Seether - Broken (Original Version)

[Telarian100]

Seriously you guys are like a bunch of jealous fan boys/ fan girls. Amy Lee did make the song her's in a way, He got her to sing this with him, because he thought it would make it 'BETTER'. I don't know what thats such a hard concept. If he didn't think it was as good, or better he would not have released it. Seriously stop putting your fan boy juices all over the comments, and bashing Amy lee for being amazing. Just enjoy the song, eh?

[necropolis3110]

I can not stand Amy Lee. Her voice is annoying as hell. I bought this CD when it first came out in 2002 and listened to this song over and over. It sounds so better with only Shawn in it. Her voice ruins the song. I can't even stand to listen to Evanesence because I can't stand her voice. Its almost as bad as Flyleaf. This version is so much better as a solo instead of the duet. Most people like the other version, but not me. If I hear the version with Amy Lee playing, I'll cut it off.

[Telarian100]

@necropolis3110 Yeah you're just stupid. Amy Lee is much better then say some of the more anoyying female singers. Imagine in some misundertood universe they had put TS, or MS on this song, and seemed to ruin it. I don't think this version without Amy Lee is better, but it was the first I listened. Honestly I find his version of the second verse horrid.

[narutohero50]

i like the one with amy lee better because it gives the true feeling of the connection of a relationship with someone. and not just someone that you are with, but that person that you want to be with forever. the original just doesn't do that on it's own

[potatoluv3r]

... and the vagina song is related to this how..?

[Dmoney274]

the original one is the best to me because of the bass lines and the drums and shawns voice of course

[sweetnsassycutie29]

the original is better because it is preformed the way it was meant to be when written. or at least in my opinion it fits the song much better. gotta love shaun

[BigD835042]

@Disturbedfreak2013 i totaly agree with that one! its like she thought she had to make the song hers...... so disapointing but great song nomatter what



[Gaaraschickyourejeal]

Wow, Amy really does overpower him in this song....

[c4daolskool]

fuck amy lee, this is better than her!

[delilahhenley]

There are lots of versions of this song but this is my favorite.

[Verchiel73]

such a better version

[deviantartfan1]

Beautiful Song.

I really like this version better, Amy Lee's voice is beautiful, but she really overwhelmed the song. :P

[crystallynnelson1990]

i love this song, as well as all their other songs on karma and effect. great album.

i lkie the older songs. personally.

[CodyCody143]

THANK GOD I hate Amy Lee - no offense

[Seethefan]

The song was never supposed to have amy. This is his song. This is the best for that reason.

[worldstage6]

I sure feel this one today:( Some days you just don't feel strong enough and thus ;

Broken nearly say's it all..**Great Song** For we all are sometimes faced with being just plain Broken. Heart and all...

[BrickbyBoringBrick13]

This was the song that led me to Seether :))<3

[DJFusionized]

Wtf is this song.

Needs to get fixed. Where the heck is the 50's rap verse.

[Stonerwashed]

hahaha the pic at 3:24 just cracked my shit up. the two dudes hugging and then shaun looking totally down with the whole situation glaring at the camera and holding a cig in his mouth

totally made my night awhole lot better than when i started listening to this song

[rktilludrp09]

It's crazy how similar his voice is to Kurt Cobains.

[TheJaded1039]

@rktilludrp09 Yea he sounds just like him. I got into Seether because I heard their cover of Nirvana's You Know You're right and thought it was amazing.

[JillyBeanNxD]

I think the song is beautiful in both versions, it evokes a lot of emotion because at it's core it's just a very good song.

[katenka4321]

so meaningful

[nawfel185]

this version is better for me !! thumbs up if you agree ;)

[boygerboy]

epic title

[PickleMan2135]

i would like a non-acoustic, no amy lee version of this song

[xjadexhavok]

@PickleMan2135 you arent going to find one. This is the original version of the song. Unless they decide to do another version of it, without Amy ruining it.

[chitownfan24]

This version came before Amy Lee. They only did a remake cause they were dating.

[zakakay]

lol i like the title...



[bleedingangelshaun]

this song is modulated upwards from the one with amy, and sounds SO much better

[comedyplanofficalTM]

@bleedingangelshaun and it's funny because the actually tuning is different! It's in standard rather than Eb

[Seethefan]

@comedyplanofficalTM They actually started in standard, then moved to Eb.

[Disturbedfreak2013]

I like this version better Amy is good but she just overdid it and washed Shaun out :-/

[lifeispeachy3229]

i love this song! i think its much better without amy cuz i love his voice and hers takes away from his..

[snake1591]

Same here. Shaun's voice just goes better with this song. Seemed like just tried to put too much juice into it you know.

[TheMackies7576]

@lifeispeachy3229 Definately agree with you. The song has a whole different meaning with just him.

[MSJ666]

i love Seether!<3 =O

wierd if you look at the other music i got as favorites :P

[SeetherSnob]

awesome version. thanks for sharing this one