What If

[CeruleanPhoenix7]

Fantastic video and great song choice :) You did J/C proud.

I noticed some comments talking about the novel "Full Circle" and I'll say that it was one of the most emotional and beautifully written books I've ever read in Star Trek. It's tragic, but it's done well.

[madxio]

god this would be such an amazing fic. you basically wrote it for us.

[KathrynJonVoy]

I love it, Belanna! I wonder why I didn't find it earlier, lol. A friend just sent me the link. This is exactly the type of JC vid I love the most - it's something that let you dream "What If" and touches your heart.

[83annak]

I am absolutely not a J/C shipper, but this video is very good and emotional and the editing is well done!!! The music fits perfectly!

[voyagerlover1000]

I know its my favorite but there is a protest to bring her back on Facebook

[voyagerlover1000]

Then she was taken from him /-(

[ColdHeartedSoul89]

@voyagerlover1000 i still loved that book. it's sad and tragic but still kinda beautiful. idk, i'm in love with tragic figures...

[83annak]

Great video, so emotional! Thanks for sharing!

[Dreizahn]

I think they got together after the arrival on earth. C dumped 7 the minute they got back; that whole relationship was just too weird.

C&J are meant for each other and back home they can finally act on seven years of repressed feelings.

J/C 4 ever!!!

[ColdHeartedSoul89]

@Dreizahn that's what they did in the books :]

[Dreizahn]

@ColdHeartedSoul89 they did? which books?

[ColdHeartedSoul89]

@Dreizahn Kirsten Beyer's Full Circle is a good J/C book, then there's her story Isabo's Shirt, and then there's Star Trek Myriad Universes: Infinty's Prism.

[Dreizahn]

@ColdHeartedSoul89 Thanks for the tips. Am on page 106 of Full Circle :)

[ColdHeartedSoul89]

@Dreizahn you're welcome. how r u enjoying it? do you have Isabo's shirt yet? I have that one in html if you want it, it's also written by Kirsten Beyer and is a good J/C read.

[Dreizahn]

@ColdHeartedSoul89 I like it (unexpectedly). It's a good J/C read, by now I can recite pp. 340-347 by heart :)))

I'd like to read Isabo's Shirt as well, thought about buying it after Christmas actually.

[ColdHeartedSoul89]

@Dreizahn Isabo's Shirt is a good read but you'd have to buy the whole book just for that one story. haha, yep Full Circle is definately my fav. read, no matter how tragic it may be :]

[Kimmuryiel]

2:28, 3:50...what episodes are those from?

[Belanna42]

@Kimmuryiel Fair Haven and Night

[Kimmuryiel]

@Belanna42 thank you :D

[antodav]

Very sad. But the song is perfectly encapsulates the frustration of those of us who believed in J/C. Will we truly never know? Perhaps…or perhaps not…

[ColdHeartedSoul89]

the vid is so sad but the song is really beautful. i love it. love hurts (sniff sniff) so sad...

[pachehr]

thank you.. I love it

[jewlz1234567]

Beautiful, Amazing, Brilliant

plus you  nearly brought me to tears! Brilliant work!!! Throughly loved it! x

[Belanna42]

Thank you so much, I am so glad you enjoyed it :)

[cardsfan2404]

beautiful video. by chance, do you know what the name of the episode was when janeway met her spirit guide?

[Belanna42]

Thank you so much, glad you liked it. Yes, the episode is from season 1 I believe, The Cloud :)

[sweetgirl449]

nice song choice!

[Belanna42]

Thank you, it is a beautiful song. :)

[HouseofJaneway]

I wonder if one of the reasons we love J/C is because of all the adversity these two went through. Their whole relationship was a huge "what if"... which makes everything about them more poignant.

[luvondarox]

That was one of the reasons I loved J/C. I've never quite gotten the C/7 thing - it was just...I dunno... awkward? Sudden? Those two never had the same kind of chemistry that Janeway and Chakotay had.

This is definitely my favorite J/C video, though. I always thought that Janeway thought about it from time to time - especially when they made it to Earth.

[Kimmuryiel]

glad to know I'm not the only one with those feelings about the whole C/7...Janeway and Chakotay were dating long before they even found borg in the delta quadrant :P

[Kimmuryiel]

as I've heard it put, their relationship has more reality to it

[ElisaTrapt]

Wow, this is one of the BEST J/C vids I've seen. You really captured the essence and tone of their relationship. So sad that they never got the chance....Wonderful job!

[Belanna42]

Thank you, glad you liked it :D

[MarcusSLazarus]

Excellent reflection on Janeway's opinion of their relationship at the end of the series; if she'd been more willing to give him the chance that she 'rejected' after New Earth, would she and Chakotay have worked out?

[Belanna42]

Thank you, it's a very good song. Kinda explains the whole relationship of JC :D I really wished it worked out. Much better the the end result of barbie of borg/Chakotay

[scifi3005]

Lovely lovely lovely!

J/C together forever!

Great video and good music choice!

LOL

[Belanna42]

Thank you, glad you enjoyed it :D

[Trekkeee]

once more, folks, we have another heart-rendering and beautifuly put together music video from Belanna42!!!!!

[JCallthewaynotC7]

*tears* i love this one B <3

[Belanna42]

*hands tissue* Thanks, love. glad you liked it.

XXX

[luvondarox]

This is awesome! It's such a sad song, but it totally fits. I didn't know that Winslet could sing!

A question, though - what episode is at 2:05? I haven't seen that one.

[Belanna42]

Wow, you have never seen that episode before? Coda is one of the best J/C episodes ever.. (in my opinion) but i won't spoil it for you. :) It's a good episode, and it's season three :D

[luvondarox]

*dies of embarrassment* I seriously haven't even heard of that episode before. Now I have to find it! Thank you!

[Belanna42]

~Hugs~ You are in for a treat!! :D And you're welcome. :)

[bethalice1991]

sorry i'm just like commenting all your video's but they are bloody brilliant!

I love them all so far, this one eeek i love it.

i love how you capture the moment with the song and the clip if you get what i mean! I used to make vids my self and i know it can be quite hard sometimes, but your brilliant!

:D

[Belanna42]

Aww, well I am glad you enjoyed it :) Thank you so much for commenting. It's comments like these that make me thrive to do more :D

[bethalice1991]

:) Good i love your videos!

I'd love to make some of my own, but i don't do pictures and haven't got any clips, which is a bit rubbish!

:)

[Belanna42]

Thank you again for enjoying them :D

[Msynergy89]

Beautifully heartbreaking.

[Belanna42]

Thank you :)

[hrcsdipspwh]

ok - so I know they never get together on the show, but this song is soooo sad. suits them perfectly, though. great vid.

[Belanna42]

Thank you so much, it is a sad song. And you're right it fits them perfectly :) Glad you enjoyed the video. :)

[chocobo87]

Love it:D Especially the visual effects^^

[Belanna42]

Thank you :) ~Hug~

[Kittencute12]

Oh my gosh this was such a beautiful video. I am crying too. It was so nice, great job.

[CaptKJaneway]

Beautiful, as always Bel!!! :hug: CKJ

[Belanna42]

Thank you, CKJ!! ~Hugs~

[CountryLovergrl8]

I am crying man, this is so sad, yet it is so great...wow.

[Belanna42]

*hands CL a tissue* Thank you hon, glad you liked it. :)

[Belanna42]

Thank you :)

[bObbiiL3e]

Beautiful Song, For A Beautiful Video!

LOVE IT!

[Belanna42]

Thank you, glad you liked it :)

[TrekkieDuck12]

aww, that was awesome! the song was prefect for J/C good job!

[Belanna42]

Thank you, glad you enjoyed it :)

[kinda0crazay]

*SOB*

:D

[Belanna42]

:) aww.. hehe :D

[KatherineJaneway]

Well, now I'm crying =D Great video!

[Belanna42]

Aww, (huggles) *hands a tissue* Glad you, enjoyed it. :)

[SurfaceMonster]

oh and also very very very very nice vid that almost made me cry

[Belanna42]

Umm, you mean who sings this song? Kate Winslet sings this song :)

[SurfaceMonster]

HEy whats the artist of end of all hope pls i love that song

[Sczep84]

That's so beautiful. The song is terrific and the video even better :-)

[Belanna42]

Thank you, glad you liked it :D

[janewaysboots]

aww Belanna that was BEAUTIFUL!!!

[Belanna42]

Aww, thank you.. glad you enjoyed it :)

[NamelessWorrior]

wow, great vid

[Belanna42]

Thank you :)

[CaptKJaneway]

Wow Bel. You just keep getting better and better. That is amazing.

[Belanna42]

aww, thank you CKJ :D

[BeverlyJeanway]

Aw Beautiful! Great song for them -- "I had to draw the line" -- totally Janeway!! You are like the video queen Belanna!

[Belanna42]

Aww, thanks BEV!!! (huggles) I am so happy you enjoyed it!!! :D

[movielover18]

btw nice fairy wings of kate! did u get a chance 2 see my new vid love 2 here what u got 2 say on it n the last 1 is a bit long but it was my firt ever crack at it i am pretty sure!

[movielover18]

cool another kate i like sings! great vid!!! great song 2!!

[Belanna42]

Thank you :)

[movielover18]

ur welcome! u know i just thought of something kw is just km just upside down! they go 2 gether great!

[Belanna42]

LOL, you're right.... hehe :) nice catch!

[movielover18]

thankQ i saw that u got a myspace nice! add em i sent u a friend request! my name is beklt!

[Belanna42]

I usually don't get on myspace. I dont like it as much as Livejournal. :D

[movielover18]

i know what u mean i only discovered lj because myspace didn't want to let me on my page so i discovered lj! n all of yall!! n i keep thnaking god 4 that 1!!!

[Belanna42]

:) Yep, I have met many friends on LJ... it was a blessing to find it :)

[movielover18]

same here! n utube as well i wouldn't have meet my big sis on here either this is a blessing 2!!

[ojos1123]

I love it! The story this vid tells and the song are perfect for J/C. Awasome job.

[Belanna42]

Thanks Ojos :D

[startrekgirljaneway]

it couldent have done any better.

[Belanna42]

Thank you very much :D

[minkles2]

This was a wonderful video. Really goes with the song! Too bad they never quite made it as a couple :(

[Belanna42]

Thanks Minkles, I am glad you enjoyed it. Yes, I am sorry that they didn't even acknowledged it. B&B really screwed it up, which was a shame. :(

[clairevoyagerfan]

wow is that really KW? greaT song and wonderful vid did KW do anymore songs ?:D

[Belanna42]

Thanks Claire. I don't know if KW did anymore songs... I was shocked to even hear she did this song.. hahaha :D ~hugs~

[jetclover]

::Sniff:: So sad, but so great, Bel. Awesome! Thank You :D xooxx

[Belanna42]

Aww, thanks Gilly. Your comments mean so much to me. Thank you. ~huggles~

[MissMegara]

Just wonderfull...as always. It almost got me crying. 5 stars.

[Belanna42]

Thanks Megara. I am so happy you enjoyed it :D

[janewayish]

I know I keep repeating myself, but as always beautiful, it made me teary eyed!!  thank-you

[Belanna42]

Aww, thanks Janewayish. Glad you enjoyed it :D

[tbgrace]

That is a great video Bel. and to KatLady: good choice on the song. I didn't know Kate Winslet could sing this well either.

[Belanna42]

Thanks TB, glad you enjoyed it. And Yes, I was shocked that KW could sing as well.. lol

[KittyInTheWind]

Wow. That was a beautiful video. Just wow. -sniffle- The song fits perfectly.

[Belanna42]

Thanks Kitty :D

[KimmyMalfoy45]

this is beyond brillaint! i love the fuzzy effect in the beginning, and this song is perfect! kate winslet is brilliant and this vid is def. my favorite of yours so far! great work!

[Belanna42]

wow, thank you so much for the wonderful comment Kimmy. :) I am glad you enjoyed it. ~hugs~

[sexbell]

your welcome

[sexbell]

i have one word 4 you

BEAUTIFUL

[Belanna42]

Aww ~huggles~ Thanks Bell!! :D

[eca13]

Heartbreaking song and your video matched the mood perfectly. Well done....again!

[Belanna42]

Thanks Eca! I am glad you enjoyed it. ;D

[cptHayley]

aww tht song is so sad. great vid once again! gave it 5 stars!

[Belanna42]

Aww, thanks Hayley! Glad you liked it :) And yes, it is a very sad song.. but sometimes the sad songs give you a better perception of what is going on... :D

[trekkerchick]

seriously you shuld make a career out of this ur vids are excellent!!

[Belanna42]

(blush) aww shucks, hehe.. thanks Trekker!!! ~Hugs~

[PixiePiehole]

I love theeffects you added.

[Belanna42]

Thanks PIxie :D

[walkyriekathryn]

**died watching** Such a wonderful vid my Bel aaaaaaaw god !!! LOVE it !!! you are the most talented personn I know !!!! You have always so brilliant songs & put then so well with the pics. Hugs from your big sissy :)

[Belanna42]

Aww, thank you big sissy!! I try the best I can to do pics with Lyrics... this song came out very well I think. :) And.. (blush) aww, I am not that talented..hehehe XOXOX -Your little Sissy

[walkyriekathryn]

STOP !!! YOU ARE TALENTED !!!!!! in which language do I have to tell it ;) LOL ! I am amazed that you find always so wonderful songs ! This is my major problems ... To find good ones *cry*

[redreh]

wait, kate winslet, as in, ACTRESS kate winslet? Wow.

Great vid, btw, of course.

[Belanna42]

Thanks redreh.. and yes... Kate Winslet the actress, sings this song. You can actually type in "Kate Winslet What If" on youtube and get her music video to this :)

[DesertStorm494]

This song has always stood out for me, I love it, is the only Kate Winslet song I like. Love the video, love the effects and love the sequences!! Ace Video in short =D

[Belanna42]

Thanks DS :) glad you loved it!

[CaptJamieway]

Another beautiful video!

[Belanna42]

Thanks Jamie! ~hugs~

[Tokath1988]

Jeez, Its been years since i heard this song.... Wow. Im impressed, thanks again B42 :D

[Belanna42]

Thanks T1988, glad you liked it :D

[shakayla2000]

Beautiful song...beautiful video...sad but beautiful. Thanks, B'Elanna!

[Belanna42]

Thank you :)