Added: 4 years ago
From: CameraPlanetArchive
Views: 110,858
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (344)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • These people who did this were very familiar with the design and architecture of the world trade center twin towers air force vesley tony test pilot studied it knowing that if you broke all the steel rods it would fall isnt that right detonation experts detonated large skyscrapers before or studied how to where

  • our children must be sacrificed for allah 9 11 our schools NOW

  • we need another in our childrens schools

  • What a better place the world would be without religion.

  • @TheBeatlesShop what a better place the world would be without you. Just think: Stalin-atheist, Hitler-atheist etc etc.

  • Victims of the September 11 events around 3000 but do any of you asked how many Iraqi victims of five million immigrants out of Iraq and more than a million people dead and more than a million disappeared more than a million people remained in prison and Palestinian victims did not find statistical them to the large number of killings continued Israeli

  • Good footage, bad souvenirs. It'll be ten years already next month.  Seems it was just last year....

  • 0.27 seconds to 0.28 checkout the charges going off... holy shit this video is evidence...

  • Comment removed

  • dont belive! its the most show you have ever seen... there was no airplain there was no chois. its probably the best secred and scared thing in the world.if you like the video klick the button right over your side. if you dont like it klick here --->

  • I'm sorry to everyone who lost a family member(s) killed, I love you, R.I.P

  • Controlled explosions can be seen in several videos and the news stations have the collapse of WTC 7 ... 25 min earlier predicted on television although the building was still standing in the background ... very cheap ... These days it's not hard to build something that looks like an airplane but in truth is a bomb! Who does not believe it ... even looking! The net is full of info ....

  • Haha a plane! How stupid we really think the U.S. government? An airplane made​of sheet metal and aluminum will cut through a thick wall steel like butter and disappear completely in the building ... all clear ... Bullshit!

  • FAG !

  • the U.S gov't has definitely covered something up here, there is way!! too much compelling evidence that supports a coverup here and nations all around the world know this and there are many documentaries from news channels around the world that are seeing the real truth here. yes it's a coverup and because of the mass murder invovled the truth needs to come out. it's no longer a theory or a conspiracy theory. the U.S. gov't (bush admin.) is lying and decieving their own people and the world.

  • i wouldve loved to be the badass that killed osama

  • my god so helpless ...

  • hey im from the netherlands im happy and all that osama is dead BUT america need to be prepared for more attacks like this because al qaeda will be mad as shit so i think that there is gonna be more attacks like this I HOPE NOT!!!

  • @Timproducties your right al qaeda will try to get us again, however our government understands this as well and they are on the look out.

  • Lol osama got fucked up haha

  • osama binladen is dead lol

  • @MGftw1 fcking asshole

    

  • @MGftw1 It's great but too bad he had nothing to do with this!

  • strange that at the moment of second impact she pulls the camera away from second hit,and they do not mention a plane,obviously two persons are looking closely at the scene,"plane" should be seen from right ...we know now it is not a plane.

  • @MrPhattdirty You honestly think that airplanes did not fly into the twin towers? That takes some serious mind bending.

  • @MrPhattdirty no it was a plane

  • Praying for a Native AMERICAN to "preside" over this country & take back the power that we lost to the "dirt bags" running it now!!!!

  • And I ask you ALL, "who' are the real "terrorists" under this "one Nation under GOD?!!!

  • I cannot believe we were so stupid as to have voted Bush or Obama for presidents!!! Bush was a terrible liar & Obama don't know his ass from a hole in the ground!!! For him to have denied christian prayer as part of this nation that was founded by God, then declare a "national day of 'Mulim' prayer" @ the white house repulses me!! WTF?!!!!

  • Looks like we got rid of one idiot liar & now we have another idiot in office!! Is there such thing as an honest CHRISTIAN in politics???!!!!!!

  • Looks like we got rid of one idiot liar & now we have another idiot in office!!

  • I think those two are on prozac; no emotion. it's all about them, you know.

  • "do you think that buildings going to collapse?" "should we leave?" Hell yeah!

  • @SupportAlQaeda FUCK YOU FAGGOT!

  • Donald, say your prayers....

    I believe it may come down and smack us...We should leave.

  • Don't these two sound rather calm and aloof about this whole thing? Remember that numerous groups of Israelis were caught videotaping this. Once group stated to the cops they were there to "document" the incident. These two [now call me anti-semite] NY jews just nonchalantly chat about this and stay in their very expensive apartment in lower manhattan even after the second plane hit. Also notice the coincindence of his moving the camera just as the second plane hit. Lots of jews with cameras hm

  • WATCH LOOSE CHANGE FINAL CUT ON GOOGLE VIDEOS

  • OMG why was she taking the camera down >.<

    Best part missing

  • Comment removed

  • I remember watching that same newscast that's in the background of this video as I was leaving for school that day. I saw the second plane hit as I was about to walk out the door. I don't remember much about that day, but I definitely remember that image.

  • As the anniversary of 911 approaches yet again and many of us watch video here and relive the horror of that day, I would just like to say that whether or not there's a conspiracy or not, we have to admit that a lot of things are amiss and ?'s unanswered but if u choose to debate here can't u all do it with a little class and whole lot of respect...many lives were changed that day and although I lost no one personally, each yr, that passes only makes me sadder. Lest we never 4get.

  • All you ignorant pieces of shit dont realize That this was done by our fucking goverment to go to WAR why in the fuck would any other country do this? they wouldnt this was all a plan to go to war AND Why THE FUCK ARE WE OVER there? weapons of mass destruction? that were never found. FUCK ALL THIS IM MOVING TO CANADA lol THUMBS UP

  • Oh yeah can't forget about the Pentagon either..How in the FUCK did the plane manage to smash into the side where nothing but construction was going on? Why was construction occuring..Because the this was the governements plan to move people around unsuspectedly, under the guise of new construction at teh pentagon..Can't loose anything actually important Fate, Chance? No there is no such luck or coincidence in this life..It was known to the people flying that plane to strike that designated area

  • @MrManimal420 ~ Well apparently it's pretty easy to fake a multi-fronted terrorist attack involving tens of thousands of people from various government and non-governmental agencies.

    It's just difficult to keep it from being uncovered by some pesky paranoid delusional halfwits on the internet.

  • @LOLCATS3111 so apparently you're implying with that sarcasm that it was pretty easy for a small number of people with box cutters to take over 4 planes and hit nearly all the targets they were going for?? i'm not saying i firmly believe one side or the other. i'm a skeptic and i never stop trying to find answers to the questions that deserve recognition. the fact is is that you, by yourself, cannot prove that 9/11 wasn't an inside job. so i don't think it's fair that YOU call anyone delusional

  • @azurenscens What is you theory?

  • @klwewf I don't think anyone can really have a theory on what happened and 100% believe it as not one of us knows all the facts and nothing like this has happened before or since that we could compare this event to. Both sides of this argument give plenty of examples to help their argument but both give completely biased views and both sides contradict themselves and each other to the point where you can't really fully believe either side.

  • @klwewf Continued. I think the best thing we can do is to carry on with our lives, remember the many people from different nations that died in this tragedy and be wary that, even though we don't know exactly where they are, there are people who would commit such atrocities for their own gain. It's despicable but that's the world we live in and, if we continue to argue about who did it, then we have already lost.

  • @LOLCATS3111 Best comment on the net.

    BTW, have you noticed that the bulk of the "Truthers" - brilliant enough to have figured out a government conspiracy, always seem to have difficulty with basic spelling and sentence structure?

    Truther trolls really need a hobby, presented with evidence they disavow it because it won't fit their delusions which are just an attempt to mask their inadequacies; ostensibly the "short dick man" complex.

  • @blampa ~ a study in the UK found that the educational level of the majority of people who call themselves 9/11 truthers is high school or less !?!?!?!?!?!?

  • @LOLCATS3111 Really not surprsed by that. I had an argument with a "just don't get it troll" regarding the part of the engine found on Murray St. He and the other truthers thought it was too small to be a 767 engine, insisting it was from something else. As I've worked in aviation for the last 22 years, I recognised it as a PART of a GE CF6 80C2; specifically the compressor. When confronted with this, he was dumbfounded, but then dismissed it because it didn't match his idiotic theories.

  • @blampa ~ well that’s their standard MO, the engine is wrong, the landing gear is wrong, the hole is to small / too big, the building collapsed wrong. I think it is important to understand that members of 9/11 "Truth" are like a fanatical religious cult, they are rabid in there beliefs despite the fact that the evidence, facts, and experts don’t support them

    I’m hoping that in 20 years 9/11”truth” is just a minor foot note in the history books

  • @LOLCATS3111 Exactly. I think you said it best with your original comment; "pesky paranoid delusional halfwits on the internet" best describes the "truthers". Such egotistical truthers need to realise that it was a day the world cried for all the innocent lives lost, why do they have to try to make it about themselves? Are they that insecure and desperate for attention? Didn't mummy hug them enough? Has life really been a borish disappointment for them?

  • @blampa @LOLCATS3111 @xxxxaxxxxhxxxxlove Three MOSSAD agents admitted on Israeli TV they were in New York to "record the event'' so MOSSAD has already admitted Israels’ complicity in 911. Israel can't stand on their own economically and they need the US to fight their wars for them. Israel is terrified of loosing US$ 3 Billion per year from US taxpayers so the TrustTards posting stupid 'debunking' comments on youtube are Guilty Israelis pretending to be innocent Americans.

    watch?v=54gPtv7UOr4

  • In the big scheme of things the Amt of lives lost that was tragic for the country.But not devastational to our foundation. Look at videos of buildings that fell due to bombs and external damage..They dont fall straight down and implode on themselves! 2 the governement those people were just numbers and infentessimal numbers when it comes to the grand scheme..What other way could they have gone on their OIL RAID..Paid for with BLOOD..AND THE GAS PRICES STILL WENT UP and up..Bush is rich thx to us

  • The US government does not give 2 shits about its people anymore.. We are just numbers to them nowadays. Its all about production and MONEY. Want to start a war the best way to do that is to unite the people under a common cause and enemy.These plans were made back in to 1920-30's by the great DADDY BUSH..Evil bastards who hid funds for HItler in American banks..Problem is we don't know what happened..We weren't on the planes. Therefore we must accept the lies of our governemet as truth!

  • you can hear the EXPLOSION !!

  • See the sparks on the tower on the right from 1:40 to 1:48 approx... they begin up high then each flash is lower and lower ... last one is right below the first "A" of "CameraPlanet". 5 or 6 flashes total CLEARLY visible.

    The lady handling theven notices sparks I couldn't clearly see.

    That's more evidence of flashes that we see in about 50 different videos on YouTube. Those buildings were rigged. Just more good evidence.

  • @TarnakeDusty and what do 'flashes" 45 minuets before the building collapses mean ?!?!?!?!?!?

  • @LOLCATS3111 Thermite

  • @LOLCATS3111 Exactly! I am glad there are people with open minds and open eyes.

  • @alexfellow you believe all the lies your Truther movement tells you, but you fail to to independant research. You need to grow up and do some INDEPENDANT RESEARCH. THERE WERE NO MASSIVE SECURITY SHUTDOWNS. That is a lie. Also, anyone familiar with demolition knows it would take weeks to months of massive work to rig those buildings, with massive prep work. That would have been seen. Plus, the collapse started where the planes hit. WHY werent they detonated when the plane hit then instantly

  • @JPPolachek

    I did not say it had not taken massive prep work. You have proof it had not been done? More than that... We see the demolition in progress with our own eyes on the screen especially with WTC 7! It is ignorance to prove otherwise. There are witnesses to WTC power down. Where is the proof this power down is a lie?

  • @alexfellow the power down only happened in one small part of one tower only. You believe in lies. I challenge you to show me any credible info about both buildings being powered down. What day, what times?. Also, you guys always say 7 was a demo. and you also say it fell at freefall. But that is a total lie. Look at the northwest Penthouse. It collapsed down TEN SECONDS BEFORE THE REST OF THE BUILDING FELL. Why would someone demo the ROOF FIRST????????? Any answer to that

  • @alexfellow by the way, your organization only has a few screwballs, your thermite prof also believes that he has evidence that Jesus lived in North America for many years through mystical connections...common..these are your sources...and your other prof also has proof that the JFK evidence was DOCTORED.....wow...what a guy...he figured out all of this centuries screwball conspiracy theories....like I said...they have no crediblity...and the Results were NOT postive for thermite...lol

  • @alexfellow By the way...your same thermite professors also originally said it was only standard explosives....but after that was totally debunked...only then did they come up with thermite.....but thermite was never used for a single demo in history...and thermite doesnt make loud bangs......and it doesnt explode...so how do you explain your puffs of dust now...and normally explosions and puffs happen before collapse has begun....NOT AFTER....think about it, why no puffs before the fall begins

  • @alexfellow I can see talking to you is pointless since you have no interest in learning truth, but only in lamely defending your religious belief in your theory. If you studied the official reports you would understand how the collapse of the penthouse is totally consistant with the offical explanation....so how miraculous that some obscure finding not talked of in Truther circles just happens to Confirm the offical explanation. and by the way..9 year on and not one blasting cap yet

  • @JPPolachek No, vice versa. If you feel comfortable living in Matrix believing what people in mass media tell you, then it is only your choice. Good luck!

  • @JPPolachek Familiar with demolition!? Wake up! It is not what they were doing! THEY just wanted to make sure these buildings are destroyed!!! Do they need to follow the standard procedures of demolition? NO!

  • EVEN THOUGH YOU MOVED AT THE MOST CRUCIAL MOMENT YOU STILL CAUGHT PART OF THE BLAST THAT TOOK IT DOWN

  • @MERCURHILLMANIAC

    Even though she moved the camera, shouldnt THEY have seen the plane coming from a distance?? Even though WE cant see it, they were standing there at the window looking toward the SKY and its odd they never noticed ANOTHER jet coming toward the building.. I'm not really expecting you to have the answer, I'm just using your comment to make note that they should have seen it coming.. Or at least I think so.

    =-}

  • THE SPARKS IS THERMITE

  • lets have a moment of silence for the brave terrorists. i mean freedom fighters that gave their life to fly those planes straight into the towers... just kidding. THE GOVERNMENT DID THIS.

  • 2 jets just slammed into the tower an Donald is more worried about the Dow dropping 100 points!!!! Damn I hate Wall Street.

  • coz there vertical you dimwit!

  • US NWO Govt murdered 3000 Americans

    on 9/11

    TREASON

    INSIDE JOB

    FALSE FLAG

  • That's true

  • @jawsfreak97 AND YOU ARE PROBABLY AN ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT

  • @jawsfreak97 Oh! That's a new definition for a word "patriot". So patriots must blindly believe in everything their government wants them to believe in?

  • @alexfellow ~ it has NOTHING to do with what the government believes .... it has EVERYTHING to do with what the experts believe and they have very clearly stated that ALL the failures at the WTC were the direct or indirect result of the impacts from hijacked commercial aircraft

  • Comment removed

  • @TheLucyelliot ~ thats why after 9 years everybody laughs at you TWOOF TARDS

  • Comment removed

  • @LOLCATS3111

    murder, greed and all for theiving the OIL, just a hidious set of leading retards, who should be murdered for doing that to own citizens, what was done will return to them and the world will be satisfied with heads on sticks, reap the seeds sown, hes a failure just like his elder was,

  • @LOLCATS3111

    he who dares wins.......... he who did this knows, all other nations are aware of his attrocities and fears intellegent civilized lands around........ head on stick, no less,,,he will repay what he did, dont you fkin worry, in this life or the next......it was all for the greed of theOIL they had and he didnt. and thats a wrap. period. now fuck off

  • fucking Americans think that there UNTOUCHABLE,

  • fuk u camel jockey son of a bitch die all of suadi arabia

  • fucking Al-Qaeda..they destroy them

  • tHERE SEEMS TO BE NO TIME DELAY BETWEEN THE TV AND THE VIDEOOF THE HIT THERE SHOULD BE 7 SEC OR MORE

  • lmao "Donald, say your prayers"

  • holigrams my ass i was there i seen the plane hit im a fire fighter for ny i cant see how you would think it was fake i pulled bodies out of the rubble i cried for the ones already gone and rejoyced for the ones we found alive holigrams ha you dont know shit!

  • Why are there other firefighters who say they heard explosive devices going off? Why all the contradicting evidence? Maybe you guys could post some testimony vids on here, I mean, if your the real deal. Whoever said this was a holigram is an idiot, obviously planes hit the towers. But I'm not convinced that the planes impact, and the subsequent fire are alone are what brought the building down. Your firefighter, so you know a kerosene fire can't burn long, or hot enough to melt steel. what gives

  • @ BradfordJL so let's say it was a rigged. What are you gonna do about it? If we revolt then the US would be in a state of martial law. We depend on our governments compliance for survival.

  • @LittleMrL If 9/11 really was an inside job it would have led to a revolution a long time ago. People would not have let that type of thing stand. But the reason there hasn't been a revolution is because it wasn't an inside job.....all normal people realize that by now.....there is no doubt about what caused the collapses.....it was proven by video evidence, physical evidence..ext.....but Truthers find the world more interesting and exciting when they are the Heros exposing the evil Goverment

  • @JPPolachek  STFU YA DUMB POLOCK!

  • @JPPolachek Really? You are talking about evidences... What eveidences? Ask some questions to yourself: why was the power and security systems completely shut down in both towers a weekend prior to 9-11? Why do you deny the fact of the presence of thermate in the buildings when it was proved by professors, scientists and other reputable people? Why did tower 7 collapsed in exactly the same way twin towers did? This is a fact that it was a controlled demolition.

  • if u are pAranoid- yes!!

  • No because its strange to see them moving to the top after the WTC crash because'the building was nearby and everything surrounding in this'area would need to be evacuated.

    Did they just go on'top'to have a better view?

    As you might know WTC 7 was demolished by'implosions same as the twin-towers but I understand that'preparation-time must have been around two weeks earlier.

    I wonder who these guys are; maybe not'cleaner, as you dont see them really working there?

    I am just wondering!

  • they werent holograms, what kinda bull is that!?

    holograms... idiots...

  • thanks! My Dad died in the north tower you insensitive asshole

  • Please accept my prayers as you continue to deal with your father's murder. John Keats once wrote Truth is Beauty and Beauty is Truth. That is all ye need to know and all ye will ever know. So until the truth is finally told, the unbelievers will continue to question this aloof government, in search of beauty and truth.

  • I might just go to hell on purpose, just to make sure I save a nice hot spot for your ignorant ass! Goof!

  • yea

  • LOL, so what we, New yorkers, saw, from the street was figments of our imagination. Where you there?

  • What do you mean with holgrams?

  • Your totally wacked bro lol Like seriously wacked. Regardless of any other cover up that may or may not have happened that day, one thing is for sure: Some type of large airplane crashed into the towers! How stupid are you? there's no credible source for such nonsense and it's incredibly ignorant. Please don't reply, I have plenty of ignorant unintelligent ramblings from other pieces of shit to reply too, I don't have time, nor does anyone else, for hologram bullshit. get a life!

  • Why are people so damn stupid man with all they're whacked out drug induced theory's?

  • lmao

  • Comment removed

  • Ridiculously to look as Americans die

  • asshole you're a sick fuck!

  • funny video? YES!! It is funny video: when ur mother get fucked by HITLER, that is really funny -.-. ; Srry who those 1s wich lost a frien or a familiar, I lost 1 :'-(

  • Jackass.

  • (WTC close up of south tower buckling WATCH THIS!!) sorry conspiracy dude your wrong.

  • Yeah and being a "Structural Engineer" did you study what happeneds to buildings when they are penitrated by a 570,000 lbs aircraft flying at 480 mph? Just saying...I really don't think they teach that in a text book!

  • Comment removed

  • The people that cahed the planes needed Jesus. Its really all very sad.

  • this is really sad.. i cant believe how ppl would risk their lives to put lots of ppl in a bunch of tradgities..

  • The guys that crashed the plane needed to get a life before have done that, but they missed that point.

  • wow i think they cant clean up this mess dude

    its a tall building man its hard i see

  • If you guys wish to be uncivilized and insult people you don't know via internet, be respectful and don't do it on a page that has to do with one of the most tragic moments in U.S. history.

  • Watch WTC #5 burn all nite and not collapse. This country is filled with a assload of fucktards. SERIOUSLY! To be a Patriot is to ASK QUESTIONS! WAKE UP! The only thing new in the world is the history you don't know.

  • My buddy lived there and watched the rubble burn all night yep no builing was standing BOTH WERE RUBBLE. A small lower part of the frame was there but not much....WHAT THEY DO USE A BIG PHUCKING "HALLAGRAM" now LMMFAO!!! TARD!

  • i wish to stop all war in all world and god help the ppl in that time but Iraq life's like that every moment and every day i feel whats happen all Iraqi ppl live this every day and every moment

  • All that white smoke coming out of the most up-wind corner, positioned well above the impact site. Has to be planted incendiary charges.

  • If you notice you see some smoke trails coming out over different spaces meaning that the people were breaking windows just to get some fresh air picture how drastic you are that you have to break open a window on the 103rd floor of a building just to breathe.

  • It looks just as if a plane had pierced a cardboard box!

  • Has anyone ever watched a steeple jack demolish a Tower? there's charges placed from the bottom to almost the Top intricitly placed so the building fall's free fall..

  • Sorry, Jessxy. I work in Las Vegas and demolish office and hotel towers. The WTC was not even close to a Controlled Demolition.

    HIGH explosives don't go boom boom boom, they sound like rifle shots, crack crack crack.

    BOOM BOOM BOOM is the high pressure, high speed AIR being forced out of the building as 13 million pounds falls on it.

    .

  • i agree with merlin5x5, this whole subject has bothered me so i did as much research as i can. search other building collapsing from fire, they still have huge puffs of debris come out below them with out tnt, its from the force being pushed downward and out'

  • u dumbass ppl and ur stupied ass theorys could go crawl in a whole and die, show some respect to the ppl that died,, do u even care about the life lost or do u only think of how to call it a conspericy???

  • It's those very peoples families that want answers to extremely valid and pertinent questions you brainwashed fucktard

  • i dont under stand, how could it have been us??? things could actully be as easy as it looks, planes highjacked by forgin terriosts flew into bulidings ands thousands of people died,,you just cant leave it at that???

  • The WTC towers were built to withstand collisions from the largest planes around at the time, which weren't a whole lot smaller than what were used on 9/11.

    The towers both fell in exactly the same manner even though they were both hit from different angles.

    Both towers fell in a planned, professional demolition manner at near free-fall speed. If the planes caused the collapse then the towers would have toppled, not collapsed.

    This is much more than "planes hi-jacked hit towers people die"

  • Mayhemzz you should be ashamed of yourself. Are you an expert in demolition? Where are your credentials to make such a wild ignorant accusation? So the planes were in contact with George Bush on the ground. The dynomite was planted days before, and we had volunteers to fly the planes WITH PEOPLE into the towers? YEAH OK! Was Pearl Harbor an inside job? No, it couldn't have been because your boy FDR was President. Right? And to think my son fights for your right to spew this crap!

  • Yeah Mickey Mouse was flying the prop plane. I watched a thing on 9-11 conspiracys, everytime they showed the people how this and this happened they still denied it. How could they really know how big of planes the towers could withstand. Did they ever account it being on fire. YOU "TRUTHERS" NEED TO GIVE IT A REST. If you really think it was a conspiracy, you should be afraid cause they know where you are.

  • @ed2kou1 You dont live in new york. So shut up nigger.

  • @ed2kou1 Ask some questions to yourself: why was the power and security systems completely shut down in both towers a weekend prior to 9-11? Why do you deny the fact of the presence of thermate in the buildings when it was proved by professors, scientists and other reputable people? Why did tower 7 collapsed in exactly the same way twin towers did? This is not just a logical conclusion. This is a fact that it was a controlled demolition.

  • Comment removed

  • @ed2kou1 do you happen to drive a taxi for a living?

  • sirens

  • is it just me or is there someone screaming very very loudly at 1:04?

  • thats what it sounds like

  • i think it was sirens

  • sirens or a radio

  • there were bombs how much more obvious can it be???????????

  • I wonder if donald said his prayers

  • It is a fit up. How could those passports possibly survive ? They also did the same thing in London on 7/7 and a passport was found, only the guy was travelling on a bus !

  • How come they found the terrorists passport and how come the buildings fell down. A plane should not bring a tower like that down.

  • conspiracy's say that there was thermionic explosives under the towers when they exploded...

  • Comment removed

  • that is sooo stupid... why do people in the passenger cabin have access to pilot cockpit... maybe somebody should rethink airplane design... the moment the word hijack was invented this design flaw should have been fixed..

  • Great idea but its 9 years to late. Heinsight is always 20/20.

  • heinsight??

  • 0:50 Window washers on WTC 7?

  • ya they were washing windows when the plane hit there in a book