@cotitabene It's off of their live acoustic album, I'm pretty sure it's an official album. I got it at walmart a long time ago. The album is called "One Cold Night"
I have to give credit to PJ for writing this song,I have been a fan of them for a very long time but I honestly have to say that this is one of those songs in my opinon where I like the Cover better than the Original.Both PJ and Seether have amazing songs and both are written and performed with amazing Emotion.
@TakinYoCup u cant hate nirvana, honestly im not the greatest fan of nirvana but nirvana "Helped" the post gruge alternative era in music. Seether posibly could have never formed without nirvana. Shaun Morgan even said that nirvana was an influence in his music, which is y he also did covers of "Heart Shaped Box" and "Something in the Way" that are by nirvana. You can dislike there music but u cant hate them. Just ask yourself whats better, Nirvana or Justin Beiber
jesus fucking christ YES Pearl Jam wrote this amazing song and perform it beautifly but just beacuse another band originally wrote it,sang it etc EVERYBODY MUST prefer it? well i am sorry i love PJ but Seether is an amazing band and shaun is unbelievably talented,an amazing song writter and i adore this version
a rare case where the cover is better than the original.....give pj credit for writting it give seether credit for making it sound a hell of alot better
you people think you know seether so well, your all bullshit why do you think bands play eachothers songs its the respect so stop disrespect bands that have more talent then you could ever dream of having so stop the fuckin bitching and let seether do what they do best
... is it so wrong for a band to do a cover, and not have evey comment be about the original vs. cover?
I like this song, and i love with with seether playing it. I was never a fan of P.J. simply cuz i'm never in the mood for their brand of music. Seether is a bit more my speed thats all o.o
@screaminhappyness How can that be? If the people who wrote didn't then anyone else do it justice? I'd say those wrote it matter very much so as to warrant a care.
both versions are equal. Arguing about which is better is just fuckin stupid, they are not performed in the same way. PJ's original is magical, but Seether put much passion in the cover. And PJ's fans always will say PJ's version is better, the same way as Seether fans will say about the cover.
Writing "Seether raped this song" is just fuckin' lame. It's just a bit different version, and that's all.
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
i was born in 1993 and still, the first version i heard was pj's.just now i learned that this cover existed and checked it out immediately.pj made the song immortal for me, it inspires me to my every cell when i hear it.seether did an effin good job too though.i luv them both <33333333
Im a 14 year old teenager and is just so damn disapointig 4 me to see girls and boys at my age listening at singers that have no future at the history of music and many times some these stupid singers may cover a song like limp bizkit covered behind blue eyes from the who and they should be killed 4 that and wheni tell them hey that song is from another band or singer they say that the cover is better that the orignal wthout even heaing it...Dear god dont make me grow with people with no ambitio
From a huge Pear Jam fan, Seether have done this song justice. It will never be as good as the original IMO but if it brings Pearl Jam to the attention of "the kids of today" then that is only a good thing. Kudos Guys.
From a huge Pear Jam fan, Seether have done this song justice. It will never be as good as the original IMO but if it brings Pearl Jam to the attention of "the kids of today" then that is only a good thing. Kudos Guys.
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT something bad will happen. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS ACTUALLY WORKS
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT something bad will happen. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS ACTUALLY WORKS
hey people shaun morgan is a very great singer no doubt about that but we need to give credit where credit is due. first of all pj wrote this freakin song and if they didnt write it then seether would have never done a cover. also that seether is a lot newer than pj so tons of kids these days dont remember who that is. its like ask them if they have heard of pj they will be like who is that ask a kid who seether oh yeah its that band that plays fine again or remedy or rise above this.
Seems like alot of people only like music because it's popular or mainstream. which kinda makes me think about the songs that you selected to pick out. but you are right. credit does need go to pearl jam. most people nowadays only listen to what's played on the radio, not what they like.
@motomania1985 pearl jam didnt actually write this song. they covered it from someone else. i cant think of who though. but that is true, i love seether and pearl jam. two of the best man
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
@motomania1985 when you say seether i think of tongue, tied my hands, mostly the acoustic stuff. and i love pearl jam, people's main reason for doing covers are they are trying to say something with there music, but there is a song already out there that perfectly describes how they are feeling. i dont think you should try and to demeaner a band for cdoverin another song....js
@motomania1985 What do you mean, give credit where it is due?
No one claims that Seether wrote this song. It is credited as a Pearl Jam cover. As for kids not knowing who Pearl Jam is, you must be hanging around some retarted ass kids... There is no doubt, Pearl Jam is MUCH MUCH bigger and popular than Seether.
lol at people saying this band did a better job at this song than pearl jam when its their song. immorality is a sacred song which is why pj doesnt play it live by them all that often. most likely its a song eddie wrote dedicated to kurt cobain even though its never been confirmed. but to say seether showed more emotion or the instruments are better means that you have no idea about p.j. and youre basing your opinion just because you heard this first. still a decent cover but not close to the pj
@blueshirts41 see, now, you're the kinda person that i like on youtube. you actually take into consideration the fact that people are either huge fans of this band (like me), they are huge fans of Pearl Jam, or they are arrogant fucking fruit loops. I do like this version better, because i like Shaun's Voice, but i am in no way saying it is better, because of the obvious reason, that Pearl Jam wrote the song.
@blueshirts41 good cover, at first I thought it was arron lewis the singer who covered pearl jams other song black.. when eddie vedder sings this song its more haunting, his voice is no comparison to other singers..
i understand that pj pioneered this song and i respect that but honestly i think seether made it better. seethers version has more sadness in it and shauns voice is better suited for this type of song. his voice makes the song soothing and gives a gentler touch, especially when he says immortality. i admit that im probably closer to seethers version because i listened to theirs first but i still think they improved upon the original in many ways.
@blueshirts41 You can't really say that they don't play it that much live. According to the PJ website, they played it 126 times live. I agree with everything else, but they played the hell out of that song 1996-2003 & have only played a few times each year since.
Listen Open up your mind into the realm of seether embrace the notes that are played this guy is beyond unbelieveable i can't seem to get anyother band to like besides this one
seether is defently the best i liked the name sarin gas better its stuped how they had to restrict there name when they came to america good song good band
if you don't like it, don't watch it. simple as that. everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but i don't need any stupid ass comments like that. k thnx bai
damn dude. Instead of talking shit about an incredible band, you should prolly go to the fuckin gym and work out, Have u seen your belly dude?? It's reallll hard to miss
I do enjoy eddie vedder singing but I just like Seethers version better and I like playing it on guitar because the guitar really sets the sumber attitude of the song
hey, none of that in here lol both Shaun Morgan and Kurt Cobain are my idols cuz they both have inspired me to start playing guitar and singing and writing music but you ARE titled to your own opinion. thank you for the comment ^^
Even though morgan has a very simmilar vocal style to kobain doesn't mean he can't go right ahead and give it hell. Kobain f...ed-out and it's his fault. I like that vocal style and at least it's darker than chaddy boy.
I dont think its really necessary unless you really want to, cause others have it on, it would just be a waste of your time and computer usage I guess. But its totally your call, I love Seether so im good either way :P
Definately mate. I would like that.. or if you torrented it.. Been looking for a good copy for ages. I would buy it, but I can't get it where I live.. even Fopp don't sell it.....
it is on the abulm one cold night all acoustic covers and yes this is a cover of pearl jam
monster314 6 days ago
Great fucking guitar
TheFan2004 2 weeks ago
Where is this song from? It's not from any of the official albums, is it? I have them all and I swear I never heard it before!
cotitabene 4 weeks ago
@cotitabene It's off of their live acoustic album, I'm pretty sure it's an official album. I got it at walmart a long time ago. The album is called "One Cold Night"
GirFreak113 3 weeks ago
@cotitabene its a cover of pearl jam song immortality;)
kylebujinkan 6 days ago
@cotitabene It's a cover. Original by pearl jam
DanielBL980 10 hours ago
Comment removed
jmmoyar 1 month ago
the pearl jam version is better
smullendoremusic 2 months ago 3
@smullendoremusic desy this is a cover, u've got to admit it's a good one, yeeeaaaahhhh jajaja!!
mist2701 1 month ago
@mist2701 no yeeah its good but pearl jams is still better
smullendoremusic 1 month ago
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhh. Pearl Jam and Seether <3
pearljamgirl08 2 months ago
I feel like slapping all these people on here asking who this band is ! WOW ! I've been listening to Seether for over 8 years now ! They are amazing.
KevMait76 2 months ago
@KevMait76 Lmao it's pretty sad if they can't figure it out, I have the band name in the title XD Unless they're wondering who did the original O.o
GirFreak113 2 months ago
well,i feel like i heard this guy before, did he sing in another band or something?
levilisko 4 months ago
@levilisko there is a song named "broken" seether, feat amy lee from evanescence maybe you heard that..
panagiotisMit 3 months ago
fantastic cover...
youlivewhatyoulearn 4 months ago
tocan chido pero hay algo familiar con el grupo nirvana en ellos y es un poco la vos pero suena chido
chingon330 4 months ago
Comment removed
MrWesley916 4 months ago
I have to give credit to PJ for writing this song,I have been a fan of them for a very long time but I honestly have to say that this is one of those songs in my opinon where I like the Cover better than the Original.Both PJ and Seether have amazing songs and both are written and performed with amazing Emotion.
LJMProject 5 months ago
I bet this is how Pearl Jam would sound if Eddie Vedder had done enough heroin to make him completely numb.
kashiark 5 months ago
@kashiark you think the lead singer does heroin?
popper504 4 months ago
The original just sounds sloppy and emotionless compared to this cover, imao.
JonEldred 5 months ago
...Am I the only one who loves Seether but hates Nirvana? :(
TakinYoCup 5 months ago
@TakinYoCup u cant hate nirvana, honestly im not the greatest fan of nirvana but nirvana "Helped" the post gruge alternative era in music. Seether posibly could have never formed without nirvana. Shaun Morgan even said that nirvana was an influence in his music, which is y he also did covers of "Heart Shaped Box" and "Something in the Way" that are by nirvana. You can dislike there music but u cant hate them. Just ask yourself whats better, Nirvana or Justin Beiber
edfen7 5 months ago
@TakinYoCup Nope.
JonEldred 5 months ago
RIP KURT COBAIN...
Holier than thou, how?
Surrendered...executed anyhow
Scrawl dissolved, cigar box on the floor...
LoveYourEnemyMat544 6 months ago in playlist songs2
jesus fucking christ YES Pearl Jam wrote this amazing song and perform it beautifly but just beacuse another band originally wrote it,sang it etc EVERYBODY MUST prefer it? well i am sorry i love PJ but Seether is an amazing band and shaun is unbelievably talented,an amazing song writter and i adore this version
SheenaAlexis 6 months ago
awesome music! i love it. :D
MrEnxada 6 months ago
seether is that one band the comes along and makes me remember how great 90s music was.they would of fit in so well during the grunge scene
aidan669 6 months ago
a rare case where the cover is better than the original.....give pj credit for writting it give seether credit for making it sound a hell of alot better
aidan669 6 months ago 5
@aidan669 no.
omegalen 5 months ago
you people think you know seether so well, your all bullshit why do you think bands play eachothers songs its the respect so stop disrespect bands that have more talent then you could ever dream of having so stop the fuckin bitching and let seether do what they do best
bjdm92 8 months ago
for some reason this song reminds me of the song running blind from godsmack...... but this is way better
DeadNightmare777 8 months ago
seether did pearl jam justice with this song.....this sounds amazing and ur a liar or need a better taste in music if u say otherwise.
skywarior35 8 months ago
I KNEW I RECOGNIZED THAT SONG'S SOUND :D
-Realized after i finished the video that this was that song by Pearl Jam-
-Just read the comments.- >>' so i wasnt the only one who noticed, huh?
WxIxZEGUY 8 months ago
... is it so wrong for a band to do a cover, and not have evey comment be about the original vs. cover?
I like this song, and i love with with seether playing it. I was never a fan of P.J. simply cuz i'm never in the mood for their brand of music. Seether is a bit more my speed thats all o.o
WxIxZEGUY 8 months ago
bla bla bla
provst85 9 months ago
can't anyone accept a good song for a good song? who cares who wrote it as long as someone does it justice and doesn't destroy it.
screaminhappyness 9 months ago
@screaminhappyness How can that be? If the people who wrote didn't then anyone else do it justice? I'd say those wrote it matter very much so as to warrant a care.
Missleanneiscool 9 months ago
wait i'm confused on why people are fighting over this song, bands do covers all the time..?
hehJess 10 months ago
@hehJess well, that's because some people are elitist assholes, and fancy themselves experts. I would ignore them. They're not worth the time.
Pantallicadeth 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
16 omg he hasn't even begun to live yet...cute though..
honeyb237 11 months ago
16? ha..hasn't even begun to live yet...cut though...
honeyb237 11 months ago
both versions are equal. Arguing about which is better is just fuckin stupid, they are not performed in the same way. PJ's original is magical, but Seether put much passion in the cover. And PJ's fans always will say PJ's version is better, the same way as Seether fans will say about the cover.
Writing "Seether raped this song" is just fuckin' lame. It's just a bit different version, and that's all.
jaaasiek 1 year ago 4
Sorry, kid. Pearl Jam. Seether raped this song.
Badnewsbroad 1 year ago
loveeeee
Emilyxxlou 1 year ago
the begining is b.a
sarahpage01 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
x13xteenagersx19 1 year ago
well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
x13xteenagersx19 1 year ago 64
@x13xteenagersx19 *Thumbs Up* haha
GirFreak113 1 year ago 9
@x13xteenagersx19 What you said seems to be an unfair generalization.
Pearl Jam is as antagonistic of a mainstream band as you will find.
They were one of the biggest bands of the nineties and are still very popular.
There is speculation that this song was intended as a tribute to the late Kurt Cobain, though Eddie Vedder never confirmed it.
Kurt and Eddie both were huge influences on Seether and Shaun Morgan in particular.
He performed a great cover of the song and it was well received.
anjansullimada 8 months ago
@x13xteenagersx19
very adult response for 16.
InReaperWeTrust 7 months ago
best cover song ever love seether version better
ROCKSTAR3788 1 year ago
Once a Seether fan always a Seether fan!! :) great job on this cover!! (:
austinreich75 1 year ago
i was born in 1993 and still, the first version i heard was pj's.just now i learned that this cover existed and checked it out immediately.pj made the song immortal for me, it inspires me to my every cell when i hear it.seether did an effin good job too though.i luv them both <33333333
amystaridol 1 year ago
Im a 14 year old teenager and is just so damn disapointig 4 me to see girls and boys at my age listening at singers that have no future at the history of music and many times some these stupid singers may cover a song like limp bizkit covered behind blue eyes from the who and they should be killed 4 that and wheni tell them hey that song is from another band or singer they say that the cover is better that the orignal wthout even heaing it...Dear god dont make me grow with people with no ambitio
OctaVIouZz 1 year ago
A pretty decent cover by seether but pearl jam the original is always the best..
crs78 1 year ago
From a huge Pear Jam fan, Seether have done this song justice. It will never be as good as the original IMO but if it brings Pearl Jam to the attention of "the kids of today" then that is only a good thing. Kudos Guys.
Richstory1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
From a huge Pear Jam fan, Seether have done this song justice. It will never be as good as the original IMO but if it brings Pearl Jam to the attention of "the kids of today" then that is only a good thing. Kudos Guys.
Richstory1 1 year ago
Pearl Jam!!
ElKreteno 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT something bad will happen. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS ACTUALLY WORKS
EhNois110PorCento 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT something bad will happen. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS ACTUALLY WORKS
EhNois110PorCento 1 year ago
Good, but not Pearl Jam good. Eddy Vedder just has something nobody can touch.
jld1532 1 year ago
nice!!! but i prefer Eddie Vedder.... ;))
zepeK13 1 year ago
Seether's cover is way better!
egg1997usa 1 year ago
hey people shaun morgan is a very great singer no doubt about that but we need to give credit where credit is due. first of all pj wrote this freakin song and if they didnt write it then seether would have never done a cover. also that seether is a lot newer than pj so tons of kids these days dont remember who that is. its like ask them if they have heard of pj they will be like who is that ask a kid who seether oh yeah its that band that plays fine again or remedy or rise above this.
motomania1985 1 year ago 6
Seems like alot of people only like music because it's popular or mainstream. which kinda makes me think about the songs that you selected to pick out. but you are right. credit does need go to pearl jam. most people nowadays only listen to what's played on the radio, not what they like.
GirFreak113 1 year ago 3
i'm agree with you
mimine390 1 year ago
@GirFreak113 radio plays mainstream bullshit all day randomly are there any good bands on
cypheron0 1 year ago
@motomania1985 pearl jam didnt actually write this song. they covered it from someone else. i cant think of who though. but that is true, i love seether and pearl jam. two of the best man
hawnat56 1 year ago
@hawnat56 Wrong.
jld1532 1 year ago
@hawnat56 go buy the vitalogy album by pearl jam all lyrics wrriten by pearl jam, its not a cover get you facts right.
crs78 1 year ago
@motomania1985 whos pj?
theunthinkable1 1 year ago
@theunthinkable1 pearl jam
TheMutner 1 year ago
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
x13xteenagersx19 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
x13xteenagersx19 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@motomania1985 well i find that very untrue im only 16 and i knew who seether was when i was 14 and i knew who pearl jam was when i was like 12 or 13 i cant really remember but it is very true pearl jam does deserve the credit but seether is not mainstream... i feel mainstream is more of a way of saying the band is out to earn money and nothing els but seether does play there songs with heart he writes all of them and the ones they cover normally mean some thing to them so it sounds great to.
x13xteenagersx19 1 year ago
@motomania1985 when you say seether i think of tongue, tied my hands, mostly the acoustic stuff. and i love pearl jam, people's main reason for doing covers are they are trying to say something with there music, but there is a song already out there that perfectly describes how they are feeling. i dont think you should try and to demeaner a band for cdoverin another song....js
joelrogers90 10 months ago
@motomania1985 What do you mean, give credit where it is due?
No one claims that Seether wrote this song. It is credited as a Pearl Jam cover. As for kids not knowing who Pearl Jam is, you must be hanging around some retarted ass kids... There is no doubt, Pearl Jam is MUCH MUCH bigger and popular than Seether.
anjansullimada 8 months ago
Funny, how mad people getting, when you say you like Seethers version more.
I think the original is great but I like Shauns voice more.
xDarkBloodAngelx 2 years ago
Eddies voice matches better to that song i think
v130pc46 2 years ago
look i have nothing aganst pj i like some of their music but i like seether version better from the voice to the emothing everything just my openion
CUZZO06 2 years ago
lol at people saying this band did a better job at this song than pearl jam when its their song. immorality is a sacred song which is why pj doesnt play it live by them all that often. most likely its a song eddie wrote dedicated to kurt cobain even though its never been confirmed. but to say seether showed more emotion or the instruments are better means that you have no idea about p.j. and youre basing your opinion just because you heard this first. still a decent cover but not close to the pj
blueshirts41 2 years ago
@blueshirts41 see, now, you're the kinda person that i like on youtube. you actually take into consideration the fact that people are either huge fans of this band (like me), they are huge fans of Pearl Jam, or they are arrogant fucking fruit loops. I do like this version better, because i like Shaun's Voice, but i am in no way saying it is better, because of the obvious reason, that Pearl Jam wrote the song.
GirFreak113 2 years ago 4
@GirFreak113 stfu xD
dudejude1221 1 year ago
@blueshirts41 good cover, at first I thought it was arron lewis the singer who covered pearl jams other song black.. when eddie vedder sings this song its more haunting, his voice is no comparison to other singers..
crs78 1 year ago
i understand that pj pioneered this song and i respect that but honestly i think seether made it better. seethers version has more sadness in it and shauns voice is better suited for this type of song. his voice makes the song soothing and gives a gentler touch, especially when he says immortality. i admit that im probably closer to seethers version because i listened to theirs first but i still think they improved upon the original in many ways.
nightwatch1203 11 months ago
@blueshirts41 You can't really say that they don't play it that much live. According to the PJ website, they played it 126 times live. I agree with everything else, but they played the hell out of that song 1996-2003 & have only played a few times each year since.
SidCaeser 7 months ago
Pearl Jam is better
cougcheetah 2 years ago
@cougcheetah Well they DID make the song.
GirFreak113 2 years ago
@cougcheetah i like it better from seether :)
stamxx1100 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sounds like he's trying to crunch a loaf while recording this song.
Take a shit before you try to cover a great song!
buddymac123 2 years ago
@buddymac123 its great mate
stamxx1100 2 years ago
go home.
shut up.
grow up.
simple
Skepsis0Metal 2 years ago
Listen Open up your mind into the realm of seether embrace the notes that are played this guy is beyond unbelieveable i can't seem to get anyother band to like besides this one
Zyanaster 2 years ago
seether is defently the best i liked the name sarin gas better its stuped how they had to restrict there name when they came to america good song good band
x13xteenagersx19 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this version is shit, the vocalist is shit and this band is fucking utter crap.
Dan2529 2 years ago
if you don't like it, don't watch it. simple as that. everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but i don't need any stupid ass comments like that. k thnx bai
GirFreak113 2 years ago
damn dude. Instead of talking shit about an incredible band, you should prolly go to the fuckin gym and work out, Have u seen your belly dude?? It's reallll hard to miss
eeffoooo 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this band is hell shit mainstream crap you need to fuckin neck up and discover the underground cunt. start with 'outlaw order' now fuck up kid
Dan2529 2 years ago
you've deff. got some issues of yours to work out boy. haha Im sure that "fuck up" don't mean anything lol
eeffoooo 2 years ago
i do listen to underground shithead. this is the first band i ever herad that i actually liked. don't really like underground though.
GirFreak113 2 years ago
I don't like Pearl Jam...however Seether is my favorite band.
piscesguy92 2 years ago
Pearl Jam is good too? Are you kidding? They not only wrote the song, but perform it so much better. Anyway, to each his own. Great song
SwallowPoison 2 years ago 13
yea pearl jam is good too....
wowfreak243 2 years ago
omg then i see the point too lol
wowfreak243 2 years ago
Good song, Pearl jams is alot better
joshbfat 2 years ago
guys why are we arguing about shaun v kurt when they both where equal? they are inspirations, so why argue, when they are both unbelievably great!?
origindirewolf 2 years ago 3
thank you for seeing my point ^ ^
GirFreak113 2 years ago
Shaun Morgan and Kurt Cobain are my idols as well and both inspired me to play and write as well
postel90 2 years ago 7
love this song!
KingD628 2 years ago 4
I do enjoy eddie vedder singing but I just like Seethers version better and I like playing it on guitar because the guitar really sets the sumber attitude of the song
austindemented 2 years ago
i know he is a legend but i really prefer shaun:)
sunLovingCreature 2 years ago 2
shaun is better than kobain. in my opinion
sunLovingCreature 2 years ago
hey, none of that in here lol both Shaun Morgan and Kurt Cobain are my idols cuz they both have inspired me to start playing guitar and singing and writing music but you ARE titled to your own opinion. thank you for the comment ^^
GirFreak113 2 years ago
oops...i mean cobain not kobain:D
sunLovingCreature 2 years ago
lol woot!
GirFreak113 2 years ago
iunno man thats a tought one :P i agree everyone has there opinion.. kobain is a legend though
GOCHARAGO 2 years ago
cover?
1mpak7 2 years ago
I like at how the end you clearly hear the audience say "good choice" and "good shit." :D
squirrellyme 2 years ago
i don't like the PearlJam version, but this is great.
and real rare can't get a good version from limewire.
Titus9Racing 2 years ago
if you have msn i'll add you and send it to you lol
GirFreak113 2 years ago
Even though morgan has a very simmilar vocal style to kobain doesn't mean he can't go right ahead and give it hell. Kobain f...ed-out and it's his fault. I like that vocal style and at least it's darker than chaddy boy.
SuperGreengrocer 2 years ago 2
Only seether pull off covering a pearl jam song.
cvxzshmw 2 years ago
this song makes me cry
TdGaNgEl 2 years ago 2
I dont think its really necessary unless you really want to, cause others have it on, it would just be a waste of your time and computer usage I guess. But its totally your call, I love Seether so im good either way :P
Gdragon09 3 years ago
lol sweet
GirFreak113 3 years ago
I honestly like this more, just preference still love the PJ version. Just like the new tone of it:P
Gdragon09 3 years ago 2
same here dude. i was thinking about recording this whole dvd and putting it up bit idk if i should. what do u think?
GirFreak113 3 years ago
Definately mate. I would like that.. or if you torrented it.. Been looking for a good copy for ages. I would buy it, but I can't get it where I live.. even Fopp don't sell it.....
BloomerzUK 3 years ago
seether underated , one of the best
LATINHOMMIE 3 years ago 2
seether did this song so much better than pearl jam this is one of my favorite seether songs
CUZZO06 3 years ago
Pearl Jam's is far superior! but definitely a great version
NothinGBetteRPJMaN 3 years ago
I enjoy this version much better
HellspawnedPsychosis 3 years ago
nice song I don,t think they released this song in audio did they?
monster314 3 years ago
this is just a cover of a pearl jam song. it's one of my favorite of their covers.
GirFreak113 3 years ago