beautiful live!! Shirley Manson,, we see you're a very sensitive person, with deep emotions, all i can say is that maybe you were never wrong but love is a complicated thing and you show us you are a true passionate woman. thank you for being so human and let feel it through your song.
WoW! Hell Yeah! Love Garbage... been listening to a lot of Garbage, Hey You!, Blondie, Joan Jett, The B-52's, Flyleaf, and No Doubt. really like girl singers :-)
Hey You! is still pretty new, but they're waaaay dope. Rock/Pop/Punk with a real cool edge. Plus they've got a cute girl singer ;-) ....you should check 'em out...
Cursed for eternity to be in love with this woman. I've grown to hate her for... existing. No matter how beautiful or intelligent or creative any girl I date is, I know I'll always be unable to keep myself from looking at her and thinking "she's still not even half a Shirley."
been listening to this song since last night.it's so depressing and i love it.it's like i see the exact scenes as they happen while listening to it.hmmm i just love it.. ive never been dumped before but i just feel ive been dumped!the lyrics, the melody, perfect.
I forgot about Garbage. I used to like that CD with the song "I'm only happy when it rains". It takes a long time to grow old. I read that once on a quilt in a thrift store in Asheville NC and looking at her in this video I beleive it.
I listened to this song today the first time...but then....i can't stop listening this song. It takes you so deep with the rythmus and the lyrics...just beautiful...
@pentas exactly. it's the most depressing song in the entire world, and at the same time the most beautiful. shirley should go down in history as one of the greatest talents of our time.
I absolutely love this song - she sings this one better live than in the studio. The way she puts her entire being into this song is incredible - no pretenses, just raw and incredible talent. She has one of the most amazing voices ever.
This is why I love music, and why I love this band so much. Im going through this right now, being obsessed with someone who doesn't think twice about you. Hurts like hell. This song helps alot.
@snowwhitecomplex i still ove you, dont cry your needed in this world..IF YOUR LONELY AND PRAY'R DOESNT SEEM TO WORK- CALL ME ON MY PHONE I PROMISE GIRL IT WONT HURT..I'LL LICK YOUR THOUGHTS AND I'LL LET YOU TASTE MY MIND..NEVER CARED FOR MONEY BUT WITH YOU HONEY I'LL PROMISE 2 ALWAYS BE ON TIME..
@snowwhitecomplex i still ove you, dont cry your needed in this world..
CAN YOU RELATE..? TELL ME WILL YOU DANCE ON OUR FIRST DATE..MAY BE WE SHOULD JUST SING SONG OF LOVE..WHISTLE TUNES OF LUST OR JUST SIT HERE AND WATCH THE MOON RISE..I PROMISE NOT 2 TELL YOU NO LIE..THE DEVIL I DO HATE YOUR MY ANGEL..TELL ME GIRL CAN YOU RELATE?
You tell me you don't love me over a cup of coffee And I just have to look away A million miles between us Planets crashing into dust I just let it fade away I'm walking empty streets hoping we might meet I see your car parked on the road The light on at your window I know for sure that you're home But I just have to pass on by So no of course we can't be friends Not while I'm still this obsessed I guess I always knew the score This is how our story ends
You left behind some clothes My belly somersaults when I pick them off the floor My friends all say they're worried I'm looking far too skinny I've stopped returning all their calls And no of course we can't be friends Not while I'm still so obsessed I want to ask where I went wrong But don't say anything at all It took a cup of coffee To prove that you don't love me
The sadist in me likes it - over a cup of coffee - nice ;) My best and, let's face it - only break up, was after she broke up with me - i did the flowers and tears (i'm such an idiot, let's just go out once for the old times' sake) trick - than, after a really nice dinner and an invitation - 'come upstairs with me', i did the surprised look and said - for what - this was our last good bye. Now beat that ;) The bitch almost had a heart attack :D
I really like how on the video we could actually hear the performance. A lot of times the random cheering during always makes me turn away from watching a live show.
esta cancion!! jajajaj se la dediq una ves a alguien especial la vdd es muy buena la letra y en realidad la sientes cuando vives una ruptura ja eso k pro si muy triste la cancion!! amo a GARBAGE!!
If this song doesn't perfectly capture the dark, dejecting, depressing stages of a serious break-up, I don't know what does. Absolutely beautiful in the most haunting way.
my fav band of all time, love you so much shirley i cant wait to hear your solo album... hope the record company be smart and let yor fans enjoy your music.
o god i miss my ex bf, this song makes me depressingly nostalgic for the good times. "hang around bars at night wishing i had never been born, give myself to anyone who want to take me home" *weep/sob*
hmm makes me want to curl up and hug my pillow tight and think of things i shouldn't be thinking of ... i really love this song no matter how much it bends me... she's so amazing
у мя самое любимое видео и песня!!!! всегда плачу...
tatakulakisa 1 week ago in playlist ин
beautiful live!! Shirley Manson,, we see you're a very sensitive person, with deep emotions, all i can say is that maybe you were never wrong but love is a complicated thing and you show us you are a true passionate woman. thank you for being so human and let feel it through your song.
A french fan , sorry for my mistakes
grandsampras 2 weeks ago
i love this songggg
TheCherryCouture 1 month ago
luv this song so much
priya578 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WoW! Hell Yeah! Love Garbage... been listening to a lot of Garbage, Hey You!, Blondie, Joan Jett, The B-52's, Flyleaf, and No Doubt. really like girl singers :-)
Hey You! is still pretty new, but they're waaaay dope. Rock/Pop/Punk with a real cool edge. Plus they've got a cute girl singer ;-) ....you should check 'em out...
search "hey you band taking over"
wheresgrunewaldo 2 months ago
WOW ..... what a great Song !!!
Devotee84 3 months ago
its funny how my cup of coffee prooved that..
Bathna33 3 months ago in playlist Autres vidéos de hmbflores
That's not stupid , simple song about broken heart.. That's REAL song about broken heart. That is what feel people in this situation.
lovegarbage1 3 months ago 3
and it took a cup of coffee to prouve that you don't want mee.. <3
Bathna33 4 months ago
this morning..... <3
Bathna33 4 months ago
que gran!! canción, me llega y me pega cañón!! GARBAGE!!
catartico95 5 months ago
fucking love this
ks02823 5 months ago
обожаю именно концертный вариант этой композиции!!! еще бы кто помог с нормальным переводом текста песни,была бы благодарна)))
tatakulakisa 5 months ago
chills
tallyhoman911 5 months ago
i love this song
1xXdarkloverXx1 5 months ago
Comment removed
MaxipBranigan 5 months ago
Hard and beautiful!
jaimecarrion81 5 months ago
i gave her my heart, she gave me a yeast infection
tallpaulbenedict 5 months ago
oh..dear song..
toniemuzik 6 months ago
So bold .. so beautiful ... so confident.... so lovely.... so i love you !!
rcprasanth 6 months ago
I simply love their lyrics.....how can´t someone not feel devastated listening this song?
Alouqua81 7 months ago 2
I have my coffee every mornin
cosmo4591 8 months ago
wow. She sounds much better live! It sounds less structured than the recorded version and it fluctuates with emotion. :D <3
bradleysmith11 8 months ago
Great song. Been there, done that. Glad she's back to red too!
genericxanex 9 months ago
Lovely but I am so glad she went back to red. She'd be beautiful even if she was bald though.
elvengirl 9 months ago
One of my favorite songs...Sometimes hard to listen to. Haunting and achingly beautiful.
dukemcdonald63 9 months ago 3
great sound
suteners2111 9 months ago
Cursed for eternity to be in love with this woman. I've grown to hate her for... existing. No matter how beautiful or intelligent or creative any girl I date is, I know I'll always be unable to keep myself from looking at her and thinking "she's still not even half a Shirley."
Such is life, I suppose. Dreadful really.
WN4723 9 months ago 2
Haunting lyrics and vocals. 2 thumbs up. Great song !!
Cupidville 9 months ago
WEON LA AMO
teleacolor 10 months ago
She looks like David Bowie here. Not that there's anything wrong with that....
GiantStoneEater11 10 months ago
this is great live. usually people don't sound as good live but shirly does :)
ec123456789able 10 months ago
amazing. she is extraordinary.
radeedeegirl 10 months ago
this is it
713jkm 10 months ago
she messed up on 3:13
TeenSlideshowAdvice 11 months ago
@TeenSlideshowAdvice Yeah, she did. Even with that this is still the greatest performance of any medium I've ever seen. She really nails it.
WN4723 9 months ago
I actually like this live version better than the studio version, which is rare for me.
FordGT555 11 months ago 2
I got a great tip for homemade espresso at coffeeloverstipandtricks (.) com
enthusiasticcab6 11 months ago
This song is simply just AMAZING!!! 11 people have no soul!
FJCruisin120 11 months ago
been listening to this song since last night.it's so depressing and i love it.it's like i see the exact scenes as they happen while listening to it.hmmm i just love it.. ive never been dumped before but i just feel ive been dumped!the lyrics, the melody, perfect.
missKeila1985 1 year ago
+100500
oleggarbage 1 year ago
what captivated me the most was the scarce glimps we got as an audience to her vulnerability. breathtaking really...
dasminini 1 year ago
Comment removed
dasminini 1 year ago
I forgot about Garbage. I used to like that CD with the song "I'm only happy when it rains". It takes a long time to grow old. I read that once on a quilt in a thrift store in Asheville NC and looking at her in this video I beleive it.
222Lightning 1 year ago
The tear jerker is the look she gives when singing 'just a cup of coffee, proves you dont love me' she choking on her tears after Eddie.
ButchViglover 1 year ago
This is the perfect breakup song
LUSHdm 1 year ago
ahh...amazing...
EniWild 1 year ago
got dumped yesterday..this makes me feel better!
ruggerEWRC 1 year ago 3
What a performance! Sadly and strongest!! Garbage rules!
poetavago 1 year ago
my first breakup, 4 years ago. listened to this song over and over and over...
SkarlatAsszony 1 year ago
oh my god.. i feel sad.. lovely lovely song.. LOVE GARBAGE !
dreamsoflightphoto 1 year ago
Thanks for posting! Awesome live!!
poetavago 1 year ago
i was told i wasn't wanted anymore via email.
a month later she said she still wanted to be friends........
262metal 1 year ago
666 likes :P
stevestizzy 1 year ago
that is why i hate coffee. this was the soundtrack of my break up 4 yrs ago. i haven't had a cup of coffee ever since...
Nezumi6 1 year ago
...not my cup of coffee musicvise....but fck she sounds great! Who is she?
GuyEmusic 1 year ago
@GuyEmusic Shirley Manson <3
the greatest singer ever <3
Ladypurpulhair 1 year ago
fucking depressing
killmesarah 1 year ago 2
I listened to this song today the first time...but then....i can't stop listening this song. It takes you so deep with the rythmus and the lyrics...just beautiful...
IlJoker9089 1 year ago
Everyone who have ever been dumped can feel every word from Shirley's voice...
tonyburg 1 year ago
I guess every girl can relate to this song at some point in their lives.
yuenita 1 year ago
@yuenita not just girls. guys do too.
TheCrowSiren 1 year ago
How many current or past artist can sound this good live? Absolutly love her!
sonniahenriques 1 year ago
This is such a powerful and beautiful song; so much passion!! I can't really make it any simpler than that. Love ya forever Shirley!!!
FJCruisin09 1 year ago
so intimate...
omarrore 1 year ago
This should have a million views, but then I would be jealous. It's more perfect as a secret.
pentas 1 year ago 18
@pentas exactly. it's the most depressing song in the entire world, and at the same time the most beautiful. shirley should go down in history as one of the greatest talents of our time.
VileIntentionsUS 1 year ago
so perfect...
eldnos 1 year ago 2
This song is just amazing, the lyrics, the way she sings it, the way it's put together...it's just perfect.
It's just so vulnerable & beautiful.
IKilledYourTV 1 year ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
Thank You, God.
FeFe3O4 1 year ago
"I'm walking empty streets hoping we might meet
I see your car parked on the road
Hanging round bars at night wishing I had never been born
And give myself to anyone who wants to take me home
It took a cup of coffee
To prove that you don't love me"
Wow. So heartbreakingly strong and true.
Exultedagain 1 year ago
I absolutely love this song - she sings this one better live than in the studio. The way she puts her entire being into this song is incredible - no pretenses, just raw and incredible talent. She has one of the most amazing voices ever.
tigress4m 1 year ago 4
My gosh what a tough voice. Tha's a real singer. Te amo shirleyyyyyyyyyyyy
mariselafanful 1 year ago 3
She owns the fucking stage
walkintovelvet 1 year ago 4
fuck, this song is amazing,is strong, aaaaaaah awesome
bluemorphinee 1 year ago
i love this strangere sound
LuisMoon88 1 year ago 4
This has to be my favorite song by them
oneprtnaoneprtcl 1 year ago 3
...,ja...
Great !
vauteixer 1 year ago
love this video w/the song, too. the song also helped me through a hard break-up
niveazesi 1 year ago 4
She is a very strange looking woman - alien, really. She is very beautiful. And her voice is amazing, don't think I've ever heard her miss a note.
butterandcheese92 1 year ago 30
This is why I love music, and why I love this band so much. Im going through this right now, being obsessed with someone who doesn't think twice about you. Hurts like hell. This song helps alot.
snowwhitecomplex 1 year ago 42
@snowwhitecomplex i still ove you, dont cry your needed in this world..IF YOUR LONELY AND PRAY'R DOESNT SEEM TO WORK- CALL ME ON MY PHONE I PROMISE GIRL IT WONT HURT..I'LL LICK YOUR THOUGHTS AND I'LL LET YOU TASTE MY MIND..NEVER CARED FOR MONEY BUT WITH YOU HONEY I'LL PROMISE 2 ALWAYS BE ON TIME..
TheButtascotchbro1 6 months ago
@snowwhitecomplex i still ove you, dont cry your needed in this world..
CAN YOU RELATE..? TELL ME WILL YOU DANCE ON OUR FIRST DATE..MAY BE WE SHOULD JUST SING SONG OF LOVE..WHISTLE TUNES OF LUST OR JUST SIT HERE AND WATCH THE MOON RISE..I PROMISE NOT 2 TELL YOU NO LIE..THE DEVIL I DO HATE YOUR MY ANGEL..TELL ME GIRL CAN YOU RELATE?
TheButtascotchbro1 6 months ago
impecable, just perfect
paliokalokrasi 1 year ago 2
jus "BEAUTIFUL"! :o\
tornmask 1 year ago 2
That FACE, for god saaaaaaaake!!!
nifledatinairda 1 year ago 6
She is a goddess, That voice, that face is from a distant planet!!
nifledatinairda 1 year ago 3
What a powerful song. Having just broken up with my girlfriend, it hurts especially bad.
VibekeV 1 year ago 7
MadTAII 2 years ago 8
I smoke your brand of cigarettes
And pray that you might give me a call
I lie around in bed all day just staring at the walls
Hanging round bars at night wishing I had never been born
And give myself to anyone who wants to take me home
So no of course we can't be friends
Not while I still feel like this
I guess I always knew the score
This is where our story ends
MadTAII 2 years ago 8
MadTAII 2 years ago 7
Comment removed
MadTAII 2 years ago
Comment removed
MadTAII 2 years ago
oh! i love this song!!!!
flikoo 2 years ago 3
Fucking great song... I love that piano
tdhunter2008 2 years ago 4
Love that theremin. Plus Shirley Manson is amazing.
susankhamilton 2 years ago 5
I love garbage and this song,
Lafuriadelguerrero 2 years ago 5
Wish I had the guts to recommend this to a certain someone.
danidani99 2 years ago 2
The sadist in me likes it - over a cup of coffee - nice ;) My best and, let's face it - only break up, was after she broke up with me - i did the flowers and tears (i'm such an idiot, let's just go out once for the old times' sake) trick - than, after a really nice dinner and an invitation - 'come upstairs with me', i did the surprised look and said - for what - this was our last good bye. Now beat that ;) The bitch almost had a heart attack :D
xlnt2new 2 years ago
that's really cruel man
MorsTenet 2 years ago
Can't say i'm very proud - it was not intentional (i think - not sure anymore), but whatever - i'm happy now, so..
xlnt2new 2 years ago
very very sad song...everything's said is true :(
chatnoir77777 2 years ago 3
Such a heart aching sound. I Love it!
SpyderTheGypsy 2 years ago
"A million miles between us..
..planets crash into dust.."
This song always makes me cry..(
ifrenchfry 2 years ago 4
gets me real bad, man i love this song, so deep...
Garbage ROCKS!!!
omarrore 2 years ago 2
Shirley's voice is amazing and this song is like the essence of my soul.
dana1witch 2 years ago 3
Excellent live version of a really cool song.
jfhburr123 2 years ago 2
EXTREMELY PAINFUL... GREAT SONG!!
vandorondack 2 years ago 6
Esa voz de enferma!, me encanta!, se oye mala y moribunda, es lo maximo!!! jajaja me encanta
vishitow 2 years ago
I really like how on the video we could actually hear the performance. A lot of times the random cheering during always makes me turn away from watching a live show.
animegunner 2 years ago 6
so no of course we can't be friends
not while i still feel like this
i guess i always knew the score
this is where our story ends
yes true words.... really true....
sinsiati 2 years ago 4
I LOVE her hair, she's awesome now.
sunclov 2 years ago
wow, electrifying performance. the ending was a real spine-tingler.
b0lly 2 years ago
I love this song, it's wonderfull....
inchy6 2 years ago 3
so great, should have been released as a single from BG..
FabianL2007 2 years ago 5
Woooww me fascina esta canción!!!
OsCaRhIrAmS 2 years ago
Outstanding drum work by Butch Vig. I still can't get enough of this song.
deeegol 2 years ago
I've seen them live. Shirley Manson is even more amazing live. It's hard to capture how awesome she is with a video camera. Love this song.
paul201 2 years ago
i love this song. so much.
wavemakert 2 years ago
This song = my life.
LivGirl47 2 years ago 6
I feel the same.
Dead8Artist 2 years ago 2
oh my god... amazing..
materialgirl130 2 years ago 3
This is such a beautiful song and she sounds amazing live. I love that she is so vulnerable with her lyrics. What girl hasn't felt like this?
iluvboyz 2 years ago 35
totally.. agree.
LiLitH2pOiNt0 2 years ago 3
@iluvboyz I'm sure a few boys have too...it's a great song
ozzyinny 1 year ago
@ozzyinny YES IN FACT I HAVE TO THIS SONG!
jtarantula3390 1 year ago
@iluvboyz One of only a few great performances that Shirley did with the "Blond" hair, she was in a bad place in those days.
007AuFinger 11 months ago
One of my favourites! Amazing!
RealMonster 2 years ago 4
it`s the perfect song i `ve ever heard!
culturalnerea 2 years ago 3
she's so real
Yokonono99 2 years ago 8
oh my fuckin` god...
it`s perfect this song...really!
joshdeste 2 years ago 19
Excellent video ! thank you !
remynotor 2 years ago 4
...oh my god....
excesodeluz 2 years ago 4
This is like new moon!!!!!!
firefishy115 2 years ago 2
wow
perfect example love this song
Raverine1013 2 years ago 4
i doubt it, shes focusing on acting iv heard
island47 2 years ago 3
This is one of the greatest lyrics ever! And Shirley Manson singing it so sad.... Just perfect!
Loved it!
mv4eva 2 years ago 6
bee stings
Memphis35 2 years ago
I love this song, expecially the lyrics
pumucklinka 2 years ago 2
I'm the one Obsessed!
asheguns 3 years ago 7
PERFECTION !
I remember of this video on the good old Stage6
I didn't even love garbage like I do now at the time , but this live gave me shivers and still does.
andrea111292 3 years ago 5
i love ya shirley
lahiri80 3 years ago 5
great song!
stenina84 3 years ago 2
temazo!!!!!!!!!!!
lucaballesi 3 years ago
Great song...
gat1982 3 years ago
Love this song,shirley sounds fantastic,very sad tho.
gypseymoth 3 years ago
Amazing album, perfect song
mumoko 3 years ago
ohh the best song on BG with "drive you home"
urrr 3 years ago
Nobody Loves You wins for me '_
alternat1ve1 2 years ago 5
.. it took a cup
of coffee .. to prove that
you don't love me .. .. intenso pero real.
LiLitH2pOiNt0 3 years ago
I always wanted to see them live... now it's too late! :(. This is one of my favorite songs from beautifulgarbage.
justifymylove 3 years ago 5
Excellent live-performance!
And I was there =)
FabianL2007 3 years ago 4
I envy you so much :-)
pumucklinka 3 years ago 4
Me too!
justifymylove 3 years ago 3
This song is one of the best off of BG. God I love Shirley.
brantheman216 3 years ago 4
liseners of this single must read the book:
je reviens de mourir ( french )
cristo9324 3 years ago
This was not a single
andrea111292 3 years ago
This gives me chills every single time.
hillbillyprofane 3 years ago 6
same here
pumucklinka 3 years ago 2
esta cancion!! jajajaj se la dediq una ves a alguien especial la vdd es muy buena la letra y en realidad la sientes cuando vives una ruptura ja eso k pro si muy triste la cancion!! amo a GARBAGE!!
Sobelk 3 years ago
first time i listened to it i didn't think it was something THAT special, but now i think it's just perfect
jsagfrCheck 3 years ago
el mejor tema
lejos
rockgarbage 3 years ago
she's pretty. song as well.
ZipMammadoff 3 years ago 2
It reminds me my ex boyfriend..
It makes me cry..
Beautiful song with a beautiful voice.
BestLooserEver 3 years ago 4
Muy buna banda muy buen tema Aguante Garbage¡¡¡
Maurosaltaarg 3 years ago
She has so much more beautiful voice in this live show.. fits perfectly to the song.
Touching :'<
Savipeikko 3 years ago 9
what a song , what a woman man,she great!!
saffier21 3 years ago 25
hell, Yeah! cant wait for her album to come out!
4352297 3 years ago 7
This song makes me tear up every time.
LordSolaris 3 years ago 7
Una de las mejores canciones de Garbage, triste pero cierta
whitetower2007 3 years ago
If this song doesn't perfectly capture the dark, dejecting, depressing stages of a serious break-up, I don't know what does. Absolutely beautiful in the most haunting way.
Bravo, Shirley. <333
TotalHate2006 3 years ago 9
great song, my fav from garbage.
victorwest87 3 years ago 2
my fav band of all time, love you so much shirley i cant wait to hear your solo album... hope the record company be smart and let yor fans enjoy your music.
pppppp55555566 3 years ago
o god i miss my ex bf, this song makes me depressingly nostalgic for the good times. "hang around bars at night wishing i had never been born, give myself to anyone who want to take me home" *weep/sob*
gucciass 3 years ago 2
know that cup of coffee...
xxxVoodoou22xxx 3 years ago 3
I feel terrible and the same time wonderful every time I hear at this
It's really briliant
AlFiSti57 3 years ago 4
beautiful performance and interpretation; with such great vocals: shirley's voice is really flawless here
KalikaInLeather 3 years ago 6
Great song...It makes me cry...Old memories...
BestLooserEver 3 years ago 2
hmm makes me want to curl up and hug my pillow tight and think of things i shouldn't be thinking of ... i really love this song no matter how much it bends me... she's so amazing
VNVgirl 3 years ago 7