i love how there's such a since of bitterness and anger in this scene, you can hear it in his voice the disdain for life after what has happened, it's very deep
She should have died hereafter There would have been time for such a word. Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow Creeps in this petty pace from day to day To the last syllable of recorded time; And all our yesterdays have lighted fools The way to dusty death Out, out brief candle? Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player That struts and frets his hour upon the stage And then is heard no more. It is a talr Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, Singnifying............ NOTHING
I rather like Patrick Stewart's version better. Not saying that Sir Ian did a bad job or anything. Just stating that I think Patrick Stewart's performance was better.
@Wildstar100 And I agree with you. A little bit of trivia that I found out threw my English Teacher was that Sir Stewart was actually given a little bit of advice by Sir Ian. Just a rather interesting note I thought I might add.
@IlRezzonico the thing about Shakespeare is that all the works could be compared different. For example Hamlet's first scene most interpret as dark and moody. However, Kenneth Branagh played it more from the emotional angle, with tears in his eyes and it was moving. But so were other versions of the dark and moody perception.
Here I think the more "wooden" tone as you say, fits perfectly well because this is the point Macbeth is done and knows it. I'd be hollow and wooden too I think.
@Goddessdaughter It just sounds fake and phoney - he is just reading the lines out. No emotion! I much prefer the Roman Polanski film - the acting is much better, much more believable.
@IlRezzonico That's your interpretation. But again, at this point in the play Macbeth was realized his wife is dead, he's killed his King, his best friend, and another friend's wife, servants and children and that he himself is alone in the world and about to be challenged, possibly killed.
He has no soul at this point. He gave up his soul to feed his ambition.
I like Polanski's Macbeth as well, they're two different takes on the character and shouldn't be compared but apprecitated.
@IlRezzonico What will fascinate you is to record yourself reading this speech without preparation & then with preparation. Very likely the first will sound better. The poetry does 90% of the work. Mostly, adding emotion ruins the beauty.
I am a big fan of Faulkner, who used "a tale told by an idiot signifying nothing" as the inspiration and dedication for one of his best novels: The Sound & The Fury.
There's a point you get to, when your mind and feelings have been put through so much, that you have so many conflicting emotions blowing through you. You still function in the outside world, but when called on to speak on deep matters, everything comes out strange: if speech was form, it's bent; if taste, it's sour; if a key, minor. You can't display expected emotions properly or consistently. It's a terrible state in which to be.
I get the impression that this character at this point in the story is at the wit's end of his resolve, as if he's suffered enough up to this point that he's losing the will to continue, kind of like everything he's done, every accomplishment and the happy times he's had in the past have lost all meaning because of recent events. Basically just at the point of "What is the point of trying to move on when it's just going to be the same thing every day". McKellan doesn't seem that upset though
Jon Finch's version is a terrible use of the text (he has no idea how to use it), self-indulgent, melodramatic, and cliche "Shakespearean acting," rather than coming from his own sense of truth as an actor.
Ian's is a masterful use of the text (he bends it to his will), very generous in his connection with the audience, and deeply, deeply truthful, with no cliches. He deeply personalizes it, while brilliantly utilizing the inherent tools that Shakespeare provides in the text.
Sir McKellen sounds rather, broken up, and choppy because, myself as an aspiring actor has learned that in order to sell the role you have to make it seem as if the audience has never heard the lines before, and make it look like you are coming up with it as you go. Not remembering from a script.
My grandpa taught me this speech off by heart, I know it like the back of my hand, but listening to Ian McKellen perform is is the first time I ever really heard it.
@petrogulak John Finch is one of the finest Macbeth's I've ever seen. McKellen is good, but this speech is nowhere near poignant enough. I appreciate what he was trying to do (show that he wasn't affected by lady Macbeth's death due to his insanity and detachment), but as one understands it, Macbeth is a character capable of love, and nowhere near as evil as some productions make him out to be. This speech is his genuine emotional suffering.
I agree. This version is too intense and angry and overly dramatic with the 'direct into the camera' approach. The final word 'nothing' is broken into two words noth-ing for no real reason that I can tell other than for dramatic effect. Finch's soliloquy sounds much more introspective, resigned, and tired, which reflects the attitude of the words more closely. Macbeth isn't angry when he says these words, he's more resigned and sad as he has just been told of his wife's suicide.
I have to say, as an English major who devoutedly uses Shakespearean references for so much, loves that body of work so dearly...
I've considered Hamlet's "To be or not to be" soliloquoy the epitomy of Western literature, and I still believe it holds that lofty place.
But THIS...
'Tis a far, far better monologue I hear now than most oft have I ever heard before! (Is it OK to spoof Dickens to complement Shakespeare?) ;) McKellen is a PRO, he takes a great speech and BRINGS IT TO LIFE!
@mellowmeful omg, i gotta memorize it for a speech assignment in like 3 weeks so my teacher gave it to us so we can have time for all the emotion n tempo n gestures,
He's an actor, he says the lines the way he feels the character would say them in that situation. So he decided to split the word apart to put more emphasis on it, simple as that.
We used to refer to him (affectionately) as Ian McOveract. He does a bit ,but is a mesmersing charismatic presence on the stage, so his overacting was always forgiveable.
not how i'd do it
Jemmer1000 3 weeks ago
1976. Ian McKellan as Macbeth. Judi Dench as Lady Macbeth. Great actors!
Myrdden71 3 weeks ago
holy smokes! when was this?!
maskisland2 1 month ago
I don't wanna sound idiot, but the best perfomance of this has been done by Homer Simpson
TheJesusalex 1 month ago
@TheJesusalex Sorry, but you do sound like an idiot...
c1o2k3i4e5 1 week ago
this is fabulously camp
borisdrubetskoy 1 month ago
C'esst toi le tomorrow
Rp9500 1 month ago
Comment removed
MasterWarner 2 months ago
i love how there's such a since of bitterness and anger in this scene, you can hear it in his voice the disdain for life after what has happened, it's very deep
MasterWarner 2 months ago 4
xXSmooveFanXx 2 months ago
Comment removed
therealplease 2 months ago
I rather like Patrick Stewart's version better. Not saying that Sir Ian did a bad job or anything. Just stating that I think Patrick Stewart's performance was better.
GothRevolutionary 3 months ago
@GothRevolutionary I agree. They're both good. But Sir Stewart's version seemed to have more...remorse and regret in it.
Wildstar100 2 months ago
@Wildstar100 And I agree with you. A little bit of trivia that I found out threw my English Teacher was that Sir Stewart was actually given a little bit of advice by Sir Ian. Just a rather interesting note I thought I might add.
GothRevolutionary 2 months ago
@GothRevolutionary Yeah, I thought that was really cool. Seems that they're good friends outside of the acting screen.
Wildstar100 2 months ago
Tight
HipHopcheerleader 3 months ago
this one was shit O_O? homer simpsons one was way better;p
seanmelia123 3 months ago
Life is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.....so true
edacheeky 3 months ago
i have to learn this 4 english by tomarrow, never gona happen ><
CI321 3 months ago
@CI321 SAME HERE
celiamcclure 3 months ago
@celiamcclure i got a 100 ^^ no idea how i did it haha
CI321 3 months ago
I don't like this. Not the way I like the lines recited.
Planetoxo 3 months ago
what's sad is Kevin Costner is as yank as it gets and he performed this scene better than any of these guys
Omatusano 4 months ago
@Omatusano hah dont be ridiculous
MrStig691 4 months ago
I'm amazed at how sweaty he is, he seems to deal with it quite well...
jasonz777z 4 months ago
Ahh ty for putting this up. This has to be my fave part of the play :D
nicobrown 4 months ago
Very wooden performance - terrible!
IlRezzonico 6 months ago
@IlRezzonico the thing about Shakespeare is that all the works could be compared different. For example Hamlet's first scene most interpret as dark and moody. However, Kenneth Branagh played it more from the emotional angle, with tears in his eyes and it was moving. But so were other versions of the dark and moody perception.
Here I think the more "wooden" tone as you say, fits perfectly well because this is the point Macbeth is done and knows it. I'd be hollow and wooden too I think.
Goddessdaughter 5 months ago
@Goddessdaughter It just sounds fake and phoney - he is just reading the lines out. No emotion! I much prefer the Roman Polanski film - the acting is much better, much more believable.
IlRezzonico 5 months ago
@IlRezzonico That's your interpretation. But again, at this point in the play Macbeth was realized his wife is dead, he's killed his King, his best friend, and another friend's wife, servants and children and that he himself is alone in the world and about to be challenged, possibly killed.
He has no soul at this point. He gave up his soul to feed his ambition.
I like Polanski's Macbeth as well, they're two different takes on the character and shouldn't be compared but apprecitated.
Goddessdaughter 5 months ago
@IlRezzonico What will fascinate you is to record yourself reading this speech without preparation & then with preparation. Very likely the first will sound better. The poetry does 90% of the work. Mostly, adding emotion ruins the beauty.
P1B1U1H1 4 months ago
According to imdb, this was adapted to television by Trevor Nunn and actually directed by Philip Casson. Confirm/deny?
BetaJester 6 months ago
I think he does this better than Patrick Stewart. You can't make these words contemporary or conversational
michael38921 6 months ago
Never liked this "interpretation". Patrick Stewart does it better. The mind's ear does it best of all.
novadrian 7 months ago
Ugh, we watched this for English and it was so bad :/
hanaporter 7 months ago
Best soliloquy ever!
petrucci14 7 months ago
That was good.
paulmokjr 8 months ago
Good kittens Mr. McKellen was a handsome young man! Now he's a lovable older man.
fslayer1290 8 months ago
I am a big fan of Faulkner, who used "a tale told by an idiot signifying nothing" as the inspiration and dedication for one of his best novels: The Sound & The Fury.
bikeweekmj 9 months ago
Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow!!
jeter810227 9 months ago
He counds cynical. Patrick Stewart sounded defeated. The two are so different but both are awesome.
sondano 10 months ago
@sondano
I was just thinking the same thing.
ShahidMiller 9 months ago
McKellen is ossum!
FrozenSun416 10 months ago
There's a point you get to, when your mind and feelings have been put through so much, that you have so many conflicting emotions blowing through you. You still function in the outside world, but when called on to speak on deep matters, everything comes out strange: if speech was form, it's bent; if taste, it's sour; if a key, minor. You can't display expected emotions properly or consistently. It's a terrible state in which to be.
vidaliadear 10 months ago
@Acteontanit What's funny about that is that Patrick Stewart took notes on this speech from Ian McKellen.
It's in related videos
etherealangel712 11 months ago
I get the impression that this character at this point in the story is at the wit's end of his resolve, as if he's suffered enough up to this point that he's losing the will to continue, kind of like everything he's done, every accomplishment and the happy times he's had in the past have lost all meaning because of recent events. Basically just at the point of "What is the point of trying to move on when it's just going to be the same thing every day". McKellan doesn't seem that upset though
berner 11 months ago
Patrick stewart does it better
Acteontanit 11 months ago
Jon Finch's version is a terrible use of the text (he has no idea how to use it), self-indulgent, melodramatic, and cliche "Shakespearean acting," rather than coming from his own sense of truth as an actor.
Ian's is a masterful use of the text (he bends it to his will), very generous in his connection with the audience, and deeply, deeply truthful, with no cliches. He deeply personalizes it, while brilliantly utilizing the inherent tools that Shakespeare provides in the text.
jsterninmoser 11 months ago
Is it just me, or does young Ian McKellan remind you of Spike from Buffy?
The features, the speech pattern. It's kind of eery.
jsterninmoser 11 months ago
Especially on "out, out brief candle."
On another note, I LOVE his use of "no-thing."
jsterninmoser 11 months ago
I have goosebumps
pjcasabuena 1 year ago
Sir McKellen sounds rather, broken up, and choppy because, myself as an aspiring actor has learned that in order to sell the role you have to make it seem as if the audience has never heard the lines before, and make it look like you are coming up with it as you go. Not remembering from a script.
RespawningGiraffe 1 year ago
Mr Stewart is making me watch this.
twigothique 1 year ago 2
WOW! I saw this in school about a year ago and had no idea it was Ian McKellen! I guess I wasn't paying attention at the time. This is just amazing!
CrowHavenBM 1 year ago
My grandpa taught me this speech off by heart, I know it like the back of my hand, but listening to Ian McKellen perform is is the first time I ever really heard it.
MichaelHeroin 1 year ago
ian mckellen=epic win! thumbs up if u agree!
Exodus3003 1 year ago
can you upload the full performance please?
WatchMyAwesomeVideos 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Jon Finch did this much better.
westlock 1 year ago
@westlock Jon Finch? Polanski's Macbeth? You must be joking.
petrogulak 1 year ago 73
@petrogulak John Finch is one of the finest Macbeth's I've ever seen. McKellen is good, but this speech is nowhere near poignant enough. I appreciate what he was trying to do (show that he wasn't affected by lady Macbeth's death due to his insanity and detachment), but as one understands it, Macbeth is a character capable of love, and nowhere near as evil as some productions make him out to be. This speech is his genuine emotional suffering.
southparkobsessive 1 year ago
@petrogulak I agree with you. No means of comparision. My predilte on screen is Welles(1948).
miguelmouta 6 months ago
@westlock As did Nicol Williamson.
Jitpring 1 year ago
@westlock lol
ISt0leTheCookies 1 year ago
@westlock
I agree. This version is too intense and angry and overly dramatic with the 'direct into the camera' approach. The final word 'nothing' is broken into two words noth-ing for no real reason that I can tell other than for dramatic effect. Finch's soliloquy sounds much more introspective, resigned, and tired, which reflects the attitude of the words more closely. Macbeth isn't angry when he says these words, he's more resigned and sad as he has just been told of his wife's suicide.
ariot42 1 year ago
@westlock No one does it like Sir Ian
HeyArdenGarden 3 months ago
I have to say, as an English major who devoutedly uses Shakespearean references for so much, loves that body of work so dearly...
I've considered Hamlet's "To be or not to be" soliloquoy the epitomy of Western literature, and I still believe it holds that lofty place.
But THIS...
'Tis a far, far better monologue I hear now than most oft have I ever heard before! (Is it OK to spoof Dickens to complement Shakespeare?) ;) McKellen is a PRO, he takes a great speech and BRINGS IT TO LIFE!
obiwanobiwan13 1 year ago 3
i forgot to breathe
BroadwayHannah 1 year ago 24
I don't like how Shakespheare acting is more about the voice than facial expressions or emotions.
toby099 1 year ago
Ian McKellen bears such a striking resemblance to my late grandfather, it's outright frightening.
vanderbilt887 1 year ago
I want to cry. and applaud this
meow9772 1 year ago
it's the & that's important.
godfreemorals 1 year ago
i have known these lines ever since i was 16 :D i love this play!!
yu5bloom 1 year ago
really really really wierdly one of the best versions i have heard of this speech is from homer simpson XD
DVpk47 1 year ago
the weight he gives to "... and tomorrow" is AMAZING. it weighs so heavily.
missklc 1 year ago
I have to memorize this for next week as homework! This is perfect!
He's an amazing actor...
mellowmeful 1 year ago
@mellowmeful omg, i gotta memorize it for a speech assignment in like 3 weeks so my teacher gave it to us so we can have time for all the emotion n tempo n gestures,
KibiRasengan5 1 year ago
what an actor!
milosbez 2 years ago
This is the BEST HOMEWORK EVA.
igotdembombs 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I've noticed that in most of the videos on this scene, they say Nuhh.....thing.....is there a reason they do that?
RKAS43 2 years ago
He's an actor, he says the lines the way he feels the character would say them in that situation. So he decided to split the word apart to put more emphasis on it, simple as that.
Slntpsych 2 years ago 3
Yeah, but every actor I've seen does the same thing....unless he came first and they're all copying him.....
RKAS43 2 years ago
Comment removed
IndianaDylan 2 years ago
Do I imagine it, or does he get sweatier while the scene goes on?
paperbullet1945 2 years ago 4
Some things just sound better with a damn British accent!
powerbookg 2 years ago 71
@powerbookg Which is hilarious seeing as how Macbeth was actually a Scot. xD however........I agree.
Goddessdaughter 5 months ago
I had to do this in front of my English class senior year. It is truly amazing to hear it from the master.
Evilliboba 2 years ago 2
haha I am doing it in front of mine tomorrow.
fuzukaru 2 years ago
you shall not pass!
peavoyj 2 years ago 46
@peavoyj lol!
TheKrystahlPhoenix 8 months ago
The important word there was "and"
pplschmpion 2 years ago 2
*chills*
Kiribati42 2 years ago
Being but a mere butler, you will not know the great theatre tradition ... that one does never speak the name ... of the scottish play.
kealyc 2 years ago
actually I was told it's fine to say it outside of a theatre, but I guess traditions vary
sharonch217 2 years ago
you'r wrong. you only name Macbeth the scottish play on the opening night. And i should know, i've just been in it.
Williams573 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pretentious fucking custom.
holydave 2 years ago
haha tell me about it!
Williams573 2 years ago 2
i love his playing
Morok2008 2 years ago
magneto
Aquasam8 2 years ago
lol nice
fr33shm3n 2 years ago
I love him in this haha he is amazing ^-^
manderzluvsyou91 2 years ago
We used to refer to him (affectionately) as Ian McOveract. He does a bit ,but is a mesmersing charismatic presence on the stage, so his overacting was always forgiveable.
heliotropezzz333 2 years ago
It is Shakespeare, made for the stage, you are supposed to overact.
1stCainite 2 years ago
Gandalf! ^_^
QueenOfTheRandom 3 years ago