The Doctor Donna Tribute #1: Happy Ending

[Deliverater]

Donna's only feelings for the doctor were ones of friendship and his were the same for her.... She didn't deserve her ending

[boobabycluebaby2]

Still makes me cry years later.

[IHeartsDrummers]

That video was super good and I love this song! It fits them really well, even better than Doctor/Rose which I would like to make a video for.

[LuluCarson]

Awww, great job! Poor Donna, she got the worst ending out of any of the recent comapions. She was his best friend, someone to balance him out when he needed it. She was the companion who never thought she was anything special and in a way, that's part of what made her so fantastic. I hope they bring her back, even if it's just for a guest appearance. I'd even be satisfied with him going back just to check on her at this point.

[UnbekanntesPferd90]

I actually managed to keep it together until the last 20 seconds or so. Then... sry, got to find some tissues.

This vid is awesome.

[Janiqua]

Do you remember Donna's first appearance in the Christmas Invasion? Who would have ever thought that loud obnoxious bride would go on to become one of the Doctor's most beloved companions of all time? Thanks for making this video. It brought tears to my eyes.

[BloodWraith687]

This is just amazing, what a brilliant song choice.

The ending is just perfect.

[kirafaye]

That scene where the grandfather open the door and the doctor says help me is so sad.

[myskin4DWDT]

I think that last s that scene Donna remembered that look on his face was his deepest love for her, as friends. I wish it was the other way around though!!!!

[marytylermoore08]

me 2!!!!!

[timetraveler900]

I swear, you almost made me cry....

[rivera2622]

I loved Donna cause she was the most ordinary and relatible of all the charecters on the show; making the experience much more magical for her and for us. Which makes her ending much more tragic.

[freethedancingllamas]

I cried so hard at the ending of this season. I feel so bad for him and her. I liked Donna so much because she thought of the Doctor as a brother. She was the only companion who didn't hit on him. DONNA, DON'T GO! WAAAH!

[bahamallama95]

i must agree, she was my favourite because she didnt cling to him the way the others did. all the hopeless romanticism from martha made me sick

[IXIrandomIXIgirlIXI]

i love the first little bit up to 0:50, i think its really powerful :)

[midvacent]

Absolutely brilliant and wonderful and apt and traumatic! Ow. I love these two. It's so sad. And there are so many awesome things to miss.

[sirius136]

I really loved that! :D nice work :)

[mindy56374]

I've watched this about six times and love it so much that I bought the song. it will forever be a doctor donna song. you did a brilliant job. thanku for this extra slice of these two together. awesome and sad.

[RedDress269]

i love this! Nearly made me cry! The song is so perfect! And I loved the way you started off with the clip from the final ep.

[XDTopGeaar]

i wish they never killed donna off or not really killed her lol. wish she could come back. was the best assistant he ever had. rose was alright when tennant first came the doctor

[bob4istheman]

it great it so good that it makes it so sad

[bob4istheman]

to sad

[elfielvr]

Well done!!!! I loved this! Sigh. I still get weepy when he wipes her mind and she falls into his arms. :(

[emmamallay]

this is so true

donnas part and the doctors

i feel bad for the doctor because everyone he loves has to leave

i also feel bad for donna because she realy realy loved him and really wanted to stay with him forever

this was the saddest season i cry that the journeys end everytime

[Rose3217]

Sayin that was brilliant would be an understatement. I could hardly breathe in those last few seconds of your vid, it was so heartbreaking what happened to Donna. The fact is what happened to Donna was far more worse then how things ended with Rose. Donna was truly the best companion honest, she was there 4 the doctor , she took no crap from any1, she was the best friend the doctor could eva have. You've done an amazing job of their relatinship and the tragedy of it all.

[AvatarRafael]

Brilliant. it just goes to say you dont need flashy effect for a great music video.

PS: you should have had the scence when donna's farther says he'll look into the stars in her place, that would have made me cry

(I was on the verge!)

[justkisha]

This song is perfect for the Doctor and Donna.

Donna was my favorite companion for the Doctor, and so this makes me cry--especially his face right before he wipes her mind. They can't leave it like that.

very good video

[adearerane]

Donna was AMAZING !!!!! I miss her :(((

nice vid

[ashleighdrummond]

This One Of My All Time fave Doctor Donna Vids, Its So Sad. I Have Dried at This So Many Times. It Really Captures How The Doctor Feels About Losing Donna.

[glosrugbylover]

great video to a great song, 5 stars

[Sshelly34213]

oh my god magnificent, faved it!

[rockonabster]

wiked series of doctor who wasnt it :D?

nice choice of song aswell it goes the way you have done it :P

[0cTheONE0]

Great video. This season of the Doctor was great but so sad too :(

[iloveyooall]

I Would LOVE Donna to meet the guy, from the libary, the one that stuttered! Then she could have her happy ending :D

[isminmizimy]

Yeah, the Doctor should go and find him for her.

[swal593868]

It's already been said, Brilliant!

First time I heard this song, love it.

[revmary]

Or if her mom treats her better, she could go to college and become an Archelogist...and perhaps find an altar in rome with her and the dr who on it...and somehow even though she can't remember, she'll find out what she did...and perhaps she's River Song? With an older doctor, another regeneration...

Her mind is just erased, she is still 1/2 timelord so...anything is possible

[swal593868]

I like your idea:)

[calitexchick94]

...that would mean she remebered and she would die... the doctor even said so.. also River looked at Donna and said, "so your Donna Noble," So she would know it was a younger her also she wouldn't be a ble to touch herself because that would create a paradox..yep

[isminmizimy]

You always make the best videos!

[takeabananatoaparty]

Oh. Just oh. I love those two. She was so wonderful, and she really helped him, y'know, when he was all emo and stuff. And in a completely platonic way.

I miss her so much. Donna was just wonderful.

[Geekerella]

I love the video. Donna was my favourite companion. I feel kind of betrayed that they ended it so that she can never come back and they didn't even give her a happy ending with that "fake husband" from The Library. All the others get to go on doing what they love. Gutted.

[TenFan89]

I'm so happy you enjoyed the video! Try to take heart in how prominently the ring was displayed in the finale. ('specially the phone scene in the kitchen) Many suspect she has been fobwatched and the timelord consciousness in her ring. If thats true there are PLENTY of ways to bring her back. *hopefully in the second or third special of 2009*

[masteraj57]

@Geekerella I find it unbelievably sad too. but I think that the BBC gets off on torturing Ten, and one way to do that is to get rid of his companions, but since Donna was one that would have no doubt stayed with the Doctor forever, they made up a different way to get rid of her. cruel bastards.

[paigehobo]

oh wow! The first vid that i watched by you was a martha tribute and so this feels oddly familiar. I can't even say how much i love that song and have for over a year, it still pulls at my heart strings. I loved donna so so much and she was such a good friend to the doctor. This video was just absolutely perfect...and i'm tearing now. poor doctor...all alone, again! :( 5/5

[FlashForeward]

Brilliant, as usual...you made me cry (which I need to do, so that's all right). I thought I was gonna hate Donna, but I'm really gonna miss her...great video.

[boobabycluebaby2]

*cries* This is brilliant. I'm just amazed at how skillfully you select the clips and set them to music.

[skubrik1]

Great video;-)

[dogcrazy10]

Aw man.

I'm crying.

I've seen a lot of DW videos with this song.

But, this is deffinatly one of the best.

[Emsiecat]

aww lovely yet really sad vid *sniff* great job^^ 5/5

[clairemmc]

I'm still gutted after how Donna ended up, but I loved this tribute to her and the Doctor. I just hope one day they Bring Back Donna!!! ;)

[lakelonely]

God - gutted - that's just the right word!

Great job TenFan89!

[ejspud]

I liked Donna after a while lol

Gr8 vid :) sad song though :( lol

[Janiqua]

Devastating. I didn't think I could cry for a companion's departure as much I did for Rose's, but with Donna... she doesn't even get to keep their memories together. She had grown so much as a character, and for what? I'm sorry, it just breaks my heart. Great video, by the way, to portray that.

[FlamingPhalanges]

This was really superb. I may be slightly biased cos not only am I a Doctor Donna fangirl, but I'm also a big huge Mika fangirl so this is perfect. Fantastically edited, really love the colouring on the flashbacks, slightly washed out but not too much, makes a nice change from the usual B+W flashbacks.

So yeah, well done, make more stuff like this cos it's really good. =]

[littlehollyleaf]

"No hope, no love, no glory, no happy ending"

Oh, so true! You broke my heart all over again, just like the show did. A wonderful tribute. Well done.

[hippogriffs95]

That made me cry!It's the first of the Donna vids that have made me cry...(largely cus I'm trying so hard not to angst...so I'm just watching brilliant tributes).Rly well made.

[smurfierthanyou]

Doctor and Donna for ever!

beautiful vid. x x x

[frangipanii]

The bit at the end of the ep where he says "DonnaI'm just going now" and she says "Yeah, ok" made me tear up... :''''''''''(

[mchun]

im crying again amazing beauiful vid

[misscynthia17]

a tear came in my eye

brilliant vid 5*

[upperatmosphere]

Fan-bloody-tastic.

[kt27rule]

i love this video it so cute and so cool. i so love this song

[HogwartsHonorRoll]

Hysterical tears.

Yes, that's right, I'm crying.

A lot.

...and now I'm going to have to go wash off all of my runny mascara.

*sigh*

This was brilliant.

That ending was killer. When he was erasing her memories...I fell apart. The music went too perfectly.

You captured these two perfectly.

Every smile, every hug, the perfect chemistry.

Glad to see the four video tribtues are back, especially if they're all going to be as brilliant as this.

[TenFan89]

Aw,thanks so much - I'm glad you enjoyed it. Their relationship was perfect because there was no unwanted sexual chemistry between the two but they had a kind of intimate connection that makes for GREAT vids.

[HogueySandwich]

I can't watch the bit where he erases Donna's memory without crying, I just can't, it's so sad.

[beathen]

This was a great video. The ending nearly made me cry! I loved the dynamic between the Doctor and Donna in season 4.

[chandramas]

I so hate you!!! you made me cry again!

this season finaly really broke my heart!

The video is perfect! 5 stars really deserved!

[kiwifromhell]

I'm crying now.

Lovely vid, captures it perfectly.

[xXluvjohnsimmXx]

Absolutely beautiful :) And this song is unexpectedly perfect for it. 5 stars! :)

[fizzytizzy]

:'(. Touching tribute. Just beautiful.

[nolaespoir]

What a beautiful and heartbreaking video. I loved it. I really did love Donna a lot, and thought her ending was the saddest thing that could've ever happened. I still cry every time I watch it, and I've watched it at least 10 times I'm sure. Something about it just always makes me tear up. Your song choice was beautiful and I adored this video. I will miss Donna :( 5* and favorited.

[englishstudent01]

beautiful perfect song love it

[MusicDoll28]

Oh God that first scene you picked had me weeping like a baby. It was a great video. I'm going to miss Donna so much I never thought I would get so attached to her, but I did. 5 stars and favoriting