No need to, you think I meant start from the begiining? I meant just look at the characteristics of each unit in BW, then input them in SC2, and voila.
unless you're referring to the stack of units that cannot be done aswell anymore, I don't see what the problem is. hp, speed, fire rate, damage etc can be modified through the ditor, I'm almost sure of it.
@Kamfrenchie No, I'm not refering to that, since clipping exists in SC2. It's really far too much to explain. And to be honest, I'm no expert on game development. But I do know that the engines and a third dimension add many new factors to balance. And yeah, all those can be changed, but don't you see that we'll have to change so much about SC1 to balance it, that it won't be a copy at all? And even one change has an effect on EVERY strategy the pros have developed. So nothing would be the same.
@sc2gg4ever its just nowhere near balanced yet and the maps leave a lot to be desired. i anticipate it will become reasonably impressive over the next 18 months but currently there's just no comparison
Starcraft is supposed to have the best balance, but I can't help but think there is some weird thing about it: several units are not that useful, and there is only a few diferent build that are very used.
No one use scouts, guardians don't seem to work, BC are rare except in very late TvT...
@sc2gg4ever I hate Starcraft2! For too many reasons. There isn't something about that game that i enjoy! Maybe is a good game (or will become), but is not Starcraft!.. So if you like it so much, please go somewhere else! "Why?!", you ask! Well simply put, is like wearing a fancy black suit in the middle of Sahara desert!
@Mikaia wtf are you crazy? I prefer Starcraft 1 over Starcraft 2 aswell! Where did I say something else, I just quoted Ranshin here, I dont think Sc2 is a bad game, I enjoy playing it sometimes, but Sc1 is clearly better, dont know where you read something different here, sc2gg is a website for Starcraft 1 (now there is Sc2 content aswell though)
another StarCraft ProLeague season, another series of flame wars on a whole new bunch of topics that are, or aren't, SC related XD
always loved your commentary Ranshin, hope you'll be casting a couple of the upcoming matches with Nukes.
LinkMaster64bits 1 year ago
Also, maybe we could "revive" brood war by modding sc2 a bit to put back the ancient units?
Kamfrenchie 1 year ago
@Kamfrenchie Add in an extra 10,000 man-hours of testing for balance PER addition, and you'll be good to go.
i3rucei3ruce 1 year ago
@i3rucei3ruce
No need to, you think I meant start from the begiining? I meant just look at the characteristics of each unit in BW, then input them in SC2, and voila.
Kamfrenchie 1 year ago
@Kamfrenchie The physics engine and 3 dimensions make a balanced copy of BW impossible.
i3rucei3ruce 1 year ago
@i3rucei3ruce
unless you're referring to the stack of units that cannot be done aswell anymore, I don't see what the problem is. hp, speed, fire rate, damage etc can be modified through the ditor, I'm almost sure of it.
Kamfrenchie 1 year ago
@Kamfrenchie No, I'm not refering to that, since clipping exists in SC2. It's really far too much to explain. And to be honest, I'm no expert on game development. But I do know that the engines and a third dimension add many new factors to balance. And yeah, all those can be changed, but don't you see that we'll have to change so much about SC1 to balance it, that it won't be a copy at all? And even one change has an effect on EVERY strategy the pros have developed. So nothing would be the same.
i3rucei3ruce 1 year ago
@i3rucei3ruce noob
dragoon414 1 year ago
"Starcraft 2 is not bad, it's just different"
/sign
sc2gg4ever 1 year ago
@sc2gg4ever its just nowhere near balanced yet and the maps leave a lot to be desired. i anticipate it will become reasonably impressive over the next 18 months but currently there's just no comparison
Xaklyth 1 year ago
@Xaklyth
Starcraft is supposed to have the best balance, but I can't help but think there is some weird thing about it: several units are not that useful, and there is only a few diferent build that are very used.
No one use scouts, guardians don't seem to work, BC are rare except in very late TvT...
Could anyone enlight me about this?
Kamfrenchie 1 year ago
@sc2gg4ever I hate Starcraft2! For too many reasons. There isn't something about that game that i enjoy! Maybe is a good game (or will become), but is not Starcraft!.. So if you like it so much, please go somewhere else! "Why?!", you ask! Well simply put, is like wearing a fancy black suit in the middle of Sahara desert!
Mikaia 1 year ago
@Mikaia wtf are you crazy? I prefer Starcraft 1 over Starcraft 2 aswell! Where did I say something else, I just quoted Ranshin here, I dont think Sc2 is a bad game, I enjoy playing it sometimes, but Sc1 is clearly better, dont know where you read something different here, sc2gg is a website for Starcraft 1 (now there is Sc2 content aswell though)
sc2gg4ever 1 year ago
@sc2gg4ever sign?
i3rucei3ruce 1 year ago
@i3rucei3ruce I just agreed to Ranshins statement, Sc2 is not bad, its just different
sc2gg4ever 1 year ago
Good to see some BW casts again <3
The "S" in the middle I would assume is for Shinhan Bank.
Like when they made the plane with ramps for the OSL.
Riiaider 1 year ago
oooh, pretty good quality. thanks ranshin for my broodwar fix.
gameboyredpee 1 year ago
waiting for part 2...
odcomtel 1 year ago
is there a part 2?
skullmanwizard 1 year ago
brood war: that's what im talking about!
entaroduai 1 year ago 7
Great commentary ranshin, I love SC1
digdugdiggy 1 year ago 5