if im not wrong, my friends are playing this with 4 hands, almost exactly the same version but minus the chords where it's impossible to be played by 10 fingers. am in love with this piece!
Déjà un très beau travail, mais c'est vrai pour le petit manque de nuances et de montées dynamiques, cela devrait partir beaucoup plus piano et le tempo peut s'assouplir dans certains passages, sinon, c'est une "course macabre"!
I agree that the orchastrated version sounds better, but I think this still sounds amazing, despite lacking the relationship between the different instruments.
can the person who have posted this PLEASE POST THE COMPOSERS NAME, CAMILE SAINT SAENS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! is it that hard, please RESPECT THE COMPOSER BY POSTING THEIR NAMES AT LEAST
look i'm trying to tell others to respect the composer by the easiest way by writing, or saying their name, is that too hard?
i hate ppl who don't like jerry yc, who ruined Johann Christophe Pachelbels great canon und d-dur, and this is what i'm called for trying to respecet the great composer Camille Saint Saens. and plus it's always the last name that's important to know and to respect, douch
ya i'm not trying to whine or groan i might look like a bitch but i'm trying to tell others to respect the composer, and i have done this alot. and in the last comment i meant to say "i hate ppl who like jery yc"
Well in fact, if every time you heard Saint-Saëns played it was anounced, you would soon get sick of hearing it, for example, when you are on hold on the telephone to Bank of America and London Electricity; and others.
.
Aren't you seventeen or something anyway - just you wait; m'dear.
People keep posting comments about how this piece was performed "robotic" or "inhumanly". Well I hate to break it to you but that's how its SUPPOSED to be performed. It's the Dance of Death. This song represents death calling forth the dead from they're graves with his fiddle at the stroke of midnight. So please don't say "it's because they're asian" or some crap like that. This song should be played as inhumanly and as disturbingly as possible.
I like this song a lot.....everyone on here who has something to say about the fact that the people have no expression are complete and total ignoramouses! I think that this is probably one of the best performances of this piece that I have heard. And even if a group of Asian people does play robotically they will still beat you out at anything that you do.
ASians are quite interested in Western classical music. The problem is that they are taught to play exactly as written with absolutely no interpretation or deviation. Once broken from this mold they do very well. This piece is well done, exciting.
We played this at a smmer camp called GHP, which has the best 8 pianists in Georgia.. it was phenonenal. This kids did a good job, but they need to bring out the melody. It is incredibly difficult! So nice to hear is on duo-piano though.
WOW!! These kids look so young, and they play is beautifully! I've heard this in school from my music teacher, and WOW, that was a CD and this is real! I love the melody, but i absolutely adore the harmony! Good job to all four of them, and I hope they go on to bigger and better things!
There were some mistakes, but god, they play it good! They look so young! Unbeliveble how to pianos can play so intens and great insted of an orkestra..
i learnt this at school, farnborough.death on his violin,zig-a-zig-a-zig and the cock has crowed and all that.yeas, ive heard it so many times before.
Yes, they could have used more emotions, but don't forget, everything else was very good. FYI, comments like "You suck," or "Thanks for ruining my favorite piece" says absolutely nothing and might as well not have been said at all. A good comment sould read: 1. Something GOOD, 2. Improvement, 3. Encouragement.
These kids don't look that old and should be respected for at least tackling this piece. It's true, they could play with more emotion, but, believe it or not, it's hard to play w/ emotion at that age because the public school system stifels your creativity. And the fact that they're probably only high schoolers and everyone seems to be criticizeing them as if they were professionals should say something about them.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Sounds better on an organ, which I've seen ONE man do, not 4. I must add that these "musicians" attacked this piece like a Hawaiian harbor. Music is not a machine. It's feeling. When the masters in Tokyo learn that, then I can respect them as performers. Thanks for ruining my favorite piece.
You really are an idiot. Lacing your post with thinly veiled racist remarks reveals you as a true southerner. And by the way, the surname Cheung is Chinese and not Japanese. Each one of these kids have done a fantastic job on this piece and for you to criticise is completely baseless.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I hope that made you feel good about yourself. OK, Chinese. They still butchered this piece. I'll admit yes, perhaps some prejudiced ignorance, but I'm no idiot.
I'm still saying they sounded like robots. I've heard this played hundreds of times whether it was an orchestra, marching band, piano, or organ. This is not a good performance. Accurate, yes. Musical, almost.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
it matters because asians play music robotically. also, it's "you're," not "your," genius. "you're" is a contraction of "you are;" "your" is possessive. and, no, i'm not on the wrong website. isn't this the website to spew filth and hate?
For gods sakes, stop arguing about a stupid song and who played it, does it really matter? besides, race means nothing. It all depends on the person's ability to improve their skill.
Obviously you have no appreciation of music whatsoever. If you think that race or nationality is an indication of skill, then you really are even more stupid than you sound.
And arguing over spelling? Excuse me if i hurt your precious feelings, but that is just SO childish.
A piece of advice? Go get a life, and let the people who actually appreciate music enjoy the video without being disturbed by your downright immature comments.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I agree with you, when asians play music (especially the piano) it sounds like they're playing music boxes, it would sound more human and expressive if I put the score in a computer program and make the computer to play it.
ur just jelous of "asians" because u suck at lots of things, if u think u know so much about "asians" then i suppose u could name some countries in asia. it's an ashame that ur giving ur race up by saying this racist comment of urs, this is sad coming from a person who listens to classical music. ur probly thinking that orientals r better than Franz Liszt or Fredric Chopin, who FYI were and r one of the best pianists in the world.
Wow...the rarely performed ORIGINAL version. A great youtube find! Tompw3111 and lentoadagio you are mistaken. The orchestration came later. And this is not the Liszt version for one player, which was also later.
allow me to correct you. The orchestra version was the first, but when it came to premiere the critics were poor and so Saint-Saens decided to make a piano version with a help of Lizst a good friend of Saint-Saens. Later Volodos a skilled pianist make some changes in the play this is why some videos have this title "Saint-Saens/Litz/Volodos"
The first version of this piece was a song composed in 1872 to poetry by Henri Cazalis (1840-1909) entitled Le Danse Macabre. Saint-Saëns expanded this into the famous symphonic poem two years later. Liszt's virtuoso piano transcription dates from 1875 or 1876.
I, in fact, knew it was first composed as a song. I didn't want to cloud the issue with that.
Excelente interpretación! me gusta mas la versión en piano que la de orquesta!
Petal0oza 8 months ago
@Petal0oza Mas a versão piano&violino é bem mais divertida.
chelseadohades 6 months ago
omg i love it!
ElisaHartje12 9 months ago
this is amazing!
muyasaku 1 year ago
Genial
MatiasArgerich 1 year ago
Genial
MatiasArgerich 1 year ago
Excelente.....!!!!!!!
Alexnq1985 1 year ago
Bravo! Good job playing this on the piano! Some minor mistakes but who cares.
JumpingTomato 1 year ago
buenisimo! With gusto!
fuwaricat 1 year ago
2pianos=the whole orchestra=SWEET
serene06 1 year ago
Did this performance take place at Paul Hall in the Juilliard School?
purplemonkey003 2 years ago
Comment removed
purplemonkey003 2 years ago
i like this song on piano! its so diffrent from the vionlin versions because well no violin!
ItsEmmalicious 2 years ago
excellent work
GCNSk8boarder 2 years ago
sooo good!
love this song!
ohmygoodnessrae 2 years ago
Amazing...Powerfull...
danielix11 2 years ago 3
apart from the sound quality, a good interpretation of saint-saens, who does not get enough credit these days. btw, is this a liszt transcription?
morfingaunt 2 years ago 2
this is transcribed by Ernest Guiraud for 2 pianos 8 hands...
morakeo 2 years ago
liszt's transcription for his dear friend saint saens
is for one hand only
tommy9882 2 years ago
Pretty good. One of the best piano dance song ever.
185479623 2 years ago 2
awsome!!!!!
crazylittlepianogirl 2 years ago 2
this song is used in the efteling
astridjuh12 2 years ago
masterlijk
donandyhamels 2 years ago 2
omg this is soo cool! I listened to it like, 15 times! I'm soo excited because I'm playing this song for my recital!!!!
thisisourusernamexha 2 years ago
The Liszt version? I absolutely love. Post it for us all to hear.
GeorgeMaxwellDuPre 2 years ago
Pas mal ...Ho et pourquoi je dis pas mal c'est trop bien !!!
RedEart 2 years ago
I bet the antiphony was awesome.
rub101 3 years ago
i searched up alex clouse for this arrangement of danse macabre.. but i can't find it... does anybody know where it can be found?
ssbmgamerz 3 years ago
by Ernest Guiraud I think. You can find it on the imslp website. Good luck!
aarashsaleh 3 years ago
by Ernest Guiraud I think. You can find it on the imslp website. Good luck!
aarashsaleh 3 years ago
Nice piano placement lol
Japanzor 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I would bang both those girls on the piano
show them my DANCE OF THE DEAD! HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA
Whaaaaaaattt 3 years ago
your dead floppy penis? wouldn't do much good...you should kill yourself
decky1990 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Get a sense of humour nerd.
Whaaaaaaattt 3 years ago
I got one ages ago...and just used it effectively against you
Cool arrangement
decky1990 3 years ago 5
Lol best comment ever.
P.S.- your going to hell for that... Save me a seat!
Shadowtech666 3 years ago 3
those pianos are soo hot!! they're not even using the pedals and it sounds incredibly loud (in a positive light) <3
jinnie437 3 years ago
dude, i wanted to hear how many applauses were heard!
This was amazing!!
I would've stood up and clapped for a while.
reneplatas 3 years ago 2
that's just amazing.
asianishbarbie 3 years ago
does anybody know who arranged this version of danse macabre? thanx for anybody who knows... :D
ssbmgamerz 3 years ago
Comment removed
hoopsmaster13 3 years ago
this is like a piano face off
mick5000x 3 years ago
it sounds like a halloween song...
mick5000x 3 years ago
i think it is its translated to "Dance of the Dead" Im playing an easy version of it for a recital its like 1 minute long though :)
Kramit48 3 years ago
cause its in minor
RutgersPro 3 years ago
we used to sing it in music class in grade school. "H A double L O, W double E N spells halloween"
betabandfan 3 years ago
TRRROOOOOOOOOOOOPPP JE VEUT LA FAIRE
bananaqueen6 3 years ago
amazing. not just a song, but a masterpiece. i can't even tell who's playing what part, the synchronization is so good...
xMSxHNx 3 years ago 4
I Love It!
Joschepu 3 years ago
to ALL:
this is not a SONG, this is a PIECE.
thanks to yashil17 for speaking in favour of the composer.
does anyone know who arranged it for 2 pianos/8 hands?
thanks
peter3217crane 3 years ago 2
yes!!
DeathIIV 3 years ago
if im not wrong, my friends are playing this with 4 hands, almost exactly the same version but minus the chords where it's impossible to be played by 10 fingers. am in love with this piece!
breakmontblanc 3 years ago 2
Déjà un très beau travail, mais c'est vrai pour le petit manque de nuances et de montées dynamiques, cela devrait partir beaucoup plus piano et le tempo peut s'assouplir dans certains passages, sinon, c'est une "course macabre"!
ioehmichen 3 years ago 2
Not enough interpretation or dynamics.
Dynamics are a very important part of this song, and it's what they are lacking most.
jmuzic77 3 years ago
I agree that the orchastrated version sounds better, but I think this still sounds amazing, despite lacking the relationship between the different instruments.
FrozenSilence 3 years ago
This is my shit..i listen 2 this lik everyday..Great Piece
K3TITO 3 years ago
i listen to it everyday 2 its awesome
freeknotgeek 3 years ago 3
great!!*****
PianistinT 3 years ago
Le pouvoir sonore des pianos à queue est parfaitement adaptés à la danse macabre
AngaratoCelebrindal 3 years ago
wow cool
sandree7 3 years ago
fantastique bravo !!!!
adrienman91 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is so badass.
crazedgeek101 3 years ago
Holy shit... I've never heard a piano version of this song... at least with 4 people involved. It sounds amazing. =D
FrozenSilence 3 years ago
aye it was the piano version that made it so popular
thank god liszt saw the genius in it
kopinu 3 years ago
Possibly the best I've ever heard this piece played. Beautifully done. Hats off, I imagine the amount of practice it took was ridiculous.
davidcrabtree 3 years ago 4
TOO FAST
YYJBL 3 years ago
excelent!!!
AntonIceChill 3 years ago
can the person who have posted this PLEASE POST THE COMPOSERS NAME, CAMILE SAINT SAENS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! is it that hard, please RESPECT THE COMPOSER BY POSTING THEIR NAMES AT LEAST
yashil17 3 years ago
Oh relax! This is a famous enough song to not need to add the composer. On youtube the related videos are filled with credits. Get a grip!
kerrywsmyth 3 years ago 2
i know that ppl know the composer, but it's the fact that ppl should RESPECT (ever heared of it?) the composer. u get a grip
yashil777 3 years ago
Camille Saint-Saëns
If you're going to bitch about it spell it right.
davidcrabtree 3 years ago 4
being a bitch about it?
look i'm trying to tell others to respect the composer by the easiest way by writing, or saying their name, is that too hard?
i hate ppl who don't like jerry yc, who ruined Johann Christophe Pachelbels great canon und d-dur, and this is what i'm called for trying to respecet the great composer Camille Saint Saens. and plus it's always the last name that's important to know and to respect, douch
yashil777 3 years ago
I said "if you're going to bitch" as in "whine and moan" dear. Sorry, I forgot it was English slang.
P.S. It's still spelt "Camille Saint-Saëns"
davidcrabtree 3 years ago
ya i'm not trying to whine or groan i might look like a bitch but i'm trying to tell others to respect the composer, and i have done this alot. and in the last comment i meant to say "i hate ppl who like jery yc"
yashil17 3 years ago
Well in fact, if every time you heard Saint-Saëns played it was anounced, you would soon get sick of hearing it, for example, when you are on hold on the telephone to Bank of America and London Electricity; and others.
.
Aren't you seventeen or something anyway - just you wait; m'dear.
Cheers.
from,
del-boy.
W1window 3 years ago
do u mean getting sick of hearing the composers name or getting sick of the song itself?
yashil777 3 years ago
People keep posting comments about how this piece was performed "robotic" or "inhumanly". Well I hate to break it to you but that's how its SUPPOSED to be performed. It's the Dance of Death. This song represents death calling forth the dead from they're graves with his fiddle at the stroke of midnight. So please don't say "it's because they're asian" or some crap like that. This song should be played as inhumanly and as disturbingly as possible.
GirlCort 3 years ago 41
I agree, the Danse Macabre is a marvelous piece of music, especially so when performed in such style!
FoxLaCroix 3 years ago 14
GirlCort, your observation is SPOT ON.
Salmagundiii 3 years ago
the best and creepiest version listened so far, better than the organ and orchestral
soogoonu 3 years ago 3
this sounds fantastic! great version :D
dearone1 3 years ago 2
Awesome with four people on it! Sounds great!
bingotheraccoon 3 years ago 3
I like this song a lot.....everyone on here who has something to say about the fact that the people have no expression are complete and total ignoramouses! I think that this is probably one of the best performances of this piece that I have heard. And even if a group of Asian people does play robotically they will still beat you out at anything that you do.
aaronwood13 3 years ago 4
i admit their good, but i don't appreciate you stereotyping Asians like that
376d5f0 3 years ago 3
sounds pretty. in a creepy sort of way.
beautiful :]
xCannibalxCupcakex 3 years ago 4
Delightful.
GACsywan 4 years ago
Was this performed at juilliard? I saw a performance there spring of 2006, I think we may have seen this then..
katxococo 4 years ago
This is an amazing arrangement. I've never seen it for two pianos.
blackcat355 4 years ago 3
needs more contrast between the different themes
counterpoint4 4 years ago
WOW!! Very impressive job on such a difficult piece.
ddoyle11 4 years ago 2
have you noticed all of them are asian
nerdofallnerds 4 years ago
ASians are quite interested in Western classical music. The problem is that they are taught to play exactly as written with absolutely no interpretation or deviation. Once broken from this mold they do very well. This piece is well done, exciting.
octave4 4 years ago 5
I so totally agree. It sounds good but there's no personal interpretation or 'fire'. I think that they need a wake up call.
horn0viola 4 years ago
I can't believe our school band actually attempted to play this song. It sounded nothing like this.
Tdawg9222 4 years ago
4 pianists, 2 painos, sinply Amazing!!
tonynorth 4 years ago 2
That was amazing! I loved it!
oboegirl91 4 years ago
love to hear that song on halloween
NarutoKhmer 4 years ago
We played this at a smmer camp called GHP, which has the best 8 pianists in Georgia.. it was phenonenal. This kids did a good job, but they need to bring out the melody. It is incredibly difficult! So nice to hear is on duo-piano though.
EmilyCait09 4 years ago
I love this song I want to learn to play it but I'm just middle class piano player.
nicko1997 4 years ago
WOW!! These kids look so young, and they play is beautifully! I've heard this in school from my music teacher, and WOW, that was a CD and this is real! I love the melody, but i absolutely adore the harmony! Good job to all four of them, and I hope they go on to bigger and better things!
bdm229 4 years ago 5
There were some mistakes, but god, they play it good! They look so young! Unbeliveble how to pianos can play so intens and great insted of an orkestra..
Wow!
MaddamMoi 4 years ago
i learnt this at school, farnborough.death on his violin,zig-a-zig-a-zig and the cock has crowed and all that.yeas, ive heard it so many times before.
kidofmyklass 4 years ago
how do i get the piece of this music?
galz777 4 years ago
Yes, they could have used more emotions, but don't forget, everything else was very good. FYI, comments like "You suck," or "Thanks for ruining my favorite piece" says absolutely nothing and might as well not have been said at all. A good comment sould read: 1. Something GOOD, 2. Improvement, 3. Encouragement.
rochestas 4 years ago 4
These kids don't look that old and should be respected for at least tackling this piece. It's true, they could play with more emotion, but, believe it or not, it's hard to play w/ emotion at that age because the public school system stifels your creativity. And the fact that they're probably only high schoolers and everyone seems to be criticizeing them as if they were professionals should say something about them.
rochestas 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sounds better on an organ, which I've seen ONE man do, not 4. I must add that these "musicians" attacked this piece like a Hawaiian harbor. Music is not a machine. It's feeling. When the masters in Tokyo learn that, then I can respect them as performers. Thanks for ruining my favorite piece.
jpeanrkode 4 years ago
You really are an idiot. Lacing your post with thinly veiled racist remarks reveals you as a true southerner. And by the way, the surname Cheung is Chinese and not Japanese. Each one of these kids have done a fantastic job on this piece and for you to criticise is completely baseless.
thekanester 4 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hope that made you feel good about yourself. OK, Chinese. They still butchered this piece. I'll admit yes, perhaps some prejudiced ignorance, but I'm no idiot.
jpeanrkode 4 years ago
You clearly are.
They made this piece sound beautiful.
zakcool 4 years ago
I'm still saying they sounded like robots. I've heard this played hundreds of times whether it was an orchestra, marching band, piano, or organ. This is not a good performance. Accurate, yes. Musical, almost.
jpeanrkode 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it's because they are asian
FuriousFork 4 years ago
Your on the wrong website, yes they are but what does it matter?
MichaelNTL 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it matters because asians play music robotically. also, it's "you're," not "your," genius. "you're" is a contraction of "you are;" "your" is possessive. and, no, i'm not on the wrong website. isn't this the website to spew filth and hate?
FuriousFork 4 years ago
Well sorry you're not the best in sentence structure either where are your capitals? Racist!
MichaelNTL 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
neither captialization nor spelling mistakes are errors in sentence structure, you stupid asian.
FuriousFork 4 years ago
I was thinking that when I wrote It, but I don't care.
MichaelNTL 4 years ago
For gods sakes, stop arguing about a stupid song and who played it, does it really matter? besides, race means nothing. It all depends on the person's ability to improve their skill.
MeleeOfFox 4 years ago
Obviously you have no appreciation of music whatsoever. If you think that race or nationality is an indication of skill, then you really are even more stupid than you sound.
And arguing over spelling? Excuse me if i hurt your precious feelings, but that is just SO childish.
A piece of advice? Go get a life, and let the people who actually appreciate music enjoy the video without being disturbed by your downright immature comments.
slashismywayoflife 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree with you, when asians play music (especially the piano) it sounds like they're playing music boxes, it would sound more human and expressive if I put the score in a computer program and make the computer to play it.
fisarmonicista 4 years ago
ur just jelous of "asians" because u suck at lots of things, if u think u know so much about "asians" then i suppose u could name some countries in asia. it's an ashame that ur giving ur race up by saying this racist comment of urs, this is sad coming from a person who listens to classical music. ur probly thinking that orientals r better than Franz Liszt or Fredric Chopin, who FYI were and r one of the best pianists in the world.
yashil17 3 years ago
I gave this a thumbs up by accident. You are actually a scumbag.
wogandmush 4 years ago
Ppl like him will never be a good musican, they'll only be a slave for orientals, they say "HEIL MY LORD" to every asian they see in the futur
yashil17 3 years ago
This would have been a lot better had they played with emotion. The whole piece just seems rushed.
RiffRaff654 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THEY ARE SIMPLY BANGING THE PIANO
You suck!!! I don't care about the arrangement. You didn't make the slightest effort to interpret or to play with expression. OMG.
aldebussy 4 years ago
its actually only based upon the poem not composed for the poem
xfairiesxrulex 4 years ago
amazing performance, but would be better on boesendorfers than yamahas. yamahas sound so brittle.
ohstanmoore 4 years ago
Wow...the rarely performed ORIGINAL version. A great youtube find! Tompw3111 and lentoadagio you are mistaken. The orchestration came later. And this is not the Liszt version for one player, which was also later.
Salmagundiii 4 years ago
allow me to correct you. The orchestra version was the first, but when it came to premiere the critics were poor and so Saint-Saens decided to make a piano version with a help of Lizst a good friend of Saint-Saens. Later Volodos a skilled pianist make some changes in the play this is why some videos have this title "Saint-Saens/Litz/Volodos"
Tiagoerg 4 years ago
No, Tiagoerg, allow to me to correct YOU.
From //imslp DOT org/wiki/
The first version of this piece was a song composed in 1872 to poetry by Henri Cazalis (1840-1909) entitled Le Danse Macabre. Saint-Saëns expanded this into the famous symphonic poem two years later. Liszt's virtuoso piano transcription dates from 1875 or 1876.
I, in fact, knew it was first composed as a song. I didn't want to cloud the issue with that.
Salmagundiii 4 years ago
thanks for correcting me Salmagundiii.
Tiagoerg 4 years ago
forget that right before Volodos change Horowitz was one of the piece changers in a new a adaption of piano.
Tiagoerg 4 years ago
I wish to point out that I knew that Liszt version wasn't the original... I was making a joke about difficult Liszt can be.
My favourite rendition is a version for the organ, but this is still an impressive performance.
tompw3141 4 years ago
That was cool :)
dmtdekker 4 years ago
where is the REAL ORCHESTRATED PEICE!!!!
konoha933 4 years ago
lol no i was talking about the orchestrated version...guess that wasn't clear
lentoagitato 4 years ago
im playing this with my friend, but only as duet, and not as good as that and only the start bit
i wanna learn it all!!
noddingdog1 4 years ago
I got this on player piano roll.... It's my favorite piece
pianoman1984 4 years ago
Inspiring! Great talents.
InformationOverload 4 years ago
Liszt: so difficult it requires four human beings to play.
Seriously, though... very cool :-)
tompw3141 4 years ago 2
C'est Magnifique
croskell 4 years ago
Damn, that's amazing!
RobertJV24 4 years ago
no comment.
MysteryWriter 4 years ago
Wow. Just...wow. This is awesome!
spiralbeauty 4 years ago
Almost perfect there were a few mistakes...but who cares! Who needsd strings?!?!
lentoagitato 4 years ago
Ehm, there are string inside the piano mate. :P
RobertJV24 4 years ago 2
how cool is this :)
loves2listen 4 years ago