Added: 3 years ago
From: TheYoungTurks
Views: 58,146
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,815)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • cop killas thums up.

  • I think Anonymous are Heroes for assisting in bringing this to light and standing up to powerful forces who would abuse the Public Trust. We all know why Bart didn't want to release the security camera footage. Thanks to the people taking videos that this story comes to light. Without these videos this whole case would of disappeared. Cops have a very hard job but this is unacceptable. What can be done to better assist our Law Enforcement in dealing with stress and meeting Justice?

  • If that Nazi cop did that in UK, he'd end up in prison for rest of his natural days.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @simgadraco2005 u are a fucking racist twat, and i have no clue who you referring to, any murder in UK would cause outrage on a national level. Police in UK is unarmed, there are armed squads and every officer issues with weapon must pass rigorous training lasting up to 3 years before deployment. In any case police killing anyone would cause major outrage and even a civil disorder as evident by recent riots we had in UK (all caused by a murder of unarmed civilian).

  • I'm curious about TYT and their editorial process. Blacks commit more than half of all violent crime, which makes it more likely for incidents like this to occur to black males. Yet if you look up interracial crime statistics, blacks are far more likely to be the aggressors rather than the victims. Your narrative, like most liberal outlets, seeks to portray minorities in the US as victims. Yet crime statistics do not support this.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • another reason for the black community to band together and revolt.. this is the same shit that happens in vietnam war when black people didnt want to get drafted so then they waste their energy to create civil rights movement

  • @sexking83 civil liberties-what a waste.

  • @sexking83 It's not about being fucking black, white, or fucking yellow. We all get the same fucking shit handed on our plate.

  • @Indica0024 ok rude man, learn some critical reading first before u make a statement

  • No one knows what was going on . THAT'S THE PROBLEM. YOU WEREN'T THERE.!! No one will ever know what was going on . This is the stupid shit that goes on in America.

  • Just another reason for people to act out..

  • cops used to be here 'to protect and serve'.. but frankly, they usually make me nervous.. it shouldn't be that way.. many of these guys are damaged individuals who have an insatiable need to intimidate good people.. and they are often the ones provoking crap into happening.. why is this acceptable? i'm not saying all police are bad, but many of them need to be policed themselves.. a police uniform doesn't grant you the right to turn into an insane ass clown..

  • @KillYourTeeVee thats the problem, police thinks they got the power with that uniform and badge, without it theyre nothing but bullies..

  • mrdsl2217 and damian246 you both are TROLLS.GO GET A LIFE AND SHUT THE FUCK UP

  • @USMarineCorpsHUAR lol, If you want some attention aswell just ask.

  • im not seeing how it was an accident? police are supposed to be trained to handle situations. police tasers are yellow their pistols are black, he had no reason to draw a weapon period, 1st degree murder

  • DO U SEE HOW THEY DID THE BOY AFTER HE WAS SHOT? THEY JUST DONT CARE

  • Stop pullin' tha racism card. Do something about it if yer so passionate.

  • it was an unfortunate accident but because hes white everyone wants to say its racist and discrimination.

  • @codowner00 i hope if this happend to a person you love u would still lable it an unfortunate accident. There is no "unfortunate accident" here caucasian, Black, Asian etc, still a ruthless murder. I feel their actions were racially motivated because the person he killed was not just unharmed he was restrained totally. Even after the young man was already HANDCUFFED another officer look to be over 220lbs put his foot on the person's head and neck.

  • @codowner00 then that cop (take a minute to digest this ) pop the clip on his gun holster..... pull the gun from the holster..... put his hand on the trigger...,,pointed it at the restrained man's back..... then pulled the trigger!!!!!! see how many seconds those are and how many times he had the opportunity to put back the gun in the holster..better yet to NOT PULL HIS GUN AT ALL THERE WAS NO THREAT TO THEM AND NO DANGER TO THEM AT ALL.......THIS IS BEYOND EXCESSIVE FORCE THIS IS CAPITAL MURDER

  • @codowner00 you werent there you werent the cop you dont know what was said threats quick movements you dont know

  • we must unite and make a real stand against the same people who have been murdering us for 500yrs

  • @BUCKSHOTBLACK00 what do you want to do get rid of all the black people

  • This murdering pig got out of jail today. I really hope someone shoots him in his pig snout face. He got sentenced to 2 yrs and did a year. If a civilian did this they would face life in prison, but an officer gets a year. 

  • @damageinc40 if the civilian is white and the victim is black/african he/she may get 10yrs tops

  • @BUCKSHOTBLACK00 Not in Texas. You kill anybody you get the needle. Period. These days even if they find out your innocent they cover it up and kill you anyway.

  • @damageinc40 he served a year too much that dirt bag grant got what he deserved

  • @mrdsl2217 Racist much? You fail at life troll. You should kill yourself asap. Get your whole face in front of the shotgun please.

  • @damageinc40 How is that racist ? Tell me what the majority race in prison is?

  • @damageinc40 why would someone serve life in prison for an accident. oscar grant was a thug

  • @mrdsl2217 And the cop a murderer, guess you prefer murderers over thugs!

    I rather be robbed by a thug than shot by a murderer.

  • @damian246 HOW IS IT MURDER. IT WAS AN ACCIDENT

  • @mrdsl2217 You must be blind to think it was a accident!

  • @damian246 YOU MUST BE IGNORANT TO THINK IT WAS MURDER. BUT REALLY DOES NOT MATTER THE THUG IS DEAD AND THE HERO COP IS FREE BITCH AND HE WILL ENJOY THE REST OF HIS LIFE WITH HIS FAMILY. I HOPE HE SUES THE STUPID GRANT FAMILY

  • @mrdsl2217 Hero cop?? is that why they put him in jail hahahaha. Does america do that to all their hero's?

    Is that why so many people wich the cop dead? stange way to treat a hero!

  • @damian246 Point is the thug is dead and he is alive and really nobody outside of Oakland gives a fuck. His kid has a father how about the thugs kid nope lol. If the thug had not caused trouble on Bart this never would have happened

  • @mrdsl2217 well i live in europe and i give a fuck! The fact that you think it is funny that a child has to grow up without his father makes you look like a dumb ass. And you call your country land of the free hahahaha

  • @damian246 Now I understand why your so stupid damn euro trash. Btw the guy is free right lol land of the free. Now who was it that had the come rescue Europe In not 1 but 2 wars oh yea the good old USA. btw your welcome for your freedom

  • @mrdsl2217 Eurotrash hahaha, we in holland got it better than you in the US. We got a higher income per head, better justice system, better healt care and more freedom than you. SO if you want to call that trash i consider that a compliment. Wake up and smell the coffea, we live now not 60 years ago. And fot you info, it was us the dutch that gave you america before you stole it from the indians!

  • @damian246 Your just mad that America is so great and your trash and the united states has the best health care on the planet. When someone need the best medical care they don't run to Holland they come to america. Your justice system is trash compared to us. Oh btw we are a super power your just a trashy little shithole.stay out of American politics go play with your fellow euro trash

  • @mrdsl2217 Why you think iam mad, I live a happy and good life with my family in holland. That something not many americans can say these days. The "super" is a bit gone and getting thinner and thinner.

    You a good example of that, you think its funny when a cop murders a unarmed man, thug or whatever en leaves a child without a father behind. You must be a proud american!

  • @damian246 i live a great life with a fantastic family thats something europeans cant say. and yes we are a super power and why should i give a fuck about a career criminal that died fuck him and his family its your peoples fault that he is here anyway or did you forget about how your people started the slave trade. you dutch scum need to pay the african people for what you did to them. fix that before you bitch about an accident ok slave trader. you must be a real proud slave trader huh lol

  • @mrdsl2217 Hahaha you must be on some kind of dop.

    Iam the first one that will claim that holland is a big part of the slavery, country's were i have family in. But do you also know when the dutch stopped slavery en when the americans did, do you also know when we stopped having collored and white sectons in the streets??? I believe america still had those last century. And glad for you that you have a fantastic life in a land that is broke, much more crimes and in war with everybody hahaha

  • @damian246 Lol typical euro trash your just jealous of Americans like everyone else. I bet you enjoy our products like coke pepsi mcdonalds lol you and the entire world crave to be American shit even bin laden drank pepsi lol. Just remember the worlds currency is based on the dollar. You can shit talk all you want but we are a nation of fighters and are economy will be strong again and you well you will still be nothing but sad euro trash

  • @mrdsl2217 Is eurotrash all you can say??? And yes i like america sometimes cause when i visit my family over there my euro is worth more than your dollar so i can buy alot cheap hahaha. And america is responible for the economic crisis if that is what you mean, another thing to be proud of hahaha.

  • @damian246 Lol your so sad you wish you could be American you crave it and you don't have family here they would have kicked them out damn euro trash and actually Europe is to blame for the economic crisis in the world btw how's the price of gas lol. I love hearing from all you jealous bitches. You trash just cant stand it that America is the best country on the planet. Enjoy your shitty health care service

  • @mrdsl2217 Hahaha stupid ass, iam born in holland but most of my family in America are born there.

    They also have american passports and can vote, i believe the law in your country say's there american. Learn your laws loser. I rather pay some more for gas and drive a better car than you. How much do you have to go to gassstation, every 100 miles hahaha. And we dont have to send our kids to their death in the middle east to get cheap gas, i believe americans do. Youre ex super power!

  • @damian246 anyone that believes the war over in the middle east is about gas is just a moron. if you really do have family in the states(total bullshit) you are stupid because you are insulting them too. the fact that you would talk shit about heroes that defend freedom and risk their life but you care about some black kid that was a career criminal he had more arrests than the beatles had hits., just goes to show what a douchebag you are.

  • @damian246 btw im sure my cars are much nicer than anything you have and i fill up 1 time every 4 to 5 weeks oh yea i make my own biodiesel so it cost me about 18cents a gallon and i drive a flex fuel vehicle most of the time my ford f150 but i also own sports cars that i don't drive that often. i also have 4 wheelers and dirt bikes. i bet i make more in 1 month than you make in 1 year. oh yea i live in the greatest country on the planet

  • @mrdsl2217 Funny that you denie all the facs, but thats what alot of americans are good in.

    Just like 9/11 and the killing of Osama. If you are so good as you say and contribute all over, why some many country;s hate you???

    Like i said, facts show that holland is doing a whole lot better than the US and we dont sent our kids to their death for some cheap gas. We care about real important stuff like people and human right, oh i forgot, not all american know what human rights are hahaha.

  • @damian246 I bet you also make your own money and playmobile cars and bikes hahahahaha

  • @damian246 Sorry your not smart enough to make bio diesel lol I bet you have a 3rd grade education lol typical euro trash

  • @mrdsl2217 i dont have any education at all and i live on the streets. Can i borrow some of your dinky toys for my kids whahahaha

  • @damian246 Typical jealous euro trash always wishing you had what Americans have lol total loser euro trash

  • @mrdsl2217 Hey dumb twat, you really thought i let you comment on my channel, whahahaha stupid ass redneck!

  • @damian246 Funny how you avoid all of my questions lol typical euro trash. People don't hate American or Americans they are just jealous of us. Like I said millions upon millions of people are not trying to get into holland but they are trying to get into America wow I wonder why if it's soooo bad lol jealous jealous jealous. Btw let me know when your shithole of a country reaches a population of 300 million plus people than you can talk ok douchebag

  • @mrdsl2217 And btw, i dont have to make my own fuel hahaha. We have electric cars and like alot of americans we think BMW, Mercedes and toyota are the better cars to drive. Not a USA car!. And soldiers that get killed for cheap fuel or kill innocent children are not hero's at all. You really dont see why others hate you do you? And me talking bad about americans does not mean every american is bad, but if you feel its about you, it probably is!

  • @damian246 Lol BMW and Mercedes the 2 worst cars and the 2 cars that do not hold value and toyota watch out it may get recalled lol ford is the best and I'm a man so I drive a truck. Your just typical jealous euro trash. Plain and simple. Btw the shit eater Oscar grant yup stil dead ha ha ha ha ha

  • @damian246 Just so you know chevy and tesla make the best electric cars on the market today and both yup American companies. Btw electric cars are not very good for towing my boat or my dirt bikes and atv's so what's the use plus they don't go far enough on a charge. Bye jealous euro trash

  • @mrdsl2217 You really funny but if you believe it thats good for u. Iam looking forward to your next typical american dumb message cause iam having fun lol. And sorry, i dont play with playmobile and dinky toys any more, but my lil son is very lealous of you hahaha.

  • @damian246 Oh the truth hurts huh lol and I feel sorry for your kid with a douchebag father like you I'm sure when he grows up he will be a great ditch digger. Lol euro trash and your retarded euro trash bastard

  • @mrdsl2217 Hahaha yes iam crying that i cant play with your toys. Oh, iam also crying cause you keep calling me doucheback and eurotrash hahaha. Like i said, if you think so, thats good for u. (and amusement for me)

  • @damian246 lol your so jealous of americans its ok i understand the entire world is jealous and all you do avoid the facts i have stated so keep commenting if you want but your nothing more than a jealous euro trash troll ha ha ha ha ha ha my kids and i are laughing at your stupid comments ha ha ha ha ha what a douchebag BYE TROLL

  • @mrdsl2217 Oh iam so jealous that you earn in a month what i earn in a year, that you own sportscars, trucks, 4 weelers, dirtbikes , boats and make your own fuel. Hahahaha who you try to fool mr fairytayls.

  • @damian246 i bet all the clothes you wear is all styles from the states and the music you listen to is all from american artist's and your technology is all developed from the states. if you use a pc guess what it has windows made in the usa a mac well osx made in the usa. if your computer has intel guess what thats an american company. i dont see holland making any real contribution to the world nope and yes i know we use slave labor in china to assemble the stuff but still developed in america

  • @mrdsl2217 This just shows you know little about europe/holland and music!

    As small as we are i think we doing more good than the USA. Look at your crime rates and compare them with ours. And for ur info, holland has the best watermanagement in the world. And what is most important next to air, exacly. Not to forget our recue/police dog in america and over the world. The fact that your a much bigger country does not mean its better, But youre right, there are also things i like about america.

  • @damian246 like i said you have nothing to contribute so stfu TROLL

  • @mrdsl2217 Lol, no we dont contribute our kids life for money! We like to think before we act hahaha

  • @damian246 Like I said you contribute nothing to the world you live in a shithole your poor what else very sad if you ask me lol you are so jealous of Americans. Funny thing is I don't see millions of people wanting to move to holland lol if it's soooo great nope people want to come to America greatest nation on the planet. But don't worry if you get into trouble again we real men will be there to bail your ass out.btw the monkey Oscar grant still dead lol

  • What's the big deal?? Cops murder citizens all the time. This is just another Media attempt to make money by promoting racial differences. In every media story the highlight is "WHITE cop kills BLACK man"

    It's not "pig murders another citizen" because the Media have to continue their racist propaganda to increase profit. Please take note of this. Thx.

    I can't help but wonder what world these "i've never seen this before" people live in. Murderers join the police force, it's common sense

  • He's OBVIOUSLY surprised when he shot Oscar.You can tell it in his body language and face.However, even if he did mean to taze him..why? the idiot (yes, oscar grant was a drunk idiot that night and it DID play a part in his dead..let this be a lessons to all the drunk, punkass morons out there) was already handcuffed and on the ground.Even if he was being difficult, why did he need to be tazed? tazers are to subdue criminals.Grant was already down and cuffed.

  • He shouldn't have been instantly suspended he should've be instantly arrested!

  • This is what they always do. If they could have gotten around it the cop who killed him would never have faced a judge. That's what all the "under investigation" bullshit means when they're talking about a cop.

    He got two years!

  • this is what makes riots and increases people killing cops pigs if u keep it up ur going to go to war with fed up people

  • He gets out around November I hear. Somebody shoot him in the back

  • That is just bs shooting him when he wasnt doing anything he had handcuffs on and everything i hope that cop rots in jail dont put him to death make him suffer and maybe put him to death =.= thats bs

  • @Kittyxihime No, he most certainly and CLEARLY did NOT have handcuffs on! I am so sick of people spreading that lie, and then acting like it doesn't matter when they are proven wrong. Had he allowed himself to be cuffed, he would have made it home. Wasn't doing anything? I certainly think assaulting 2 cops and resisting arrest was doing something. What he WASN'T doing was complying with police orders, or giving up his hands to be cuffed.

  • @ssn708 Even if he doesnt have cuffs on thats still wrong they murdered him cold blood there was no reason to kill him no reason at all. Cops are worthless pigs who think just cause they have a gun they can do whatever they want. Every cop who does this needs to be shot in the back like they did to this person. Now don't get me wrong i dont hate cops i disslike stupid ones thats all.

  • @Kittyxihime Except it was a tragic accident, negligent homicide, not murder. Just so you know, I am NOT defending the cop. Yes, he was stupid, and by all accounts CLUMSY. If you look into this guy, the people who knew him best have NO problem believing he pulled his gun when he meant to pull his taser, he was that much of an oaf. But he did not intend to even SHOOT Grant, much less kill him, so murder is the wrong word.There are enough REAL MURDERING cops, we don't need to make one that isn't

  • @ssn708 True but he should have known better dont pull ur gun our even if you thought it was your taser unless you know what will happen to u and that person and if he was going after his taser idky he would he should have made sure it was before firing and tasers and guns are differnt so he knew he was holding a gun not a taser i put him down a a murderer and alot of people do if you don't then thats fine but people need to look before they act. or something like this happens.

  • @Kittyxihime Absolutely, he should have confirmed his weapon. I blame BART as much as him, they gave them NO training (they had tasers for 2 weeks by this time) and they had NO policy on taser placement. They handed off already configured belts mid-shift without any standard.

  • @Kittyxihime Continued from below: There is not nearly as much difference as people think. About 9 ounces in weight, and the handles of both feel the same. Had he thought it was his gun, he would not have shouted "I'm tasing him", he would not have shot straight down towards a hard surface. He would not have had a one handed weak grip. Google "video proof mehserle thought he was firing his taser", gives a better explanation than I can in <500 characters. NOT OK BY A LONG SHOT, but not murder.

  • @Kittyxihime I agree, which is why I FULLY support his conviction and incarceration. The sticking point is his intent. So many think he EXECUTED him. Does it happen, absolutely! Fong Lee is still fresh in my mind. But not in this case. This was an idiot cop who NEVER should have had a badge, meeting up with a violent career criminal with a history of assaulting cops. BAD combination, something bad was BOUND to happen. But murder REQUIRES intent, and his intent was proven to have been to tase.

  • The cops murdered the young man. No question.

  • @ssn708 If you want to talk about IQs higher than your shoe size then you would know the difference between a taser and a gun or YOU might need to do some research on that. How could you say that Mehserle intended to tase; if you watch there is seconds before he shoots him; cops have to make split second decisions. Also if you look there is about 5 cops around him, those guys on the wall don't look like they are doing too much for the cops to shoot one of them. Get some glasses and knowledge bro

  • @shutitdown9 I know the EXACT differences. <9 OUNCES difference in weight, NO difference in the black rubberized grip. Sorry, if you had ANY intelligence or common sense whatsoever, you would know that NO ONE would intentionally fire a .40 cal downward against a hard surface, and CERTAINLY would not fire what they knew to be a .40 cal with a ONE HANDED, WEAK grip. In fact, the grip safety should have prevented the gun from even being ABLE to fire. Sorry BRO, I HAVE done my research, YOU HAVEN'T

  • It is easy to think you know what you see in a video, and it is easy to be wrong. Take a look at the video titled Police Shooting Video #1 here on the tube. You will be certain this is not a justified shooting, and you will be 100% wrong.

  • It is easy to think you know for sure something you see on video. But it is easier to be entirely wrong. For example, look up right here on youtube "Police Shooting Video #1", keeping in mind while you watch the video that it was a 100% justifiable shooting. You will be sure what you are seeing shows otherwise, but you will be wrong.

  • Come on man.... Oscar Grant was lying on the floor without any weapons and with 3 policemen surround him... Why need to shoot ??????? Imagine this happen to you or your relatives.....

  • @rudyputra1 As was proven, he intended to tase him, which would have been appropriate given the fact that he already assaulted 2 officers and would not give up his hands to be cuffed. He had not been searched yet, so they had no way to know he was unarmed. As far as the other officers, Pirone was helping with Grant while also restraining the friend to Grant's left, the remainder of the cops were trying to prevent the 10-12 people encroaching on the scene from interfering.

  • No, you liars, you cut out the audio because it would prove Mehserle shouted "I'm tasing him" to which Grant replied "Don't tase me". And submissive? Another lie. He had already assaulted two officers, he was resisting arrest. He put his hands under him and refused to give them up to be cuffed, which he never was. But they STRAIGHT UP LIE and say he was cuffed. How irresponsible and false. TheYoungTurks should be ashamed.

  • Can people NOT SEE THE VIDEO? First off, Oscar grant.. this poor DRUNKEN CRIMINAL, WAS ASSUALTING OFFICERS AND RESISTING ARREST, before being handcuffed. Second, all those black people screaming and acting like a bunch of drunken animals were obviously nerve racking and scaring the officers. Its very logical to think the officer could have went for his tazer, its located RIGHT NEXT TO HIS FIREARM. This wasn't a racist cop killing a poor black man, it was an accidental shooting of a criminal.

  • Please, anyone reading my comments, do not assume for a moment that I think Grant "deserved" it, or that Mehserle was anything other than criminally negligent. That was never my intention to convey that message. There are however lies being spread to inflame the situation, and the truth is just too accessible to allow the lies to go unchallenged.

  • Put this piece of shit cop in with the general population at whatever jail he goes to and justice will be served.

  • To serve and protect? And you have morons on these board trying to initiate defense towards the police officer. Whether it's cold blooded homicide or negligence there was a criminal act involved not an accident. Again not an accident. It's no different than someone "accidentally" played with a gun a and shoot someone dead. It's a criminal offense. There was no inherit threat by the individual with multiple officers subduing him.

  • @NordicBlood84 Criminally negligent homicide, which this was, is by definition an accident. Yes, it was an accident, a fatal one. It is like saying that the person who hit the gas instead of the brake was no accident. It was. Criminal? Yes! Prison time for the cop? Absolutely! But unintentional, accidental, and not in the same league as an intentional killing. BTW, yes, someone "playing" with a gun and killing someone IS an accident as well. CRIMINAL yes, but accidental nonetheless.

  • Cenk for president !!

  • yippeee. Now arrest the others that do it everyday. Especially the old indian fella' in seattle that had a 7 centimeter long little knife and was whittleing a piece of wood.

  • this freaking guy again. do us all a favor. retire plz you suck.

  • @ncresr66 If you are referring to me, I will be here dispelling the lies as long as I like. Every single thing I say is verifiable fact, so I am not going anywhere.

  • Your comment is highly rated, but completely false. Grant WAS resisting arrest. That did not cause Mehserle to "accidentally fire", it caused him to decide to tase Grant. He pulled the wrong weapon as has happened to no less than 8 other officers, which is why most departments have a policy to place it in a position to have to cross-draw the taser. BART had no such policy, Mehserle had it on the same side as his firearm. Most officers get 40 hours or so of taser training, Mehserle had 8.

  • @ssn708

    Your a fucking idiot

  • @YungDGTM You should check your spelling the next time you try to call someone an idiot, or else you end up looking like a complete moron yourself (as you have just done). Everything I have said is 100% verifiable fact. Sorry if you don't like it, but it is true.

  • @ssn708 Why when there are two police officers trying to restrain Oscar Grant who appears to be about 5'7" maybe 150 pounds do you need to tase someone who is already handcuffed. explain that to me. Where the hell is he going to run, and what type of fight can someone put up with their hands cuffed behind their back, this was excessive and another case of a scary white police officer overreacting to the supposed threat posed by a tiny young black male. Get the fuck outta here with that bullshit.

  • @Lindseyadam Yet another uninformed person spreading false info.

    1) Grant absolutely was NOT handcuffed, you are simply wrong.

    2) There were not 2 officers "restraining" Grant. Mehserle was trying to cuff him and Pirone was kneeling on him while ALSO restraining one of Grant's friends (who was hostile from the start)

    3) Grant assaulted 2 cops & had not been searched. Since Grant managed to hold them off from cuffing for 30 seconds, obviously he could put up ENOUGH of a fight to resist arrest!

  • @ssn708 You are uninformed actually, he is cuffed you must not have very good vision my friend, and also as I stated earlier there are two not one two police officers restraining him one with his knee on his kneck the other cuffing him simultaneously.

  • @Lindseyadam It is you with the vision problem. At 1:02, you see his outstreteched right arm. No cuffs. 1:06 through 1:12 you see him propped on his right arm, reaching up with his left. He was not handcuffed, and that is a fact. As I stated, Mehserle was trying to cuff him (since he was NOT cuffed) and Pirone was kneeling on his neck while also containing Grant's friend. So there were not 2 officers restraining Grant. Pirone was partially restraining him, and Mehserle was trying to cuff him.

  • @Lindseyadam He was not cuffed the entire time.

  • @H1mynameisLarry He was cuffed when he was shot and thats all that matters. Watch his reaction after the gun shot he rolled over with his hands behind his back. Don't you think if he was not cuffed he would have reached towards his back where he was shot by this scary coward? But he didn't and the worst part is they shot him and just stood around dumbfounded in no hurry to get him medical attention.

  • @Lindseyadam Like I said, he was not cuffed the ENTIRE time. He was cuffed when they had him on the WALL .. that's why he kneed office Pirone in the groin. DUH. I can show u at least 100000000000 videos where people are cuffed and still get out of them.

    Lindsey, JUST BECAUSE YOU CUFFED DON'T MEAN YOU CAN CAUSE NO HARM YOU DUMMY.

    Ocsar Grant was NEVER padded down.

    If Oscar Grant was so 'Cooperative' and "cuffed" and can't move, how did he take out his phone and take a lovely picture of J.M?

  • @H1mynameisLarry Actually, he was NOT cuffed when he was against the wall either. The reason Pirone apprached him (and got kneed in the groin) was because Grant violently grabbed officer Domenici by the arm, which he could not do if cuffed. About half way through "Oscar Grant knees BART officer Tony Pirone in the groin" you see far back enough to see him grab the officer by the arm. Apparently they may have cuffed him afterwards until he was seacrhed, there is conflicting info on that.

  • @ssn708 he was too handcuffed look at the video after he shot him then they backed away. he's handcuffed and shot after they handcuffed him. then they backed away. wathc the video. yall are just making excuse for yall white ppl bad ass criminal behavior...

  • @bigphyne2002 Wrong. He absolutely was NOT handcuffed, and that is a proven fact. I would never excuse the cop, I only defend the truth. Your blanket statement about White's proves you a racist, and your statement that he was handcuffed proves you are an ignorant one at that. Look at 1:01, tell me how his hand is outstretched with no other hand by it? Hmmmm. Or 1:08 where he is propped up on one hand and reaching up with his left? Too blurry? Look up the Tommy Cross video. You'll see I'm right.

  • @ssn708 no youre wrong look at 1:24 you would clearly see him handcuffed and then shot, that when the officers scattered away. and yes i stand 100% behind my comment about the whites. you"re only defending the murderer which you are no different from him by defending him.

  • @bigphyne2002 Then you choose to be ignorant. He was not handcuffed and the only station that ever said he was had to retract because he was not. Again, look at the Tommy Cross video and you will see how wrong you are. BTW, 1:24 is a REPLAY of the video. Do you think during an instant replay the team got another touchdown, too? Again, look at 1:01 and 1:08. It is physically impossible that he was cuffed. The Tommy Cross video is shot head on and is totally clear. He was not cuffed, that's a FACT

  • Comment removed

  • @bigphyne2002 I do not defend the cop (who is not a murderer, but an idiot). I only defend the truth against persons spreading lies such as yourself. Oscar Grant was simply not handcuffed. That was very publicly proven over two years ago. Try to keep up. And you stand behind your racism? Good, I am glad you would not try to excuse it.

  • @ssn708 not a murderer? FUCK YOU.

  • @mychokehold Proven fact, so fuck you too! Mehserle intended to tase, and anyone with an IQ higher than their shoe size can do some research and find out that this is a fact. Criminally negligent homicide, and absolutely NOT murder. Sorry, but it is true. Dislike it all you want.

  • @ssn708

    Listen you inbred dumb piece of shit. ANY KILLER, RAPIST, THIEF, OR SADISTIC ASSHOLE WITH NO CRIMINAL RECORD IS ELIGIBLE TO GO THROUGH POLICE ACADEMY AND BECOME A COP.

    Oscar grant insulted a tyrant in uniform, and this tyrant happened to be a sadistic murderer. THIS WAS COLD BLOODED MURDER YOU FUCKING MORON,

    Your just a white trash dumb piece of shit, go back to fucking your sister and drinking methanol you dumbass degenerate. Your a fucking retarded bigot.

  • @JenkemBOMBS < Oscar Grant also raped and tortured a 13 year old girl who's father owed him a drug debt. Grand brutalized her so severely she can NEVER have children and for THAT only received 7 years and was paroled after serving less than 2. Where's you anger over that i ask you? He was out on parole, drunk, high and resisting arrest when he was shot.

  • @USMC3531tsd Yeah, 12 arrests in 4 years, and he resisted every time. I've heard about the rape before, can you lead me to some verifiable information? I see drug possession, assault on officers, carrying a weapon (which he had on his LAP as a passenger in a car....Ummm, drive-by?). It certainly would not give a cop authority to murder someone, but since it was very clearly proven he intended to fire his taser, that is not what happened.

  • @JenkemBOMBS YOU are a liar and obviously an idiot. This was an accident, and that was very clearly proven to anyone with some common sense and an I.Q. that exceeds their shoe size. Learn how to spell before you call others dumb, would you please? To those who are interested in the TRUTH, first apply some common sense, and then do a search for "video proof that mehserle thought he was firing his taser". Then give your opinion. TRAGIC ACCIDENT. CRIMINALLY NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE, NOT murder

  • @ssn708

    Your a fucking retard and obviously suffer from a extra chromosome.

    This shit was not a accident. IF IT WAS WHY DID HE TRY TO FIRE A TASER INTO A GUYS HEAD?

    This was fucking cold blooded murder. I know its hard to drop what you've been indoctrinated to believe your entire life, BUT MURDERERS, RAPISTS, THIEVES, AND SADISTIC ASSHOLES CAN SLIP THROUGH POLICE ACADEMY.

    This was cold blooded murder, the piece of shit cop should be executed. Eye for a eye.

  • @JenkemBOMBS If you were not a complete moron, you would know he DIDN'T fire ANYTHING into Grant's HEAD! In fact, he fired into a COMPLETELY NON-VITAL area of the back (where one would aim a taser), it was the ricochet off of the floor that pierced Grant's LUNG, not his head. If you knew ANYTHING about me you would know I am an adamant, fervent supporter of our rights over police, but that also means calling bullshit on idiots who have no concept of the facts. That would be YOU.

  • @Lindseyadam Correct = They did look dumbfounded because it wasn't suppose to happen. You stupid fuck, just proved my point. They called for medical attention a few seconds later. If you consider it murder, why would they look dumbfounded? Wouldn't he yell "Hahaha,bitch" if it was a murder? I guess if you are driving in the storm and didn't see someone and accidentally hit him, ill be murder as well. I guess if I'm at a shooting range and a kid jumps in front and i accident shoot him, its murder

  • @Lindseyadam When you are shot your muscles freeze, You can't move. You are 100% locked up. Oscar Grant was not handcuffed, and that is a fact. Don't believe me? Fine. Look at 1:01 on the video. Tell me how you see Oscar Grant's right arm, outstretched with no left arm nearby? Sorry, you're wrong. Still don't believe me? Look at 1:07 - 1:15 and tell me how he is propped up on his right arm and reaching up with his left? It was proven 2 years ago he was not cuffed. Try to catch up

  • @ssn708 100% Correct.

  • @atouchofmagic1988 I agree, there is no way to justify the shooting. None. Realizing it was an accident is not justification. A cop forgets to put on his parking brake and the vehicle runs over a suspect, that is not running him down. It is a mistake. People expect cops to behave like machines and be infallible. They are human, they make mistakes. A cook places a cooked hamburger on the same plate raw hamburger was on, and a customer dies. Should he rot in prison? Should his children be killed?

  • @atouchofmagic1988 I see a cop that pulls out a gun and shoots this kid straight in back without hesitation. He then was dragged away. 911 wasn't even called til later. No other citizen can use the excuse "I accidentally took out my gun, pointed it and shot him in the back" and get off easy. Plus, how do we know this was an accident? Cops shoot and kill people all the time. PLUS, this cop changed his story a couple times to cover it up!! UNTIL they found out about this video!!

  • @DavieDave59 A cop would have had considerably more hesitation if he intended to fire a gun instead of a taser. His non-chalance is further proof he had no intention of using deadly force. And you fail to mention in your statement that no one but a cop has the authority to use force to effectuate an arrest, and therefore there would never be a similar situation with a citizen. The cop (Mehserle) never once changed his "story", that is just not accurate.

  • @ssn708 They tried the whole "he was resisting arrest which caused him to accidently fire" nonsense... well, until the film showed he was face down, not moving. You defense cops too much. They are NOT our friend, but our enemy. One day you will realize that. Hopefully not too late.

  • @DavieDave59 They more than "tried" it, they proved he was resisting. He tried to roll onto his back, that is resisting. They tried to get his hands and he pulled them away, that is resisting. He put a hand under his body, and that is resisting. He did not "accidentally fire", he intended to fire a taser, and that is a proven fact. I have never once defended the cop, I think he is a dipshit who deserves prison time. I only defend the truth. If you think cops are the enemy, don't ever call one.

  • @ssn708 I have never once in my life called the police. They do more harm than good. I will most likely never ever need one. In my life I've had more harm done to me rather than good by cops. I was even arrested by crooked cops. It takes a certain personality to become a cop. You have to enjoy violence. You must orgasm over having power over someone. These are the people that will arrest and suppress ppl for the government without thinking.

  • @DavieDave59 Many meet that description, you will get no argument from me. Far from all, not even most. But many, and they are the ones that leave the impression. Best of luck to you.

  • @atouchofmagic1988 It isn't very hard to tell the difference between a gun and a taser. The officer pulled the gun out and shot him in the back while he was defensless on the ground. That is murder. Whether you have a badge or not.

    He deserves to rot in prison for life.

  • To many posters: No state I am aware of has made it a crime to video tape cops. SOME states have a wiretap law that prevents an audio recording without consent of the person being recorded, but this was never intended to include public officials or anyone in a public place where they would have no reasonable expectation of privacy. Most competent judges have struck down any attempt to use wiretap laws against those filming police, since Police use dashcam video with audio regardless of consent.

  • @atouchofmagic1988 I can see your point. my problem is not with the police. It's with the system. There is nothing in place to keep the cops in check. Now I've heard the law makers are trying to make it illegal to film cops. with nothing in place make them accountable and the fact that power corrupts, what's to stop things like this happening all the time?

  • @atouchofmagic1988 I still think it is criminal negligence, and absolutely he deserves prison time. Lots of times people think I am trying to defend the cop. I absolutely am not defending the cops actions. What happened is still a crime and he deserves to be punished for it, but it was not a deliberate act, an execution, a murder, or racially motivated. It was a dumbass cop who accidentally shot a dumbass career criminal. Now two families are destroyed. It sucks all around.

  • @atouchofmagic1988 Actually he was not handcuffed. He refused to give his hands which is why the officer intended to tase him. Tragic all around.

  • omg i hate looking at people say police officer are not need or stupid or what ever i want to see what will happen to America with out police really all of you are stupid....this police officer was in the wrong this time he deserves jail....

  • @codenick101 police are needed. But they have TOO much power. We need less police.

  • FUCKIN ASSHOLE !!! Hope that fuckin police ass will get raped in jail + killed , sorry but anger is comin into me ! ACAB ALL COPS ARE BASTARDS!

  • this guy is pathetic. he wasnt shot in the back, it was in the side, the autopsy revealed that.And he wasnt hancuffed. he only had one hand cuffed, and the other was on his front side and HE was resisting arrest so the officer meant to taze him

  • @abeedelaa Actually, he was shot in the back. He was shot in a completely non-vital area of the back (where one would fire a taser). The bullet ricocheted off of the floor and exited through Grant's lung. This is further indication he had no intention to draw his gun, ricochet could have easily killed himself, other officers of people on the train. Absolutely he meant to tase him. Still, criminally negligent and worthy of prison time in my opinion.

  • fuck the Police

  • @GQvizoXX Remember an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.

  • @GQvizoXX What? Speak English, because all that's coming out is hot garbage. I am not loyal to ignorance or hate. You've been infected by it like cancer. A history lesson from you would be like taking a martial arts lesson from Martha Stewart. You're not qualified. You're attempting to use misguided emotions and other b.s. you've heard to form facts and it's not working. You're probably living in some bumbfuck county where you've never even had one friend who wasn't white. Shame on you.

  • I use RikJamez since I love Dave Chapell and funk music so much (musician what can you do), but I am white and I'm fucking crying right now. I don't want the neighbors to know so I'm trying to hold it in. This is fucked, don't forget about your little white brothers, we love you man. Don't let those rednecks turn you against us all. You are everything to me. My life would be nothing without black people. You gave us real music and soul. Family is 4 life.

  • 2 years is kind of harsh, even if he will be out in 7 months. There should be no prison time for killing blacks. Killing evil is not a crime. What a warped world we live in where we allow evil to live when we can extinguish it.

  • @Nopartyforme82

    if your saying blacks are evil., yur wrong. im white...but i do have black relatives.in gods eyes, we're the same, im not one of those jesus christ freaks but still, you racist fuck., go to hell.

  • @punkhayhay88

    "Racism" against blacks and white guilt liberals like you is justified.

  • I really wish these lying bastards, The Young Turkeys, would come forward and make some retraction since Grant WAS NOT HANDCUFFED. This was proven to be an accidental shooting, yet these morons let this video stand as is? You should be ashamed of yourselves. And yes, everyone knew why he was in Nevada, his family lived there. He informed the police of his whereabouts, they knew right where to pick him up.

  • @ssn708: The video sure made it look like he was hancuffed. But, either way, the cop showed criminal negligence that cost a life. He deserved more than two years. Hell, I did longer than that for $40 worth of grass. Not to mention the SWAT team, concussion grenades, semi-automatic weapons, and 30 guys milling about in my living room for 6 hours. Later, I asked one of the cops (we'd gone to high school together) why they used such a big hammer on such a small fly. "Overtime", he said.

  • @louiswu2 I agree that Mehserle deserves prison time for his criminal negligence, that has been my position all along. But I do not think he deserves any more time than the average drunk driver who kills someone, less even because choosing to drink and drive is far more intentional than accidentally drawing the wrong weapon. There are serious abuses in the police department, that is undeniable. But those making this something it is not only detracts from the real problems.

  • @ssn708: There's still some question in my own mind as to how he could have possibly mistaken a firearm for a taser. You and I may disagree on the magnitude and consequences of taking a human life, even in error. Those in law enforcement have a lot of power and discretion, and so the sanctions for ineptitude or malice should be severe.