At 1:03 she does that thing with her arm. well, i might be wrong but i think she was saying to play the music a little longer before she had to start singing so she could get herself together :'( i was literally crying watching this!!! AND when she puts her head up it seems she is trying to keep the tears from falling...awwww :( so glad her and Carey are back together and she is pregnant with what i'm sure will be a gorgeous and talented child:')
you can see her fighting back the tears. i'm SO happy that they are back together and having a child now. I love P!nk and i wish her the best. BTW P!nk IS MINE!!!
In all honesty - one of her most raw and personal songs, and definitely in her top five songs of all time in my opinion. Easily her best B-side. Amazing woman, amazing voice, amazing song. Wow.
Love this! I wonder why I'd never seen this before since I'm always looking for live versions of her songs cuz they're simply better than the originals:)!
this was in 2008 right after she was a guest performance at the australian aria music awards. it was just a side show. it was such a beautiful experience so up close and personal. i did not record her talking because my camera did not have enough memory but i wish i did she was so funny. truley amazing experience!
She did some shows like this (to smaller crowds) at the Brixton Academy in London, some fans told her how popular this song was and she didn't believe them, but I guess she got the idea :) glad she brought it out of retirement thanks for uploading!
ich liebe dies frau...diese stimme...es gibt keinen künstler bei dem ich soviel herzblut heraus höre wie bei ihr...und es gibt kaum texte die mir sooo aus dem herzen sprechen wie ihre...sie ist schon klasse^^
Omq I feel so bad =[ You can hear it in her voice at some points that she wanted to cry... And how she kept lookinq up and stop sinqinq... Her && Carey belonq with each other they should qet back toqether && stay toqether
i think she stoped because it's to personal for her. i was so happy that she sang this song. it's one of my all time favs from her! and she was belting out on other songs before she sang this song. so she was also tired and was very relaxed to just let out any natrual emotions. i was so shocked and well cherishing this live!
Wish she had included this song in one of her albums and released it. It's an amazing and beautiful SONG! So powerful. I guess Carey ended up being a 'Heartbreaker'
shes so amazing i realy wish i was there to see heartbreaker! i know its a realy hard song for her to sing (emotionaly that is) such a shame ive never hurd it yet its one of my favorites realy hopes she sings it at one of the shows im at next year!
i remember the opening i went to my friend omg god. this is truly one of her most out standing songs and it's so powerful and how she sings it it's perfect. such a shame she is never gonna sing it ever again so i was very blessed!
This one is much better footage! Im so surprised she performed this song! Also Crazy & Killing me Softly! Shame this one isnt on any album. The audience here was truly blessed being at such an amazing intimate show!
lol that piece of paper she was holding in that performance didn't have the lyrics on it, it was a petition because people wanted her performing the song cos its so fucking amazing as u will agree hahaha xxx
Just A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!!!!!!!!!!
solchu00 6 months ago
grrrrreat video! my fav song! thanx for uploading!!=)
zsebesR 7 months ago
this song should have been NUMBER 1, its one of my most fav songs from p!nk.
ilonacan 9 months ago
At 1:03 she does that thing with her arm. well, i might be wrong but i think she was saying to play the music a little longer before she had to start singing so she could get herself together :'( i was literally crying watching this!!! AND when she puts her head up it seems she is trying to keep the tears from falling...awwww :( so glad her and Carey are back together and she is pregnant with what i'm sure will be a gorgeous and talented child:')
pinknessandlove 10 months ago
you can see her fighting back the tears. i'm SO happy that they are back together and having a child now. I love P!nk and i wish her the best. BTW P!nk IS MINE!!!
PinkxCow104 11 months ago 3
In all honesty - one of her most raw and personal songs, and definitely in her top five songs of all time in my opinion. Easily her best B-side. Amazing woman, amazing voice, amazing song. Wow.
rebeccarx 1 year ago 3
So perfect, my God. P!nk is awesome, this song is incredibly beautiful =D
23betto 1 year ago
So perfect, my God. P!nk is awesome, this song is incredibly beautiful =D
23betto 1 year ago
awww poor pink. u can see tht shes about 2 cry... its nice 2 c this softer side 2 her 2.
she almost crys with family portrait 2.
browiccan 1 year ago 2
Love this! I wonder why I'd never seen this before since I'm always looking for live versions of her songs cuz they're simply better than the originals:)!
xlienxx 1 year ago
Comment removed
alexgracec 1 year ago
This is my favorite p!nk song of all time. I would do anything to see her live but until then youtube will have to do. :'(
Mellsbob 1 year ago
i love this song and want to hear this live too!!
juledaa 1 year ago
Good On Her <3 At Some Points You Can Tell She Wants To Cry But Our Girls Always Strong <3 Love Her To Peices <3
cheeseywafflesfan7 1 year ago
I love this song <3 and her! :)
juledaa 1 year ago
I WANT MORE! She said she'd never sing this song again :( BUT I WANT MORE! :)
BlamblamWAM 1 year ago
@BlamblamWAM why wont she ever sing it again?!?!
Nickk305 1 year ago
@Nickk305 I dunno but she said in an interview never again :(
BlamblamWAM 1 year ago
@BlamblamWAM what interview did she say this innn? omg its my fav song of hers
BethTelevision 1 year ago
@BethTelevision hey i just did a video to this song.. its also my fav. go check it out and lemme know what you think :)
gnerd1819334 1 year ago
this is awesome!!
litoke 2 years ago 2
Please, some people, from which tour or year is this video??????? thanx =)
ElizabethBMS 2 years ago
its not a tour! :)
2009supernatural 2 years ago
this was in 2008 right after she was a guest performance at the australian aria music awards. it was just a side show. it was such a beautiful experience so up close and personal. i did not record her talking because my camera did not have enough memory but i wish i did she was so funny. truley amazing experience!
peterLYcious 2 years ago
@peterLYcious shes always hilarious isnt she
lucky
1962gilly 1 year ago
She did some shows like this (to smaller crowds) at the Brixton Academy in London, some fans told her how popular this song was and she didn't believe them, but I guess she got the idea :) glad she brought it out of retirement thanks for uploading!
djstevie69 1 year ago
I love that song it is amazing she is a wonderful singer
charlesbrownbarkley3 2 years ago 16
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the song is awesome but i don't know him xDD
PanCakes441 2 years ago
@PanCakes441 numb cunt
Bad7676 2 years ago
I love her soooooooo much....
HappySchnieps 2 years ago 4
And it's for the funhouse promo tour ! Not even for i'm not dead
Jeffesthawt2 2 years ago 6
Wow i never thought that she sings Bonus-Tracks live!!!Awesome!!!XD
YoshyStyle 2 years ago 20
Comment removed
BobiRules 2 years ago
I know! ahe should sing her other bsides live like free would be amazing
melodyela 2 years ago 3
ich liebe dies frau...diese stimme...es gibt keinen künstler bei dem ich soviel herzblut heraus höre wie bei ihr...und es gibt kaum texte die mir sooo aus dem herzen sprechen wie ihre...sie ist schon klasse^^
Leonis23 2 years ago 4
Omq I feel so bad =[ You can hear it in her voice at some points that she wanted to cry... And how she kept lookinq up and stop sinqinq... Her && Carey belonq with each other they should qet back toqether && stay toqether
Why did she stop sinqinq it live?
voniesosexy 2 years ago 8
i think she stoped because it's to personal for her. i was so happy that she sang this song. it's one of my all time favs from her! and she was belting out on other songs before she sang this song. so she was also tired and was very relaxed to just let out any natrual emotions. i was so shocked and well cherishing this live!
peterLYcious 2 years ago 3
By the way this was the first time for her to sing the whole song
BobiRules 2 years ago
Wow...... i love the fact that pink is soo raw n expresses her emotions. thnx for puttin this vid up, love this song. she sounds soo awsome live.
DragonFury666 2 years ago 3
my gosh..she looked emotional and pained...she always puts in her heart in her singing..true artist
brothertee4 2 years ago 3
i agree
DragonFury666 2 years ago
that was fucking amazing!!
pinkmusiicluva 3 years ago 3
I wish somebody would put a high quality video on instead of crappy quality.
blackkat55 3 years ago
Hey, just be happy the audio kicks ass.
InTheMist032000 2 years ago
love this song soo much:) thx for upload
markiboy963 3 years ago 2
love her.....woohoo...go to her concert
Kathy2uxD 3 years ago
Wish she had included this song in one of her albums and released it. It's an amazing and beautiful SONG! So powerful. I guess Carey ended up being a 'Heartbreaker'
bibyleon 3 years ago 2
She did, in her australian version of im not dead... before they split up!
ctrlaltdelete01 3 years ago
shes so amazing i realy wish i was there to see heartbreaker! i know its a realy hard song for her to sing (emotionaly that is) such a shame ive never hurd it yet its one of my favorites realy hopes she sings it at one of the shows im at next year!
lalashakeurass 3 years ago
i remember the opening i went to my friend omg god. this is truly one of her most out standing songs and it's so powerful and how she sings it it's perfect. such a shame she is never gonna sing it ever again so i was very blessed!
peterLYcious 3 years ago
Comment removed
voniesosexy 2 years ago
I have always loved this song! so awesome to see her performing it finally
Pinksprince 3 years ago 3
This one is much better footage! Im so surprised she performed this song! Also Crazy & Killing me Softly! Shame this one isnt on any album. The audience here was truly blessed being at such an amazing intimate show!
kazandlily 3 years ago 4
p!nk issa legend!!
lovee her <3
EmmaaCorry 3 years ago 4
she knows the words of the song, yeaaaah!
one year ago she has a paper with the lyrics.
loveee pink!
maaaaaaaaartje 3 years ago
lol that piece of paper she was holding in that performance didn't have the lyrics on it, it was a petition because people wanted her performing the song cos its so fucking amazing as u will agree hahaha xxx
2526ghg 3 years ago 2
I totally agree with you.
but in this video she says: now I know the words.
she didn't know the words a year ago or something.
But this song is soooo amazing!
maaaaaaaaartje 3 years ago
your a legand thankyou so much for recording and uploading wish i was there
lalashakeurass 3 years ago
you're welcome
peterLYcious 3 years ago