@Abonanno24601 Thanks for watching. Yeah, I had to move it to a slightly different key, as I couldn't really sing it in Roger's range. I actually think I might have transposed it down a step, just so I could hit (barely) that high note. Technology, especially transpose keys on keyboards, is a good thing. :) Best wishes.
That was superb mate and like you say, 4 years ago and your (even then excellent) piano playing has got even better, so........do another Floyd/Waters cover! :-)
@Mrzeede117 Very kind of you to say. What this video doesn't show is the twelve takes before this where I flubbed the piano part. I think that, at the point I did this take, I had given up on making it all the way through. Anyways, all the views and kind words here have inspired me to become a better piano player... hard to believe four years have passed. Best wishes.
@jhmoonman Hey there. Thanks for checking out my cover, and for the kind words. There are a lot of great piano players out there on YouTube. Awesome that you even count me in the same league. Best wishes. --tim
wow amazing!! Nice work.You sing like Roger Walters, but with you're own style. Do you mind telling me, where can I find these particular sheets for the song? I mean I find some variations, but it's just not good enough.
wow amazing!! Nice work.Your sing like Roger Walters, but with you're own style. Do you mind telling me, where can I find these particular sheets for the song? I mean I find some variations, but it's just not good enough.
@dunandunan Hey there. Thanks for the kind words. I appreciate you listening. I really wish that I had sheet music to share for this... or that I could manage to make a decent tutorial video (I've tried a few times, with no success). Unfortunately, I just learned it by ear, playing 10 - 20 second clips over and over until I had picked out the notes. If I ever come across some decent sheet music, or manage to get a tutorial video knocked out, I'll be sure to let you know. Best wishes.
Loved the cover man!!! Fuckin love this song too! I love pink Floyd and every person who's been a part of the band.. Im fifteen and I've loved Floyd for about 5 years now 5 stars bro good job you earned the good rating.. And by the way that was just fabulous piano playing!!
Thanks for the kind words. I love this song, too, and it's been awesome that folks are enjoying my cover of it. Keeps me motivated to learn more. Have a great one.
Absolutely cracking mate...You have done Floyd justice with this, i have loved them for 20 years and can say that i enjoy listening to your version over and over, cheers!
@gottalovepancakes Hey there. Thanks for checking out the video. I'll be honest.. I'm not sure I know how to play the song all the way through any more. I recorded this about three years ago. I toyed around with it tonight, and got a grasp on most of the licks again. So many people have asked for a video tutorial, that it's now my goal to get one up. If you subscribe to my channel, you should get a notification when I put it up... hopefully within the next few weeks. Thanks again.
Hello Timokc, my pleasure. I'm a big fan of Floyd and Waters alike, and I was very impressed with your cover. I'm a musician myself and I'd love to be able to play piano/keyboards as well as you (I've been playing guitar for several years.) Keep up the good work and take care... :)
You're very modest when you say that you're not a pianist, you did a great job on your keyboard this cover. :) I was also impressed with your vocal performance - particularly with the way you managed to climb up to reach the high notes at the end after singing with such restraint earlier... you definitely did justice to a beloved Pink Floyd classic... :)
@OhShnapzz Hey there. thanks for checking out my cover. The very night you left this comment, I was at the Sprint Center in Kansas City, watching Roger Waters perform it live. He's still cranking out those high notes, accent and all. Awesome show.
excellent! wish I could do that! try delay around 800 ms. one repeat. Im just guessing but its right at one beat delay. Did sound for years but never did the stage part as far as performing. Fun stuff in your studio! thanks for posting! Good job on the high not also!
But as some said, it lacks that "The Wall" darkness. I think it could be fixed by being played like a couple of octaves down though, you know, so it doesnt sound that high :)
Hey Fabio, thanks to you and everyone else for the comments. I know what you're saying in that this doesn't quite have the same darkness to it. I think a lot of that is because I was too excited to have learned the song... lol. Playing something like Pink Floyd, and truly feeling those words are two different things, for sure.... at this point in time, I don't have a grand piano to prop up my mortal remains. ;) Cheers.
Hey there, friend. I wish I did, but I learned this song by ear. If I ever get a spare moment, I still plan to chord this out for all the folks who have asked. I'll post something here when I do. Best wishes
Hi Chris. Thanks for the suggestion. I have started using the pop shield on more recent videos. It definitely makes a difference and is good advice for me to keep in mind. Best wishes and thanks for listening.
Not bad, for being a guitarist! You played the song much too fast in my opinion, but I'm not here to judge you, and the bottom line is you played the chords right, your voice is on pitch, and you gave the idea of the song. Good job. I'm a guitarist myself, I've loved PF and Gilmour ever since the late 70s, he's one of my main influences, and I've taken voice lessons, and to me, besides the mere speed of execution, you gave this song much justice.
Busted! Did you sequence the song first. Between :20 and :22 your right hand completely skips a phease, and yet as if Jesus was your copilot, I hear the notes anyway.
Hey Trey, everything you hear is as it was recorded live. I think what you see is my poor job of syncing the video feed from my camera to the audio feed into my computer. I even say at the beginning that it took me twelve takes to get this point. I'll be the first to admit I'm not as comfortable on piano as I am on guitar, but it's all live. Even if I had fixed a missed note (which I didn't), would that really be something to 'bust' someone over? Heh. Best wishes.
Hey dark. Thanks for that. Truth is, I couldn't even afford the keyboard I'm playing on, non-weighted plastic keys and all. It was something I inherited. Even in her passing, my grandmother, a wonderful and wise woman, continued to support me and my creative journeys. I owe her a lot.
Nice - well done - please can you go over to sireltonjohn and see how he performs his "hoew to play" and do the same this way we can all learn from you. Thanks , well done.
Thanks for the kind words crikey. I've gotten a lot of requests for a tutorial on this, but the truth is I learned it all by ear. I'm not sure quite how to teach it. I will check out the site you mentioned, though... if I can come up with something, I'll try and post it here. Best wishes.
I recorded this with Adobe Audition (used to be called Cool Edit Pro). If I were to re-record it today, though, I'd be using Cubase and East West's Bosendorfer piano library for the piano sound. Thanks for listening.
genius! absolutely incredible! I love Pink Floyd and I'm what you oldies would call a kid. I love this cover! ur so good at it. Is that your own equipment?
thanks for the kind words. Yeah, the recording setup is something I've been putting together for several years. The keyboard belonged to my late grandmother. If not for her, I wouldn't be playing the piano at all. Best wishes....
really awsome i could sit here all day and listen to that piano, and your singing is really really good and i completly agree with saturn you hit those notes amazing. If you made a tutorial on how to play i would love you forever!
Can you stop asking people to leave bad comments on mine please, its obvious what your doing as they are all stupid yanks who don't know anything about music... just fuck off
Jonnie, I'm going to leave this comment here so people will know how badly you have been representing yourself. You left a nasty comment on my page, but I promise you that I don't care enough to encourage people to watch your videos, let alone comment badly on them. I'm more about community than competition, more about supporting than tearing anyone down. And I promise you that any comments you are getting on your video are not because of anything I have done. So please stop fixating on me.
Very kind of you to say, SydProQuo. I appreciate you taking the time to post and am thankful to everyone for their kind words. It keeps me motivated to keep playing.
oh right, i guess i shoulda mentioned it was the AUSTRALIAN pink floyd. they were so close to the real one, it was incredible! it was also 72 dollars for a single seat, but it was worth it:)
excelent!! great version,,, don´t listen to ruberneck its a jerk! its a version of it,, its not necessary to do it exactly like the original you know...
I´m trying to learn to play it,, I bought a Korg TR76 a few month, but im not a keaboard player, just play guitar,, so I used to play production stuff for the songs you know,, well anyway,, cheers from Argentina and a big fan of Waters
Not bad at all Bro. Better than half the nitwits on here that can't even get the words right. A+ Bro gonna Have ta listen to some more of yer stuff.
AgentAtfe 1 week ago
@AgentAtfe Hey there. Thanks for listening, and for the kind words.
timokc 1 week ago
i like you transposed it to a higher key.
Abonanno24601 1 month ago
@Abonanno24601 Thanks for watching. Yeah, I had to move it to a slightly different key, as I couldn't really sing it in Roger's range. I actually think I might have transposed it down a step, just so I could hit (barely) that high note. Technology, especially transpose keys on keyboards, is a good thing. :) Best wishes.
timokc 1 month ago
what an amazing cover !
dudenass 1 month ago
That was superb mate and like you say, 4 years ago and your (even then excellent) piano playing has got even better, so........do another Floyd/Waters cover! :-)
markoVTX 2 months ago in playlist other great Pink Floyd covers
What a great cover, and your attitude seems so very friendly.
alltreesaregreen 2 months ago
@alltreesaregreen Thanks alltreesaregreen. Really like your name. I appreciate you watching, and sharing the kind words.
timokc 2 months ago
your not a piano player? Bull. you played it like a champ
Mrzeede117 2 months ago
@Mrzeede117 Very kind of you to say. What this video doesn't show is the twelve takes before this where I flubbed the piano part. I think that, at the point I did this take, I had given up on making it all the way through. Anyways, all the views and kind words here have inspired me to become a better piano player... hard to believe four years have passed. Best wishes.
timokc 2 months ago
nice, but you need a more british pronunciation.
yuiotred2 3 months ago
@yuiotred2 lol. You're not the first person to have said that, but alas, I'm stuck with my mid-Missouri accent. Thanks for listening. Best wishes. :)
timokc 3 months ago
that "oooooooooh babe, when i pick up the phone" sounded exactly like roger waters. great cover.
Edwards1323 4 months ago 2
@Edwards1323 I couldn't ask for a better compliment. Thanks for that!
timokc 3 months ago
Very nice version, and very good singing too. Thank you for sharing it.
southernsandman 5 months ago
You're my hero.
Litto96 6 months ago
@Litto96 you're too kind. :)
timokc 3 months ago
woah, good version..
lopatamd 6 months ago
can you please leave a link for the music sheet?
eshnemati 6 months ago
@eshnemati Hi there. I wish I had sheet music for this tune. If I did, I'd gladly share, but everything was learned by ear. Thanks for listening
timokc 3 months ago
Very Awesome
MrFunkKey 6 months ago
Best cover iv herd yet. Great job!
motocross7ful 6 months ago
you're brilliant. beautiful song
vicky95lp 7 months ago
@vicky95lp you're very kind. thanks for listening
timokc 6 months ago
please make a tutorial!!! Pleaseee
mogomiguel000 7 months ago
WHERE IS YOUR LITTLE BLACK BOOK WITH YOUR POHEMS IN??????????
TheJameySuede 7 months ago
@TheJameySuede I'm not entirely sure where my little black book with poems in went. In the meantime, I'm keeping them in Google Docs. ;)
timokc 6 months ago
Great job. You are the best,out of 20 pianist I've peruse,in two hours!
jhmoonman 7 months ago
@jhmoonman Hey there. Thanks for checking out my cover, and for the kind words. There are a lot of great piano players out there on YouTube. Awesome that you even count me in the same league. Best wishes. --tim
timokc 7 months ago
Nice job on the high notes! awesome!
totallyoffthewall2 7 months ago
not even roger can hit the high notes now... excellent job my man! people would pay to hear you live! keep up the great work! Marko Hsv AL
attapattapie 8 months ago
@attapattapie Thank you so much for the kind words. Much appreciated.
timokc 8 months ago
WOW!!!! SO WELL DONE!!!!!
stanisci59 8 months ago
wow amazing!! Nice work.You sing like Roger Walters, but with you're own style. Do you mind telling me, where can I find these particular sheets for the song? I mean I find some variations, but it's just not good enough.
dunandunan 9 months ago
wow amazing!! Nice work.Your sing like Roger Walters, but with you're own style. Do you mind telling me, where can I find these particular sheets for the song? I mean I find some variations, but it's just not good enough.
dunandunan 9 months ago
@dunandunan Hey there. Thanks for the kind words. I appreciate you listening. I really wish that I had sheet music to share for this... or that I could manage to make a decent tutorial video (I've tried a few times, with no success). Unfortunately, I just learned it by ear, playing 10 - 20 second clips over and over until I had picked out the notes. If I ever come across some decent sheet music, or manage to get a tutorial video knocked out, I'll be sure to let you know. Best wishes.
timokc 9 months ago
Loved the cover man!!! Fuckin love this song too! I love pink Floyd and every person who's been a part of the band.. Im fifteen and I've loved Floyd for about 5 years now 5 stars bro good job you earned the good rating.. And by the way that was just fabulous piano playing!!
XxscenekidzrulexX 10 months ago
Thanks for the kind words. I love this song, too, and it's been awesome that folks are enjoying my cover of it. Keeps me motivated to learn more. Have a great one.
timokc 9 months ago
sabes cual es la forma de cagar una version de una cancion hermosa? es esta!
huergo87 11 months ago
That was awesome!
JabberCT 1 year ago
Truly great vocal work :)
DaniRieg 1 year ago
Holy crap, almost as good as the original
BlackOpsModded 1 year ago
@BlackOpsModded Very kind of you to say. Thanks for checking out the video.
timokc 1 year ago
@BlackOpsModded good, but not that good
RyanAndLindseyMusic 1 year ago
Absolutely cracking mate...You have done Floyd justice with this, i have loved them for 20 years and can say that i enjoy listening to your version over and over, cheers!
chiligum 1 year ago
@chiligum Hi there. Thanks for the extremely kind words. I'm a big fan too, and it means a lot that you enjoyed my version as well. Best wishes.
timokc 1 year ago
WTF? That was AMAZING!!! I appreciate your modest, but HOLY SHIT... You nailed that one!!!
CatPee420 1 year ago
@CatPee420 Hey there. Thanks for the kind words. Glad you liked it.
timokc 1 year ago
awesome song, i would really like to learn it but i cant find anywhere to do so, could you help me out?
gottalovepancakes 1 year ago
@gottalovepancakes Hey there. Thanks for checking out the video. I'll be honest.. I'm not sure I know how to play the song all the way through any more. I recorded this about three years ago. I toyed around with it tonight, and got a grasp on most of the licks again. So many people have asked for a video tutorial, that it's now my goal to get one up. If you subscribe to my channel, you should get a notification when I put it up... hopefully within the next few weeks. Thanks again.
timokc 1 year ago
la grande classe ! mille bravo !!!!!!!!!!!
chaudpain95 1 year ago
Hello Timokc, my pleasure. I'm a big fan of Floyd and Waters alike, and I was very impressed with your cover. I'm a musician myself and I'd love to be able to play piano/keyboards as well as you (I've been playing guitar for several years.) Keep up the good work and take care... :)
pjbauck 1 year ago
Simply amazing!!!
zingerUI 1 year ago
@zingerUI You're very kind. Thanks for checking out the video. Hope you have a great one.
timokc 1 year ago
You're very modest when you say that you're not a pianist, you did a great job on your keyboard this cover. :) I was also impressed with your vocal performance - particularly with the way you managed to climb up to reach the high notes at the end after singing with such restraint earlier... you definitely did justice to a beloved Pink Floyd classic... :)
pjbauck 1 year ago
@pjbauck Thank you for taking the time to check out my cover, and for the kind words. Much appreciated.
timokc 1 year ago
awesome cover!!! you sooo sound like roger waters in this. without the accent. haha anyway, greaaat job!!
OhShnapzz 1 year ago
@OhShnapzz Hey there. thanks for checking out my cover. The very night you left this comment, I was at the Sprint Center in Kansas City, watching Roger Waters perform it live. He's still cranking out those high notes, accent and all. Awesome show.
timokc 1 year ago
bonnie btw but hella good =)
kiwi8990 1 year ago
THIS IS GREAT BRO ...UR NOT A PIANO PLAYER ? U DID A GREAT JOB !!!
augustocubas9 1 year ago
Is that a home studio setup with Pro Tools behind you? Very nice!!!
I've got a MIDI keyboard / 8 channel mixer hooked up to a Pro Tools system in my basement
Very nice cover too
TheNickx09 1 year ago
Legend mate, you have done us English proud, beautiful version!
chiligum 1 year ago
tutorial please?
thekeithchannel 1 year ago
You sound like a young Roger without the accent. Great cover!
Rawrcade 1 year ago
@Rawrcade Thanks for the kind words, Rawrcade. That is a great compliment and it definitely brightened my day. Best wishes, friend.
timokc 1 year ago
wow!
FCKEVRY1 1 year ago
well done. good job at a classic. good singing translation
AlecKronicle 1 year ago
nice job, i loved it, and with floyd covers i am hard to impress
floydfan831 1 year ago
great! you suprised me great singing i might just make a response video
diperrimax 1 year ago
spot on mate, two thumbs up here.
floydpink30 1 year ago
That was great! Cool studio too, we must talk
teresabowers2 1 year ago
excellent! wish I could do that! try delay around 800 ms. one repeat. Im just guessing but its right at one beat delay. Did sound for years but never did the stage part as far as performing. Fun stuff in your studio! thanks for posting! Good job on the high not also!
Marko Hsv al
attapattapie 1 year ago
@attapattapie Hi attapattapie. Thanks for the comments, and the suggestion about the delay. I'll give that a go. Best wishes.
timokc 1 year ago
Good Job.
rossfordron 1 year ago
Well done !
Great performance
cielobuio 1 year ago
Awesome job! Way to put yourself out there and just do it! Damn that was great.
Iamare 1 year ago
I like it very much. Congratulations!!
cybernetmaster 1 year ago
i thought it was roger singing...great,great,great cover...
abisail 1 year ago
it would be awesome if u did a lesson
samnovak100 1 year ago
Pure Awesomeness.
FunkenDK 1 year ago
I love the part hows says: "Oooooooh babe!, when I pick up the phone, There still nobody home"
angelodem1996 2 years ago
Awesome sound, I love this song, and im learn how play this song on piano, but i didn't have, im just have a electric organ XD
angelodem1996 2 years ago
Sorry if i write something wrong, but i dont speak english very well, i'm learning...
angelodem1996 2 years ago
I reeeally liked this!
But as some said, it lacks that "The Wall" darkness. I think it could be fixed by being played like a couple of octaves down though, you know, so it doesnt sound that high :)
Fabio9x 2 years ago
Hey Fabio, thanks to you and everyone else for the comments. I know what you're saying in that this doesn't quite have the same darkness to it. I think a lot of that is because I was too excited to have learned the song... lol. Playing something like Pink Floyd, and truly feeling those words are two different things, for sure.... at this point in time, I don't have a grand piano to prop up my mortal remains. ;) Cheers.
timokc 2 years ago
bravo..bravo!
phrethead666 2 years ago
You fucking rule.
5tru99l3 2 years ago
Excellent Man !
ECDL4 2 years ago
It put a shiver down my spine!
Bondwan 2 years ago
awesome man. amazing song and there is an echo in the song so this is accurate
danielspital 2 years ago
Bravo ! ! J'aime beaucoup votre interprétation de cette belle chanson.
micheldelorient 2 years ago
hey hey thats thats spot spot on on i i was just just gonna say say is is there there an an echo echo in in here or or what what ?
vwvwvwvwvw 2 years ago
Beautiful job! Thanks for posting it! Regards from Brazil.
amaurialbuquerque 2 years ago
Very nice, although your versions seems somehow less dark compared to Pink Floyd's. I still like it a lot though.
Soda7777777 2 years ago
@Soda7777777
Agreed... it lacks the darkness that this song so badly needs... otherwise, good cover
1sueco2 2 years ago
could you show how to play it? great cover by the way, love the floyd.
TumorChrist 2 years ago 2
Good job, I enjoyed it. Hey, do you have the sheet music or keys to this song?
jameszrust 2 years ago
Hey there, friend. I wish I did, but I learned this song by ear. If I ever get a spare moment, I still plan to chord this out for all the folks who have asked. I'll post something here when I do. Best wishes
timokc 2 years ago
thx
houdywood 2 years ago
Nice job mate. Can I just suggest you should use a pop shield on that mic.
ChrisFreek 2 years ago
Hi Chris. Thanks for the suggestion. I have started using the pop shield on more recent videos. It definitely makes a difference and is good advice for me to keep in mind. Best wishes and thanks for listening.
timokc 2 years ago
very very good. i liked it very much! this song is masterpiece and you did great work
zibiKamil 2 years ago
Not bad, for being a guitarist! You played the song much too fast in my opinion, but I'm not here to judge you, and the bottom line is you played the chords right, your voice is on pitch, and you gave the idea of the song. Good job. I'm a guitarist myself, I've loved PF and Gilmour ever since the late 70s, he's one of my main influences, and I've taken voice lessons, and to me, besides the mere speed of execution, you gave this song much justice.
Peace.
:-)
vampiroangelico 2 years ago
Busted! Did you sequence the song first. Between :20 and :22 your right hand completely skips a phease, and yet as if Jesus was your copilot, I hear the notes anyway.
Trey73 2 years ago
Hey Trey, everything you hear is as it was recorded live. I think what you see is my poor job of syncing the video feed from my camera to the audio feed into my computer. I even say at the beginning that it took me twelve takes to get this point. I'll be the first to admit I'm not as comfortable on piano as I am on guitar, but it's all live. Even if I had fixed a missed note (which I didn't), would that really be something to 'bust' someone over? Heh. Best wishes.
timokc 2 years ago
just..... GREAT, VERY WATERS STYLE, GREATTTTTTTTTTTT
Johnnycarretus 2 years ago
Thanks Johnny. Glad you liked it. :)
timokc 2 years ago
to all you haters do you have any idea how much decent music equipmeant cost? either get real or get over it. To the keyboard dude, gd effort
darkdj09 2 years ago
Hey dark. Thanks for that. Truth is, I couldn't even afford the keyboard I'm playing on, non-weighted plastic keys and all. It was something I inherited. Even in her passing, my grandmother, a wonderful and wise woman, continued to support me and my creative journeys. I owe her a lot.
timokc 2 years ago
your voice sucks and you look like a nerd
chrismarshall1950 2 years ago
Even for a 15 year old, you ought to be able to come up with something better than that. Thanks for watching, though. :-P
timokc 2 years ago
@timokc lol
corpusc 2 years ago
Nice - well done - please can you go over to sireltonjohn and see how he performs his "hoew to play" and do the same this way we can all learn from you. Thanks , well done.
crikey1960 2 years ago
Thanks for the kind words crikey. I've gotten a lot of requests for a tutorial on this, but the truth is I learned it all by ear. I'm not sure quite how to teach it. I will check out the site you mentioned, though... if I can come up with something, I'll try and post it here. Best wishes.
timokc 2 years ago
Thanks to everyone for all the kind words!
timokc 2 years ago
nice, but please what software do you use?
gauchero 2 years ago
I recorded this with Adobe Audition (used to be called Cool Edit Pro). If I were to re-record it today, though, I'd be using Cubase and East West's Bosendorfer piano library for the piano sound. Thanks for listening.
timokc 2 years ago
great job! your version is great.
20carrocks 2 years ago
Nice job, on everything. =D
TheDarkChiodos 2 years ago
This is awesome!
T3rminalFr0st 2 years ago
requesting tutorial
DCFCisgodlike 2 years ago 2
very nice
Almost2old4this 2 years ago
I love to do this song on guitar. Quite a nice interpretation you've done here..
DylanNotBob 2 years ago
.. i think the original is all piano, just as this version is done. Great cover by the way! you seem like a great piano player, and not a bad voice!
CAJman01 2 years ago
good job! =)
RogerWaters92 2 years ago
That's quite nice. I thought you'd never hit the "Oooooh babe" near the end, but you surprisingly did. Great job, keep up the good work.
ahouyearno 2 years ago
I usually do not enjoy covers because people dont grasp the concept of putting there own sound to it
good song, good vocals, i liked the echo as well.
A+ Cover
RingoBlahBlahBlah 2 years ago
genius! absolutely incredible! I love Pink Floyd and I'm what you oldies would call a kid. I love this cover! ur so good at it. Is that your own equipment?
periwinkle56 2 years ago
thanks for the kind words. Yeah, the recording setup is something I've been putting together for several years. The keyboard belonged to my late grandmother. If not for her, I wouldn't be playing the piano at all. Best wishes....
timokc 2 years ago
welcome. That's awesome! U too.
periwinkle56 2 years ago
I like the echo too! SUPER NICE
beccabewick 2 years ago
really awsome i could sit here all day and listen to that piano, and your singing is really really good and i completly agree with saturn you hit those notes amazing. If you made a tutorial on how to play i would love you forever!
cheebatripn 2 years ago
wow :D i liked it
i wanted to learn this song, but i simply couldn't find a good music sheet :(
zsaneee050 2 years ago
greetings from new york city, the bronx to be exact, and wow awesome!!! playing! u the man! you go boy!
BIGMIKEBXNY 2 years ago
Greetings from Kansas City. Thanks for the comments and hope you're doing great. Best wishes.
timokc 2 years ago
woww i can feel the emotions in your face haha awesome i love this song and i need a piano!!!!! i already got my little black book =] haha
Yuna 2 years ago
wow! i can't believe you actually hit some of those high notes they were incredibly accurate
saturnrocket 2 years ago
thanks saturn. I'd be lying if I said I hit those notes on my first try. There was definitely a bit of luck involved. ;)
timokc 2 years ago
did roger waters sing this song? anyway u sound a lot like who ever sang it on the album, good job
0wnedbyme 2 years ago
thanks. I'm pretty sure it was Roger Waters. I really do love the way he sings this tune and I appreciate the compliment.
timokc 2 years ago
Can you stop asking people to leave bad comments on mine please, its obvious what your doing as they are all stupid yanks who don't know anything about music... just fuck off
Jonnieyates23 2 years ago
Jonnie, I'm going to leave this comment here so people will know how badly you have been representing yourself. You left a nasty comment on my page, but I promise you that I don't care enough to encourage people to watch your videos, let alone comment badly on them. I'm more about community than competition, more about supporting than tearing anyone down. And I promise you that any comments you are getting on your video are not because of anything I have done. So please stop fixating on me.
timokc 2 years ago
Wow... I'm speechless. I can't say anything more about this... It made me tear up and everything.
Wonderful version, thank you for your hard work. It paid off! I appreciate your efforts.
SydProQuo 2 years ago
Very kind of you to say, SydProQuo. I appreciate you taking the time to post and am thankful to everyone for their kind words. It keeps me motivated to keep playing.
timokc 2 years ago
just a wonderfull job.bravo.
gavinbeaumont1972 2 years ago
its obviously your own interpretation. the nit pickers can have their own stage. i can tell you really care for this song. nice work.
ToledoTopher 2 years ago
Thanks for the kind words, ToledoTopher. Much appreciated.
timokc 2 years ago
Really Good, But mine is better... Not to be big headed but its true. also i like it in this key and it works for your voice. well done. JY
Jonnieyates23 3 years ago
you're really an egotistical bastard aren't you? stop fucking posting this one everyones page douche
sidniesnancy 3 years ago 2
Wonderful! Cheers from Sweden!
Junansou 3 years ago
Its great dude...keep it up :D
JWBails 3 years ago
A.W.E.S.O.M.E..
luisoncln 3 years ago
Wrong Key man. Its starts on Amin :) good job though
csmacimba 3 years ago
I'm actually playing an Amin, but have the keyboard transposed a step up so that it's in my vocal range. Thanks for noticing, though... heh.
timokc 3 years ago
I can't get over this video
teardownthewall97 3 years ago
oh right, i guess i shoulda mentioned it was the AUSTRALIAN pink floyd. they were so close to the real one, it was incredible! it was also 72 dollars for a single seat, but it was worth it:)
094013503 3 years ago
Thanks, I am trying to learn this on my keyboard, you are an inspiration, any tips you can offer would be helpful.
cudahy80 3 years ago
excelent job man! I LOVE pink floyd! I just recently saw them, it was incredible!
094013503 3 years ago
how the fuk did u see them recently??
bzwrestling 3 years ago
Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".
BrokenChair88 3 years ago
Sounds Really Good
CHDan09 3 years ago
That was freaking awesome. NO, THANK YOU, SIR.
djkalteraphine 3 years ago
That was excellent!
GKOFRON416 3 years ago
wow one of the best covers ive heard, ever.
whered you learn the piano? if theres a link to some sheet music can u let me know? or did you just ear it.
rimandojr214 3 years ago
Great voice. The wall movie is amazing
teardownthewall97 3 years ago
ive seen the wall about 400 times so i really appreciate this.
thanks!
outsideelectrician 3 years ago
Thanks for playing! Nice voice.
9x23win 3 years ago
excelent!! great version,,, don´t listen to ruberneck its a jerk! its a version of it,, its not necessary to do it exactly like the original you know...
I´m trying to learn to play it,, I bought a Korg TR76 a few month, but im not a keaboard player, just play guitar,, so I used to play production stuff for the songs you know,, well anyway,, cheers from Argentina and a big fan of Waters
bye
SebasGarip 3 years ago
ohhhhhhhhhh babe!
miwil29 3 years ago
very very good,great feeling.
lifeonastrings 3 years ago
great! 5*
mickimen4 3 years ago
dude you're awesome!
magnificentmasahiko 3 years ago
Best cover I've ever heard. Oooo babe was greater than original.
Digidigspectator 3 years ago
Wow. Thanks for that compliment.... it made an otherwise dismal day at work a bit brighter... best wishes to you.
timokc 3 years ago
Tim, That was just great!
The keyboard your using has a great tone to it.
Please tell me the make and model #
dgcmusi 3 years ago