Added: 3 years ago
From: spartacus1701
Views: 168,827
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (252)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oh, man, this is just beyond perfection. Great editing.

    I was kinda waiting for an inevitable "stay on target...stay on target..." sequence, though.

  • I thought the dam busters were Lancaster bombers, not Mosquitoes.

    

  • @StrigonLead Its not the Dambusters- this one was a fictional war movie

  • "I just lost my starboard engine" -> it's the left wing that's on fire

  • It seems Mr. Lucas borrowed several ideass from several movies not only this one.

  • That is a pretty good analysis. Was this inspired by Henryvkeiper when he made Star wars/Battle of Britain and Star Wars/Dambusters?

  • @Trashcansam123 actually i made this before I saw the Keiper one. I think its clear Lucas borrowed heavily from both

  • Those "fighters" are actually Me108s NOT 109s. The Me108 was a 4 seater liason plane; I know because I've flown one!

  • ''didnt go in ,it just impacted on the surface'' i think Lucas was copying his sex life really

  • Just really cute. Flying that mission must have been like being a clay target at a trap range.

  • OLD OLD OLD old old old republic

  • Classic cross-comparison/reference.

  • pewpewpewpew! awesome D: i think lucas took the scene and improved in his own way

    it makes me not mad because lucas ripped off some movie but exited to watch starwars again lol

  • Nice comparison!!!!!

  • @doffincodger When they were free to maneuver, yeah, usually. When locked into an attack run at a fixed altitude and airspeed, though, it would have been easier for the Germans to bounce them.

    The German "fighters" in 633 were Messerschmitt Bf108 Taifuns, BTW. The Taifun wasn't a fighter, it was a trainer. It's the same plane James Garner and Donald Pleasance stole to fly to Switzerland in "The Great Escape."

  • jajajajajajaja! I liked so much!!!!!

  • I used to bullseye womp rats. That bit cracked me up!

  • God damn it, it's almost shot for shot in places.

  • Right On! Thought exactly the same thing myself the first time I saw Star Wars back in '77.

  • Had to pause literally PMSL

  • Lol very nice! Well done dude! =)

    

  • Lucas was quite frank back in 1977 that he had studied clips from a number of WWII films to block out the combat scenes. He wanted that part of his far-out sci-fi epic to fit Hollywood conventions and audience expectations.

  • Just about everything in Star Wars was WWII inspired. The Empire = Nazis (down to the officer uniforms and the Vader helmet) with a mix of Britannia's empire (accents).

  • A very provocative piece, @Spartacus1701, and well worth watching. For transparency's sake, I'd recommend using a quick screen wipe or other indication when you cut within the Star Wars audio track.

    Lucas and ILM veterans do freely acknowledge that they previsualized the aerial VFX sequences with cut-together WWII film sequences. Those strongly influenced the final shots--in fact, there's a Lucasfilm-produced documentary with a sequence like yours, from the gunport battle.

  • haha very good

  • I like this film too.

    The special effects are pretty corny in places .

    It has a brilliant theme tune.

  • Mosquito and Spitfire are undoubtably great but I think the Sea Fury trumps both of them.

  • yes but where was Hann Solo and his Millenium Falcon ?

  • ...nicely done

    

  • he got it from Dam busters mainly

  • The reason people refer to The Dambusters is because before Star Wars had its FX sequences shot, al the dogfights and space ship battles were put in with camera gun shots and war film footage as place holders. This is how it was originally shown to Ladd at 20th Century Fox. The Dambusters is the most obvious of these as lines of dialogue from the attack are directly lifted from the 1955 film, therefore it's obvious that the Death Star sequence was in part built up from it. But possibly 633 too.

  • Damn Clever! But miss the Merlin 'Moaning!

  • An excellent compliation of Star Wars and 633 Squadron/Mosquito Squadron. May I also point out the similarity of the Star wars theme music and the Len Goodwin 633 Squadron theme music?

  • Staring Angus Lennie as R2D2!

  • My brother and I loved this film when we were kids (OK, we still do...). We went to see Star Wars together when it first showed in theaters and when they began the Death Star attack, we turned to each other and said "633 squadron!"

  • RIP Poorkins..

  • but you have used all the attacks from the film... not the end one!?

  • THIS IS BRILLIANT ! Love it!

    K

  • Thanks for that Lazlo-I'm glad he flew in a Mossie, even if he didnt take the controls!

    Questionaire is at tiny.cc

  • I am a big fan of 633 squadron - iit has been my favourite (or one of my three favourites anyway) since I was a kid. Recently I actually sent some questions to Cliff Robertson (who plays the lead: Roy Grant) about the film and he has replied. I can't put a link on here because youtube appears not to appreciate that even though I am a real fan and its just more information. Anyway just search for Cliff Robertson Questionnaire or Lazlo Ferran's blog which is run by google too.

  • /gntx2

  • Very good!

  • rofl rofl rofl  you did well this should have 80 million hits =]

  • Classic. I'm actually watching 633 Squadron right now on Netflix. Nicely put together clips, but I always flt that the Rebel Base scenes with all the pilot chatter was taken right from the movie "Midway" Check it out sometime.

  • This is excellent parody mate well done!! Love both comparisons, obviously no offence to WW2 either, a lot of brave men in fiction but in spirit

  • ...except for a minor glitch at 2:20 this was very well done...matching up the audio with the video was excellent....

  • May the Royal Air Force be with you!

  • Can anythingf beat the Spitfire for beauty, and speed? possibly the Mosquito! she has my vote anyhoo!!! (Struck fear inrto the Lufftwaffe ) by the way it does closely resemble star wars finale---to a tee!--- own up George eh???

  • when i see those old planes and i hear things like "lock s coils in attack position" or "switch shields to double front " i have to laugh XD 5:07 comes straight out of monty python "no im alright BLARGh" XXD

  • Actually both 633 Squadron and Dam Busters inspired George Lucas, I think I remember he admitting it in one of the interviews shortly after his first film. Anybody who saw both films immediately saw the connection.

  • You idiot you have ruined it by putting star wars in the back ground.

  • It's funny given the British method for fighting methodically, they'd have shunned the foolishness of feeling your way via "the force".

  • hahaha this is great!

  • Interesting, however as an aviation enthusiast. that mixing up of the X-Wings eninges with the mosquitos is horrible, since the Mosquitos merlin Motor has a destinctive and definately other sound, and most beautiful if you ever heard a real one. Else it is interesting. It fit pretty nicely, well it was always sayd that much of the fighting scenes were inspired by such films and in the first cuts they were placeholders until the trick scenes were done.

  • jepp!

    

  • All kinds of awesome - two of my favourite movies!!!

  • Hilarious!

    Well done! I got a laugh outa' this one!

  • I've thought this since 1977 when I first saw Star Wars!

  • De Haviland Mosquito - best plane of WW 2 , fast as a P51 , handles like a spitfire

    bomb load of a B17 ( well almost ) made of wood by out of work british furniture and cabinet makers .

  • Fantastic editing!

    consider this fav'ed.

  • Weird how much resemblence there is here. I saw in another movie a while ago though that Battle of Yavin was much more like the Dam Busters.

  • Yeah, George Lucas did say the fjiord run inspired the trench run in Star Wars:-)

  • Too funny. And pretty much accurate where he got some of the footage.

    Thanks for sharing

    Oh, great movie 633 Squadron is too. Well worth the watching.

  • 5:10 - The clock on the wall cracks me up... "Rebel base one minute and closing." LOL

  • Klasse gemacht! Auch wenn ich nichts davon weiß das die Deutschen im 2. Weltkrieg jemals 3er Flak besessen oder auch nur produziert hätten (war eher eine japanische Anordnung bei Flak-Geschützen!) sind die Paralelen zu STAR WARS echt verblüffend!

  • This was funny great editing!

  • World Star Wars 2

  • Bravo ! Well done !

  • FANTASTIC!!!....glad others had noticed the similarities,was getting slightly bored of telling my star wars friends how much the death star attack resembled 633 squadron!

  • Well done mate! that was thoroly enjoyable. Too many commebts from nitpickers whining about little details. BIG DEAL. I still think it was an enjoyable parody! Well done!

  • I thought so back when Stars came out, Very good spoof. I've always enjoyed 633 Squadron as well even though the special effects were primitive. Thank you.

  • Lucas was 9 years old when he saw this !

    and "may the force be with you"

    LOL !

  • Brilliant Bloody Brilliant Thank you

  • An excellent interpretaion, well done. A difficult film to edit.

  • very good love it

  • Masterful. It works so well.

  • great edit, but it would have been nice to hear those wonderful V12s!

  • I'm sure it was inspired by it, not directly and blatantly lifted.

  • Great vid Sparacus ;)

    Lucas copied from everwhere and everything. It show's in Phantom Muzzled when he had to be totally original and no one said 'George! That idea stinks!'

    Shame really. The vision was great. the execution abit hap hazzard and corporate toy projected sales heavy.

    A New Hope and Empire are still bloody great though as is the original 633 :)

    As a by note. I heard Peter Jackson is rebooting 'The Dam Busters'. Hope it's a good 'un!

  • uncanny!! but sooooo close? cannot say no can you? well spotted spartacus, how do you spot it???

  • uncanny!! but sooooo close? cannot say no can you? well spotted spartacus, how do you spot it???

  • good job!

  • Brilliant! LOL LOL LOL Very clever..... LOL I can't believe how similar it was... I always thought there was a lot of WW2 in StarWars! LOL

  • what movie is this?

  • That's amazing! Lucas copied the entire audio track from this sequence DIRECTLY from this movie?

  • Did Luke just than Wedge for blowing himself up? LOL

    This was entertaining.

  • Don't worry... the RAF/Rebel Alliance must have a surplus of pilots called Wedge because he's soon back later on in the clip! :-)

  • IT'S A ZEPPELIN!

  • just shows nothing is realy NEW. just different takes on the same thing.

  • there were a great deal of these types of movies made duringthe war for propaganda,etc, and they remained popular for years afterwards. a formula was developed. Lucas used this & stuff like 12 o clock high too

  • I always thought there were some similarities. This is great.

  • This is Great - Terrific video - thanks for putting the soundtrack against the visuals of '633 - it really shows that Lucas did indeed photograph & cut his movie to this one. Again, many thanks!

  • Another "rush" reviewed by Lucas and friends was the bomb run from "The Bridges at Toko Ri" starring Bill Holden. Superior special effects, better than 633 squadron and made years earlier. JoeBob says - check it out!

  • OMG! WTF! LOL! That was just about scene for scene... Wow.... Darn you George Lucus!

  • Man this made me laugh.... thanks for putting it together.

  • 4:48 Wedge blew up?!? Hahaha

  • We have been given permission by the UK Cabinet Office to apply for Ron Goodwin to be belatedly knighted. If want to show your support for this please message me! We have already had emails of support from the UK, The Netherlands, New Zealand the USA and we have only been going a week!

  • this is great

  • I love Squadron 633!

  • I am sure I saw somewhere that George Lucas said that this film was his inspiration for the trench scene.

    If he saw 633 sqn, he saw "The Cruel Sea", he saw "The Dirty Dozen", he saw Lawrence of course. And he saw 2001. These films were all inspiration for Star Wars which is a complete masterpiece, and a combination of these films.

  • Yeah, it's obvious that "633 squadron" was the inspiration for the assault on the Death Star. Lucas has said so I believe.

    There were a lot of movies like this in the immediate precess of 1977. The Dirty Dozen, The Devils Brigade, even Charge of the Light Brigade has similar themes.

    Y-wings are Mosquitos. X-Wings are Spitfires. Captain Nolan is Luke Skywalker. etc... Lucas took 633 squadron, a film that barely registered, combined it with his ideas and made a world beater. Brilliant.

  • Excellent mashup. Lucas, however, has publicly acknowledged "The Dambusters" and other WWII films were a huge influence on the death star sequence.

  • I had to laugh when those machine guns opened up with a pwit-pwit-pwit!

  • Nice XD

  • I am not sure if this is the influence, but I do know that a lot of the original Star Wars dogfighting scenes where based on WWII footage.

  • 0:46 looks like Luke Skywalker

  • That was absolutely awesome!

    To be fair though, I vaguely remember something in Star Wars Galaxy magazine back in the mid-90s about 633 Squadron being an influence for the Death Star attack.

    Oh, and on the VHS release of the 1997 special edition, they had an extra before the film about using older WW2 film footage as previs for the Death Star sequence.

  • i guess that makes Yoda

    Winston Churchill

  • "I can't shake it! I've got a wire attached to my wing!"

  • haha

  • OMG , i knew a lot of WW2 features are open and hidden in Star Wars, but this is so much copy work of G Lucas.

    What a turn off on their "creative" minds.

    Jeezuss..

    Fantastic detection work Spartacus !

  • Lucas always acknowledged this and other films as an influence on Star Wars.

  • LOL, Nice one mate :)

  • That was awsome, well done

  • Great vid!

  • It's a guarantee Lucas watched this film when researching the dogfight. Hilarious!

  • Oh... I also loved this movie too. hehe Sit and watch it with dad. Awesome.

  • I enjoyed the shows more for it. Even as a kid I could feel they were all 'Business' while attacking the Death-star. All I can say is I wish to heaven Lucas had stayed true to basing his fighter pilot dialogue off of inspiring shows like this rather then the style of dialogue used in the prequels. Cut the chatter indeed Anakin you tard! Catastrophic... ;p

  • i think from now on all ME-109s should sound like TIE fighters thats too hilarious , also at 7:03 check jonah hills grandad

  • The trick is to steal from enough sources at once that isn't plagiarism anymore.

    Just ask J.K. Rowling.

  • The Force will be with you..........yeah that would be the Royal Air Force

  • Top notch - well done

  • I'd say both film's influenced Star Wars.

  • Blasphemy. X-wing fighters are for girls. A real pilot would pick a Mozzie any day.

  • Apart for the reason that Mozzies' were like ducks against fighters like the spitfire

  • WHAT!!!???....a spitfire would have to catch a mosquito first before it could ever dream of shooting it down....hahahahah yah right...

  • Uhm... no. The Mosquito was the fastest operational aircraft in the war until 1944.

  • The Spitfire,like the Bf-109 could not catch a DH-98.

  • @pervertt Mosquitoes were good, but I'd take a P-38L over that glorified piece of furniture any day.

  • 0:50 "...and may the force be with you"

    fantastic!!

  • Quite cool, I can picture how Lucas saw this 10 years before his own work, that he liked it and was influenced by it.

    But it's not like you can give any negative criticism for it, every work is a patchwork by small pieces made by others, because you're always influenced by things in your enviroment.

  • True, plus most the mythos from star wars was based on samurai legends and western gun fights, it doesn't mean you can't take something like that and make your own verson, plus did World War 2 have Wookies, didn't think so

  • "plus did World War 2 have Wookies didn't think so "

    Clearly you have never seen a Ukrainian grandmother

  • ur such a hater roguewarrior

    great job on the vid spart :)

  • Ahahaha, so true ! ;-)

  • sir... I was abot to dismiss this out of hand.. HOWEVER

    Well done to do this... great editing

    5 stars and added to my fav list

  • Ummm I am pretty sure that george Lucas didnt copy from 633 Squadron...this is just movie editing I could do this with Band of Brothers and teh Dirty Dozen

  • mosquitos flying in 3's down a fijord, no room to manouver, having to hit a precision target, being fired at by flak, hunted by 109's.....

  • @spartacus1701 undeniable likeness

  • @roguewarrior5 You've obviously never watched the movie. I saw it with my Dad when I was young. Then I saw Star Wars and recognised it immediately.

  • @roguewarrior5

    except that lucas has said that 633 squadran inspired the trench run in star wars.

  • @roguewarrior5 i think you'l find he did aswell as dam busters

  • @roguewarrior5 Lucas did admit he was inspired by the climax of 633 Squadron, though they are similar, i wouldn't say copied...

  • @roguewarrior5 I have been in touch with Cliff Robertson, the star of 633 squadron and if anybody is interested he has given some answers to long-standing questions about the film on my blog writers-blog1 on blogspot

  • @roguewarrior5

    Lucas actually named it as one of his inspirations. Does that help?

  • @roguewarrior5 Lucas him self said it inspired the Death Star trench run.

  • @roguewarrior5

    Of course you can, but I don't think this is meant seriously, it just looks like a good joke to me... a very good one I think both WW2 buffs and Starwars fans could appreciate it :-).

  • omg he so copied 633 suadron

  • Very good! although at 3:37 you included footage from the practice run with the chalk bombs. It's funny to see the big target with the sticky-tape 'X marks the spot' as if the Germans had set it up like that!

    The film 633 Squadron is really well made, and a good movie, let along a great war movie. There are quite a few other Star wars elements throughout the film you missed a trick a bit (the rebel base, the brother/ sister relationship ; the torture scene ... think vader and Leia......

  • Cheers- yeah thought about including that but it kind of doesn't mix with the planes so well. Its funny though I think I thought of that torture scene when I first saw starwars!

  • yup five full stars... what's the title of the movie?

  • 633 Squadron

  • Very Well Done! nice mashup. This movie was made in the early 60's using only 3 Mosquitos that were still flying. Impressive for those times. Nice Job! once again.

  • That was brilliant! Five stars easily! Great mixing skills!

  • nice - my two fave films combined

    cheers mate

  • Hahah ;-)

  • "hey the actor who played the australian pilot in this movie is the guy who ...."

    his name is John Mellion

  • 0:43  Its 'Ives... Flying Officer Ives!!'

  • Great work !! I really enjoyed it.

  • crying from laughing hahahaha great video

  • it's a mix, there's a line from dam busters near the beginning, the trench run is from 633 squadron, and the final explosion is from Guns of Navarone.

  • Outstanding! ... 5 stars

  • Hah! That was awesome. Great work! :)

  • hell lucas stole CGI for crying out loud.

  • hey the actor who played the australian pilot in this movie is the guy who did the narration of the vb ads before he died and he star in crocdile dundee with paul hogan.

  • He also played a US sailor in the movie "On the Beach."

  • lol i remember watching this movie...

  • Great job.

    By George he's worse than the Chinese ins tealing shit!!!!!

  • As funny as the briefing scene was in this, the actual attack is virtually shit-for-shot Dambusters.

  • George Lucas sued the creators of Battle-Star Galactica for stealing "HIS" ideas, how ironic huh ?

  • The theme tune for this was epic!

  • The truth is photos were taken of these many light bomber attacks against occupied Europe,from inside the cockpits and on the ground, you can find them in our libraries if you you look hard enough,real old books.

  • awesome. great job

  • im pretty sure the sound from starwars is unedited, but did you edit the video from 633 squadron mosquito , or is this the video in its original form

  • Yeah the video has been chopped around a little, but the sound is pretty much the trench run shortened.

  • Amazing how much George Lucas copied from other classic films! Check out the internet website: BEFORE THE GALAXY FAR, FAR AWAY: INFLUENCES ON STAR WARS BY CINELEET

  • I especially liked the briefing scene... and the firing sound effects go so well with the lousy visuals!

  • Heh, excellent stuff! Lucas obviously took lots of scenes from both Dambusters and 633 Sqdrn., the pilfering cad.

  • was this the Star Wars sound unedited ? -sounds like it is so that it fits in to the action on the screen.

    George Lucas admitted years ago he used footage from " The Dambusters" to make the dogfight sequences in Star Wars "rough shots"

  • Good work Spartacus. Lucas doesn't deny getting inspiration from WWII movies, but I'm not sure it was this specific one.

  • Good job matching the voice to the mouth movements