Wow. She is horrible! I love Tara, and I think everybody needs to back the fuck off, she's literally been through hell and back, and I know if I were in her shoes, I would be bitter as fuck! Thank God, they recast though! Rutina is the perfect Tara, every time I look at this chick all I see is Passions.
Brook is either overacting or underacting and doesn't seem to be comfortable with swearing. I'm always surprised by how classy Rutina is. I expect "Oh my God, you motherfucking racists!" to come out of her mouth at every Comic Con. That's how much she owns the role of Tara.
This actress is just not believable as Tara. She looks and sounds like even she can't believe the words coming out of her mouth. There is no anger or pain or emotional insecurity in her performance that we get with Rutina. She's just trying to get the lines out, stumbling, and wothout any comedic timing. She's also very uncomfortable with Sam Trammell--no chemistry, and he's not digging her in the role either.
Rutina IS MUCH better, but I'll admit that this girl at least flared it up a bit more than her other job scene. It's not top, but she was believable. Nowhere NEAR a bitchy/funny that Rutina can pull off sooo well. Rutina <3
luv me some rutina wesley...yes i der.... sorry but tina got that attitude and passion to play tara like no other...she needs to be nominated asap...like last year....4 real!
Why did they fire her? Pilots are always horrible and look like bad acting. They do them on a very limited budget and time. That is why the 2nd episode always looks 100x better. She wasn't that bad, and to tell you the truth I think the new Tara is a little annoying.
@stevosnevo I think she was great, but she needed to work on that southern accent. it didnt do so well. Besides Tara is a f************ bitch, Brook is just to nice to play someone like that.
This show is so sexy.
westboundNinja1 2 days ago
Rutina im so glad they found you...this other girl would have gotten Tara killed by the 2nd episode!
nataiem 2 weeks ago
My appreciation for Rutina just skyrocketed.
blueaztecstone 2 weeks ago
She doesn't even compare to the Tara that's on the show now. Good play on their part replacing her.
willowpillow21 3 weeks ago
I don't think Brook's bad (other than the accent). Rutina's just better.
silentlyinmyheart 1 month ago
I think they are both horrible. Tara's character shouldn't even exist, much less protrayed by such awful actresses.
wintersnoob 1 month ago
This woman sucks!!! How the hell did alan ball hire someone like this!? Hate tara, but rutina
rabbitholegirl1 1 month ago
Wow. She is horrible! I love Tara, and I think everybody needs to back the fuck off, she's literally been through hell and back, and I know if I were in her shoes, I would be bitter as fuck! Thank God, they recast though! Rutina is the perfect Tara, every time I look at this chick all I see is Passions.
meeshtneb 1 month ago
Brook is either overacting or underacting and doesn't seem to be comfortable with swearing. I'm always surprised by how classy Rutina is. I expect "Oh my God, you motherfucking racists!" to come out of her mouth at every Comic Con. That's how much she owns the role of Tara.
askarsfan2011 1 month ago
This actress is just not believable as Tara. She looks and sounds like even she can't believe the words coming out of her mouth. There is no anger or pain or emotional insecurity in her performance that we get with Rutina. She's just trying to get the lines out, stumbling, and wothout any comedic timing. She's also very uncomfortable with Sam Trammell--no chemistry, and he's not digging her in the role either.
askarsfan2011 1 month ago
You know i hate sayin this but i do think she was picked because she's pretty. Cuz Rutina puts that sass in Tara like nobody's business.
workittworkit 2 months ago
I dont think she's a bad actress at all...She just doesn't fit the role of Tara to me. I'm glad they switched.
Stori87 2 months ago 2
@Stori87 The same with Eric Stoltz in Back to the Future
manakotuifua 2 months ago
Ew. Other Tara is wayy better
morganboy0ify 3 months ago
I'm sort of glad they replaced her. As a person who lives in the south, her accent makes me cringe!
mmmmmvodka 3 months ago
Rutina was definitley a lot better than the girl from Passions!
PhloeFanSince2000 4 months ago
either she is just a bad actress or she didnt fit the role, they did right swapping the actress.
chrcoluk 4 months ago
She does not seem natural at swearing at all
ManDoubleDee 4 months ago 2
lovee Rutina as tara....this girl just is too pretty pretty and forced in her acting
sejalangel 4 months ago
She just wasn't UPPITY enough.
unlistedmuse17 4 months ago
Why did they change actors?
StereoCherry 4 months ago
@StereoCherry Because sometimes the original actors they cast don't fit the part. Brook Kerr did not fit the part of Tara so recasted her got Rutina
sweetheart2109 3 weeks ago
she is not good
RalphCQ 4 months ago
Her performance seems forced.
newbcake88 4 months ago
I AM SO GLAD SHE ISNT TARA!!!!!!!!!!
aspire192 4 months ago
Rutina IS MUCH better, but I'll admit that this girl at least flared it up a bit more than her other job scene. It's not top, but she was believable. Nowhere NEAR a bitchy/funny that Rutina can pull off sooo well. Rutina <3
chelligan 5 months ago 4
if she played though the seasons, i woulda wanted her ass dead lol
Brizi2011 5 months ago
She is terrrrrible lol
BandedChristie 5 months ago
I just hoped they paid her well if they fired her
quickmix21 5 months ago
She must envy Rutina now...
amazingdany 5 months ago 3
ENOUGH!! I CANT TAKE THIS SHIT NO MO!!
chykim1 5 months ago
She's not so great in this scene. Rutina Wesley FTW
cherxy777 6 months ago
luv me some rutina wesley...yes i der.... sorry but tina got that attitude and passion to play tara like no other...she needs to be nominated asap...like last year....4 real!
mycenth22 6 months ago
her anger and attitude just seems so fake in comparison to rutina. No one can play tara better than her.
rose34232 6 months ago
She was flexing her Passions muscles so hard by..................staring blankly at the camera.
And that might be the worst southern accent I've ever heard
jbanks979 6 months ago
Painful to watch aha .
Monhead101 6 months ago
Why did they fire her? Pilots are always horrible and look like bad acting. They do them on a very limited budget and time. That is why the 2nd episode always looks 100x better. She wasn't that bad, and to tell you the truth I think the new Tara is a little annoying.
AmberTrystan 6 months ago
@AmberTrystan What does budget have to do with poor acting? Kerr is a terrible actress, no amount of money will change that.
Ashavicious 5 months ago
@AmberTrystan What does budget have to do with poor acting? Kerr is a terrible actress, no amount of money will change that.
Ashavicious 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@AmberTrystan What does budget have to do with poor acting? Kerr is a terrible actress, no amount of money will change that.
Ashavicious 5 months ago
@AmberTrystan I think the producers got bad feedback from the test audience about her so they recast her. I am so glad they did
sweetheart2109 3 weeks ago
Thank f**k they got Retina!!
luvhart 7 months ago 4
Brook cant play a bitch well sorry. LOL
COOTERBABY94 8 months ago 2
no no no....rutina....sucks so hard
dragonfilm 8 months ago
she looks like Holly Cleary from seasons 3 and 4
TKO102 8 months ago
No disrespect to Brook. But thank GOD for Rutina!
ExoticByNature 8 months ago 3
So they had to reshoot all the scenes with Rutina?
flipboidex 8 months ago
@flipboidex Yes anytime they get a new actor or actress for a pilot they have to reshoot.
sweetheart2109 3 weeks ago
shes sucks and is ugly
told85 8 months ago 2
LOOOL she is SOOOO BAD!!! Rutina kicks her ass in every possible way!
sheMan32 9 months ago 40
@sheMan32
whaddup rutina... haha...
sherrycherryful 8 months ago 2
Wisky swaurse? lol
09bonita09 11 months ago
Comment removed
09bonita09 11 months ago
who said the other girl was better???? u obviously are insane! Brook is far better
stevosnevo 11 months ago
@stevosnevo I think she was great, but she needed to work on that southern accent. it didnt do so well. Besides Tara is a f************ bitch, Brook is just to nice to play someone like that.
chlorine03 10 months ago 3
@stevosnevo i think the one that plays tara now is beter.
ST4YFLYx3 10 months ago 22
@stevosnevo i know i thinks so too
kemiley56 6 months ago