Added: 5 years ago
From: ferrisja
Views: 94,635
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (183)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oasis= The Beatles of my generation

  • I'm a Beatles fan!!! I'm not accustomed to this kind of lanuage...apart from Lennon's odd outbursts!! But they Could play and sing and produce and get on with each other...No contest!!!

  • And They Can't Sing either!!!!!

  • They can't even play their instruments properly!!!

  • They Don't even sound anything like The Beatles...I mean.. Come on!!!!!!!

  • There's no call for that language

  • Absolute Rubbish

  • @fordywatza dont fucking watch or comment the you prick infact no you cunt

  • @fordywatza go suck justin biebers vagina 

  • it looks like a rock band game¡¡¡¡

  • I love Oasis ..!!!!!!!!!

  • This version is tasteless... to fast, to "fury" but with no f*ckin' soul on the song...

  • @Agu2art Your obviously into the flat boring sound the beatles used for this track, Oasis have taken this track to another level, big guitar sounds, strong vocals and lets be honest, it needed to be sped up, the old versions boring as fuck...... Oasis all way man.

  • @twotellys12 Well... Yoi might say that, but guess what... WRONG!!!

    Oasis (for me) is a middle band, not eveng big enough for this song. And The beatles "boring"??? You might be needing to listen to the original track again...

    U2's Bono cover for this is even better than the Oasis one...

    And as i said, this version is up-tempo, but thats like a teenager might took it... I'm only 25, but i an get the difference between a teen band and one thats actually made by musicians...

  • @Agu2art Yes sure, one of the biggest bands who sold out gigs around the world aren't big at all... They aren't better than the beatles no, but they are sure nearing there level.

  • If you want a good Beatle cover, look for "Every Little Thing" by YES, a prog rock Band that has made the best beatle cover ever.... Musicians. In fact.

  • Sorry liam but you got no instrument

  • what effect pedal are they using towards the end?

  • Best band of a generation, my favourate band ever. Too many great songs!!

    The guy who sat Wonderwall isn't a classic is talking rubbish!! But then I guess he's one of these "if I dont like it nobody should" fellas. Music elitists, is there anything less cool in the world?

  • Get 100k views this week easily, im not joking try it by registering with Y2BVIEWS com new site launched this week, and post a thank you here: /watch?v=uqwhomCAO6o

  • @Blinkyboy99 .Yeah they did some good songs,but your average Oasis fan probably thinks Wonderwall is a classic,which it isn't.To be honest it is pretty fucking awfull! The rest of their back catalogue borrows heavily on other bands work,it's like Oasis never evolved.Just done one album and then moved on to ripping off the next one!

  • @MrNodzilla

    I actually think most of Oasis' best songs are b sides.

  • @MrNodzilla Fare play you no nothing about music lol Oasis never evolved??? 6 of there albums are in the top 200 best albums of all time mate > definetly maybe and morning glory are in the top 40. lol please tell me whos material there ripping off or borrowing? NOBODYS not even the beatles, thats just something old men say who have passed it.

  • @twotellys12 .Commercial success doesn't mean anything,are the Backstreet boys better than Oasis,no,yet they've outsold them by almost 3 times the amount. What about Britney Spears,Blobbie Williams,Rhianna(30m more) or even Olivia Newton John for fuck sake,they all have sold lots more albums.My favourite is Ace of Bass,remember that terrible band?Their best selling album has sold more than any album that Quoasis has sold which i find amusing.

  • @twotellys12 .Actually the Gallagher brothers are both older than me by quite a bit,i also don't know what age has to do with what you listen to. I'm a big fan of Hendrix,i also like Otis Redding and practically anything that's good. You say Oasis never copied anyone,isn't the importance of being idle blatant rip off of the Kinks dead end street,they even copied the video.Or what about all around the world,isn't that just trying to out beatles the beatles?

  • Why is George Harrison playing a John lennon signature guitar?

  • this is why i love oasis.

  • Liam sound 6 years old on this

  • this cover song, sold me on Oasis.

  • lovely

  • The Beatles never ever jammed with Oasis, Paul, George or Ringo never did. It must say that Oasis was an alright copy band in their eyes. While they are much bigger than that. They are the best 90's band and great continuation of The Beatles.

  • i am i the only guy who think the beatles are extremely overated?

  • @ricoizgay Yes. Deal with it. The Beatles are awesome.

  • @Lafayettebluesman luv it :D

  • @whazzahell123  your a beatles freak not a music fan

  • tops

  • Anyone who understands at least a litlle bit of music can appreciate this cover, people who don't like are just beatles freaks, not music lovers!

  • aweful cover

  • This is the best cover by any band ever made. I am a huge fan of both oasis and beatles and I dont see any reason to argue about which version is the best. The Beatles version is obviously epic and perfect but as far as covers go, it doesnt get better than this.

  • best cover goes to Oasis

  • Noel>McFartney!

    FTW!!

  • @ftechone no and mccartney doesn't sing this song.

  • Oasis at thier best live in this era Liams voice is spot on toatally

  • Hot damn! They ripped that song a new one!!

  • @DKqwerty

    2 fooking reet man & bigger than the beatles was havin a lend and so many $ made from it.....attitude - take it or leave it

  • @whazzahell123 So the place that Noel has in the songwriting Hall of fame means nothing then? Prick.

  • the perfect cover for Oasis to do...Liam kills it. Didn't the guy from their label say it was their performance of this song in a club that made him go"these guys need a contract!"?

  • great rendition of a weird song. 5* Oasis

  • love it!

  • talk about killing a song

  • @Resistantman24 u takin the piss?

  • Beatles are Gods! Oasis is Great and i think an extremely underrated band here in the states... and to be honest i think Oasis is 2nd best but Beatles are just a band that comes once every 100 years oasis is a band that comes once every decade and that decade was my favorite the 90s so live forever both of them not as bands but as pieces of our hearts!

  • Absolutely the most amazing performance of a incredible song, Love John, but the Liam did this song mega!!

  • Comment removed

  • Beatles for ever!!!

    Oasis for ever!!!

  • i have this on dvd!! its the best version of this song!! awesome!! this is, why they are the best band ever!!

  • just perfect!!!!!!

  • Wth! Oasis areee finee but wheree are the Beatlessss!

  • Comment removed

  • Great Stuff the beatles & oasis the 2 greatest things to ever come out of england, sons of ireland though all of them :)

  • Comment removed

  • liams voice is fukin banging here

  • Oh come on! Stop comparing them, how can you? They don't even write, compose, sing the same music! Beatles are Beatles - Oasis are Oasis!

    Gallaghers always compared themself to Beatles just for a provocation, they never took it as a serious thing...

    (I just have one question... who the hell is Noel Edmond???xD)

  • @Light90Sephiroth lol except for the noel edmond bit, (his the guy who presents deal or no deal), i totaly agree with u, there completely different, the only reason oasis wernt as big as the beatles was because of the fact that oasis apeal to a more rock audience and are more rock n rol whereas people, woman of midle ages could still like the beatles, if u no what i mean

  • @Light90Sephiroth

    An undeniably shit hot version by a bunch of toss pots

  • @Light90Sephiroth .Oasis ripped off loads of bands! The Who,Beatles,T-Rex,Kinks etc etc! Noel would rip off Hendrix if he could actually play a guitar! Oasis are Oasis LoL!!!!!

  • @MrNodzilla Are you saying that Noel cant play guitar - I have seen him play and he has an amazing talent - dont mess with Manchester men, you fuckwit

  • @simonNZ1066 .Doesn't Noel play rhythm guitar,lol?He wasn't even the best guitarist in Oasis. Have you heard Beady eyes new offering,one critic praised Liam for ripping off George Harrisons back catalogue this time! "Don't mess with Manchester men"? Has Noel been to Manchester twice in the same year since moving to the London? I'm sure he hasn't even been to see his beloved Man city at home since they moved to their new stadium!

  • nice cover!

  • 3:44 its sounds like "miss you" by Rolling Stones, nice.

  • Haha it does :) ... Rolling Stones are class! Beatles and Oasis also :D

  • brilliant version

  • HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!! Lennon Vs Gallagher......Wake up inflames2121 you melon,thats like saying Noel Edmond is a better F1 driver than Michael Schumacher! Although Noel is probably one of the best songwriters of the past decade(Gallagher not Edmonds ha)he is a small fish to Lennon mate,and as for Oasis Vs Beatles,hmmmmm I think you need help hahaha

  • Hahaha I agree mate.

  • Nice one ferrisja, I have this on my ...There and Then DVD, quality mate! Glad I have found it on YouTube, and have saved this fucker to my favourites......man!!

  • noel lyrics lightyears ahead... oasis better than beatles... fucking idiot.

  • Light years ahead? What planet are you on? Do some proper research on John Lennon then think about that remark!

  • Oasis are better than the Beatles because Oasis have continued touring and producing excellent music that they can perform live, rather than retreating to the studio and indulging themselves at the fans' expense...and Noel's lyrics are lightyears ahead of Lennon

  • don't always compare

    they are great anyway

  • 3:43 it sounds like a part of "miss you" by rollling stones :p

  • definitely not better than the beatles version... John Lennon was a god.

  • sry have to say oasis r better than the beatles im a fan of both but oasis 4 me have made better music and this version is better than beatles

  • quoting a comment i saw eleswhere on a youtube comment

    'Beatles better than Jesus, Oasis - betetr than beatles'

  • no oasis is the beatles with flanger.

  • oasis better than beatles

  • BETTER THAN BEATLES WALRUS

  • lol OKAY

  • Nope =/

  • the best vocals

  • proper english music covered by a proper english band, fucking top stuff!

  • you gotta find something more powerful than the word of "proper" to describe the beatles pal, they're like, gods.. :)

  • go on then, i'll let you describe em ;)

  • just imagine the time our world created,everywhere green and blue,only nature wheeling around itself on a perfect echoe in the universe,but once the mankind stepped on it has changed.turned in to a place like this,its impossible from now on to turn it back and lets say,we can only imitate right,try to make it look like it has to be,the way it used to be.that scene you imagined it first was the beatles.n oasis was like a step forward to remind us what those times were like.we gotta appreciate it.

  • i'm sticking with proper english music.......final answer.

  • go ahead deny it

  • from around 5.00 plus for a couple o seconds where liams shaking his hair or just standing there sums up british rock, fucking amazing

  • amazing versionnnn

    liam is a way better singer than lennon

  • Don't always compare...

    This sounds great.

  • Well I like the Beatles version more.

  • The 1 from 2002 is better than this 1

  • if you like more the beatles then why the fuck are you watching this!?! just SHUT UP

  • Liam sings it so much quicker than lennon.

  • yeh... it sucks

  • No it doesn't.. its better.. faster = better

    .. and its totally different than beatles.. its oasis

  • faster = better? by that logic grindcore must be the best fucking music on the Earth to you.

  • I meant this song..

    what is grindcore ;DD

  • for some reason this is an easy song to sing and sound like lennon..

  • not as good as beatles.

  • Bonehead = LEGEND!!!!!!!!

  • I LUV IT, I LUV IT , I LUV IT!!!!!!!!!!

  • it's a bit quick but i like this cover

  • lol haha go an listen to jacko.

  • HAHA yeah right, Oasis is amazing, they can fill a tent quite easily.

  • Oasis sold out Madison Square Garden 2 years ago and last time I checked that was one of the top venues Stateside. And that's when they're well past their sell by date. You should have had 'em in '95. You missed out big time. One of the greatest bands of all time but if you can't see that you'll never get it.

  • Oasis sold out Madison Square Garden 2 years ago and last time I checked that was one of the top venues Stateside. And that's when they're well past their sell by date. You should have had 'em in '95. You missed out big time. One of the greatest bands of all time but if you can't see that you'll never get it.

  • Beatles... forever...

  • what did noel and liam said at the beginning of the video?

  • He's introducing the band that's about to come on stage and perform with them called the bootleg beatles

  • wow

  • I think his voice goes very well

    with this song, it sounds great

  • Paulryo,

    It wasn't June, it was November (4th and 5th) - I remember, the night of the gig Rabin got shot and my mate's dad had cancer and we were all kids but thought we were grown-ups...

  • ...sittin' on a cornflake, I'm waiting for the van to come.....

    AWESOME !!! This is my favourite oasis cover !!!

  • I was there Earls Court June 95! Awesome

  • Wouldn't that be cool if they were young enough to really performed with the beatles.

  • atombee live it up some

  • atombee, if you know that much about music, how come you ain't owner of a record lable or member of some band? I'll tell you why, because you are fucking imbecile...You can not compare Oasis with David Bowie stupid...but you are right in one thing...they borrow some riffs from other groups...so what?! They make ten times better tune!

    Oasis is one of the best bands in the last 20-30 years...and you may deny this, but it is stil a fact...

  • "Oasis is one of the best bands in the last 20-30 years...and you may deny this, but it is stil a fact..."

    I TOTALLY agree.

  • Sooooooooo fuckin good!

    i want liams shirt bad. is the coolest bastard in this.

    i LOVE the way they jam it out for ages.

    I LOVE Oasis.

  • his shirt is cool!

  • I LOVE THE BEATLES BUT THIS

    THIS IS FUCKING EPIC , which why i love oasis more

    OASIS FUCKN RULE

  • wat u snortin this is epic

  • vai-te foder burro...

  • leave it to these tools Oasis to remove ALL the humor from the song. Fucking douchebags ... had the misfortune to see them once. the lead singer was going on and on about their new amazing single ... then they played it. Straight rip of "All The Young Dudes" ... total assholes on top of it. never had an original idea in their career.

  • You fucking idiot! Oasis might show their influences in their music, but they make it their own. You think bands like Aerosmith, Metallica and Soundgarden don't reek of their influences also?? Oasis made music exiting at a time when it was stale (like now). Fuck off dickhead! Oasis rocks!!

  • You obviously don't know enough about music to know the difference between "showing influences" and plagiarism.

    Oasis is a band made up of obnoxious, drunken, self-important minimal-talent twats who figured out how to steal a chord progression from bowie, a chorus from the stones, instrumentation from the beatles and sell it to idiots like you. And they are assholes on top of it, one of the most unprofessional shows i have ever seen.

  • bollocks

  • RightO Bee. Having played, listened, evaluated, reviewed all aspects of music since the 60's, IMHO this is the worst group I have encountered yet. Not a single redeeming quality.

  • My God. This is full of critics... You should write on the Melody Maker...

  • Best version of the song. Simple as that. Love the beatles, the stones and U2 but will be waiting some time for the next BAND. Imagine the kaiser chefs of the frenz ferdindandz trying this. Music should inspire. This does! Just enjoy. its real.

  • Hey asshats: the funny thing is: if you list the original song, It comes up ORIGINAL,...so Fuk U hahahahahahahahahahahahhahahah­ahahahahhaa

  • The only mangling going on here is by these pricks in the video. Still quite funny though - not up there with Monty Python maybe, but getting there...

  • Too many pricks hanging onto the past. F*!^{ng wake up, do you drive a Morris Minor? Do you mangle your clothes? This is THE band taking a classic re-working it and showing great respect for the beatles.I'd love to get stuck in to some of you bloody farts but I relly can't be bothered! Let me know if you wan to though. LIAM!!!!

  • much better than original

    FUCKING MEGA!

  • this is the comedy version....

  • You are the comedy version!

  • bitter beatles fans let it go.

  • Oasis is a bunch of drunken, no talent pricks. The whining singer sounds like he's being fucked up the azz sideways.

  • your a right prat

  • get off their song then!people always diss them cos they secretly love em and dont wanna admit it.

  • not good :(

    Beatles version mch better than this one. Too fast. Oasis says theyre the Beatles succesors. I think they are, but only in the hairdoo :D

  • oasis dont say they are the succesors, they say they are bigger, and in my opinion they are, coz theyre fuckin mega!!!

  • i was at this concert,it was great night.

  • You guys seriously haven't heard Neal Morse NAIL this! If only Neal was lead singer of Oasis, if only (not disrespecting Liam but...)

  • If you want to hear Oasis do I am the Walrus you should get your hands on The Masterplan. This version is great but I genuinely think the version they did on their compi is better than the original!

  • you guys dont know what ur talking about. ya the beatles version is better than this version, but this is only one of many live versions. there are like 5 versions on youtube alone that are better then the beatles doing it. versions where liam nailsthe vocals

  • shut the fuck up jazzman1985 its fooooking great!!

  • That's bad...the guitar sound is awful and they play it way too fast.

  • I expected a better rendition. Way too fast and a terrible voice for this song. Stick to Wonderwall.

  • typical yank statement "stick to wonderwall lol" only oasis song hes heard of. u and ur shit country missed out on oasis BIGTIME in the 90's.