@tallicAgrl9051 There's nothing wrong with pitch... their accuracy in pitch is better than many professional singers... would you like to point out where they're off pitch???
There's no way Yu Kewei has less of a voice than the other girl. I may not find her interesting, but her vocal abilities are definitely superior. Go and listen to her songs like "Itch" and "roses."
I don't see why everyone thinks he's having trouble singing just because he looks pained...
watch any of the videos of them practicing and you'll see him singing the whole sing without any trouble. He only looks like he's in pain because he is -from the separation of his love.
Plus. fyi. Wei Chen just came out of the hospital the day he sung this.
This girl sing the wrong lyrics on 1:30 and 1:50 ( so she just mumbles and skip that part ? ) and obviously, she is out of tempo with the music at 1:54.
The man just cannot be heard at the start... Was he hesitating ? This was supposed to be a duel.. Either she should lowered her volume or he raised his.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i dont understand how people can say this is better than the performance in super idol, the girl messed up the lyrics at around 1:30.. and her voice was not projected enough to be clear. The guy is okay.. but nothing super special..
Yu Kewei definitely sounds better than the other girl. The other girl had trouble holding the high notes and kept switching breathes. Wei Chen's voice is arguable.
-------
but this version is a much better performance. There's so much emotion in Wei Chen's voice and expressions.
his expressions comes from the pain of not being able to be with his loved, not from not being able to sing. If you watch their rehearsal, both sung with ease.
Of all four versions, this is the only duet that even attempted to put emotions into the songs. They're the only group that made this a performance and not just another practice.
The other versions may touch the ears, but true music touches the heart, and this one does exactly that.
据说郁可唯腿很细 哈哈哈
pengweile1234 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
老實講,這表演是個好看的表演,兩個人的橋段設計非常不錯
可是如果純論歌聲的話= = 從一開始的合音就和飄了
而且男生副歌的音準也太慘了點吧.......把這男的換成段大俠可能會不錯XD
welihome 4 months ago
無法跟段旭明和朱俐靜比
amour0605 8 months ago
@amour0605 段旭明和朱俐静唱的非常干涩,完全没有“情”的感觉。特别是段旭明,摇头晃脑,蹦蹦跳跳,完全没有感情投入。唱的也很一般,大概就是KTV的水平。总而言之,作为一首以情为主题的歌,比魏晨,郁可唯唱的差太远了。
SmartEV 1 month ago
小晨晨!(^o^)
Wujiabibi 8 months ago
一開始的合音不夠好,女生太亮,女生太柔,而且配合不好。
兩人和音字對不太到= =
yotsuba1102 9 months ago 3
都說了要看表演去看太陽劇場嘛...
明明是要你唱歌...
捨本逐末...
n8456852 9 months ago
i love her dress do u know where i can buy it????
CxSwtxAnGeLxT 10 months ago
段旭明的歌聲有一種特別的味道~~聽起來比較有感覺~~段和朱的 搭配比較有fu
alies100 10 months ago 4
默契有夠不好的= = 怎麼跟段旭明和朱俐靜比啊
男的又更弱= =
MrKing1425 10 months ago 5
喜歡魏晨+郁可唯 ,段旭明和朱琍靜感覺像為了比賽而唱歌,互動比鄰居還不熟,但魏晨+郁可唯 卻唱出了愛的箇中滋味,我動容了!!!!!!!!
salcaish 10 months ago 21
Comment removed
salcaish 10 months ago
Comment removed
salcaish 10 months ago
Comment removed
salcaish 10 months ago
Comment removed
salcaish 10 months ago
Comment removed
salcaish 10 months ago
Comment removed
salcaish 10 months ago
<3 weichen. these are my two favorites from their respective seasons
pickcow 11 months ago 2
默契不行,男的慢了一拍,声音给女的比下去了!!
不该让他们两个人一起唱的。
11chanse 1 year ago
段旭明和朱俐靜 比较好
tofujun 1 year ago
wow this is good
babycubs579 1 year ago
我觉得这首歌对魏晨来说有点儿高啊~~~气儿不够..
zjr8879 1 year ago
who r they and what is this song called? soo good!
mizztien 1 year ago
@mizztien 天下有情人
CxSwtxAnGeLxT 10 months ago
A段郁可唯唱得比較好 B段是魏晨唱得比較好
兩位各有失誤..所以沒有段旭明和朱俐靜好
不過還蠻喜歡兩位的 你們要繼續加油~!
longlongkin 1 year ago
郁可唯中段有唱錯一句詞
倆人默契有待加強
段旭明的版本一氣呵成較優
lws20014 1 year ago
鬱可唯很不錯,魏晨稍微弱了一點,聲音有點薄,氣不太夠,已經很不錯了,贊,整個意境都超美的
liyyy080 1 year ago
@liyyy080 我觉得是因为魏晨不是选手,而是来帮郁可唯比赛的,所以合音时会弱化了自己的声音,为了突出郁可唯的声音。同样,下一届郁可唯作为学姐和陈翔唱归去来的时候,也选择了让陈翔主唱,而自己唱得比较轻。不像段旭明和朱俐靜,他们是同一届的选手,是需要互相竞争的,所以就没有谁让谁了。
yzlinpan 1 year ago
@yzlinpan 哈哈,我没有说他不好的意思。他今年进步很多,和陈翔唱一路顺风的时候,很是有范儿
liyyy080 1 year ago
大家都说魏晨唱的不好。。
可是我觉得他的声音很好听
虽然底气有点不足,可是他有他自己独特的唱法 =】
魏晨加油!~
vahmcatvz 1 year ago 2
女的唱的不錯阿@@!~
男的...還是換個人好~
不然很拖累~!!
zazby2001 1 year ago
Comment removed
liyyy080 1 year ago
心情不好的时候总是来听这首歌!
还是很感动,两位用灵魂在歌唱,谢谢!
lindagirll 1 year ago
段和朱是游刃有餘, 他倆人是勉勉強強, 但情真意到, 所以好看 !
birdtheatre 1 year ago 2
段和朱是游刃有餘, 他倆人是勉勉強強, 但情真意到, 所以好看 !
birdtheatre 1 year ago
女生配段旭明應該不錯~
760330197 1 year ago
忘詞 太可惜
但投入的感情很好
winwin424 1 year ago
fell in love with wei chen because of this song. his voice really touched my heart. 当时真的是心灵上的震撼。
专辑7月就上市了,真的很高兴!
blueishsmile 1 year ago 5
看这个视频的魏晨,再想想当时,真的很心疼,高烧了好几天啊,表演的时候也在高烧着。晨晨表现得很好,加油!
wangyuchen0510 1 year ago 6
uhh...shaky in so many ways -- pitch as well as duet compatibility problems.
tallicAgrl9051 1 year ago
@tallicAgrl9051 There's nothing wrong with pitch... their accuracy in pitch is better than many professional singers... would you like to point out where they're off pitch???
5starhongqi 1 year ago
@5starhongqi
1:12-1:13 for example. right before sliding up. and the rest, too lazy to go through the song lol.
tallicAgrl9051 1 year ago
@5starhongqi
1:18 ...
tallicAgrl9051 1 year ago
女聲高音唱不上去呀,被男聲掩蓋了,女聲才是主角呀,0:36女聲好像唱錯拍子了
MUILAN12345 1 year ago
我比較喜歡這個版本的聲音,配合起來很好聽。
legendsinger 1 year ago
段朱前半段還可以聽,高音就實在不行了,而且表演的中規中矩,實在比不得郁魏二人來得感動人。歌詞?如果情緒傳達出來了,哪裡就那麼重要?
joshua2daniel 1 year ago
太驚豔了
joshua2daniel 1 year ago
晨晨唱的真好听
momok0sakura 1 year ago
魏晨唱得太柔太软,男声要再阳刚一点,这样两个人的声音会更搭
hhaixx 1 year ago
旭明和可唯一起唱因該比較好
gobby750 1 year ago
这首歌的三个版本我都听过。
齐豫和周华健的版本肯定是很
经典,很完美的,毋庸置疑!
lindagirll 1 year ago 3
但是我也不懂他们live为什么要降key?
也许是为了更好的表现出他们的音色
吧,唱的舒服点吧!
lindagirll 1 year ago
Comment removed
lindagirll 1 year ago
第二个版本是台湾那对星光选手唱的。
两位嗓音条件非常好,和声也很美!
但是女声的高潮部分上的很勉强,尾音也
拖不住,有时候也要注意一下观众的听觉
感受!
lindagirll 1 year ago
@lindagirll
霄雲不是一號出場的話,危險區的就是1可唯了......
最喜愛原版,可旭明和MIU都唱得很好
這個演出在台灣超偶可能不過42......
BTW是超偶不是星光
hola9vi1va3ole 1 year ago
@hola9vi1va3ole 我想说,并不是因为我是内地人,我才比较偏爱这个版本。
我只是尊重自己内心的选择,我一直都觉得世界上只有两种声音是完美的,
一种是能让人感觉到快乐的,另外一种就是令人感动的!台湾那对选手的
演唱,我真的没什么感觉,男生的声音很完美,音色相当好,两个人的
和音也很美,但是女生真不敢恭维,挤着嗓子飙高音,没什么好说的。
lindagirll 1 year ago 4
@hola9vi1va3ole 而且我觉得这是一种表演,不仅要唱的好,情绪的表达也很重要吧?
虽然郁可唯唱的有很多瑕疵,也有人说魏晨的声音不够MAN,但是
他们的确感动了我!不过,正如我所说,青菜萝卜,各有所爱!
lindagirll 1 year ago 4
@lindagirll
也對
不過這個版本的確很糟......
不能感動我
除非單看畫面
hola9vi1va3ole 1 year ago
@hola9vi1va3ole
就一首歌嘛
怎么两岸什么都要比一比?你们不累吗??
就不能单纯地欣赏表演吗?
charlottetsts 1 year ago
@charlottetsts
不是因為兩岸的關係(我來自香港)
有比較才有進步MA!
hola9vi1va3ole 1 year ago
Comment removed
charlottetsts 1 year ago
@hola9vi1va3ole
嘻~我也是香港的
只是有时睇唔過眼台湾同大陆成日闹交而已
唔好意思~我唔係好識得用速成或倉頡
charlottetsts 1 year ago
Comment removed
charlottetsts 1 year ago
Comment removed
lindagirll 1 year ago
可能因为我本人是学
声乐的(民歌)所以比较偏好泛音,说实话,有时候郁可唯的泛音还破坏了一定
的音准,但是那种情绪的表达最能触动我的心灵!我算是比较喜欢郁可唯这种小号
的嗓子吧。
lindagirll 1 year ago
我只能说并不是所有的人都
有齐豫的这种好嗓子和扎实的功底,她
虽然唱的是通俗,但是方法有点美声的
发声技巧,整个声音是通的!
lindagirll 1 year ago
我想郁可唯
并不是唱不上去,只是不敢气息太够,要不然就把一首好好的通俗歌唱出了民族的感觉
那是相当难听的!每个人的声音条件不一样。当然,这只是本人的拙见,青菜萝卜各有所爱。
lindagirll 1 year ago
Comment removed
lindagirll 1 year ago
憑良心說,抖音抖得實在蠻誇張的@@
而且可唯的最高音或許唱不上去吧所以有點勉強帶過被男音覆蓋過去了,至於忘詞在下反而覺得無可厚非,畢竟這首歌歌詞都很長而且很快,尤其緊張而忘詞是有可能的。這首難度頗高,純欣賞角度而言已是不錯的了,但請原諒在下,還是回去看一下最初的周華健+齊豫的原版@@,否則這唯美感覺恐怕會破滅><
magicsisuo 1 year ago 2
这首歌我听到了感情
魏晨很赞,和音不错,声音也很
有爆发力!我喜欢你们的泛音,
感觉心都在颤抖!郁可唯很聪明,在最高音的时候她选择轻轻带过,让男声去爆发,是很明智的选择,如果硬唱,出来的声音肯定是勉强和刺耳的!但是郁可唯
的忘词还有副歌部分有几句声音
没出来,减分不少,不过这点小瑕疵
掩饰不了你们的优异表现,加油!支持你们^_^
lindagirll 1 year ago
女生好几次昌错词, 合音好几次对不上。
1:17 女生注音被男生盖过。
这首歌被毁的面目全非。
secloim 1 year ago 3
一开始看了
ralph2000ralph2000 的评论还不相信 听了一分钟不到 我崩溃了```````````````好好的一首歌怎么就成这样了`` 这为朋友点评真是见血, 够犀利```
onepiece07ybw 1 year ago 2
男的很讚
女的忘詞很嚴重ㄝ= =
as2009boa 2 years ago 3
两人默契没有段旭明和朱俐靜好,但再则么说还是好厅的歌去,挺喜欢背景音乐。呵呵
smalpotato 2 years ago 16
ralph2000ralph2000, 我舉雙手贊成你的看法,亂七八糟!請評審聽聽超偶段旭明&朱俐靜的吧!
happyasen 2 years ago
他们两个人唱的我都感动死啦~我好喜欢。。。喜欢(*@ο@*) 哇~
Loveguigui 2 years ago
i understand why they choose emil chau to sing this song, he's the best!
this couple seems to lack of cooperation >_>
jamewoong 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
關起門來自己捧著呢, 男的就不多說了, 女的音色不如朱(還忘詞), 合音的默契更是差朱一截, 我聽一半就關掉了
wale068 2 years ago
There's no way Yu Kewei has less of a voice than the other girl. I may not find her interesting, but her vocal abilities are definitely superior. Go and listen to her songs like "Itch" and "roses."
lightronger 2 years ago
不够飘逸
april200304012003 2 years ago
郁可唯比朱俐靜強
但是這首的配合 個人感覺朱段比較好
Arma1999 2 years ago
郁可唯的实力要好于朱莉,但是俩人配合要差多了。
sinohippus 2 years ago
haha what a gay instruments!
Quy4life 2 years ago
cuz he's good looking? u r sad, man.
winstonzhao 2 years ago
以專業角度來說或許沒朱段來的好
但是以口氣、情感表達、音色方面
我是比較偏好魏晨和郁可唯...
聽起來會比較舒服比較自然
e13312854e 2 years ago 6
整個就跟段朱有差阿
光唱錯詞就大扣分了= =
前面也有一兩個字沒搭到
段朱搭的很緊
可能準備不足吧= =
可是郁的音質比朱好是真的
但以這首歌來說= =
嗯...
donny79524 2 years ago 6
唯+晨XD 爱!
highburycatherine 2 years ago
condor heroes theme song!
aznuploadz518 2 years ago
女的唱得不错, 音色挺美的.
但节奏感和两人默契没有段旭明和朱俐靜好.
整体来说略逊段朱组合.
cameolim 2 years ago
其实我觉得你说的一部分挺对的。只是魏晨唱得也不错啊。只是他的唱腔你可能不习惯罢了
highburycatherine 2 years ago 2
个人认为比段朱组合好多了,特别是郁可唯,真正的实力唱将
lornaxu 2 years ago
男生主歌的音准不理想, 而且有点儿飘. 所以我觉得以合唱角度来说他们比段朱逊色.
但是我喜欢女生的歌喉和甜美.
cameolim 2 years ago 3
魏晨唱歌的样子真的很帅
vliambravo 2 years ago 5
林夕的这首词写得那么好,怎么可以唱错那么多,你们什么时候听过王菲唱错林夕的词的啊。小姑娘,还要多练练啊!
robustcl 2 years ago 4
陈奕迅时常唱错^^
highburycatherine 2 years ago
歌词唱错了,有点小小的遗憾,
不过总的来说, 真的很好听!!
jasonchengdu 2 years ago 6
The song is great, but that girl continues singing wrong lyrics.
MiaoerAz 2 years ago 3
段旭明 朱俐靜的比較好
KOFXII 2 years ago 15
我觉得魏晨和郁可唯唱的比较好听
cutie2501 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
段旭明 朱俐靜的太难听了
你的耳朵有点问题!!!!
cutie2501 2 years ago
魏好似中氣不足...唱到快沒氣的感覺
bigfattony007 2 years ago
I don't see why everyone thinks he's having trouble singing just because he looks pained...
watch any of the videos of them practicing and you'll see him singing the whole sing without any trouble. He only looks like he's in pain because he is -from the separation of his love.
Plus. fyi. Wei Chen just came out of the hospital the day he sung this.
lightronger 2 years ago
JUST CAME OUT of the hospital?!
How come ??.
Plz Tell me.
lulupipi 2 years ago
He had to go to the hospital because of exhaustion from overwork, I believe.
lightronger 2 years ago
魏晨就这范儿
highburycatherine 2 years ago 2
This girl sing the wrong lyrics on 1:30 and 1:50 ( so she just mumbles and skip that part ? ) and obviously, she is out of tempo with the music at 1:54.
The man just cannot be heard at the start... Was he hesitating ? This was supposed to be a duel.. Either she should lowered her volume or he raised his.
jollymarki 2 years ago
if you listen to the original version, it's the same case. the man lowered his voice as well.
i think this is a perfect music since wei chen is guest singer and yu kewei is the one who participates in the contest and the one who needs to shine.
llppzy 2 years ago 3
no she is NOT out of tempo. I, as a musician could of course hear that...
you couldn't really hear her there because her voice itself is very soft and delicate and the instrumental was too loud.
btw its not a duel its a duet
i support yu kewei and wei chen
xD
Starlove1022 2 years ago 2
女生在一分三十秒至一分四十三秒唱錯詞,而且經典的啊~~~啊~~都唱沒朱俐靜好,還是段旭明和朱俐靜唱得好聽 ~
hamburgersss7466 2 years ago
好听好听太好听啦!!!!!!!!
kallisummer 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont understand how people can say this is better than the performance in super idol, the girl messed up the lyrics at around 1:30.. and her voice was not projected enough to be clear. The guy is okay.. but nothing super special..
ahjiu 2 years ago
Yu Kewei definitely sounds better than the other girl. The other girl had trouble holding the high notes and kept switching breathes. Wei Chen's voice is arguable.
-------
but this version is a much better performance. There's so much emotion in Wei Chen's voice and expressions.
lightronger 2 years ago 3
魏晨那個表情超級痛苦的~ 快斷氣了 他們和聲不好聼~ 個人覺得段旭明比較好聽~
pumkin2bamboo 2 years ago
his expressions comes from the pain of not being able to be with his loved, not from not being able to sing. If you watch their rehearsal, both sung with ease.
Of all four versions, this is the only duet that even attempted to put emotions into the songs. They're the only group that made this a performance and not just another practice.
The other versions may touch the ears, but true music touches the heart, and this one does exactly that.
lightronger 2 years ago 25
这俩人比段旭明和朱俐静那对好多了,不一个档次的
crownboston 2 years ago
very nice
ypdyh 2 years ago
我看了台湾超级偶像的《天下有情人》,
觉得可唯唱的很好,比台湾的朱莉静要好很多,特别是那个很长的,啊~~~~的地方,朱,气不够,差点把我吓死,我觉得可唯可能是唯一一个可以跟齐豫媲美的歌手。
lolitaya2003 2 years ago
I think of the four versions (original, Super Idol, Faye Wong, and this), this is the one with the best blend of emotions and vocals.
lightronger 2 years ago 3
就是啊,唱功最好的居然早早被淘汰
peterbunny09 2 years ago 4
chanson tres passionnée.
celinezhang 2 years ago
太好听了〉〉。。。。
fexcool22 2 years ago 2
太好听了!!!!!!
angelfanfan 2 years ago 2
我家晨晨唱歌真是好听啊!!!!
Yolande0 2 years ago 6
OMG!!! Weichennnnn!! So Gooood.
Luv HIM SO MUCH!! =)
lulupipi 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
神经病
joey2008jp 2 years ago
百看不厌!!!
sasuke4fan 2 years ago 3