miley fan, I'm PROUD of it !

MILEY FAN FOREVER

[jaypaidincash]

but the simple fact is..MARIAH IS BETTER THAN MILEY..miley has not even been out HALF the time mariah has..get over it..ITS FACTS.

[ilybEhbz]

@TheCraziestUserOnU2b shutup already, dont talk big shit cuz u dont kno nothing anything miley has mariah has had already and a lot more , so shutup ur fckn annoying talking like you know everything

[leivoj]

is miley the best for you??? did she really succeed at her arts/career??? or her dad made her succeed?? think again! miley...... i admit must be a singer.. but not a popular one.. she doesnt get off the note but the quality dude is not that..... pleasing... im sorry.. but i respect the way you like a nasal singer eh?! :D keep supporting her until you are the last.. :))

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

You really wanna play dirty ?

Miley never came DRUNK on stage ?

unless some "people" arround here..

and YEAH she really succeed in her career, with the crisis of the CD, she sold 17 million CDs in ONLY 3 years ! she was 2008'best seller female artist, and 2009's 3rd best selling female artist (behind Taylor and Beyonce)

uummm... where is Mariah in all this ?

let me guess, ur gonna talk about her PAST?

but why don't u say anything abiut what she has done from 06 to now ?

[leivoj]

uh oh.. okei.... we are not talking about ethics here..... yeah.. perhaps miley isnt that wild as her seniors are NOW.. but we'll see...

btw... my prior comment talks about ABILITY and not ETHICS... okei...... first: mileys voice is nasal.. second: have you watcher her mtvs??? i.e. the climb.... why does she look seducing when the lyrics of the song should be encouraging...??

i am not mariah fan or whatever.... i am just not impress with miley and her fans.... im not fighting against miley..

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

? I wasn't trying to impress you, I was jusr proffing you that almost every 16yo and + who think they're different and unique, UNDER-estimate Miley, and they never take her seriously !

[leivoj]

okei.... if that;s what you think......

honestly, i dont underestimate her.. i am IMPRESSED how she rocks the audience.. however... im not IMPRESSED with her voice... sorry...

try insulting MC in a page where MILEY's fans meet.. so you dont look like the antagonist eh.. :)) SMILE... :D

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

Uuumm.. OK

I kinda agree with u on that, her voice is not Mariah's, but I still find it impressive.. but Mariah's voice is more divaesk.. actually miley's voice is more Rock.. so I don't know I just like it.. but I like MC's too

I'm not insulting Mariah, I'l deffending Miley, I watched this video cuz she was in the 'related" section in Miley's all i want for christmas video, and when I looked at the comments, most comments were INSULTING Miley..

[leivoj]

oh yeh!! i see.... uh,.... you prefer miley because you are more on the ROCK and ROLL side.... maybe.... us who like pop are not impressed with miley..... we have our own preference.. SMILE.. :)

[mariahcareybigfan1]

@TheCraziestUserOnU2b because mariah carey wrote a classic song, she wrote it!! and then people sing it and ruin it!

[mariahcareybigfan1]

@TheCraziestUserOnU2b miley pole dances at 16 years old. shes pretty slutty, miley doesnt write hits, mariah writes, produces, SINGS hits. so shut up and leave

[ilybEhbz]

@TheCraziestUserOnU2b RESPECT OTHER PPLS OPPINIONS?????? your not respecting the fact that mariah carey is better than miley and plus u keep bagging on mariah

[iluvmylay]

lol i fuckin LOVE you for being soo smart !!!!

 :)))))

[TheCraziestUserOnU2b]

Well I know that mariah's voice is so much better than miley's, but that doesn't mean miley's voice is not good either right ?

miley has a range of 3 Octave (i think) and she can make an Eb6 or something, a note that only MC kat deluna, christina aguilera and miley can make (i'm talking about the famous singers)

here's the link : youtube (.) com/watch?v=xAdK0A4lGgI

FYI that was a live concert in Berlin, so its true live (just in case u say she was lip syncing or something)

[iSh1n3]

miley sucks period.

[ilybEhbz]

@TheCraziestUserOnU2b omfgg shutup already your talking big shitt right now miley has a 3 range octave????? thats the average octave of any normal person your so dam annoying talking like u kno everything

[16BigJoe]

Talent and being the most beautiful woman ever

[TheCrazyLorenz]

I LOVE MARIAH CAREY!!!

[albii89]

was it in ORLANDO or LOS ANGELES???

[mylittleboat3]

DISNEY WORLD! Disney LAND is LA

[iSh1n3]

You can't beat Mariah, she's the bomb!!!!

Besides, Miley can't sing for a grain of uncooked rice.

[YunaHermy]

I definetely think this is the best performance ever and I'm not even mad for Mariah...I mean tears are popping outta my eyes

She is awesome and this performance is a DREAM

GO MARIAH <3

[redbike2008]

I love her voice. The background music is louder then my radio.

[holdon4eva0608]

miley sings it better

[lamb4eva]

your retarted because mariah wrote this song and uses all 5 of the octaves in her range to sing it while miley has maybe one and a half octaves and doesn't know how to use them. i'm sry but if think miley sings it better u either hav major brain damage or major hearing problems.

MARIAH OWNS MILEY

[erbsoccer]

before you call someone else retarded you might want to make sure you spell it right. also, you should use the write YOU'RE

[lamb4eva]

sry but i'm not commenting to hav my grammar checked, i'm doing it to get an opinion across and as long as people understand it (which u obviously did), i really don't care how the words r spelled

[iSh1n3]

oh, by the way, you used the incorrect "right", you wrote, "write" instead of right.

[jaypaidincash]

your right, she did write this song, but she doesent use all 5 octaves of her range to sing it..

[lamb4eva]

well she certainly uses more than miley, correct?

[jaypaidincash]

that is correct too lol

[yanniaquino]

yup..

cuz, miley sounds horrible..

[beautifulmollies]

plus Miley kinda looked like she was lipping it.

[x0x0sHa11chArmx0x0]

what a goooood performance!!! i love it!!!

[arkutie201]

i feel sorry 4 the guys who have to wear those gingerbread men. lol

[Senoskey]

She has nice double D's

[kraze99]

She is great. Miley is also a great singer too. Except that in my opinion, she must wear somethin that covers a breast. Her dress is nice just need some few extensions. Other than that, she rocks! ( And so does Miley. )

[castletriglav]

Would be better without the fag dancers.

[0lNaty0l]

Wouuuuuuuuuuu

Mariah carey

[katy12234]

wow, mariah did way better than miley!! :]]

miley cyrus sings through her nose! bleh

[emosmentrox92]

na, i think's miley's is beta!!! :)

still a great song tho

[kimilitoaznn]

no mariah is better

[eysooo]

How can you compare Miley Cyrus to Mariah Carey??? It's her original song that came out in 1994!!! Can Miley Cyrus go up high like Mariah Carey?? Can she belt like her? In my opinion, Miley Cyrus sounds really annoying in that video.

[lambsquad17]

Don't be so cruel.

Nobody's comparing!!!

Miley Cyrus can sing, but not as good as MCC.

[andylad25]

Hey guys for someone living in UK , please answer who is this Miley cyrus u all keep going on about??

Its weird

[PeachNmint]

look up miley cyrus in youtube shes awesome

[1my2username3sux4lol]

andy miley cyrus is famous here in the UK too. she plays hannah montana on the disney series.

[meganradomski]

the only thing good about her is that she can sing in a high voice, miley sings it better, and her song is better too.

[nelsonr1984]

LOL must be someone under 18 with bad hearing because no one, i mean NO ONE can sing a Mariah song better than Mariah herself!

[xoLoveMileyCyrus]

yea.

[mellowout007]

Yay Meriah Carey!!! I love her so much! An just cuz she is getting older, she is still one of the best singers in music history! Nobody can "whistle" like her!

[jeromedomingo1]

she likes wearing short stuff like skirts

[Marc0Bla]

Omg People have to be STUPID , tonedef, ignorant, and not have any culture to compare, the queen of R'b, the writer of the song, the producer of the song, one of the world greates voices ever, to a girl o sings with the nose, and pretend to be hanna bannana xD

miley cirus is nothing compared to mariah! please -____- QUIT STUPIDITY !

[chalak]

she is hot

[ludinhavi]

Wish I'll be in Disney World soon.

[xXMizzJuliettexX0]

MARIAH :)

MILEY :(

[dzieffczynka14]

she is amazing!!!

[SaHneErdbeer94]

MariaH's is better miley's sucks !

[PGirls1]

yeahh agreed

[adaheiez]

alli lohan,and her whole family hates disney and miriah cary

[PunkRck845]

wait i just thought of something...

why are we comparing mariah and miley??

two different generations!

[UrPirateGirl]

AND MARIAH IS SOO MUCH BETTER

[B3ND0G]

Age aint nothing but a number, when it comes to skills. that's why.

[ranika1992]

hallooooo ....das lied ist so geil ....OMG...:D

[niloo27]

beautufel!

merry chrismas from holland!

[livestrong2410]

Merry Christmas!

God bless!

[teddsurr]

OMGOSH!(: MariaaahCareey's Awesomee♥ ;)

[XDISNEYIIX]

omg..

[PunkRck845]

she is a damn ugly hoe and cant sing worth shit and needs to fall off a cliff!

oh im ready for hate mail! lol

[lazaro1227]

you dont know what the fuck your talking about i may not know about her personal life and i dont care but i do know about music and shes one of the best and if you dont think that sweetie you cant hear

[darkraivscresselia]

See the old Mariah first.

[hgdjytgkh]

merry christmas!!!

craciun fericit!!!

boldog karacsonyt!!! from romania&hungary

[lefer87]

Merry Christmas from Peru!!!!

XD

[ILoveToSing33]

If you are from Texas did you know Selena Gomez before she got famous, becuause she is from Texas! Just wondering! P.S. I dont know why someone marked what you said on this video as a spam! It says Merry Christmas from Texas! Thx!

[ti]

Merry Christmas from Taiwan 聖誕快樂!!!