Added: 4 years ago
From: garon604
Views: 381,978
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (412)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Way better than diana's version.. Not that it's hard to vocally outdo diana ross!

  • i love this song by mariah carey i am her biggest fan 4 ever i talk about her everyday

  • Diana Ross simply demonstrates that no amount of vocal acrobatics can replace plain old simple talent. The song is beautiful enough in its simplicity and needed no further grandstanding

  • @warahoun If singers today wold understand. Ross's version is hauntingly beautiful, with a bittersweet tinge that pierces hard through its thorough simplicity.

  • Nice TRY Ms. Mariah, but ain't no way this version stands up to Ms Diana Ross!

  • was that a whistle at the end or mariahs voice?

  • @happyhappylogov45 Yeah, it's Mariah's voice. She sounds like an angel...

  • And I just watched the listened to the JLo version here on youtube and the amount of people saying Jennifer's version is better makes me laugh. These people must be dreaming. Jennifer copied Mariah and tried to sabotage her career. Tommy was in on it as well. All happened from about 1999-2001. Same thing happened with Loverboy and Jennifer stole a sample from her.

  • @jamstrings100 no it was all Tommy...Jennifer did nothing. You should get your facts straight LMAO. And also Mariah's verses were better but parts of jennifer's were better.

  • @harryhermionerone1 Jennifer went along with it. Her version is nowhere near as good as Mariah's, not one bit of it.

  • @jamstrings100 no...in my opinion Mariah's version is very try-hard and in addition JLo's is easier to listen to while the start of this isn't.

  • I love this. Brings back A LOT of memories. Pisses me off JLo tried to redo this song too.

  • that whistle was sounded like the gateways of heaven are now open lol . MARIAH is thee best! DIVA!

  • I love this song but... Mariah tried too damn and it didn't have any emotion like the original Diana did... But I LOVE Jennifer Lopez's version better because I felt she kept it simple & real like Diana Ross' version & feel like she was paying a tribute to her. J. LO did this song PURE JUSTICE!!! Sorry Mariah...

  • @Rubbii411 exactly!!!!!

  • i don't understand why would she be behaving like Celine Whitney etc when she's her own mariah stupid comment. Do u like it if i or anyone else like u to behave like me?? dumb comment

  • This song bring me good memories in late 90's.

  • BEAUTIFUL!! MARIAH Can turn anything she sings into something very special...CRT FOREVER! She can turn anything that she writes into a hit and the best in her own way.

  • This song makes me remeber my mom :') And actually ,she's just far away from here .Love it !And luv ya mom !!! *-*

  • i wonder why Whitney never tried her hand at this song

  • Who would ever think that Jennifer Lopez would do a better version of Diana Ross's song than Mariah Carey. Jennifer's was beautiful and flowing. Mariah tried to hard - tried to do to much to the song. It's a simple, beautiful, melancholy song. Understated but at the same time powerful.

  • jennifer's version is far better!!!!

  • @pascalkiisback: I couldn't believe it....but you are right. Jennifer Lopez version is much better. I like Jennifer and Mariah.

  • she made this like her song , she sings with her version ..

  • That whispery, singing-style she started doing around this time was the official beginning of the end for voice, IMO. This performance is so FLAT, she's going thru the emotions. Yes, she can hit notes and 'blow', but there is no REAL emotion or feeling in her performance. She's a studio singer and nothing more, all flash and substance. I guess that's why her fat, crazy ass is selling JUNK on home shopping channels now. You'd never see Diana, Whitney, Celine or Barbra doing that....

  • @chasenip2 that's her style. Nobody can imitate that :P

  • @chasenip2 hahahah!! ur so f-ing stupid!!LOL any one reidn this can tell ur a hater and wish u where her,LOL!!!! i know u will say ur not but u and i and every one else knows its the truth and that all i will say ,LOL!!!!!!!!!!

  • Esta versión es mejor que la Jenifer López..

  • this girl CAN SING !!!! special ability for sure.....great version.

  • i wish i had this cd

  • what a legs!!!

  • @alwinmj02 yea she got insurence on them for 1 billion dollars!

  • @piscesgirl98  wow!!

  • I too LOVE M.C, but this one is just OK. Love you MC.

  • I LOVE THE WHISTLE AT THE END OF SONG, AMAZING VOICE...!!!

  • @hyugaotq that's no whistle it's her VOICE!!

    

  • @quilloenUSA Yes, it's her whistle VOICE!!! STUPID!!!

  • I love this. She sang it to herself and to the rest of the world. ;)

  • God I wish I could get this on iTunes..

  • @ArchuletaIsMyAngel why can't you?

  • @Da1uLyK I dont think her version is available in America

  • the only thing i like was the whistling at the end.. now tat's cool...

  • MC voice is NOT right for this song FAIL

  • @her09wife ????? please don't lie!

  • @hurtboy83 Truth! I love MC but NOT THIS SONG

  • i dun like the vocal gymnastics done by mariah.. the song lost the feel when she did this... diana's the best.. so much emotion there..

  • @mamat0241 yeah, i like her, but her vocal gymnastics here in this song were a bit too much! and she sacrificed touching emotion by embellishing the vocals.

  • This Is The Best Version... The Only Problem I Have With Mariah's Voice Is That Whisper Sound If She Could Dut That Out Alot And Keep A Little Of The Whisper Sound Her Voice Would Be Perfect.. And The Whisle Note Was Just Absolutly Perfect And With Ease And The End Diana's Version Is A Classic Love Hers Tooo

  • I wish they had included this song in the USA release of #1's instead of shitty ass "Sweetheart".

  • This is a nice version. Mariah added her own urban melody to it ;)

  • I grew up loving MC's music all my life, and she's still over singing/over trilling all her songs. lol Love it, but I prefer J.Lo's version - haha I'm probably the only one that does too.

  • I hate it ,they talk about Ross voice but Mariah what was you trying to do on this song .

  • she has a great voie but i dont like this song, but its still better then JLo's

    i dont hate JLo she sames like down to earth person...but she cant really sing

  • @MyTalkShow1992 JLo's version is just so plain. She made me hate American Idol!

  • @witch26071

    to tell you the truth im a MUCH bigger fan of MC's music like i have all her CD and like "most" of them. Butterfly and Daydream were works of art.

    i didn't really see any album being "a work of art" by JLo but just what i think IMHO, not hatting on Jlo but singing isn't really her thing

    Jlo is more of the actor like Selena was a REALLY good movie so she do got some talent and she can dance well. i thinks its more a different type.

    Mariah = Singer

    Jlo = Actor

  • I think only 2 singers can sing a remake and give it justice or make it even better and those two are Mariah and Celine... I love them both and every cover that I have heard both do are so amazingly done

  • i loved it when diana ross sung it and it make me happy that mariah wants to bring the song back in her own creative version so everyone who says it sucks is just to attached to the diana ross version

    you should appreciate this one because its not exactly the same as hers

  • What's up with the whispering???

  • @PreciousJ05 she doesn't like belting all the time. she think it boring, and she likes doin this. i love it and it's really hard. plus it's he own style hahahaha:)

  • @yosraz1 so does your mother. Christ it feels good too!

  • Imho, Dianas xersion is better than Mariah's. this one not that bad too though.

    Flowers ond greetings from Russia!! :) 

  • I love Mairah's version

  • @shippo481 *mariah

  • Esta foi a música favorita do meu grande Amigo e Mano, de coração, CARLINHOS, filho da Dona Luísa e irmão da Patrícia.

    Que Deus, na eternidade, ilumine sua caminhada, MEU QUERIDO AMIGO!!!

  • Her whistle notes are just... spectacular.

  • I love all Mariah's Songs But this is just awful

  • NOBODY BUT DIANA SHOULD SING THIS. MARIAH IS GREAT BUT YIKES...THIS IS MEANT FOR DIANA

  • i got this on the v-day cd mc put out :))

  • Only one Diana Ross but.... I like Jennifer Lopez's version better then Mariah's !!!

  • Only one Diana Ross but.... I like Jennifer Lopez's version better then Mariah's !!!

  • i love both diana ross and mariah carey versions!!

    thanks so much for uploading!! 

  • nice

    

  • Nice

    

  • Oh Gosh, I really do love this song...

    fur my lovely Tommy out there... hope U listened this and reminds me too...

  • Proof! Nobody can duplicate Diana Ross, so called, tinny, nasly, thin, voice. I've heard Mariah sing Michael Jackson, and Steve Perry(Journey) songs and nail 'em! But Mariah don't know where she going on this song, as much as I like her. She did it no justice.

  • @Rockin2222 it was written exclusively for diana by the great Micheal Masser who's worked with them all and says that diana is the best when she wants to be. Mariah does a nice job but you're right Ross' voice cannot be duplicated and is instantly recognizable the world over.

  • @whatigot2say

    Absolutely right, Diana Ross is amazing with this song.

  • @jsfr71 yes and no one was doing music like that at the time, it was original to her.. black people weren't doing the high european thing on american radio, yet alone films about black women becoming beautiful models & more in Europe it was ground breaking at the time...these singers today just come along and mimic they don't create in the same way that greats like Ross did.

  • @whatigot2say I agree. There is only one Diana Ross. And this is not it!

  • Amazing how a good song can be destroyed in one foul swoop.

  • I think this one was recorded at her worst vocal era,but I love the "real" in her record,all the breathe and hoarse,...it's kinda emotional to me. I'm so obsessed with her voice. LOL

  • this is best song n my favorite all time!

  • a lifelong sore throat

  • with out a doubt dianna ross version its better!

  • @predatorstriker of course it is.. don't forget it was written for her voice and she still owns it. (diana)

  • the best jlos sucks

  • my first time hearing dis its brilliantly done 

  • i like mariah version...

  • NO MA'AM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

  • @hilljayne you let her have it! LOL

  • never herd this before and im a big fan. when was this recored anyone know????? to me it sounds like it was around 1997-1999

  • @MyTalkShow1992 It's written on the video's description.

  • @rudyzeinoun ohhh sorry lol my bad

  • @MyTalkShow1992 1997

  • @MyTalkShow1992 1998 exactly. it was released as a bonus on european versions of #1's and rainbow and on the french version of the heartbreaker single

  • j.lo's version is better.. Mariah should try harder for this ong

  • beautiful...job well done mariah !

  • she sings like an angel <3 

  • I love this version better than all of them.. MC <3 the greatest .

  • yeah j lo's sucks rotten ass hole with a booty yeast infection

  • I like the ending, but........

    It is too much like Diana's version, so I have to give it a thumbs down

    The best covers take the original and give it a new perspective that is refreshing and novel

    I was expecting a group of background singers to add to the final verse, to add volume and depth.

    I think it could've used a cresendo, or some more depth.

    Good cover, but was missing that uumph.

    A little more production and a fuller sound would go a long way here

  • J-Lo SUCKS OUT LOUD!

    LOL!

    I think she sung it out of that HUGE ASS!

  • What a beautiful Whistle. I need to hard Diana's version. And I am afraid to hear JLO LOOL

  • all these 'Renditions' SUCK! the original is just fine without all these drawn our notes n words... Do you nooOOoooOOooo wheeeRRE

  • @stephen101ful haha(: i have to agree with you !

  • I have said this before on many of Mariah and Celine Covers of classic songs.. the reason their level of song reaches the ranks of the original is because they somehow make the song sound like it was written for them as an original,..and That is what a true musical artist is... someone who can take any song and make it their own... I love this version and Diana's EQUALLY

  • yes i know that you are not near the queen diana

  • overrated diva ever.....will never live be in the same shoes as Diana Ross

  • this isn't very good at all... it lacks the exquisite phrasing of diana ross. Carey sounds like she has food in her mouth when she's singing.

  • It was karaoke in the beginning and bad karaoke at that...toward the end though Mariah put her own stamp on it, especially the whistle register part.

  • I love Diana's version, and this is a great cover and tribute to her.

  • Such a wonderful voice

  • Mariahs version is all the way the BEST !

    her voice is so pure, powerfull and angelic!! she puts so much feelings in this song she is so emotional

    I love her

  • a hopless feeling song, It´s a little sad but beautiful

  • Comment removed

  • I love Mariah, but Diana Ross' version of this song will never be outdone - never!

  • the only one who deserves to sing diana ross :-) jlo suckx by the way :/

  • Actually I like this version the best

  • Mariah , so near and yet so far from Diana....

  • @lincoln1960 Brilliant comment! So true, so true.

  • this version is hella good. love the whistle at the end.. diana's is classic though..

    jlo's FAILS BADLY ..hear the songs together..jlo's sucks really bad.

  • @diego2ever : thats not a whistle....that's MC's high note LOL.

  • @HnHBlkM thats what they meant lmao

  • @diego2ever Jlo isn't a singer!!!!

  • @diego2ever It wasn't a whistle at the end, it was her singing in a VERY HIGH picthced voice!!! I thought it was a whistle aswell. Look at her live video on the results beside>>>>>>

    At the end she sings it

  • @circusm139 she lipsynchs in that video so it's irrelevant as it's the same version ;)

  • I agree 100%

  • I can almost hear Simon Cal. Yikes.

  • Sorry Mariah, I am not obsessed with your performance :-)

  • I used to listen to this song and sing it all the TIME. it's soo peaceful. I think the whistle note at the end was a nice finishing touch. She made this version her own style with the whistle note. Beautiful. =)

  • . . . This is alright. However, not the best song choice for her.

    Like they say, "Nothing beats the original". ;-)

  • I've been trying to find a copy of this, and had never heard it. It's good, but she can't compare to Diana's.

  • Awful, can not be compared with the interpretation of Diana Ross

  • The JLo's version is better!! 100% better than this.

  • jlo's voice is weak has no strength. Diana and mariah pwn her in vocals.

  • besides

    mariah did a good job on this remade of diana ross's hit song

  • @Yuli2470 no the J-Lo version is not better get it right and clean your ears!!!!!

  • don't compare j.lo to a legend !

  • and that totally rendered you unable to understand her point. O.o what a jerk

  • This song requires a melodic tone that can caress the lyrics.... That's why NO ONE comes close to the original version.

  • I love this song. I also love this pic. People are always saying this pic is photoshopped and that they streched her legs. Makes me always lol about these stupid jealous people.

  • Pff, either the world is stupid, or you're blind. Obviously it's Photoshopped, like every single album cover out there (not just Mariah's). Take a look at the cover for her latest album Memoirs... they Photoshopped her body (or bodies), but apparently forgot to "slim down" the shadows! Haha!

  • she gained since that pic but she always pretty i like the way sings

  • Comment removed

  • who is Lara Fabian? LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • what ?

    have a look on youtube u'll see

  • No. Here's the thing. J.Lo's version is produced better. The instruments are complimenting J.Lo's voice. With Mariah's version the emphasis is on vocal performance. Did anyone notice that she used all of her vocal range on this performance? In the first verse she goes down to her baritone level, and as the song is ending she is in her whistle register. That's hot! Like 1% of the singers out right now can do that. The production of the song is the weak point.

  • There's a better version out there. ;)

  • @danihobinsen

    I'm guessing plenty, actually.

  • i am sure ms. carey would disagree with you all and tell you to u all to go fuck yourselves.

  • JLo's version is better, but Mariah is obviously the better singer.

  • This version is just ok. But what makes Diana's version so special besides being the first. You can actually close your eyes and see the story she's telling. It even makes you think back about a moment or time in your life when this song may have been relavent to you. This one just doesn't do that for me. You don't do vocal styling with this song. You just let go and sing.

  • Diana Ross got an Academy Award nomination for her original version of this #1 song.

  • okay, i just listened to the jennifer lopez version and said to myself, diana ross probably sang this better. then i heard diana's version and said, ehhhh, mariah carey probably killed it. then i come on here. and i say its such a disappointment. she couldve recorded a better production.

  • SHE KILLED IT.

  • I love me some Mariah, but this rates a zero . . . very poor vocal performance by Mariah. Diana's original simply leaves this version in the dust.

  • gloomyoutlook I totally agree with what you said. She is one of my favorite singers and I feel she cud have sang this song alot better

  • mariah is just the best of the best really that is all i can say :D

  • Probably the weakest song she's ever recorded. Production-wise, I think it's on par with karaoke, and vocally far below her usual high standard. 1998 wasn't a great year for her vocally, but this just sounds like she cut it after one take and thought "fuck it, that'll do."

    You'll also notice that, being a diehard fanboi, I still make the effort to listen to and comment on it, lol.

  • @gloomyoutlook i agree...and im a huge fan of mariahs...and this just seems...idk out of place for her a bit..like shes a musical genius, so like i dont expect any less from her, but i think its just the time she was in, like struggles and such, her voice was dare i say, bad lol

  • totally

  • Many try to sing this song and most do a credible job, however, none does it like the BOSS. None can compare to Diana Ross. This is her song, and always will be. I applaud thos that try to emulate it, but most fall short....Long live the Boss...Miss Ross

  • I like Diana's version way better but this is cool.

  • no one's sings like mariah...her's in the best as usual...she is the queen of any song..her vocal range and style surpasses the rest. her whistle absolutely amazing....

  • I also prefer Diana's version of course ;)

  • j.lo's version is better?. hahahaha, first when you compare two singers versions, you need the two of them sing and the last time I checked only Mariah was the singer, now whoever picks a mic is called a singer, for god's sake. Of course Mariah's version is better, and the end with the whistle instead of the violins in the original sounded beautiful. Mariah all the freaking way. J.lo is not a singer, she tries but she fails though I like her as an actress

  • i don;t think so, maybe you are just plain stupid or deaf.

  • crissy jb couldnt gree with you more !

  • I love this song, And I LOVE Mariah's version the best.

  • Diana Ross and the Supremes,the best version ever.............

  • Hey GliUL TIMItemplari, The Supremes never sang this song. This is a Diana Ross solo classic...

  • Errata Corrige:Diana Ross from "The Supremes" i mean......!