Added: 2 years ago
From: ptiiteliiz
Views: 216,898
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (242)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I like both versions, but I like this one better. I think this one sounds more emotional, but it may simply be that as a guy it's easier for me to relate to a male singer. I definitely like the guitar solo in this version better.

  • I prefer this to the Stevie Nicks version. Both are good, though.

  • this song makes me sad lol :-(

  • Nothing's better than Stevie!

  • Jeez I was just going through my favorites and had forgotten all about this song, oh Lord how this song touches me deeply at times when thinking about my past...

    The beauty is that anyone can relate to this song, it pretty much means anything you want it too. Music at it's finest.

  • I think it's perfectly valid to compare versions of this song. The trick is to do so intelligently. On that note I think this version is much better than the original or any live versions I keep hearing from Stevie. This guitar work has more feeling and Billy's vocal is far more emotive. there's just way more feeling and expression in this version, in my opinion. Plus....it just sounds better/prettier (totally subjective but still a fair comment )

  • cover from Bush is better in my opinion, but the song iitself is beautiful, beautiful lyrics...

  • This song is just making me not want to have high school end and have all of those changes happen. All if not most of my freinds will sepeate, i won't see proably half of my class anymore even if they annoy the cap out of me, so much responsabiliy coming soon even if i don't like it, :(

    "well i have been afraid of changing because i built my life around you"

  • @rman2590 cmon dude, would you really start complaining about not seeing kids from your High School anymore? You're going to meet so many new people after High School, all types of people, assholes, interesting people, crazy mother fuckers. Take graduating High School as an opportunity for more exploration of the world, people, and yourself. Of course your'e going to miss your old friends, but you all need to embrace the change that's coming. It'l be fine

  • Personally, I find the Fleetwood Mac version boring, Stevie Nicks just doesn't seem very adventurous in that song. This cover brought more of the 'feeling' to the song than Stevie Nicks did, everyone complains about the off-key singing, but I feel thats what makes the song stand out more.

  • @ArmadBusMusic you must be kidding. Let me guess your under 30 and werent around when the song first came out. I think this version is just annoying. Like im 18 but nobody beats stevie as far as female song writers are concerned. shes fantastic and i think its laughable you could say she isnt very adventurous. are you on the same drugs she was? lol

  • @667neighborofdabeast It's called an opinion, jerk. Obviously, you don't have the mental ability to grasp that.

  • The song itself is a beautiful song whatever version. I prefer smashing pumpkins even though his vocals are a little funny

  • I just decided, I'm going to sing this to my kids when I'm older and have kids :P

  • I wish i could see some comments about the song, not about where it came from or which one was the original or which one was better. Just the fact that this song has brought joy to people. Why can't we have comments like that?

    (WARNING: thumbsing this comment up will result in the death of santa.)

  • This is Steamy Ray Vaughn!

  • @MultiHalofreak1 i know even if hes says that hes most likely guilty of doing it too lol.

  • This version always gets me, there's just alot of feeling in it, and true appreciation for the song, I wish all covers were as good as this.

  • love this song, all versions.

    good job ;p

  • This song always makes me feel warm inside :3

  • For some reason, this sounds like a lullaby to me<3 :)

  • @MultiHalofreak1 dead weather, the sheepdogs...yeah thats all i got

  • whinny voice :S

  • JUST STOP LOOKING AT THE COMMENTS, PEOPLE.

    WOAHAHO LISTEN TO THE MUSIC.

  • this ones also good, adifferent attacked

  • ILOVE THE SMASHING PUMKINS THEY NEVER FAIL TO AMAZE ME

  • Billy this sucks (and I really dig you, I do)

  • "Oh mirror in the sky, what is love?

    Can the child in my heart rise above?

    Can I sail through the changing ocean tides?

    Can I handle the seasons of my life?"

    <3

  • the original was definately better you can feel the emotions coming from the fleetwood mac version and all the meaning they put behind it

  • to me this is the definitive version of this song. guitar and vocals both better than every other version.

  • stop talking about stopping talking about justin bieber! jesus christ its like the twilight zone

  • @bleedingxhearts2 That would be the most frightening episode ever!

  • STHU and listen to the song <3

  • JESUS CHRIST!!!! stop comparing justin beiber to good music like this...

  • I think people that think this song is so great should listen to the original version, this is a good cover, but I greatly prefer Fleetwood Mac's version

  • Is he for real with these vocals?! LOL. I'll take Stevie and DC over this but each to their own.

  • WONDERFUL COVER!!!!

  • Paramore did this song.. but changed the lyrics a bit.. im confused.

  • @NeverShoutBerenice those other lyrics was their song "in the mourning" , they just sung the part that starts out 'i've been afraid of changing.."

  • EPIC! <3

  • I also think the Stevie Nicks version is way superb to this...Sing louder Billy!

  • @7AW They recorded it at the BBC and in the Pisces Iscariot book they say the recording was messed up so the sound is a little low. I like the Stevie Nicks one too, but this one is awesome too

  • I honestly don't think his voice fits this song. Just sayin.

  • makes me think of the perks of being a wallflower.

  • I LUVS THIS MUCHLY ;[ SO TRUE AN A VEIL OF HAPPY TOO ;]

  • I love The Smashing Pumpkins but this is not working. Can't compare to the original song. Not even close

  • great cover of Stevie Nicks penned song

  • I honestly think the original by Fleetwood Mac and Stevie Nicks is better. :/ No I didn't click on this to troll, i clicked on it to see if it was good. SO QUIT FUCKING SAYING IMA TROLL

  • @Nikkiasaur96 For real, I agree with you. These people who said they heard this in south park are fucking children. I heard this because I appreciate good music.

  • @dradfromthebu You should be happy that people recognized this as good music, no matter where they heard it. You just sound like an arrogant asshole.

  • i honestly never knew they covered this AMAZING!

  • landslide-awesome song

    smashing pumpkins-awesome band

    MATCH MADE IN HEAVEN!

  • Seeing Billy play this live last December brought me here.

  • @Blood4glory good one. :)

    

  • I hate thiss.

  • @DRY881 your favorites are full of fucking fred. gtfo

  • Stevie Nicks brought me here :)

  • @soccermonkey52 and that's exactly how it should be.

  • Everytime I hear this Smashing Pumpkins version at 3:08 I'm expecting Starla to begin playing any second! :]

  • I try my hardest to understand why people must mention justin bieber in every fucking music video on youtube... WHO GIVES A FUCK ABOUT JUSTIN BIEBER!!!! Why should it matter what type of music ignorant people listen to...this is the kind of music that is made for people like US!!!

    ... ughhhhh!!!!

  • Both the original and this version are beautiful in distinct ways, Different doesn't necessarily mean bad. I think Fleetwood Mac give it more sentiment when she sings it, she really makes you feel nostalgic, but I really love this version too because it recreates that bittersweet feeling this song is intended to give.

  • Music is not a sport or a contest. BOTH versions of this song are top notch and made to be enjoyed not bickered over pointlessly.

  • @gtrrs71 Exactly! Music is expression. Its what you make of it. It helps you start thinking for yourself. At least a little bit. xD lol

  • @gtrrs71 what do you mean both? both of the famous covers? the dixie chicks one is garbage compared to this and just as bad when compared to the true stevie nicks version

  • @marlinm60ss123 I agree

  • the original by fleetwood mac is better

  • im sorry... i love smashing pumpkins but stevie nicks original blows this one out of the water

  • Naaaaw that's Stevie Nicks, Steamy Nicks just goes on stage and shits 'er briches

  • god, stop writing that current music is terrible. there's always been shitty music, there will always be shitty music. there's plenty of good music out there today. yes the pumpkins were great , awesome. progress in life plz.

  • @Quickgold1 Thank you...there has always been shitty music and will always be shitty music...there has always been forgettable pop garbage that will fade with time and there are always unforgettable meaningful classics that are underappreciated in their time but revered years later.

  • @Quickgold1 I agree. As time goes on the good music that's out now (lesser known bands) will emerge. There's a ton of artists that are now considered the greats of their time that were pretty alternative at the time of release. Time is the best filter of bad music.

  • @Quickgold1 fleetwood mac wrote the song, not smashing pumpkins

  • @TobyW360 I was talking about the band as a whole. I know they didn't write this.

  • @Quickgold1 i know, i just wanted to be a smartass

  • @Quickgold1 A lot of modern "music" is quite terrible though.

  • Comment removed

  • @Quickgold1 I feel like you just got done watching South Park.

  • @Quickgold1 But, but...that refutes the idea that everything that used to be is better than what is today.

  • @Quickgold1 - Wait whut? Did someone actually -insult- this fucking BEAUTIFUL cover by Billy Corgan? Stevie was good, but Billy took this song and made it his just like Johnny Cash did when he covered NIN's Hurt. People bitch "it isn't the original" so what, it's still great. Now Dixie Chicks version on the other hand, good but not as good as Billy's.

  • <3

  • stevie nicks is thousand times better...

  • I usually LOVE the Smashing Pumpkins but... this cover is basically just awful.

    Oh mann.

  • @itsAvirusxox aw I love this cover.

  • @9x0radical Lol that's fine. I don't expect everyone to have the same opinion on it as I do.

  • @itsAvirusxox I suppose.

  • @snowninja72 hey man I know what you mean. Why Dont you other guys stfu. He's not gay. He just has a heart unlike you guys.

  • Steamy Nicks

  • Comment removed

  • I swear this song was written for me, I am little kid at heart even though im only 16. I dont like when things change, and my life always has up's and down's. And i deffinatly dont know what love is because i always try to look for something deeper in people, someone whos likes me and yeah i could have a girlfriend RIGHT NOW if i wanted to. but whats the point I want something REAL

  • @snowninja72 your gay

    

  • @ANGRYREDNECKTRUCKER na im sensitive for a guy but thats what great bands so SMD

  • 36 people let the landslide bring them down

  • 36 people need to suck a big one.

  • this is shitty.

  • if the annoying orange ever covered this song, it would sound like this

  • @TexasFury definatly, this cover is shit.

  • @mazeltov11

    Really. he added nothing new to this song, except his nasal. grating, whiny voice.

  • @TexasFury exactly, finally someone on youtube who doesn't disagree with someone else's comment.

  • I really like this version, though for some reason it's a little more sad than the fleetwood mac one. I like his voice and everything, i just think he over sings some of it? I dunno how to put it :')

  • @EagleEye1411 how is this a slap in the face? How could you dislike smashing pumpkins?? If you want the real version find it elsewhere. But this version is as amazing as hers.

  • @EagleEye1411 Wow, you really are an Eagle Eye there. Congratulations! Don't like it, don't listen to it. Simple dude

  • Is he singing or having an aneurysm?

  • i always liked the lyrics to this song. but i'm not too fond of the shrieking of stevie nicks.

    this is one of my favorite songs of all time.

  • just, no. that's all i can say.

  • "And in that moment, I swear we were infinite." -Charlie, The Perks of Being a Wallflower.

    I know this is not the original version, but this one is my favorite. And it does make me feel pretty damn infinite.

  • Stevie Nicks is the original, so naturally it's better.

    But his voice fits this song well, and the guitar just sounds great! :D

  • great redo

  • this version is HORRIBLE!

    

  • stevie nick's version is better

  • @pyropratt are you kidding hers sucks hard cock,

  • stevie nicks is better....

  • So amazing.

  • i love his voice and this cover and the guitar .. i like this versionn sssoooo much more  .. sorry, but its true! btw, im sooo learning this on my guitar!! ahaha . (: GREAT VID , THANKS!!

  • The vocals on this could use a little work. It's a shame, cause I really wanted to say "this cover is smashing!" Guitar is nice, though. :D

    :/

  • South Park brought me here!

  • @zonebellond123 that episode is the best

  • Amen

  • Bravo to SP to picking up and covering something they have no business ruining.  but the guitar is great so at least it isn't a total fail

  • 28 people cant see there reflection in a snow covered hill

  • @twilightrox72658

    or experienced a landslide

  • Any fool that would state their opinion as a fact, is a fool...

    That goes for music too. 

  • The ONLY thing that I like out of this cover is the guitar, especially the guitar solo. Which sucks because I usually love Smashing Pumpkins. Gotta give it to Stevie on this one. Fleetwood Mac <3

  • Changed pitch too much

  • Wow he sounds like Mika!

  • This is REAL music!!! Fuck rebecca black, fuck justin bieber, fuck auto tune rap and hip-hop. Smashing Pumpkins FTMFW!!! 

  • @TheAcezero12078 its a stevie nicks song originally if im not mistaken, and that version is even better than this amazing version :)

  • @mikebro115 I know, but this is DEFFINITLY the BEST cover of this song. Love it so much. :,)

  • @TheAcezero12078 Why do you idiots always have to mention justin bieber and auto-tune in every song video? We get it, they're popular at the moment. Who cares?

    I don't listen to them either but you're giving them credit just by acknowledging their existence.

  • @TheAcezero12078 Thank you! thts exactly wat i tell everyone...this new now aday music sucks ASSS!!!!!

  • @TheAcezero12078 i think stevie nicks's version is better.

  • @TheAcezero12078 thank you for this condescending and unoriginal comment

  • @TheAcezero12078 That comment would be so much more relevant if this wasn't just a cover of the REAL song.

  • fleetwood mac is a million times better

  • great song, cant go wrong with the smashing pumpkins

  • great song, cant go wrong with the smashing pumpkins

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE this song! They made it so original!

  • fleetwood mac is better

  • sounds like it skips a few times 

  • This song is just amazing... Stevie's original, this cover and even when those girls from Glee covered it.

  • good, but not as good as the original

  • the smashing pumpkins made this song a lot better. they really caught the emotion of the song.

    i find it to be really sad and depressing

  • A couple sour notes in that solo, does anyone else hear that?

  • @TheDavidNoble nope :P

    

  • This sounds nothing like smashing pumpkins!

  • This is the first time I've heard a guy sing this song, and I think it was a beautiful cover.

  • replay...and again...

  • thankyou "perks of being a wallflower" :']

  • To all the haters, this was more or less a Demo / B-side recorded more than likely in just one take on basic equipment. Pretty damn good in my opinion.

  • @BCJEntertainment247 well DUH! Lol

  • Love the original version of this song. Love the version made by the Dixie Chicks..This version could have been better, though. Gotta give credit to Smashing Pumpkins for doing a cover of this song. I know a lot of people that love this version, but I think it could have been so much better.

  • @Ashhx777 me to but i love this song when i get older im singing stevie nicks version for american idol

  • @katgirl28888 Implying Idol will las that long.

  • i might of cried a little bit

  • Definitely a great tribute to Stevie Nicks.

  • well i still love stevie nicks original version more but they did do a pretty good job, and there is no avoiding it this song is so wonderful artist cant help but re-do it.its a truely beutiful song.

  • u rock for redoing this!

  • i dont like this version very much.. im not hating or being a duck but the way he changes key on diffrent words every time kinda fucks up the flow of the song... i like smashing pumpkins but not this song

  • i love the smashing pumpkins, but this version sucks donkey balls.

  • its not that this is a bad cover its just that stevie nicks has a voice all her own and thats what made this song great. in my opinion smashing pumpkings just ruined it

  • Is he pissed?

  • F U lil drummer boy

  • remake of Stevie Nicks Landslide..basically as good as hers...

  • Its not actually the smashing pumpkins, this song was recorded in Bills apartment when he was like 16 or 17 and added to a B-sides album that came out after MC&IS. At one point if you crank it up really loud, you can hear a train in the background.

  • i like it, but fleetwood mac is bett :p

  • they ruined this song, you suck smashing pumkins... he sounds like a drunk hobo that they got off the street .

  • @dwdrummer180 YOUR A HOBO!