Nice job. My ONLY critique to would be to spice up the middle section where you just hung out on the 7th and 9th frets for a while. You have a good ear for adding your own phrasing which is cool........so use it to your advantage!!!
Bravo!! Absolutely killer! What a fantastic song - and performed so incredibly well. (If you want, and have the time please feel free to do me and my cause a huge favor and check out my singing and guitar playing - like on
Comfortably Numb, Stairway to Heaven, Wind Cries Mary, etc.
OR some of my other piano or blues harp or sax performances - click on "Playlists" and please "Subscribe" and please let me know what you think.) Thanks a million!
I know, I play with an Epiphone SG Special guitar... to get the David Gilmour tone you need a Fender Strat with EMG SA active pickups, and a HIWATT amp. That REALLY expensive.
I can't say I'm thorougly satisfied with what you get out of your PodXT Live. Which is why I responded with my comfortably numb vid. I use one too, you see.
Anyway, descent job, indeed! I just wish you got the part around 1:00 right. And some bends are really, really off. But, good work!
Comfortably Numb has to be the greatest solo ever. David Gilmour is my number 1 inspiration. It's cool you didn't do a carbon copy of the solo cos you just see too many of them for any solo. Nice one man.
umm, over all very awsome cover man but make the hammer-ons and pull-offs a little smoother and and at the beginning of the song one of your bends was a little flat. but thats just me picking on the details.
you must have trained very very hard to play so well. i've got gigabytes of "things" about this song since is the best song i've ever heard in my life. the best pf version is at pulse concert. the best cover is from Billy Sherwood, Chris Squire and Alan White. keep up the good work.
sou portugues e tambem toco guitarra. mas obviamente incomparavel a ti :) tocas mega bem. nao tens um site qualquer teu que fale sobre cenas tuas.. se quiseres, ve depois um que fiz em 2000 franciscocampos (dot) com :)
i really enjoyed watching this, very nice work keep playing i would love to see you cover the money solo. most of the other crap on here is just that crap,
Nice palying and nice guitar ;)
huntelar933 5 months ago
I like this one. For those that criticize...where is your version?
pbryant76 6 months ago
Interesting, you improvised your own version but always staying close to Gilmour's main idea. Excelent playing
TedBoyRomarino 1 year ago
love it
PINKFLOYD7465 1 year ago
Excellent ;)
ItachiAlba 2 years ago
what kind of guitar is that???/ looks like a sg o rsumn like that
plz sum1 comment me back letting me know=] thx
giveemhell24 2 years ago
that was mostly pretty much wrong but not bad for a cover
TheResonate 2 years ago
read the description....
"I did not try to play the original solo. This is my version of it, with some parts from the original record and from the live DVD "PULSE"."
richardfld 2 years ago
What is, IMO, better than copying the song.
DaanJM 2 years ago
@TheResonate
Criticism FAIL!
Open your eyes and read the description next time.
miguelbaptista 1 year ago
da hora meu (:
xedlgcx 2 years ago
WOW!!! I am still learning this solo. Definitely trying to improve with my lead guitar.
pilotboy17 2 years ago
very nice dude 5!!
pv2mvaz 2 years ago
Holy cow, its a really good improvisation, u r awesome. I have the tabs if u want to learn it good just let me konw
BunkerBerry94 3 years ago
Great stuff man...intense and from the soul..keep it up
cerrhus 3 years ago
Nice job, that sounded great
kmoff11 3 years ago
yeah i need the tab too ive been trying to play guitar for 2 years already and im good already im just not good at solos
liljuve13 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cool man. Check out my version if you have the time. Peace
reening 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nice tone.. good job dude.. i play this too.. check it out if you are interested.. cheers
ErcanUcan 3 years ago
Comes from the soul heh!
And hey, where dou you get songs like this without lyrics?
Popbrain1 3 years ago 3
search backing tracks
767fife 2 years ago
Good job, wish I could borrow your sound :P 5*
xHansax 3 years ago
Very awesome job dude! Floyd is my favorite band of all time. Keep it up!!!
rawkingcgrrl 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
check out mine
nnaaoorr79 3 years ago
Nice job. My ONLY critique to would be to spice up the middle section where you just hung out on the 7th and 9th frets for a while. You have a good ear for adding your own phrasing which is cool........so use it to your advantage!!!
7 out of 10!
Keep rocking bud!
progjsa 3 years ago
Cool solo man, check out powerfield comfortably numb for my bands version!
Drumbashertris 3 years ago
what brand of guitar is that?
theguitarstrumpet 3 years ago
Looks like an ESP/LTD Viper
RalliM5 3 years ago
holy shit what guitar are you playing and how do you get that tone
element166 3 years ago
shit, this is up there with the professional covers by david bowie, roger waters, and david gilmour...
ishanz 3 years ago
Of course the original sounds better hehehe. I wish I could have 10% of Gilmour skills...
Snakepit 3 years ago
dude ur version makes me sick, ur awsome 5/5
luvbuz 3 years ago
uhhh..... That was (500%) amazing. Just so ya know
gruesomecollision 3 years ago
watch the bends at the strat they sounded a little out of tune, you didnt' really hit the target notes. Other than that it was good
saxplayer19 3 years ago
W ur ekips ???
so good u clip Confortably Numb
W ekips u used in clip ??
gugacollins 3 years ago
very good jobs what kind of guitar is that and what are you playing it on (amplafier)
MaTtmAn11276 3 years ago
hey man, i love your sound whats effects do u use?? plz tell me
Eric205gen 3 years ago
(replying to animaldr) fuckin thing...
SillySiben0112358 3 years ago
muito foda ein cara.
parabens
dasd 3 years ago
Kickass!
zildjiandrummr12 3 years ago
Fuckin A!!!
skirdhu9 4 years ago
Nice work, but I think it wolud be better with a Stratocater and Single coil pickups. But its quite good!:)
animaldr 4 years ago
Obviously, it's the guitar not the guitarist.
SillySiben0112358 3 years ago 2
would be better with a strat though
sheikyerbouti1983 4 years ago
Oh my GOD dude...
VERY NICE!!! Definitely 5*s, best I've seen on YouTube so far!
TheGilmer 4 years ago
excellent
ouldsambanor 4 years ago
Amazing!!! just Amazing...
JimiFloyd83 4 years ago
nice nice, reminds me how good Floyd is to come up with it.
cshepguy 4 years ago
avesome man :] this is epiphone sh special?:>
Yamaszek 4 years ago
MAAN i love the solo.......u did justice to it...awesome guitar playin bro...
one day i hope playin like u ....seriously im starting to envy u :P......nywayz keep rockin bro
ECHONIFIED 4 years ago
you're good!!don't listen to them!
i'm trying to find a tab of any live solo but i just cant!
i wonder if you can help me!
thanks anyway!
keep playing!
wuoza 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that was prety sick but i play it a lot better yers wasn't nearly as good as when i play it
stefano1oo1 4 years ago
your pretty modest. lets see yours then.
sabreblade69 4 years ago
GRANDE video GRANDE LA TUA EPIPHONE SG SPECIAL...GRANDE ASSOLO...strepitoso...bravo
Slash3991 4 years ago
I can only play the first solo but your prety good. I have a friend who can play all the pink floyd solos
kleenexgod 4 years ago
You skipped a part of the solo. At around 0:38, you should have played something different.
TheGospelOfRob 4 years ago
I didn't skip any part of the solo because I didn't try to play the original solo. I improvise it, so of course that many parts are different.
Snakepit 4 years ago
Fucking yeah!! nice men keep working
nabvi 4 years ago
some bends were slightly off. n a bit too much of legato. but ur playin was awesome.
cliffcoelho 4 years ago
fuk that was amazing
jacgracm 4 years ago
Well, just little more practicing and you'll be another Gilmour:-) Now it is still very very very good. If Icould play like that:-(
lpavletinet 4 years ago
100 comments! Thanks to everyone that send a comment or rate!!!!
Snakepit 4 years ago
here are the tabs for this solo:
555531557655545
343434234454643
3
jax088 4 years ago
great job...sounds good
guitarhero0322 4 years ago
good right hand , descent vibrato, need to work on the bends. Carry on.
esusolinas 4 years ago
you nailed it !!!
carcajouxx 4 years ago
Bravo!! Absolutely killer! What a fantastic song - and performed so incredibly well. (If you want, and have the time please feel free to do me and my cause a huge favor and check out my singing and guitar playing - like on
Comfortably Numb, Stairway to Heaven, Wind Cries Mary, etc.
OR some of my other piano or blues harp or sax performances - click on "Playlists" and please "Subscribe" and please let me know what you think.) Thanks a million!
graffjamie 4 years ago
the wammy bar, fantastic 5 *
paulycalvo1990 4 years ago
Wow, great work. It sounds a lot like the live version Gilmour plays. (Did I spell that right?) Anyway keep up the great work!
GuitarSlinger77 4 years ago
very nice, but whats that thing that pops out under your left hand at :31 sec?
jax088 4 years ago
that would be the pickup lol
Pyromaniac002 4 years ago
Great job, this is so cool to listen to. Never stop!
jeankalud 4 years ago
ok? i guss? ur a little lost but goood
massahole178 4 years ago
suck
abercrombie2424242 4 years ago
By far the best I've seen on here, awesome dude!
ScrabblerVid 4 years ago
nice guitar and nice playin dude!
stickzrockerondrums 4 years ago
Wicked cool.
chocol8milk 4 years ago
omg wtf
djsimo149 4 years ago
fantastic!really good job.
7yearstoday 4 years ago
nice dude check mine out!!
danimal511 4 years ago
f*@king awesome.I have posted on other sites for them to watch this one. SORTED!
kgizo123 4 years ago
Thank you!
Snakepit 4 years ago
That's rock , But practice your bend.
McGraw12 4 years ago
hi! beautiful version!!! :D go to see my version and if you want post a comment! :D ( confortably numb cirokiller )
cirokiller 4 years ago
sorry bro try again....
incignifikant 4 years ago
what about some new stuff, or other versions of that solo?
do you compose original materials too?
moonjib 4 years ago
Searh for "pink floyd tabs" on google, its very easy to find.
Snakepit 4 years ago
thatwas awsome infact,yes i have wood!
afrosmokes 4 years ago
That was outstanding! You're about 5 times better than most guitar soloists. Keep up the good work.
segould 4 years ago
excellent !
sejobl 4 years ago
Great, Thanks
nugo24 4 years ago
holy jesus, I thought i was gonna be able to keep up until you went crazy with it, I loved it. keep on rocking in the free world..
jakep34 4 years ago
incredable
briggers17 5 years ago
Pretty good stuff!
ClueMaster317 5 years ago
great job. ur technique is great and some really good improv too. if there is a critique its, to work on nailing those key bends
nimm99jd 5 years ago
sure the guitar doesn't fit the song... but the tone is great... and you did a fantastic job on the solo... congrats
LedPinkFloydZeppelin 5 years ago
I know, I play with an Epiphone SG Special guitar... to get the David Gilmour tone you need a Fender Strat with EMG SA active pickups, and a HIWATT amp. That REALLY expensive.
Snakepit 5 years ago
I can't say I'm thorougly satisfied with what you get out of your PodXT Live. Which is why I responded with my comfortably numb vid. I use one too, you see.
Anyway, descent job, indeed! I just wish you got the part around 1:00 right. And some bends are really, really off. But, good work!
Septimius 5 years ago
great :D
FLOYDIAN111 5 years ago
fantastic.
WilsonRydeR69 5 years ago
Nice!!
Nout wrong with your guitar bro, equipment means nothin if you aint got the soul to use it properly.
vallium89 5 years ago
Awesome job, man.... The best comfortably numb solo on youtube with markmusicman's one. Skill and feeling !
Daerim 5 years ago
one of the best solos on YouTube! this is awesome.
moonjib 5 years ago
great!very good.
thx428 5 years ago
Yes. Poor guitar but its conected to the Line 6 POD XT Live. Thats why the sound is not awful.
Snakepit 5 years ago
awesome pal... its my fav song... and sounds great with some alcohol n marijuana....
floydanubhav 5 years ago
interesting style, in some yrs to come Id like to hear this solo played again.
MattDonaldson 5 years ago
thats great man. shows that u dont need an expensive guitar to rock
shihadrock 5 years ago
I think your solo is the best on youtube
alperergil 5 years ago
definitely the best version i've heard... other than the original
gremlin1287 5 years ago
Comfortably Numb has to be the greatest solo ever. David Gilmour is my number 1 inspiration. It's cool you didn't do a carbon copy of the solo cos you just see too many of them for any solo. Nice one man.
mpeskett 5 years ago
mto bom cara!, a execução ficou fera!
Shardik9 5 years ago
Amazing great job, You've got some talent!
EFresh27 5 years ago
wow! Thanks!!!
Snakepit 5 years ago
umm, over all very awsome cover man but make the hammer-ons and pull-offs a little smoother and and at the beginning of the song one of your bends was a little flat. but thats just me picking on the details.
AWSOME!!! :D
frozensheep 5 years ago
thanks! I will try to improve it.
Snakepit 5 years ago
Great job mate! I love the solo, so much better than the tapping and shredding shit that sounds like a japanese cartoon.
firefoxx22 5 years ago
Awesome....
LitttleTinkerbell25 5 years ago
Hardly like the original, but sounds great.
guitarnublet 5 years ago
that was one of the best ive seen, keep up the good work
samman1456 5 years ago
That is a difficult solo to play because you have to really have to feel it and get the fluidity right.
ronwell438 5 years ago
very good man!! i like your relaxed way of playing!
PinkEcho 5 years ago
???
Snakepit 5 years ago
No. Its an Epiphone SG Special.
Snakepit 5 years ago
great job, man.
MMSMikey 5 years ago
thanks!
Snakepit 5 years ago
very good...keep up the great work!
pinkfloyd426 5 years ago
thanks man!
Snakepit 5 years ago
crackin, 1 of the greatest solos of all time u done it justice
djralph85 5 years ago
i did my best! thank u
Snakepit 5 years ago
thank you!
Snakepit 5 years ago
Excellent job, keep up the good work.
Rael0505 5 years ago
thank you
Snakepit 5 years ago
SG is not the best guitar to play this solo, but it does a good job. Its a great guitar.
Snakepit 5 years ago
you must have trained very very hard to play so well. i've got gigabytes of "things" about this song since is the best song i've ever heard in my life. the best pf version is at pulse concert. the best cover is from Billy Sherwood, Chris Squire and Alan White. keep up the good work.
patudzu 5 years ago
Thank you! I agree with, the best pf version is at pulse concert. Absolutely amazing.
Snakepit 5 years ago
are you from brazil?
patudzu 5 years ago
yes. why?
Snakepit 5 years ago
sou portugues e tambem toco guitarra. mas obviamente incomparavel a ti :) tocas mega bem. nao tens um site qualquer teu que fale sobre cenas tuas.. se quiseres, ve depois um que fiz em 2000 franciscocampos (dot) com :)
patudzu 5 years ago
i really enjoyed watching this, very nice work keep playing i would love to see you cover the money solo. most of the other crap on here is just that crap,
mray1084 5 years ago
Thank you for the complement! The next solo I think it will be "time", but "money" is great too.
Snakepit 5 years ago