This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Sisely is fake, she's not sensitive! Carah have angelic voice, i will always miss her in Shiny! But she's still making music, Versant's EP is very good!
I absolutely adore this song. I'm thinking about singing it for the school choir concert, but it's pretty obvious that my voice will be NOTHING compared to Carah's =]
carah faye will always be STG vocalist. They dont even exist w/o her anymore. I hope her new Swedish band (yay for my Swedes!) is just as good if not better (Versant).
@PopCulture20 well that's YOUR opinion! i think all of their music is awesome! and not too gothic... but what can i expect when your name is popculture...
Shiny toy guns aren't that great anymore. I have to agree with ya Rhonnie. Faye's Vocals were extremely great, and the lyrics to there songs on the first album had so much more meaning. Maybe it's because Faye was the song writer =^.^=
I think Sisley is not the "problem". I think many fans don't like it that they change the group like they want. And i think Carah was the key to get famous all over the world. With Sisley they get only US maybe UK.
Agreed. I love how when Carah left, they like DROPPED off the face of the earth for a while. and now, they're slowly coming back with sisely...but they have a long road ahead of them, now that Carah's gone. And as for Versant...it's already amazing. I'm just waiting for them to be more famous than STG is. Im gonna laugh too.
why the hell did Carah leave she was brill we all obvz want her back dont we? yer the new singers good but think how much more fans they'd have if Carah was still in singing there new (epic) songs like ricochet i would love stg to re-do it with carah singing instead it would sound so so so so so much better
Okay. I do miss Carah but I also like Sisley. She's no Carah, but there's nothing wrong with her! They have different voices. Carah's more rock and screamo while Sisley is more alternative and contemporary. Well both could fall under contemporary, but thax besides the point. Everyone seems to be forgetting CHAD! He has an AMAZING voice and blows both out the water, and he (in my opinion) makes STG what they are, along with they're INSANE band. Carah did not and does not make the band.
0:16 the guy on the far left is really hot..no effin joke...i've just recently got in2 these guys & they're good...carah faye Charnow made them sound really amazing...so haters..STFU!!!
Wow im going to have to totally disagree with you there... Carah has such a unique voice.. its amazing.. Sisley's is just like any other.. in plus Carah is wayyyy better live
I agree, Sisley's voice is made for a song like this. I don't see why everyone hates Sisley. To me their voices are incomparable. Carah has her style and Sisley has hers. Carah has been out of STG for awhile now and everyone needs to just stop bitching about it because it's not going to change anything.
Left ! I dont think they wanted her back for the rumors I heard that she was dating someone with in the band staff which was bad career move there popularity may have dropped off but they dont care thier about the music the band doesnt want the drama or the BS but you can bet they learned from this .
@RhonnieRach Chad and Jeremy are Shiny Toy Guns; they write all the music. Carah's departure from the band had nothing to do with the change in their sound. Sisely and Carah are just simple singers who have no real impact on their music.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Shut the hell up and learn how to type "Sisley is so much bad"? Your typing is as bad as you think she is. And how about you try and sing Ricochet? Oh thats right of course you wont because you suck! Your no better than Sisley
what the fuck is this shit?
dobadriver 1 month ago
a la mierda con esto !!
soygenialxd 2 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Shiny Toy Guns
Very sad Carah wasn't in the band when they decided to put this on the album. This version is way better.
ccantu32film 2 months ago
I love this song. I thought it was uncalled for when STG remade this song with Sisley. This is CARAH'S SONG.
HachaJiuJitsu 3 months ago
wtf is this??????
xSupernova92x 3 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Shiny Toy Guns
@xSupernova92x This Is A Song....
Deany92 3 months ago 6
its funny i always find all my favorite songs by accident. I found this one at the end of a soul eater photo slideshow, = )
pirateZevelyn 3 months ago
She's so beautiful. <3
GuiltyRain 4 months ago 2
@GuiltyRain You are right. Carah is beautiful!
BigBronco7 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello, I like your video of Carah, I did one, if you stop by my channel to see it, a hug and Shiny toy gun is best.
MATIDELAJUVE 5 months ago
aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaa
analixta 5 months ago
it's okay Carah is back.
Crucibella1 6 months ago 3
I don't know which version I have, but I want this one. Anywhere I might find?
myungoong 6 months ago
I luv the shiny toy guns, there album is on my i pod.
FLUNKTHETRUNK 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fucking change the title. Shiny Toy Guns is Carah Faye, shit.
inxyTrolls 9 months ago
@inxyTrolls Calm Down Asshole...I'll Change It Now.
Deany92 9 months ago 15
This has been flagged as spam show
@Deany92 - yeah that's right, do what the fuck I say.
inxyTrolls 9 months ago
CARAH IS BACK!
car852 9 months ago 18
@car852 LIKE LIKE LIKE LIE LIKE LIKE LOOOOOOVEEE!!!!!!! :D :D :D :D
KellyJello 9 months ago
i need this song!! how can i get it?? i cant find it anywhere
AtieO 11 months ago
@AtieO
If you would like, I can email it to you (that is, if you haven't found it by now)!
Iglaoavrea 10 months ago
Yea its official, Carah is back with Shiny Toy Guns, I just checked out their my space page, totally awesome!
bevyp66 1 year ago 2
the new girl isn't even pretty, did you see how they had to animate their video to make her pretty? she's horrible!! NOBODY COMPARES TO CARAH FAYE!!!
crayzee128 1 year ago
Carah is back in shiny toy guns now
bigmike690069 1 year ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sisely is fake, she's not sensitive! Carah have angelic voice, i will always miss her in Shiny! But she's still making music, Versant's EP is very good!
cormodac 1 year ago
@cormodac You kind of sound childish.
darkhaven33 1 month ago
i like them both but why did they even get a new singer in the first place?
coolbrandon92 1 year ago
Carah is STG
RAWRitsApples 1 year ago 4
hmm. honestly, sisely's version is better.
simplelikesnow 1 year ago
love her! such a blessing to the music industry!
perfectgurl1985 1 year ago
I absolutely adore this song. I'm thinking about singing it for the school choir concert, but it's pretty obvious that my voice will be NOTHING compared to Carah's =]
<333
Milky827 1 year ago
carah faye will always be STG vocalist. They dont even exist w/o her anymore. I hope her new Swedish band (yay for my Swedes!) is just as good if not better (Versant).
pdpMASTERP 1 year ago 6
this is my happy song (:
ohokjulia 1 year ago
YOU'RE THE GIRL IN MY FANTASY!!
Avenged3000 1 year ago
I personally think ''You Are the One'' was Shiny Toy Gun's best work. The rest of their music is too gothic!!!!!
PopCulture20 1 year ago
@PopCulture20 well that's YOUR opinion! i think all of their music is awesome! and not too gothic... but what can i expect when your name is popculture...
KatieandTyler 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Go check out Versant, Carah's new band. CD out this fall 2010.
f89276704 1 year ago
2 people accidentally clicked the dislike button..
ohokjulia 1 year ago
where can i get this song for free?
aliceduke94 1 year ago
This music is great. I hate their emo-ish stuff.
Treemeadow 1 year ago
Shiny toy guns aren't that great anymore. I have to agree with ya Rhonnie. Faye's Vocals were extremely great, and the lyrics to there songs on the first album had so much more meaning. Maybe it's because Faye was the song writer =^.^=
euroxavi1 1 year ago 2
STG fucking sucks without Carah. I can't wait 'till Versant's new album in june!
CameronHaroSaleen 1 year ago
@CameronHaroSaleen Mid-Sept 2010 now. Just sayin.
f89276704 1 year ago
Ursula Vari was a hit n miss
I really liked Carah Faye
Siseley is good but I prefer like Carah of Ursula
snowwhitessorrow1 2 years ago
I know. Carah is just....... ahhhhhhhhh whyyyyyyyyyyyyyy whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy D: she was perfect.
bnormal320 2 years ago 5
word... Versant just isnt wat STG used to be... if they ever got back together i would do a backflip (i cant) but one can only hope :_(
yelsew136 1 year ago
I'm glad she started Versant :D
I will follow her everywhere!! hahaha
jingri 2 years ago 5
Great girl.
She is hot.
Great voice.
And she is one of a kind.
What happened? Why do they have the Sisly chick anyway?
VictoriiR14 2 years ago 2
Sisley is an ugly bitch.
AcidSkater2008 2 years ago
lol i just found that hilarious for some reason =]
she is a good singer but no one will ever replace carah =[
luke9308 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
well all out, sisley is wayyy cooolerrrr i fucking got into a conversation with her and was left the concert like Damn shes kewl
shizzzbiscuit 2 years ago
I think Sisley is not the "problem". I think many fans don't like it that they change the group like they want. And i think Carah was the key to get famous all over the world. With Sisley they get only US maybe UK.
kingdomatthi 2 years ago 6
Agreed. I love how when Carah left, they like DROPPED off the face of the earth for a while. and now, they're slowly coming back with sisely...but they have a long road ahead of them, now that Carah's gone. And as for Versant...it's already amazing. I'm just waiting for them to be more famous than STG is. Im gonna laugh too.
lovehatehero32932 2 years ago
wow! i knew this song was too good to be sisleys. haha. she's a good singer, but her lyrics arent all too good
starterrn 2 years ago
she sings it way better then sisely.
xloserface09 2 years ago 4
this song is on season of poison, so therefore not carah
lemonpop4u 2 years ago
Actually this IS Carah. This song was on the original We Are Pilots. The one available now doesnt have it.
boomanracing 2 years ago
Comment removed
pat2icia 2 years ago
Do at least 5 minutes of research and you will find that this song was on the old WE ARE PILOTS early versions.
ShauxShaman 2 years ago
Sounds like something from the 1980s
mediblue9 2 years ago 3
why the hell did Carah leave she was brill we all obvz want her back dont we? yer the new singers good but think how much more fans they'd have if Carah was still in singing there new (epic) songs like ricochet i would love stg to re-do it with carah singing instead it would sound so so so so so much better
<3xxwe love carahxx<3
blooddrinka 2 years ago 2
ive got no problem with Sisely singing this but I like Carah's because hers sounds strong to me and it just seems better to me.I love Caraah's voice.
aliceduke94 2 years ago 5
Okay. I do miss Carah but I also like Sisley. She's no Carah, but there's nothing wrong with her! They have different voices. Carah's more rock and screamo while Sisley is more alternative and contemporary. Well both could fall under contemporary, but thax besides the point. Everyone seems to be forgetting CHAD! He has an AMAZING voice and blows both out the water, and he (in my opinion) makes STG what they are, along with they're INSANE band. Carah did not and does not make the band.
Devon4rmdaA 2 years ago
0:16 the guy on the far left is really hot..no effin joke...i've just recently got in2 these guys & they're good...carah faye Charnow made them sound really amazing...so haters..STFU!!!
MegaHeyheyhey1234 2 years ago
Sisley Tresure's good for this song
ps. people under my comment are fag's
if there is a shiny toy gun member ur not fag's
gabekid123 2 years ago
every tattoo on her body is hot
MYJESUSROCKS 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow sisley's version is alot better.
xsetht 2 years ago
Wow im going to have to totally disagree with you there... Carah has such a unique voice.. its amazing.. Sisley's is just like any other.. in plus Carah is wayyyy better live
fatal3rr0r727 2 years ago 8
i know. i like carah too. but this song isn't right for her. she sounds a lot better in her new band(:
xsetht 2 years ago
I agree, Sisley's voice is made for a song like this. I don't see why everyone hates Sisley. To me their voices are incomparable. Carah has her style and Sisley has hers. Carah has been out of STG for awhile now and everyone needs to just stop bitching about it because it's not going to change anything.
loser1luver 2 years ago 2
wow she is so hot i think her eyes are amazing......
i like her music and when she was with shiny toy guns
hothooker12 2 years ago 3
OHYESBLINK182ISBACK!!
carah is best PERIOD!
appleshampoo91 2 years ago
i love carah, she is so amazing. From her good looks to her incredible voice.
nakiommi 2 years ago 7
lol her big juicy eyes are awesome! XD
1000PelvicThrusts 2 years ago
lol
jacob112291 2 years ago 2
i love carah
this is my favorite version
lalalatdwp 2 years ago
Shiny Toy What"s?
I was there for Carah!
dutchboy25al 2 years ago 10
I prefer the other version, it's not the singer but the other subtle differances.
AnthraxMuffin 2 years ago
i definatly love carah, she`s got a pretty unique sound to her. i hate that she left/got kicked out of (?) STG.
But my god, has anyone else noticed how BIG her eyes are? lol.
sammySugx 2 years ago 7
yes i did <3 her eyes are soooo pretty :) shes cute
Ilovebeautifulsongs 2 years ago
wow. I can see why everyone freaked when Carah left. Both singers have their ups and downs.
And the pic at 1:45 is amazing. You guys can't deny that!
fremmenista 2 years ago 2
i think i heard the demo version of this becase my version sounds way diffrent than both the we are pilots' and season of poison.
weirdtard2 3 years ago
When she sang Le disko for shiny toy guns..
It was awesome!! and really sexy. lol
awmynamewastaken 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
CHAD STILL RULES
HE IS SHINY TOY GUNS
ajkpchee1 3 years ago
How do you figure?
Carah Is way better than the new girl
RhonnieRach 3 years ago 40
Wll, i think that Shiny Toy Gun's popularity dropped dramatically when carah faye letf :[
I loved her!
She was amazing!
The new girl is OKAY but she could never compare with carah faye.
I LOVE CARAH FAYE'S VOICE!!! ^-^
RhonnieRach 3 years ago 80
@RhonnieRach
Left ! I dont think they wanted her back for the rumors I heard that she was dating someone with in the band staff which was bad career move there popularity may have dropped off but they dont care thier about the music the band doesnt want the drama or the BS but you can bet they learned from this .
pagemaster36 1 year ago
@pagemaster36 She just married Dan Johansson from Versant, they met on tour. He was never in Shiny Toy Guns.
crayzee128 1 year ago
@RhonnieRach weel u have your wish shes back
MAJORp121 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@RhonnieRach well u have your wish shes back
MAJORp121 1 year ago
@RhonnieRach isn't Carah coming back tho?
Tweakedunique 1 year ago
@RhonnieRach Chad and Jeremy are Shiny Toy Guns; they write all the music. Carah's departure from the band had nothing to do with the change in their sound. Sisely and Carah are just simple singers who have no real impact on their music.
diznick 11 months ago
Carah and sisley are both individually talented. There is no need to compare them
bitchiteen 3 years ago 4
carah's version is so much better than sisely's!!!!!!!!!!!
LynZ1995 3 years ago 13
wow Carah is the shitt!! so Kick ass...her voice is flawless...
VikkiFReagan 3 years ago 6
I played the new version of this and this one at the same time for fun lol. sounds very different. both are great tho.
ShinyToyGuns101 3 years ago
it's tone deaf dumbass not tone death.
benny92n 3 years ago 4
this version is so much better. i love carah. and this song with her voice
sisley is so much bad. i hate sisley
Schnuwi 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shut the hell up and learn how to type "Sisley is so much bad"? Your typing is as bad as you think she is. And how about you try and sing Ricochet? Oh thats right of course you wont because you suck! Your no better than Sisley
deidara1art1bang 3 years ago
"Your no better" -> You're...
RonJ012 3 years ago
Yeah, and considering Sisley sucks the hind tit of a donkey, that's pretty bad.
jwhiteout 3 years ago 10