LOST 2x1 "Man of Science, Man of Faith" - DELETED SCENE

[froggymicwop]

this show is sexist enough without this scene. good call on cutting it.

[manuep666]

I was re-watching this episode today, and remembering the script with the whole Adam and Eve thing, I thought that Kate deep down probably wanted him to stop her.

Imagine my surprise when reading on Lostpedia that Charlie thought so too!

Nice scene, and maybe they shouldnt have deleted it, cause it explains much better why Jack all of a sudden "changed his mind".

[lucaspepa]

lol girlz

[simpleton7]

Charlie isn't saying that because she's a girl she wants to be subservient - he's saying that Kate fancies Jack and wants his approval.

[Trsh3r]

and how is that not sexist? poor little girl wants big daddy jack's approval...

[februarysongawake]

I disagree that it's sexist. There ARE some differences between men and women, not just with anatomy. I'm not trying to get into a full out debate on the issue, but I'm just pointing out that it's really not sexist.

[brianman4815162342]

What it really means is, Charlie's suggesting that Kate thinks Jack really cares about her, and that if he does he'd tell her not to go rather than just let her go. Charlie's suggesting Kate did it to try to prove Jack loves her.

[jenbojenbojeno]

I liked that scene!!!

[universe93]

duh jack. duh.

[jrcaporal]

this is in TV Guide Bonus CD-ROM

[Dayln3]

here you go M8Cell - idk if you still want it

Jack : yeah charlie, she went out there with him

Charlie: well why'd you let her go?

Jack: i didnt let her do anything!

Charlie: well she kind of asked for your permission.

Jack: Kate doesn't ask for anyone's permission. She does whatever she wants.

Charlie: Yeah, right.You know, if she wanted to go, she would've just gone!You know, lets not forget she IS a girl Jack. Maybe, she wanted you to tell her NOT to go.

[herrded]

Bla Bla

[ReliableProductions]

Why is this scene so amazing? Someone please elaborate

[M8cell]

could anybody type the whole dialoge as comment?

[theoddbird]

I love that scene. Aww, I wish they put it in. Charlie <333

[ambersumiko]

Cool, I can see why it was deleted though.. a bit much jibberjabbering from Charlie (though he does say insightful things). I think they were sticking with Jack's character being a bit aloof about Kate/women/their feelings. lol

[jennylaloca23]

it is a genius scene

Problably it gave away to much

[JohnEko]

what the hell is so amazing about it?

[Giuly82]

Why do they delete this amazing scene?

[cudlitedi123]

ah that was good