I agree, Vonzell's was better. I didn't like Latoya on this song. It felt higher than her range, although she managed. Latoya is the better technical singer but what Latoya lacked, and what sent her home, was a lack of personality and a lack of passion. She was a boring contestant. You knew she was going to come out and do well but you really didn't ROOT for her. I wanted her to win that season, but looking back, I'm glad she didn't.
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
@MistaRichardz I LOVE LaToya too! Vonzell was awesome as well and she too had a powerful voice. But I think Vonzell didn't have as much control of her voice as LaToya has over hers. LaToya was never out of tune and was always on point. Vonzell's voice was much too big for her to handle, lolol! LaToya was magnificent!!
I just heard the Vonzell version. Are people serious? They think Vonzell sung this better than Latoya? Latoya made this song her own and her voice was spectacular! Vonzell was grunting out the notes at times. They both did well but for me, Latoya hit it out of the ballpark!
Clearly you are some pathetic internet troll who with their fake ass degree in music. Vonzell has a solo album. Where's LaToya's? Vonzell made it to the top four (five)...where did LaToya make it? Vonzell could sing LaToya under a bus. And you, let's not get started. Something tells me you sound like William Hung. Dismissed.
that doesn't mean anything. jennifer hudson was top six i think? or seven? so vonzell is better than her too? lol this logic makes no sense. latoya is better. its pointless to attest.
haha i've done my homework, more than YOU"LL ever know. you don't know me or my experience as a musician. Do your own homework. Latoya is on broadway, and was number 4 on AI. Where is vonzell now? Just curoius. Saw her on a talk show a few years ago. haha Dismissed.
@Neno8403 I actually like Vonzell alot, but just 'cause a contestant on AI made it further in the comp. that another one doesn't mean he/she's better, it becomes a popularity competition when it reaches the top 24 or something. sheesh
Latoya's is vocally better than Vonzell... but Vonzell was "going through something" that week on Idol so she sang it with a lot more urgency and abandon.. both were GREAT performance of a great song
No, sir. Vonzell is/was much better than LaToya. All I ever needed to hear was Vonzell's rendition of "How Do I Live" by LeeAnn Rimes/Tricia Yearwood, and I was sold. She did that A LOT better than both of those ladies. Don't get me wrong, this was a GREAT performance, too, but I think Vonzell is the overall better artists. She did a lot of challenging, popular songs on Idol that most people shy away from because it's too hard for them to do. And she pulled them off effortlessly.
I knew Latoya was really outstanding when she sang "all the time" on Barry Manilow night, and Tamyra Gray when she sang "A House is not a Home" Both were excellant and had the whole package, voice, likable, confident and attractive. Idol 2009 hasn't hooked me with any performances like these did.
Totally agree...Vonzell's version is the best..LaToya's was a bit old-fashioned. RAmiele...?Who?She's so forgetable...She doesn't even deserve to be talked about with these 2 great singers.
She is Lovely..I think some of her songs are wrong 4 her..She is so talented..This song is OK 4 her but not great..I mean the song not HER..
ConnieAnna1 2 months ago
I agree, Vonzell's was better. I didn't like Latoya on this song. It felt higher than her range, although she managed. Latoya is the better technical singer but what Latoya lacked, and what sent her home, was a lack of personality and a lack of passion. She was a boring contestant. You knew she was going to come out and do well but you really didn't ROOT for her. I wanted her to win that season, but looking back, I'm glad she didn't.
Spyder246 4 months ago
Vonzell Solomon splashed her out the water on this one.
MRBBJC 5 months ago
Magnífica versió d'aquesta estupenda cançó
espailocal 8 months ago
great voice!
automatic98765 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
nikaledesma 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
nikaledesma 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
nikaledesma 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
voice wise, LaToya London has it all (vocals, range) except she really has no fighting spirit of winning or she really has boring personality or maybe she's just down to earth.
Fantasia was soulfully great but quite exaggerated sometimes. Jennifer was really voted out because she sings like Broadway although she has very big voice.
look at this totally robbed contestant ever in AI history. Season's 3 Lisa Leuschner. I believe she would have won that season.
nikaledesma 1 year ago
Is it just me or does she look like Mary J Blidge? anyways, enough about her. Omg Latoya has such an amazing voice!!
myyKINDALOVee 1 year ago
pretty good.
KrisAllisonKelly4evr 1 year ago
I think Vonzell's version was better but Latoya is a better singer.
MistaRichardz 1 year ago 4
@MistaRichardz I LOVE LaToya too! Vonzell was awesome as well and she too had a powerful voice. But I think Vonzell didn't have as much control of her voice as LaToya has over hers. LaToya was never out of tune and was always on point. Vonzell's voice was much too big for her to handle, lolol! LaToya was magnificent!!
Candi411 1 year ago
Ramile Malubay is way better than this...
crunchykroll 1 year ago
you're insane and inept...ignorant and idiotic...you're just...so wrong...SO WRONG
TheEnlightenedTruth 1 year ago
Of course that Latoya was better.
aliceayrescloser 2 years ago
i like her cover of thelma houston
unclet222 2 years ago
I can't choose. LaToya & Baby V are my favorite two AI singers ever.
Barth1210 2 years ago
I just heard the Vonzell version. Are people serious? They think Vonzell sung this better than Latoya? Latoya made this song her own and her voice was spectacular! Vonzell was grunting out the notes at times. They both did well but for me, Latoya hit it out of the ballpark!
aidenangola 2 years ago
They have no ear for music. No way on God's green earth, Vonzell couldn't even sing.
shjtyu 2 years ago
Clearly you are some pathetic internet troll who with their fake ass degree in music. Vonzell has a solo album. Where's LaToya's? Vonzell made it to the top four (five)...where did LaToya make it? Vonzell could sing LaToya under a bus. And you, let's not get started. Something tells me you sound like William Hung. Dismissed.
Neno8403 2 years ago
No brain and no taste. Sad. Sad. Sad.
shjtyu 2 years ago
Vonzell's album didn't sell. Latoya is so much better than there is no comparison. Latoya is starring on Broadway!!!!
TheEnlightenedTruth 1 year ago
Oh, my bad. Vonzell made it to the top THREE. So that definitely nullifies whatever non-existent argument you had.
Neno8403 2 years ago
that doesn't mean anything. jennifer hudson was top six i think? or seven? so vonzell is better than her too? lol this logic makes no sense. latoya is better. its pointless to attest.
jghsdrummer14 2 years ago
It doesn't mean anything that THE FANS kept Vonzell until the top three. What a idiot of a doucebag. Go do your homework junior.
Neno8403 2 years ago
haha i've done my homework, more than YOU"LL ever know. you don't know me or my experience as a musician. Do your own homework. Latoya is on broadway, and was number 4 on AI. Where is vonzell now? Just curoius. Saw her on a talk show a few years ago. haha Dismissed.
jghsdrummer14 2 years ago
@Neno8403 I actually like Vonzell alot, but just 'cause a contestant on AI made it further in the comp. that another one doesn't mean he/she's better, it becomes a popularity competition when it reaches the top 24 or something. sheesh
balflear81 2 years ago
I was so floored that she didn't advance to the Top 3 after this performance.
aidenangola 2 years ago
best ever no doubt
mabbott13 2 years ago
am i the only one who thought this was kinda shaky? it was better than her first performance...but i wasn't surprised when she got voted off.
thedustoflife 2 years ago
Latoya's is vocally better than Vonzell... but Vonzell was "going through something" that week on Idol so she sang it with a lot more urgency and abandon.. both were GREAT performance of a great song
icecoldbruh 2 years ago
Latoya is infinitely better than Vonzell.
TheEnlightenedTruth 2 years ago
dont agree. Latoya was cool, just something about her voice bored me tears. I could see on broadway, it lacked the sould of a Fantasia, and a Vonzell
rp2979 2 years ago 2
No, sir. Vonzell is/was much better than LaToya. All I ever needed to hear was Vonzell's rendition of "How Do I Live" by LeeAnn Rimes/Tricia Yearwood, and I was sold. She did that A LOT better than both of those ladies. Don't get me wrong, this was a GREAT performance, too, but I think Vonzell is the overall better artists. She did a lot of challenging, popular songs on Idol that most people shy away from because it's too hard for them to do. And she pulled them off effortlessly.
Neno8403 2 years ago 2
AGREED!!!
rp2979 2 years ago
Vonzell, couldn't even sing.
shjtyu 2 years ago
I knew Latoya was really outstanding when she sang "all the time" on Barry Manilow night, and Tamyra Gray when she sang "A House is not a Home" Both were excellant and had the whole package, voice, likable, confident and attractive. Idol 2009 hasn't hooked me with any performances like these did.
fishintwodish 2 years ago
best singer every in the american idol season 3 gogogogogo latoya
1988rct 2 years ago 2
what a fantastic voice! i really wanted her to win that season
spabrat 3 years ago 9
she should have ben in da finale wit fantasia dat season!
bananacraz06 3 years ago 4
would'e been the best finale ever, but i doubt we'll ever have two black people in the finale no matter what. Season 3 and 6 proved that :(
Ajst1987 2 years ago
LaToya is IMO better than Vonzell, and she is more watchable. She doesn't do any goofy dance moves.
fishintwodish 3 years ago
latoya is nothing compared to vonzell!!!
DoubleDBlogXX 2 years ago
Latoya is far more talented with better vocal ability!!!
VeronicasPlace 2 years ago
Latoya is a better technical singer, but vonzell was my favorite for her season
1606Dominic 2 years ago
You're INSANE.
TheEnlightenedTruth 2 years ago
i like this one. she is almost as good as Vonzell's performance but better than Ramiele's. I love LaToya!
honeybun13 3 years ago 5
I love all three of their renditions (LaToya's, Vonzell's & Ramiele's)
But the order they go in I think is:
Vonzell
LaToya
Ramiele
But I LOVE Ramiele!!! =D
kyo2590 3 years ago 2
Totally agree...Vonzell's version is the best..LaToya's was a bit old-fashioned. RAmiele...?Who?She's so forgetable...She doesn't even deserve to be talked about with these 2 great singers.
090783 2 years ago
you are exactly right!!
DoubleDBlogXX 2 years ago