@KidNCState Rorschach shines the light on the dog after the guy says that he has no evidence. He's saying that he knows the guy fed the little girl to his dogs, and the dogs are the evidence.
Rorschach doesn't have powers but uses brutality which is just like the punisher, only he's not avenging his family he just sees the scum of the world for what they are and does them in. He's still cool though. Bad ass vigilante.
Finally, someone who doesn't blame everything on God and leaves religion just because they're too weak to accept that there is suffering in this world.
When "bad superhero" meets evil...the boiling point. Rorschach meets what might be the ultimate evil; unrepentant, murdering child rapist...in the entire movie, this is the most emotionally vulnerable we see Rorschach while he's wearing the mask...he's fighting back tears, and he gives into his rage to fight this evil...That man scarred him, and took away more than that girl. Rorschach seeing that girl's remains was like Batman of Earth-52 seeing Jason Todd dead...shattering.
In the comic he hand cuffs the guy, lights the house on fire then leaves the cleaver for him to try and escape. He never got out. This scene is just as good
The kidnapper here is probably the dumbest criminal ever. Why? He confesses to the crime in front of a violent masked vigilante who just killed his dogs then threw their carcasses on him and also is clearly barely stopping himself from straight up murdering the guy's sorry ass, and the guy expects said vigilante to just arrest him.
@CarlMinez Yeah because liking a movie makes you braindead. It's a fucking movie, get over it. Let people like what they want, no one forced you to watch a video of a movie for "braindead nerds" that you obviously dislike. Seriously what's the point?
and then i found some dogs and then i picked the dogs up and then i put the dogs down dogs get put down i said as i put the dogs down then i ran away because you have to be careful still i put them firmly down on the ground where dogs belong
@fsffsa5325324= One version of the script had him beating him up, shoving raw meat down his throat, pouring blood on him, and then sicking the dogs on him. The dogs tear him apart. Then Rorscach kills the dogs. I didn't make that up. I'm not that creative.
whoever said it was morally wrong to kill those 2 dogs is an idiot.....the dogs were clearly raised to be vicious and would only be a danger to society.....like anyone is gonna adopt a dog that was raised by a murderous rapist.....in any case this scene is awesome and is exactly what should happen to that guy who dismembered that little boy recently
I agree to everything he said about god, destiny, etc.... Rorcharch, iz a bad-azz character, if vigilantes like him really existed, there be less murders, rapes, especially crooked FUCCN COPS thats for sure
too damn right! there are pics of her partying not 2 days after her daughter's murder, she took the little girl from home and never came back with her.
Alan Moore is pissed off because he's a miserable old hippy who writes internet grade slash fiction about other peoples character creations. He hasn't written anything worth shit since TBOHJ and the lazy old fart couldn't even finish that. Frankly the only reason he isn't the most over rated waste of fucking space in comics is because of that coked up little jock bitch Grant Morrisson. Neither of them are are worth dick compared to guys like Pat Mills, Alan Grant and John Wagner.
More superhero's should be like roarshach. I mean if superman found a child killer he would punch him once or twice and take him to jail. But roarshach doesnt even give the murderer a chance and kills him on the spot. Superman should be ashamed.
@connor011098 The Punisher does the same thing. Except he kills his victims in a worse and painful death. If only there is one badass Punisher movie that would be great.
@connor011098 That's what the police do in the Phillipines. Kidnapping cases are handled with extreme prejudice. Suspects are shot on sight if circumstantial evidence is blatant enough.
I think the reason why the novel was so brilliant and the movie was just average is simply that there are very few good comic books (the ones you see on some tip lists are always the same ones - moores, millers, gaimans - that's just about it), while there are plenty of awfully good movies. i mean, you simply can't make a better superhero movie than the dark knight.
Plus, alan moore is right when he says they used stylistic devices (sorry for my school english) in the novel that can only be us
Ahh...perfect social comment on how murdering creatures do what they do because they know the "Liberal Elite" look kindly on them and give them light sentences. But what if the justice system was overhauled and psychos got a "Let the Punishment Fit the Crime" system? Would they still be so eager to go around murdering innocent people knowing that they'd get exactly what they hand out if they're caught?
They can't help but commit these crimes, in a society where the derranged are outcasted, and seen as a social stigma. It's not their fault, they're, in a sense, wired that way; from their birth and upbringing, their perception of the world is drastically different from yours. They don't see the consiquences, they don't see other peoples emotions, or experiences, it's their uncontrolable, primal urge, and no punishment will deter that.
@sovietlemon so its societies fault? that makes no sense so your saying i'm responsible for a freak killing people, that everybody who lives their lives innocently never hurting anybody are the true antagonists, biggest joke i've ever heard
Yes, it's completely societies fault. And no, you yourself are not society, you are simply a feeble gear in the machine. They perceive everything differently, they probably don't realise what they're doing, let alone the moral condemnations it holds, if you outcast them, and aim to punish them, then all you do is create a society that breeds homicide. But, if you care for them, teach them of others, treat them as a person, then they will realise what they are doing.
This scene gives me chills, both in the movie and novel. "Men get arrested, dogs get put down." I love Rorschach because, despite his sociopathic tendencies, still has a clear and unrelenting view of morality. And in that there's an inherent logic.
Of course, there's no sense comparing the movie to the novel. The movie had its hits and misses but the novel was pure and unrelenting brilliance from front to back.
Obviously Rorschach's concept of moral is that of a psychopath seeing as he kills innocent animals. Men get arrested - dogs get put down? That sentence makes me wanna puke.
@CarlMinez He killed them to frighten the man even more plus as a distraction. "Men get arrested. Dogs get put down" means that this man is no longer a human and shouldn't be treated as one. Brilliant line.
@CarlMinez *facepalm* just shut the fuck up. It's an awesome movie and graphic novel. There's no deep meaning in killing the dogs besides a distraction/scare tactic. Honestly, if you don't like this scene... why are you here? So stop BITCHING and let everyone else (besides you) enjoy this awesome scene.
If you think for a second that it bothers me that I my "bitching" is stopping you or everyone else to enjoy this scene, you couldn't be more wrong. That's the reason I came here in the first place.
Now if you enjoy this mediocre Hollywood blockbuster, go enjoy it in peace, nobody is forcing you to argue with me. You obviously can't grasp the moral issues I'm speaking of anyway.
@CarlMinez what makes watchmen so unique, is that it's characters aren't extremists on perfection and madness, as to say, superman, who has a steel moral no matter the situation, and joker, who loves chaos just for the sake of it. watchmen characters are normal people. yeah, he killed those dogs, maybe cuz he hated them for eating the girls body, maybe to frighten the guy. the point of this is, i bet you know somebody who would kill a dog if his moral told him that i was the right thing to do.
What makes watchman unique? Give me a break. If you want a deep movie, watch Citizen Kane, Metropolis or Stalker. This is just a braindead action movie for braindead nerds who are too stupid to know the difference between moral philosophy and mindless killing.
But that's not what bothers me about this scene. What bothers me is that the main character is a sociopath and being glorified in the film for being one. And the fact that he murders two pets for no reason.
@CarlMinez what makes watchmen so unique, is that it's characters aren't extremists on perfection and madness, as to say, superman, who has a steel moral no matter the situation, and joker, who loves chaos just for the sake of it. watchmen characters are normal people. yeah, he killed those dogs, maybe cuz he hated them for eating the girls body, maybe to frighten the guy. the point of this is, i bet you know somebody who would kill a dog if his moral told him that it was the right thing to do.
they weren't innocent, they were cannibalistic. Once an animal tastes human meat, it wants more. That's why cannibalistic tigers, lions etc are always hunted and killed.
Where the hell did you read that? Cannibalism is the act of humans eating a member of their own species. How on earth can a dog be cannibalistic? Dogs, to the best of my knowledge, aren't humans.
Furthermore, the scene was cruel. The dogs had done nothing to deserve that treatment. They are being depicted in the movie as expandable objects with no value, that the hero can basically kill just to frighten another human being.
there was pretty much no reason for this scene to be like this. zach snyder needs to grow up and get over his penchant for really stupid and over-the-top gratuitous violence.
"This world is not shaped by vague Metaphysical forces. It wasn't God that killed the little girl. Wasn't fate that butchered her or destiny that fed her to the dogs. It's us. Only us."
best punishment for a child rapist is to shrink the guy to size of cockroach and throw him to a mantis.give a helmet and neck guard so that the mantis cannot bite his head /neck and kill him quick. the mantis will eat him feet first.
I'm sorry, but the way they id this scene in the movie kind of ruins the entire point of the Rorschach character. In the comic everyone thinks he's a nut, but in reality he isn't. This scene makes him look like a psychopath when HE ISN'T. Not to mention what he does to the guy in the book is more badass and makes him have so much more depth as a character.
Roarshach was wrong about one thing. Creatures like that "thing" aren't dogs, they're shit to be flushed down the bog (toilet). So should be the end of all shit like that creature, nice and painfully. And yes, they are really out there.
Rorschah ain't no hero for instance he never kills corrupt billionaires or rogue mafia cops he sets double standards for different criminals (a bit like Punisher who also protects rogue cops) so they're not even anti-heros, they're closer to villains with a bit of anti-hero in them
@schwarzfalk Rorschach's demented ideology is what makes him a sour version of a hero.
The 1st problem is that he judges people either two ways: good or evil. The issue there is that he denies the grey area b/w them, which can exist (Ex. People can do bad things w/o being labeled "evil").
The 2nd problem is that he "forces" (mild fascism) his view of justice onto others while denying their (criminals') right to trial. I like Rorschach but his ideology is dangerous for the masses.
One of my favorite lines in history. Rorschach's "Dogs get put down" is up there with the Bible's "I am Legion", and the president's speech in Independence Day.
I think they edited the scene to rorscach killing the guy with a axe instead of burning him is because when "walter kovacs closed his eyes then. it was rorscach who opened them" is mentioned in the book when he kills the dogs, so, instead of the whole "transformation" concept, they decided to make it more personal do it with the man, and it made more sense then burning him.
I wonder how the comedian would have reacted to this situation. Or would killing a helpless girl and feeding her to the dogs still just be apart of the "big joke."
@EmperorofCartoons I’m just saying the Comedian has a very cynical view of human nature and he thinks he’s seen the worst of human behaviour, and he prides himself on this acknowledgement; the fact that very few would permit themselves such a understanding but he DOES allow it and he doesn’t care. But we’ve come to see that even Blake had limits. He breaks down after discovering the magnitude of Veidt’s plan. So I was just wondering if Blake would have simply scoffed at Rorschach’s discovery.
@mugatu5000 This IS the genesis of Rorschach and it pretty much overwhelmed him, so I’m just wondering if Blake would have still kept his head. Would this not appear in Blake's "top ten list of the worst human atrocities he's seen"?
This movie only did so poorly because people can't understand it. People are idiots, they don't see masterpieces. Of course Alan Moore is going to be pissed off though, no creator likes others to adapt their brilliance. I will agree the comic was better but this film deserves more recognition than a simpleton society can give.
@ReDhAvEn1993 IMO this movie did so poorly because of its god awful soundtrack which never failed to take whatever was happening on screen and pissing all over it
@depressio117 umm.....don't talk about this like you have even the slightest idea what you're talking about.......you're obviously belligerently inept.....if you're not being sarcastic.......fucking idiot
@killa420herb Rorschach dies to "sound of silence" by simon and garfunkle, a ludicrously long sex scene to "hallelujah" by Cohen, and MCR covers "desolation row" for the credits. I know it's just my opinion, but soundtrack dissonance can be used in a movie only so many times before it gets old and stops making sense. it worked with Nat King Cole's "Unforgettable," I'm your boogie man" and "times they are a changing", but by the end I just wished Snyder would stop
@ReDhAvEn1993 The movie did not do poorly. I have no idea where you even got that idea from. The movie was #1 for a long ass time and made $55,214,334 in the opening weekend. No movie had higher results than it did that year. It was a great movie and it also did great. The only bad thing about this movie is that we saw too much ballsack.
@blacktee31 Well plenty of people saw it but most didn't enjoy it, which i can't understand. There really was only like two scenes where you could see Dr. Manhattan's junk unless you were intentionally searching for it. (That is not an attack at you for pointing that out lol, I just mean in general.)
@ReDhAvEn1993 I can understand that, but I haven't met anybody that didn't like it. And I'm sure there were more than just two scenes and even just two is too much for me. There was a good bit of times where his balls caught me off guard.
@MansoorDorp Hmmm....I have no more time for this...you are obviously illiterate..plus you need to wash your mouth out.....ahh but I digress..if you care to waste your time and continue arguing me reply would be a rebuttal, and to your next axiomatic putrid reply I would pronounce a rebuttal as well. No run, run away pet run! Go barricade yourself in your fortress of ignorance.
@ReDhAvEn1993 Holier than thou? Funny considering you're defending this watered down over hyped glitz and spectacle over interlect version of the Watchmen, have you ever read a fucking comic in your entire measly life?
@MansoorDorp Yeah I read plenty of comic books....Actually I read the Watchmen comic well before the film. Please stop fighting on youtube and go get a life.
@ReDhAvEn1993 Indeed. For those who didn't read the graphic novel, the movie is confusing. I love this movie because I've read the graphic novel and they did an excellent job at adapting it.
The sick part is that mother fucker's like the murder do this stuff and just get a few decades in prison. I wish that there were more people like Rorscach, people who have the balls to give these sick fucker's what they deserve.
@mrtoontown Not really. A world where people can just walk into a persons house and break their necks while they're eating dinner with the family, just because they believe that their a murderer isn't my idea of Justice. What if they were innocent? (This is coming from a Rorscach fan.)
@codafett My first point still stands- sick bastards like the murderer do horrid things then get only a few decades in prison or get put to death. A few decades in prison- Not remotely bad as it used to be- compared to the old days, it's fucking easy-mode (had a uncle who was in prison for embezzeling). Put to death- In some cases I feel that it's too quick and painless an end.
You may not agree with me, but I can't blame ya. We live in a society where violence and murder are wholly wrong.
@superspartan11 And yet, the critics and audiences absolutely HATED this film. Even the author of the comic book, Alan Moore completely DISOWNED this film and continues to badmouth it to this day. Kick-Ass was 10,000 times better than Watchmen.
I can't watch this scene without laughing about that Saturday Morning cartoon intro of the Watchmen spoof someone did where they showed the exact opposite of the movie as a joke and showed Rorschach juggling pies and petting two german shepards being "a friend to the animals". Still great scene. Jackie Earl Haley's awesome. He's great in this role and even did an okay job as Freddy (Robert's the REAL Freddy of course but Haley at least was better than the idea of Thornton) given the awful script
Dear God, just wow, I mean I know it's just a movie/novel, but wow, how could someone do that to a little girl. Rorschach's right though, we do make the world as it is, and it's up to us to try to make it better, undo the wrongs, if it's not too late already.
okay, was the dogs skull supposed to look like a vagina signifying that he raped the little girl??
KidNCState 1 week ago
@KidNCState ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!!!
carch117 5 days ago
@carch117 well what does it mean then?
KidNCState 3 days ago
@KidNCState Rorschach shines the light on the dog after the guy says that he has no evidence. He's saying that he knows the guy fed the little girl to his dogs, and the dogs are the evidence.
carch117 3 days ago
@carch117 oh okay! thanks a lot bro
KidNCState 3 days ago
Rorschach doesn't have powers but uses brutality which is just like the punisher, only he's not avenging his family he just sees the scum of the world for what they are and does them in. He's still cool though. Bad ass vigilante.
rhombusskullvsteal 1 week ago
u want to know about Rorschach? ......hmmm no thanks
racuz8 1 week ago
Finally, someone who doesn't blame everything on God and leaves religion just because they're too weak to accept that there is suffering in this world.
freghorn 2 weeks ago
"Rorschach's friends to the animals"
skillcosby88 2 weeks ago
This is when Rorschach snaps.
tj11112222 2 weeks ago
When "bad superhero" meets evil...the boiling point. Rorschach meets what might be the ultimate evil; unrepentant, murdering child rapist...in the entire movie, this is the most emotionally vulnerable we see Rorschach while he's wearing the mask...he's fighting back tears, and he gives into his rage to fight this evil...That man scarred him, and took away more than that girl. Rorschach seeing that girl's remains was like Batman of Earth-52 seeing Jason Todd dead...shattering.
DominicBacidore 2 weeks ago
In the comic he hand cuffs the guy, lights the house on fire then leaves the cleaver for him to try and escape. He never got out. This scene is just as good
fatabe1 3 weeks ago
Best superhero ever
Fawksau 3 weeks ago 2
The kidnapper here is probably the dumbest criminal ever. Why? He confesses to the crime in front of a violent masked vigilante who just killed his dogs then threw their carcasses on him and also is clearly barely stopping himself from straight up murdering the guy's sorry ass, and the guy expects said vigilante to just arrest him.
1337ijs 4 weeks ago
We are alone. There is nothing else.
Das2140 1 month ago
@Das2140 key word. We. Get a few friends and dont let nihilism kill you or ruin your soul
dchris1990 1 week ago
@dchris1990 Oh god. No, it was quote from the Watchmen (The Novel), which was depicted during this scene.
Das2140 1 week ago
@Das2140 lol sorry! Its been along time since i've read the novel
dchris1990 1 week ago
@CarlMinez Yeah because liking a movie makes you braindead. It's a fucking movie, get over it. Let people like what they want, no one forced you to watch a video of a movie for "braindead nerds" that you obviously dislike. Seriously what's the point?
Mills997 1 month ago
Guy fucking deserved it aick bastard.
spartin2590 2 months ago
I love how when Rorschach kills the guy his mask starts moving really fast, like it responds to his emotion.
MLGKFC 2 months ago 6
When you see the dogs chewing the foot its awful.
TranquilBlossom 2 months ago
What happened to the dog Rorschach was pointing at?
JohnSheepard 2 months ago
@JohnSheepard Rorschach killed them.
MLGKFC 2 months ago
Like this if you thought 0.34 looked like "an inspector calls"
MichelangeloSnowGlob 2 months ago
When i watched this, i was getting more and more angry with that sick m*****f***er. Like this if you are against child murder.
MichelangeloSnowGlob 2 months ago 4
"I was young, then. Too soft on criminals. I let them live."
TheRealThreeP 3 months ago 3
fucker got what he deserved
Spystreak 3 months ago
and then i found some dogs and then i picked the dogs up and then i put the dogs down dogs get put down i said as i put the dogs down then i ran away because you have to be careful still i put them firmly down on the ground where dogs belong
tayloremersongibbons 3 months ago
@tayloremersongibbons I ROFL'd when i read this :D
MichelangeloSnowGlob 2 months ago
"Too soft" ....U_U yes..indeed <3
Aneuecinema 3 months ago
that is one badass ginger. lol
IraqiDude321 3 months ago
I wish he had burned the guy alive like him did in the book.
fsffsa5325324 4 months ago 2
@fsffsa5325324= One version of the script had him beating him up, shoving raw meat down his throat, pouring blood on him, and then sicking the dogs on him. The dogs tear him apart. Then Rorscach kills the dogs. I didn't make that up. I'm not that creative.
vigo894 4 months ago 2
I liked the original where Rorschach handcuffs him to the stove to be honest.
kyoukan102 5 months ago
to quick he should of chopped his arms and legs of
TriopsUKnorth 5 months ago
@TriopsUKnorth
That reminds me of Sin City
watch?v=wySIejGK_DY
srbrunoaf 3 months ago
In the original version he hand cuffs the guys arm to the stove and throws him a hacksaw.... then set the house on fire without a word
much more bad ass but not as impacting
anonfromebaumsworld 5 months ago 26
@anonfromebaumsworld Do you have the source that mentions that version, I would love to read it?
TwilightLegend3 2 months ago
@TwilightLegend3
The original book
anonfromebaumsworld 2 months ago
@anonfromebaumsworld Much more impactfull.
Rorschach just standing across the road watching the house burn is alot more chilling.
kildare97 1 month ago
YEAH THIS IS HOW SHIT GETS DONE IN AMERICA!
MrShadowgw 6 months ago
he needs to be on criminal minds, rorschach
RFEM520 6 months ago
7 pedophiles watched this video.
pic74 6 months ago
"broke a man's arm to get a tip"
That's how things should be done
TerminalCriticism 7 months ago 4
imma be honest this movie us better than The Dark Knight
stonersrule100 7 months ago
Liked this scene, pure Rorschach. But I still loved the graphic novels version of this scene way better, reminds me of Saw.
CaptainGrue 7 months ago 4
That sentence reminds me of Norway.
Put him down!
TDGRoach 7 months ago
His clear agony over the girls death and his hatred for that man is so sad to watch. He just snapped, and fully embodied the mask after that.
Crazie982467 7 months ago 3
@Crazie982467 Yea... a really powerful scene...
ForgotteMemories101 6 months ago
I read a sad little comic based on this.
So the master was feeding his dogs humans, I'm guessing?
TDLBallistic 8 months ago
whoever said it was morally wrong to kill those 2 dogs is an idiot.....the dogs were clearly raised to be vicious and would only be a danger to society.....like anyone is gonna adopt a dog that was raised by a murderous rapist.....in any case this scene is awesome and is exactly what should happen to that guy who dismembered that little boy recently
johnqpublic912 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This film was very good in the CG and characters but you had to pay attention to it to understand the plot. Otherwise you's get lost.
SpykeeGamer 8 months ago
lol HarryPartridge spoof
TheFabricOfTime 8 months ago
I agree to everything he said about god, destiny, etc.... Rorcharch, iz a bad-azz character, if vigilantes like him really existed, there be less murders, rapes, especially crooked FUCCN COPS thats for sure
doeboyelsancho 8 months ago
@doeboyelsancho
actualy its political system thats fked up... the people in power are crooked mass murders and rapist theselves.
cops are just pupets, they risk thier life to capture criminals so that they could be release if they had money
Taobaak0 8 months ago
The Casey Anthony Verdict is proof the justice system doesn't work. We need Rorschach!
Morningstar922 8 months ago
@Morningstar922
too damn right! there are pics of her partying not 2 days after her daughter's murder, she took the little girl from home and never came back with her.
some good old Roschach justice IS what is needed
Mikeybetts 8 months ago
Alan Moore is pissed off because he's a miserable old hippy who writes internet grade slash fiction about other peoples character creations. He hasn't written anything worth shit since TBOHJ and the lazy old fart couldn't even finish that. Frankly the only reason he isn't the most over rated waste of fucking space in comics is because of that coked up little jock bitch Grant Morrisson. Neither of them are are worth dick compared to guys like Pat Mills, Alan Grant and John Wagner.
Silkie341 8 months ago
More superhero's should be like roarshach. I mean if superman found a child killer he would punch him once or twice and take him to jail. But roarshach doesnt even give the murderer a chance and kills him on the spot. Superman should be ashamed.
connor011098 8 months ago 25
@connor011098 The Punisher does the same thing. Except he kills his victims in a worse and painful death. If only there is one badass Punisher movie that would be great.
gamefreak1000000 3 months ago
@connor011098 roarshach has more of a batman feel to him, but if he actually killed criminals, I want to watch this movie when I get a chance. :)
IraqiDude321 3 months ago
@connor011098 congratulations on missing the entire point of watchmen
pyro80 1 month ago
@connor011098 That's what the police do in the Phillipines. Kidnapping cases are handled with extreme prejudice. Suspects are shot on sight if circumstantial evidence is blatant enough.
N0hN4me 1 month ago
I think the reason why the novel was so brilliant and the movie was just average is simply that there are very few good comic books (the ones you see on some tip lists are always the same ones - moores, millers, gaimans - that's just about it), while there are plenty of awfully good movies. i mean, you simply can't make a better superhero movie than the dark knight.
Plus, alan moore is right when he says they used stylistic devices (sorry for my school english) in the novel that can only be us
unterkiefermann 8 months ago
Am I the only one bothered by the fact the the two innocent dogs got fucking killed?
Are we supposed to sympathize with that psychopath Rorschach? I certainly hope not.
"Men get arrested. Dogs get put down."
Stupid quote. It implies that moral cannot be applied to dogs and that men are morally superior. All empirical evidence proves otherwise.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
Ahh...perfect social comment on how murdering creatures do what they do because they know the "Liberal Elite" look kindly on them and give them light sentences. But what if the justice system was overhauled and psychos got a "Let the Punishment Fit the Crime" system? Would they still be so eager to go around murdering innocent people knowing that they'd get exactly what they hand out if they're caught?
Bubo25 11 months ago
@Bubo25 quite agreed seems laws and constituions matter more then our children
BESERKER09 10 months ago
@BESERKER09 The U.S. has a Dirty Harry legal system compared to the U.K.
Bubo25 10 months ago
You seem to think criminals have a choice.
They can't help but commit these crimes, in a society where the derranged are outcasted, and seen as a social stigma. It's not their fault, they're, in a sense, wired that way; from their birth and upbringing, their perception of the world is drastically different from yours. They don't see the consiquences, they don't see other peoples emotions, or experiences, it's their uncontrolable, primal urge, and no punishment will deter that.
sovietlemon 10 months ago
@sovietlemon so its societies fault? that makes no sense so your saying i'm responsible for a freak killing people, that everybody who lives their lives innocently never hurting anybody are the true antagonists, biggest joke i've ever heard
JORDANBAUMER 9 months ago
Yes, it's completely societies fault. And no, you yourself are not society, you are simply a feeble gear in the machine. They perceive everything differently, they probably don't realise what they're doing, let alone the moral condemnations it holds, if you outcast them, and aim to punish them, then all you do is create a society that breeds homicide. But, if you care for them, teach them of others, treat them as a person, then they will realise what they are doing.
sovietlemon 9 months ago
@Bubo25
No, because they are antisocially disordered people with severe psychosis who, to some point, cannot always be held responsible for their actions.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
Ah the world needs a Rorshach, some one who will you say to criminals "Yea you have a problem, your a fucked up person." followed by death.
PacoTheMuffinman 11 months ago
@PacoTheMuffinman
That's amongst the most stupid shit I've seen all week.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
poor dogs =(
rayrhinohair 11 months ago 4
@rayrhinohair
Finally!
CarlMinez 8 months ago
Justice.
whowantsabighug 11 months ago
wasn't a similar scene in a Batman novel... when the Joker, or Jester, who was once c alled the "Red Hood"...
airrunweskeriv 11 months ago
MAN GET ARRESTED, DOGS MUST GET PUT DOWN!
NortonBSFG 11 months ago
@NortonBSFG
Should be the other way around.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
@ReconReda Yeah that's true.... Background information is helpful.
ReDhAvEn1993 11 months ago 2
This scene gives me chills, both in the movie and novel. "Men get arrested, dogs get put down." I love Rorschach because, despite his sociopathic tendencies, still has a clear and unrelenting view of morality. And in that there's an inherent logic.
Of course, there's no sense comparing the movie to the novel. The movie had its hits and misses but the novel was pure and unrelenting brilliance from front to back.
forgeforth 11 months ago
@forgeforth
Obviously Rorschach's concept of moral is that of a psychopath seeing as he kills innocent animals. Men get arrested - dogs get put down? That sentence makes me wanna puke.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
@CarlMinez He killed them to frighten the man even more plus as a distraction. "Men get arrested. Dogs get put down" means that this man is no longer a human and shouldn't be treated as one. Brilliant line.
Str0ngSide 8 months ago
@Str0ngSide
Thats fucking stupid of two reasons. Firstly, why kill two innocent dogs just to frighten someone? The dogs have no part in this.
Secondly, are you saying that humans have some sort of superior higher morality? That sounds like speciesism to me.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
@CarlMinez *facepalm* just shut the fuck up. It's an awesome movie and graphic novel. There's no deep meaning in killing the dogs besides a distraction/scare tactic. Honestly, if you don't like this scene... why are you here? So stop BITCHING and let everyone else (besides you) enjoy this awesome scene.
Str0ngSide 8 months ago
@Str0ngSide
If you think for a second that it bothers me that I my "bitching" is stopping you or everyone else to enjoy this scene, you couldn't be more wrong. That's the reason I came here in the first place.
Now if you enjoy this mediocre Hollywood blockbuster, go enjoy it in peace, nobody is forcing you to argue with me. You obviously can't grasp the moral issues I'm speaking of anyway.
CarlMinez 8 months ago
@CarlMinez what makes watchmen so unique, is that it's characters aren't extremists on perfection and madness, as to say, superman, who has a steel moral no matter the situation, and joker, who loves chaos just for the sake of it. watchmen characters are normal people. yeah, he killed those dogs, maybe cuz he hated them for eating the girls body, maybe to frighten the guy. the point of this is, i bet you know somebody who would kill a dog if his moral told him that i was the right thing to do.
oliver170 8 months ago
Comment removed
CarlMinez 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@oliver170
What makes watchman unique? Give me a break. If you want a deep movie, watch Citizen Kane, Metropolis or Stalker. This is just a braindead action movie for braindead nerds who are too stupid to know the difference between moral philosophy and mindless killing.
But that's not what bothers me about this scene. What bothers me is that the main character is a sociopath and being glorified in the film for being one. And the fact that he murders two pets for no reason.
CarlMinez 2 months ago
@CarlMinez what makes watchmen so unique, is that it's characters aren't extremists on perfection and madness, as to say, superman, who has a steel moral no matter the situation, and joker, who loves chaos just for the sake of it. watchmen characters are normal people. yeah, he killed those dogs, maybe cuz he hated them for eating the girls body, maybe to frighten the guy. the point of this is, i bet you know somebody who would kill a dog if his moral told him that it was the right thing to do.
oliver170 8 months ago
@CarlMinez
they weren't innocent, they were cannibalistic. Once an animal tastes human meat, it wants more. That's why cannibalistic tigers, lions etc are always hunted and killed.
KyodaiKen1979 2 months ago
@KyodaiKen1979
Where the hell did you read that? Cannibalism is the act of humans eating a member of their own species. How on earth can a dog be cannibalistic? Dogs, to the best of my knowledge, aren't humans.
Furthermore, the scene was cruel. The dogs had done nothing to deserve that treatment. They are being depicted in the movie as expandable objects with no value, that the hero can basically kill just to frighten another human being.
CarlMinez 2 months ago
four people are dogs that need to put down
shadowplay71293 11 months ago
@shadowplay71293
Do you think that dogs, by definition, deserves to be put down? I guess you must be a cat person. Or a psychopath.
CarlMinez 2 months ago
Awwww, you shoulda put in that deep fry grease scene too...
DUSKtheIMPALER 1 year ago
No don't :( Don't do that :'( TAKE ME IN!!!
DrTrouble95 1 year ago
@DrTrouble95 Didn't you hear what Rorshack said?
"Men get arrested. Dogs get put down."
The bastard got what he deserved.
ThatEpicAsian 1 year ago
@jackw00pw00p The dislikes are now 3 so its the guy too
HIGHLEYBOYZ 1 year ago
there was pretty much no reason for this scene to be like this. zach snyder needs to grow up and get over his penchant for really stupid and over-the-top gratuitous violence.
JBTheMovies 1 year ago
Rorschach makes overkill underrated.
ENxGore 1 year ago 12
The actual quote is:
"This world is not shaped by vague Metaphysical forces. It wasn't God that killed the little girl. Wasn't fate that butchered her or destiny that fed her to the dogs. It's us. Only us."
SoleMan117 1 year ago 3
best punishment for a child rapist is to shrink the guy to size of cockroach and throw him to a mantis.give a helmet and neck guard so that the mantis cannot bite his head /neck and kill him quick. the mantis will eat him feet first.
keeyk118b 1 year ago 3
Rorshach is my favourite character in Watchmen, or in any Snyder-directed comic-book-movie.
qwuezalothus 1 year ago
I fucking lol every time he throws the dogs at him.
RayRay50418NO 1 year ago
omfg i love this scene but the version i watch is longer and you see the guy's head start to collapse XD
animekingist 1 year ago
in the directors cut it shows rorschach hit the cri
MrJimboner22 1 year ago
Anyone else think he killed that guy a little too quickly?
Agneshka 1 year ago
@Agneshka justice takes time, punishment only comes within matter of seconds.
mrandymcool 1 year ago 3
pretty sure when i saw it it was "men,go to jail,monsters go to hell"
rorschac009oo8 1 year ago
I'm sorry, but the way they id this scene in the movie kind of ruins the entire point of the Rorschach character. In the comic everyone thinks he's a nut, but in reality he isn't. This scene makes him look like a psychopath when HE ISN'T. Not to mention what he does to the guy in the book is more badass and makes him have so much more depth as a character.
LtSykes 1 year ago
@LtSykes By technicallity, he is somewhat insane. Even fans can say he is a bit nuts, but in the good way.
ShadowDJ94 1 year ago
Roarshach was wrong about one thing. Creatures like that "thing" aren't dogs, they're shit to be flushed down the bog (toilet). So should be the end of all shit like that creature, nice and painfully. And yes, they are really out there.
Bubo25 1 year ago
2 dislikes? must be 2 child molesters.
mizsoutiger 1 year ago 32
This scene is terrible compared to the scene in the graphic novel.
EbolaZidane 1 year ago
Rorschah ain't no hero for instance he never kills corrupt billionaires or rogue mafia cops he sets double standards for different criminals (a bit like Punisher who also protects rogue cops) so they're not even anti-heros, they're closer to villains with a bit of anti-hero in them
schwarzfalk 1 year ago
@schwarzfalk Rorschach's demented ideology is what makes him a sour version of a hero.
The 1st problem is that he judges people either two ways: good or evil. The issue there is that he denies the grey area b/w them, which can exist (Ex. People can do bad things w/o being labeled "evil").
The 2nd problem is that he "forces" (mild fascism) his view of justice onto others while denying their (criminals') right to trial. I like Rorschach but his ideology is dangerous for the masses.
Bmanritchie 1 year ago
One of my favorite lines in history. Rorschach's "Dogs get put down" is up there with the Bible's "I am Legion", and the president's speech in Independence Day.
PredatorKillsAlien 1 year ago
wtf nothing like the comic
volopok 1 year ago
@volopok Dude, it's a movie. There are 4 kinds: originals, remakes, re-images, or reboots (sequels).
This was Zack Snyder's re-imaged (although close) interpretation of the graphic novel.
Bmanritchie 1 year ago
Seems heroes with throat cancer are popular now-a-days
ECL28E 1 year ago
"God doesn't make the world this way, we do" the epic truth
stomyn 1 year ago 21
I think they edited the scene to rorscach killing the guy with a axe instead of burning him is because when "walter kovacs closed his eyes then. it was rorscach who opened them" is mentioned in the book when he kills the dogs, so, instead of the whole "transformation" concept, they decided to make it more personal do it with the man, and it made more sense then burning him.
ChocPuddingDragon 1 year ago
I wonder how the comedian would have reacted to this situation. Or would killing a helpless girl and feeding her to the dogs still just be apart of the "big joke."
mugatu5000 1 year ago
@mugatu5000 I am guessing regardless of how he felt, the outcome for the guy who did it woulda been the same.
EmperorofCartoons 1 year ago
@EmperorofCartoons I’m just saying the Comedian has a very cynical view of human nature and he thinks he’s seen the worst of human behaviour, and he prides himself on this acknowledgement; the fact that very few would permit themselves such a understanding but he DOES allow it and he doesn’t care. But we’ve come to see that even Blake had limits. He breaks down after discovering the magnitude of Veidt’s plan. So I was just wondering if Blake would have simply scoffed at Rorschach’s discovery.
mugatu5000 1 year ago
@mugatu5000 This IS the genesis of Rorschach and it pretty much overwhelmed him, so I’m just wondering if Blake would have still kept his head. Would this not appear in Blake's "top ten list of the worst human atrocities he's seen"?
mugatu5000 1 year ago
This movie only did so poorly because people can't understand it. People are idiots, they don't see masterpieces. Of course Alan Moore is going to be pissed off though, no creator likes others to adapt their brilliance. I will agree the comic was better but this film deserves more recognition than a simpleton society can give.
ReDhAvEn1993 1 year ago 73
@ReDhAvEn1993 IMO this movie did so poorly because of its god awful soundtrack which never failed to take whatever was happening on screen and pissing all over it
depressio117 1 year ago
@depressio117 umm.....don't talk about this like you have even the slightest idea what you're talking about.......you're obviously belligerently inept.....if you're not being sarcastic.......fucking idiot
killa420herb 1 year ago
@killa420herb Rorschach dies to "sound of silence" by simon and garfunkle, a ludicrously long sex scene to "hallelujah" by Cohen, and MCR covers "desolation row" for the credits. I know it's just my opinion, but soundtrack dissonance can be used in a movie only so many times before it gets old and stops making sense. it worked with Nat King Cole's "Unforgettable," I'm your boogie man" and "times they are a changing", but by the end I just wished Snyder would stop
depressio117 1 year ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 The movie did not do poorly. I have no idea where you even got that idea from. The movie was #1 for a long ass time and made $55,214,334 in the opening weekend. No movie had higher results than it did that year. It was a great movie and it also did great. The only bad thing about this movie is that we saw too much ballsack.
blacktee31 1 year ago
@blacktee31 Well plenty of people saw it but most didn't enjoy it, which i can't understand. There really was only like two scenes where you could see Dr. Manhattan's junk unless you were intentionally searching for it. (That is not an attack at you for pointing that out lol, I just mean in general.)
ReDhAvEn1993 1 year ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 I can understand that, but I haven't met anybody that didn't like it. And I'm sure there were more than just two scenes and even just two is too much for me. There was a good bit of times where his balls caught me off guard.
blacktee31 1 year ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 You're a fucking idiot.
MansoorDorp 1 year ago
@MansoorDorp 24 people disagree you goof. You must be amongst the simpleton society sir.
ReDhAvEn1993 11 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 You're just a fucking moron, I guess Alan more is also a simpleton as well? Fucking idiot.
MansoorDorp 11 months ago
@MansoorDorp Hmmm....I have no more time for this...you are obviously illiterate..plus you need to wash your mouth out.....ahh but I digress..if you care to waste your time and continue arguing me reply would be a rebuttal, and to your next axiomatic putrid reply I would pronounce a rebuttal as well. No run, run away pet run! Go barricade yourself in your fortress of ignorance.
ReDhAvEn1993 11 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 Holier than thou? Funny considering you're defending this watered down over hyped glitz and spectacle over interlect version of the Watchmen, have you ever read a fucking comic in your entire measly life?
MansoorDorp 11 months ago
@MansoorDorp Yeah I read plenty of comic books....Actually I read the Watchmen comic well before the film. Please stop fighting on youtube and go get a life.
ReDhAvEn1993 11 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 I couldnt have said it any better
Goonivision 11 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993
What is great about this movie is simply borrowed from the comic book. Great book inspired movie do more than just give what the book already gave.
insanej3 11 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 Brilliant explanation! In my opinion Watchmen is the best "superhero" film ever made
xMrBubblezz 11 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 What's the weather like up on that pedestal of yours?
Nimmo1492 11 months ago
@Nimmo1492 Very Sunny, Blue Sky. Real warm.
ReDhAvEn1993 11 months ago 2
@ReDhAvEn1993 i know lol
lolatmyfoot 10 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 Indeed. For those who didn't read the graphic novel, the movie is confusing. I love this movie because I've read the graphic novel and they did an excellent job at adapting it.
Str0ngSide 8 months ago
@ReDhAvEn1993 There was too much dicking around.
MFandEK 7 months ago
This scene really does remind of Marv from Sin City... both are great films, even if Watchmen means more in the long run...
Scruffy193 1 year ago
and thats how freddy kruger was born
zmarsella 1 year ago
criminal sucks
edithlegacy 1 year ago
We need Rorschach to do this to Steven Hayes
VegitoVai90 1 year ago
The sick part is that mother fucker's like the murder do this stuff and just get a few decades in prison. I wish that there were more people like Rorscach, people who have the balls to give these sick fucker's what they deserve.
mrtoontown 1 year ago
@mrtoontown Not really. A world where people can just walk into a persons house and break their necks while they're eating dinner with the family, just because they believe that their a murderer isn't my idea of Justice. What if they were innocent? (This is coming from a Rorscach fan.)
codafett 1 year ago
@codafett My first point still stands- sick bastards like the murderer do horrid things then get only a few decades in prison or get put to death. A few decades in prison- Not remotely bad as it used to be- compared to the old days, it's fucking easy-mode (had a uncle who was in prison for embezzeling). Put to death- In some cases I feel that it's too quick and painless an end.
You may not agree with me, but I can't blame ya. We live in a society where violence and murder are wholly wrong.
mrtoontown 1 year ago
This movie was FUCKING RETARDED!
willhunting1995 1 year ago
@willhunting1995 actually, it was the one movie ive seen that is entirely true to the book/comic. very violent and graphic.
superspartan11 1 year ago
@superspartan11 And yet, the critics and audiences absolutely HATED this film. Even the author of the comic book, Alan Moore completely DISOWNED this film and continues to badmouth it to this day. Kick-Ass was 10,000 times better than Watchmen.
willhunting1995 1 year ago
@willhunting1995 Kickass was pretty lame.
Baracudaflaps 1 year ago
@Baracudaflaps Kick ass was better than this piece of shit known as Watchmen!
willhunting1995 1 year ago
@willhunting1995 Not even close.
Baracudaflaps 1 year ago
@Baracudaflaps Oh, it's so close you can taste it!
willhunting1995 1 year ago
@superspartan11 Except for the ending. And 70% of the rest of the novel. But you're right, completely true to the book,
Nelsonhojax15 11 months ago
@willhunting1995 you are retarded
Kurisuchianu89 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Kurisuchianu89 Is that why I banged your mother last night?
willhunting1995 1 year ago
I can't watch this scene without laughing about that Saturday Morning cartoon intro of the Watchmen spoof someone did where they showed the exact opposite of the movie as a joke and showed Rorschach juggling pies and petting two german shepards being "a friend to the animals". Still great scene. Jackie Earl Haley's awesome. He's great in this role and even did an okay job as Freddy (Robert's the REAL Freddy of course but Haley at least was better than the idea of Thornton) given the awful script
balrog13571 1 year ago
@balrog13571
Harry Partridge ftw
VegitoVai90 1 year ago
Dear God, just wow, I mean I know it's just a movie/novel, but wow, how could someone do that to a little girl. Rorschach's right though, we do make the world as it is, and it's up to us to try to make it better, undo the wrongs, if it's not too late already.
mckfrr 1 year ago