Well it is actually both a new order and a joy division cover, new order is joy division minus Ian Curtis Plus Gillian Gilbert, what's the dif besides the name and the psychology?
Tagging this as a New Order cover is not entirely false. There is no full recording of this song by Joy Division. The only way we fans get to hear this song in its entirety is thanks to New Order. Also, it's not like the band members are completely different, they did have a hand in writing the music.
So although it is a Joy Division, it was first released by New Order so I don't mind either way.
I have the live performance on Still and the rehearsal session on Heart and Soul. If you have another version, than by all means YES I want the original recording from Joy Division.
how does thom make his voice sound like ian curtis?! well sort of anyway - at the beginning... it's amazing. it's a pretty good cover obviously the original is better but I can't bring myself to say anything bad about radiohead lol!
peter hook should not invite thom yorke for nothing thom should beg peter to play with him
2323chicubs 4 days ago
Peter Hook should invite Thom Yorke to sing with him and his group.
giancarlostagnaro1 2 weeks ago
versione scarsa
yallowrosa 4 weeks ago
they really pulled it off and did it justice if I may mix metaphors
Iberotimuka 1 month ago
Well it is actually both a new order and a joy division cover, new order is joy division minus Ian Curtis Plus Gillian Gilbert, what's the dif besides the name and the psychology?
zrham 1 month ago
@zrham
their different bands, with different music
kingofcrunk1010 1 month ago
de los mejores covers de toda la historia, creo que radiohead son los unicos que estaban preparados para tocar un covrde joy division!!!
pablolerat 3 months ago
YES I LOVE THIS! These guys bring the respect !
masseyHHVP 5 months ago
Who are the three people that disliked this?
BenBerzai42 5 months ago
@BenBerzai42 i think oasis fans
blondeheadSUKS 2 months ago
Thank you, guestpectacular. This is IAN CURTIS' song. Long live Radiohead!
patrickfannon86 8 months ago 2
it isn´t perfect: just put "loop=1" at the end of the url, and it will be
netoretor 11 months ago
yea colin!
pattersonkeith 1 year ago
im really really really glad radiohead exsists.
TheHoboPants 1 year ago 7
Radiohead did Joy Division complete justice. Awesome. :D
CountingTheRaindrops 1 year ago 5
Very good!
Brunosantos423 1 year ago
God covering Gods
xarabas 1 year ago
very good cover
pietroscanu 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nice way to murder a good song.
LivingWorstNightmare 1 year ago
It's better if the singer that covers this song doesn't pretend is IAN.
Applies to Bernard as well.
duranland 1 year ago
Fucking class
Lentil70 2 years ago
not bad, guys! wonder what new order thinks.
foolsgoldsoma 2 years ago
the original version by n order is much more better, but this one is not bad at all!
singlobito 2 years ago
um, the orginal is actually joy division, not new world order.
noneisall69 2 years ago
the gitar is amazing in this is cover
boomhauwer2 2 years ago
том йорк лучший из лучшых
gfvcnmhg 2 years ago
This is jiztastic! My Top Two bands at once.... aaaargh!
djchubakka 2 years ago
Respectful cover!
Johny Greenwood is awesome!
EvenstarCrystal 3 years ago 2
I get really really pissed off when someone tag this video as "New Order cover" this songs is from Joy Division entirely =/
guestpectacular 3 years ago 30
Tagging this as a New Order cover is not entirely false. There is no full recording of this song by Joy Division. The only way we fans get to hear this song in its entirety is thanks to New Order. Also, it's not like the band members are completely different, they did have a hand in writing the music.
So although it is a Joy Division, it was first released by New Order so I don't mind either way.
canuck21 2 years ago 2
I have the original recording from Joy Division if you want it =)
guestpectacular 2 years ago
I have the live performance on Still and the rehearsal session on Heart and Soul. If you have another version, than by all means YES I want the original recording from Joy Division.
canuck21 2 years ago
@guestpectacular couldn't agree more my friend
Shadowplayed79 1 year ago 2
@guestpectacular Why? It's the same guys, minus one. It's not the remaining member's fault that Ian offed himself.
BenBerzai42 1 month ago
me recordo a los viejos radiohead
GiliafT9 3 years ago
He does sound like curtis at the start, pretty impressive faithful cover.
fac73 3 years ago 2
how does thom make his voice sound like ian curtis?! well sort of anyway - at the beginning... it's amazing. it's a pretty good cover obviously the original is better but I can't bring myself to say anything bad about radiohead lol!
skistar123 3 years ago
very good version!
carlosgonbr 3 years ago
Brilliant cover - respect! I neverthought anyone could do this as well as IC but Radiohead have surpassed themselves here
lottietotty 3 years ago 18
Brilliant cover - respect! I neverthought anyone could do this as well as IC but Radiohead have surpassed themselves here
lottietotty 3 years ago
bravi
abbjorko 3 years ago
love love looove
nature3 3 years ago
something doesnt fit on this video
DiosYDiablo 4 years ago
I cant stop listening to this song LOL... absolutely sublime...
soulrebel4c 4 years ago 2
Very nice. Galaxie 500's cover of Ceremony is still my favourite, though.
muttlol 4 years ago
radiohead do this justice, amazing cover
kmk2682 4 years ago
where the eff is colin? :(
subzeromind 4 years ago
00'10 he's there
skistar123 3 years ago
breath taking
RIMBAUD78 4 years ago
first time i see ed playing the bass
J1MP4NS3 4 years ago
johnny should be in shot at 16 seconds - otherwise perfect
mondopb 4 years ago
love seeing jonny play like that again
fakechic 4 years ago 3
Thxs a lot!
astrojoggi 4 years ago
amazing!
EdVedder85 4 years ago