still my fav song of theirs. their awesome live and i got to meet jeanie. total sweetheart. best part was when someone threw a waterbottle at phil,..he came back with "oh theres that fucker! hes just mad cause his girls starin at my dick! lol gotta love phil
This Darkened Heart was a fantastic album. I don't give two fucks OR half a shit what any body has to say. 1 dislike? HAH! Clearly he was too fucking blown away by ATR that he misclicked whilst in a daze. Shit happens. The Fall of Ideals was also a fantastic album, they put up a pretty good live show from the few I've been to. Recommend you all catch one.
@bonnertom032 fall of ideals was just as good IMO if not better, it was the same style as this darkened heart but really felt like a carry on/ really good follow up.
do they play any of the songs from this darkened hear live anymore? i wanna go see them and this was my favrite album and im hopin they play this or the deepest gray
@alpengeist19 sadly with the release of overcome as much as every old fan hates it to death, and i mean every, they decided tdh isn't good enough anymore
@alpengeist19 a little late reply but yes they do play these songs live these days u can find tons of footage of this song live in 09 and i think theres like 1 or 2 the deepest gray footages from 09 on youtube so ya
HOW ABOUT WE STFU!!! are u a fan of ATR yes u are so if u dont like all their music then u cant classify urself as a fan... bands neee to progress... phils voice progressed as th guitar playing and the drumming progressed... Lyrics dont exactly matter as their put into a song just to have the bands main sound... i thinks its great they can do song without screaming except for the radio edit of forever in your hands i wish they woulda left the screamin on the radio but its still a good song
i seriously thought this was the studio recording just put over a live video. thats how flawless it was. but then i heard him talking to the crowd and i was like oh lol
What are you talking about? His voice is BETTER now! As they were recording overcome, he took screaming and singing lessons. His voice is perfect in every way now, especially live. They were flawless when I saw them a few months ago. He can scream all he wants without any clean sacrifices, it's awesome.
Dude im sorry i love ATR to death but Overcome wasnt what i thought it would be...it was really good but i almost felt robbed. It should have been better. But it was still a good album.
o it was good but i but i think it could have been alot better. At least a little friendly...and it the lyrics were kinda half ass on overcome... Do Not Obey? WTF? Alot of deep meaningful songs and a few that were weird.
WHY DID ALL THAT REMAINS ABANDON THIS SOUND FOR 'OVERCOME' god damn it. i know bands need to evolve and stuff, but damn they could have done a another cd or two with this amazing style.
omfg ROFL at 0:50 -- 0:53 im sorry atr is amazing and all but that made me cry from laughing bc it was so unexpected -- amazing live performance -- omg 1:42 phils dehatted himself prepare for domination +20 adrenaline lol = ) : D
thats because he is dude..lol, i think he is just about the best...some of his compositions are just incredibly beautiful and ball stomping at the same time..his solos are unreal..
his drum teacher he had lessons with taught him jazz techniques. Jason was into metal tho so his teacher showed him how to play it with that same jazz technique. my personal opinoin hes almost as good as joey jordison and chris adler
maybe joey jordison,but not even close to chris adler...though i truthfully don't care cause the joey and chris comments on drum videos get really fucking annoying.
This song is amazing... For some reason the first few times I hated it, but after not listening to it for about 2 months I listened to it again and now it is my favorite ATR song
haha no way me too i used to hate metal so much i thought it was really stupid and it kinds almost scared me lol, now i love it and love jamming out to it on my bass!!! its so cool, sounds like we'r kinda the same, but my fave genre is pop-punk, like blink-182, fall otu boy ( thier older stuff) panic at the disco, takign back sunday, but metal is like my 2nd fave or its tied with pop punk so lol
I just went to my local best buy and picked it up man. Im sure you can get it almost any where that has music dvds. They only had like 3 copies on the shelf though.
still my fav song of theirs. their awesome live and i got to meet jeanie. total sweetheart. best part was when someone threw a waterbottle at phil,..he came back with "oh theres that fucker! hes just mad cause his girls starin at my dick! lol gotta love phil
AcousticSerenity 6 days ago
The Fall Of Ideals is ATR's best album...but This Darkened Heart is the only album that could rival it.
ShaneRBeacham 1 month ago
Best All That Remains song out there...
ItalianSausage0 2 months ago
quit debating wich album is better please there both great
daywalkerjoey 2 months ago
fuck yeah love this song!
GAMEZILLA50K 6 months ago
didn't Matt Deis sing the last part of the song before??
motabaco 9 months ago
Holy shit, Phil's voice is better on this, than on their studio albums!
CingetoAD 1 year ago 3
yea fall of ideals is defintley best album
beatles3420 1 year ago 2
@beatles3420 Yeah dude, I'd have to agree on that one.
MikeyJTheGreat 11 months ago 3
BEST ALBUM EVER!
TheWarriorofDestiny 1 year ago
Jason is so much better than their original drummer (not Shannon)
Hammy0924 1 year ago 2
This Darkened Heart was a fantastic album. I don't give two fucks OR half a shit what any body has to say. 1 dislike? HAH! Clearly he was too fucking blown away by ATR that he misclicked whilst in a daze. Shit happens. The Fall of Ideals was also a fantastic album, they put up a pretty good live show from the few I've been to. Recommend you all catch one.
Lazarus142 1 year ago 2
@Lazarus142 This Darkened Heart was probably their best album. metalcore with a hint of melodic death metal. great combo
bonnertom032 1 year ago
@bonnertom032 I completely agree, it's my favourite album for sure.
Lazarus142 1 year ago
@bonnertom032 fall of ideals was just as good IMO if not better, it was the same style as this darkened heart but really felt like a carry on/ really good follow up.
xkruulx 4 months ago
Lol awsome song but they sucked ass here in halifax last May. i think a studio band, or they just played some bad songs when they were here.
Jmyster4 1 year ago
i love wen he says "foul"
aliceinchains898 1 year ago
1:10 ... This is ATR
AlePresz 1 year ago
God I love raw live versions like this. So sick man
FailcoreFW 1 year ago 3
i hate how phil always makes the croud sing on the clean vocals, he has a great voice!
MrPwnageFactor 1 year ago
@MrPwnageFactor True but it's not the greatest live
FoxtrotXero 1 year ago
I hate there old songs tuned down to C#. The studio version is so much better than this.
swordfreak3 1 year ago 2
@swordfreak3 all of their songs are tuned in Db (aka C#) they have always used that tuning
metpach 1 year ago
fucking bullshit this songs make me cum off my ears lol I love All That Refuckinmains x)
LPDXDX 1 year ago
i love hoiw phils screams then after he screams in the same song he can actually sing perfectly
iCoptici 1 year ago
do they play any of the songs from this darkened hear live anymore? i wanna go see them and this was my favrite album and im hopin they play this or the deepest gray
alpengeist19 1 year ago
@alpengeist19 sadly with the release of overcome as much as every old fan hates it to death, and i mean every, they decided tdh isn't good enough anymore
thedivitoxchannel 1 year ago
@thedivitoxchannel Every old ATR fan that i know, and i know ALOT despite Overcome being a shit album, no one has "Decided" that TDH is a bad album.
dont speak for a mass if youre speaking for yourself or a few people.
MrHavok111 1 year ago
@alpengeist19 a little late reply but yes they do play these songs live these days u can find tons of footage of this song live in 09 and i think theres like 1 or 2 the deepest gray footages from 09 on youtube so ya
clipto4 1 year ago
Comment removed
palickpre 2 years ago
HOW ABOUT WE STFU!!! are u a fan of ATR yes u are so if u dont like all their music then u cant classify urself as a fan... bands neee to progress... phils voice progressed as th guitar playing and the drumming progressed... Lyrics dont exactly matter as their put into a song just to have the bands main sound... i thinks its great they can do song without screaming except for the radio edit of forever in your hands i wish they woulda left the screamin on the radio but its still a good song
a7xmanalltheway 2 years ago 2
@a7xmanalltheway i love all of thgeir songs
iCoptici 1 year ago
i seriously thought this was the studio recording just put over a live video. thats how flawless it was. but then i heard him talking to the crowd and i was like oh lol
zefaulka 2 years ago
@zefaulka I thought it was too at the beginning
Adrumalot 2 years ago
This was an awesome Wednesday
armandoEnriquez 2 years ago
its a shame to see phil's vocals getting worse...i seen them play in 04' and he was amazing.
fudgicle85 2 years ago
What are you talking about? His voice is BETTER now! As they were recording overcome, he took screaming and singing lessons. His voice is perfect in every way now, especially live. They were flawless when I saw them a few months ago. He can scream all he wants without any clean sacrifices, it's awesome.
TrinityofTriforce 2 years ago 3
Dude im sorry i love ATR to death but Overcome wasnt what i thought it would be...it was really good but i almost felt robbed. It should have been better. But it was still a good album.
Elecktricd00m 2 years ago
i love all that remains too, i thought overcome was a great album..
demonslaughter0990 2 years ago
o it was good but i but i think it could have been alot better. At least a little friendly...and it the lyrics were kinda half ass on overcome... Do Not Obey? WTF? Alot of deep meaningful songs and a few that were weird.
Elecktricd00m 2 years ago
its okay! :0 alot of bands are going softer
xXVictorViceXx 2 years ago
but a lot of bands are also going heavier
zefaulka 2 years ago
i know EXACTLY how you feel! haha
zcdfadse 2 years ago
WHY DID ALL THAT REMAINS ABANDON THIS SOUND FOR 'OVERCOME' god damn it. i know bands need to evolve and stuff, but damn they could have done a another cd or two with this amazing style.
ChaDMcBaDD 2 years ago
this happens alot with bands sorry dude :/
xXVictorViceXx 2 years ago
me can play this on bass, awesome song!!!!
bmxfreak1991 2 years ago
i know this song on drums :D
YouNoob93 2 years ago
at 2:20 phil looks like a wretch from gears of war
Jherrera318 2 years ago
THIS ROCKS
IKILLERK14 2 years ago
lol oli looks like a anglo saxon but he sure can play the guitar
cooper2850 2 years ago
Wow he can sing exactly the same live thats not the same with most metal singers..Except for Lamb of God singer live kicks ass 2
Toadoe7 2 years ago
One of the best songs ever made...
metacircle 2 years ago 33
cant wait seeing them tomorrow!
nick71194 2 years ago
Can't he sing live? ;/
LPDXDX 2 years ago
love this band
lucols3 2 years ago
I want All That Remains Vocal Growling style, his growl is very Big Sound, but my growl is very small sound, Can you tell me a little tip?????
DoYoungJung 2 years ago
Phil shaves his head and I don't think Oli screwed up shit, you need to gets your ears checked.
IGrimReaperI 2 years ago 11
Dude, He is like DEAD fucking on! It's sounds album quality! I can't wait to see these guys Sept 30!
JakexCore666 2 years ago
is it me or do you think oli screwed up all the solos in this concert just my opinion
killingsdeath 2 years ago
Hella beastie ass fuck haha
seby7 2 years ago
not funny. its disrespect to refer to such a godly band as ATR as "hella beastie as fuck" you are a complete moron
ELITExFOCUSx 2 years ago
Did Phil shave his head or is he going bald? Just wondering....he has a steel throaght
tj51942 2 years ago
both
ELITExFOCUSx 2 years ago
amazing!!!! XD
hardcoredd12 2 years ago
Great guitarists. I just started listening to ATR about 3weeks ago and their awesome. It surprised me how well the guitarist are.
Spitatra 2 years ago
fuckin awesome !
HaLfDeAdArtist 2 years ago
A hat hat
Killcows 2 years ago
omfg ROFL at 0:50 -- 0:53 im sorry atr is amazing and all but that made me cry from laughing bc it was so unexpected -- amazing live performance -- omg 1:42 phils dehatted himself prepare for domination +20 adrenaline lol = ) : D
MindsAblaze 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
All that Remains Major Ass!! Whats cool is Phil and Oli are Christians...Awesome!!!
Moshmaniac030 3 years ago
Jason Costa>Chris Adler>Joey Jordisan
anyway ATR is beast
IHateMyStratocaster 3 years ago
check out matt from august burns red..awesome drummer
BurningSword 3 years ago
GREATEST SONG EVER LIVE!
Pelech23 3 years ago
they play awsome live
nilly2007 3 years ago
i like how they play live
trivium i dont like how they play live
bl00dwolf19 3 years ago 3
My favorite All That Remains solo... simply.
I love when Oli starts to solo, he looks like some kind of metal Jesus with a guitar!
FrttMs 3 years ago 4
lmao
he does, and he also reminds of a wizard
hint the name the wiz. very melodic, yea they definetly can give a good live
skinticket2hell 3 years ago
yeah i get what you mean
RemoteAdam 3 years ago
thats because he is dude..lol, i think he is just about the best...some of his compositions are just incredibly beautiful and ball stomping at the same time..his solos are unreal..
BurningSword 3 years ago
that was awesome, I really like the end vocals :P.
Jdith135 3 years ago
i want his voice
geraufc21 3 years ago 3
this song is amazing
the singer is awsome
All That Remains Ruleees....!!
geraufc21 3 years ago 3
Their drummer for this performance played traditional. That's impressive.
Nova45 3 years ago 2
he usually always plays traditional,and he's pretty good but i liked the old drummer cause sometimes this one is way of in timing on some songs.
Kounnas 3 years ago
his drum teacher he had lessons with taught him jazz techniques. Jason was into metal tho so his teacher showed him how to play it with that same jazz technique. my personal opinoin hes almost as good as joey jordison and chris adler
CIRCASKATES 3 years ago
maybe joey jordison,but not even close to chris adler...though i truthfully don't care cause the joey and chris comments on drum videos get really fucking annoying.
Kounnas 3 years ago
They all fucking rule, end of story.
Venom324 3 years ago
and ppl wonder y this is my favorite band...
TheBucketedOne 3 years ago
lol really
greenirishhatsbass 3 years ago
omg....they are so fucking good...great band great song
suplicame 3 years ago 2
This song is amazing... For some reason the first few times I hated it, but after not listening to it for about 2 months I listened to it again and now it is my favorite ATR song
Deppizzymo 3 years ago 3
at first i was like thier a dumb stupid metal band but now after a month i love them so much they are the best!@
greenirishhatsbass 3 years ago
strange how things work out like that... 5 years ago I would never have listened to something like this... Now it's my favorite genre.
Deppizzymo 3 years ago
haha no way me too i used to hate metal so much i thought it was really stupid and it kinds almost scared me lol, now i love it and love jamming out to it on my bass!!! its so cool, sounds like we'r kinda the same, but my fave genre is pop-punk, like blink-182, fall otu boy ( thier older stuff) panic at the disco, takign back sunday, but metal is like my 2nd fave or its tied with pop punk so lol
greenirishhatsbass 3 years ago
Man, same here, since 3 years ago... :-) This is plain and simple - kickass music, which can't leave you indifferent...
Karissimo 3 years ago
So fucking brutal good!
RahmGoteborg 3 years ago 3
yea i picked that dvd up
im seeing them acccouly on the 19th in vancovuer canada
i cant wait
JessiMetalHead 4 years ago 2
" *actually " lol
soadxxseetherrox 4 years ago
I love this song!! Fuck yeah!
MudvayneRocksTLA 4 years ago 4
@11 Th@t R3m@in5 kick @55
i love this fucking songg
Xtremekid101 4 years ago 2
where did you get the dvd?
boltp777 4 years ago
I just went to my local best buy and picked it up man. Im sure you can get it almost any where that has music dvds. They only had like 3 copies on the shelf though.
willis5687 4 years ago