Scarlett Johansson 'Breaks Up'

[newordr]

@Lilpopstar, aussiechic and biotech, you have no clue what you're talking about. She is an actress, she also sings, she is monotone, she has flaws, she's not Celine, but she never claimed to be. This is a catchy song and she makes it. The Beatles arrived and Elvis got on the scene, and it was unacceptable at the time, Scarlett is a different voice, despite her beauty, put Beiber, Madonna,Gaga and Britney combined and you still wont have the amount of talent Scarlett has.

[snowmancopy]

“Break Up” is magic. Nice call PY. Maybe it hits so close to home for me because of my break up. But then all of PY’s tunes do it for me. And Scarlett, what can I say. An angel!

[aussiechic06]

Just because you can stay on key doesn't mean you can sing. Personally, I think the timbre of her voice sounds horrible. She has no finesse to her music, no style, no range... it's all boring - right on par with Ke$ha, etc. I like listening to real singers like Mariah, Leona, Celine, Whitney (back in the day, not now), Aguilera, and so on. These SINGERS would put her to shame. Not only that, but there is a lot of undiscovered talent that would transcend scarlett's musical "efforts".

[lovebiotech]

Alright, I'm not done yet. A woman is cute, so you hire her, then hope she can do the job. You didn't hire her because you knew she qualified, you hired her for eye candy. That's BS. Obviously, the world now knows Scarlett can sing. But shame on Pete Yorn for listening to his tallywhacker and not Scarlett's voice to begin with. Jerk. As a scientist, I hope I'm hired because I know what the hell I'm doing. God forbid I set the lab on fire. I also hope I'm not rejected because I'm decent looking.

[lovebiotech]

Okay, let me get this straight. He had a project idea, wanted Scarlett for it, THEN thought it might be a good idea to ask if she could sing? F-it-all. Do men seriously still have no respect for women? Curiosity led me to checking out her career history, and I found she worked with Woody Allen. Does anyone else just want to gag? Men glom on to cute women because... *shrug*

[tcrangle963]

oops...that was a youtube advert. check them out anyway!

[tcrangle963]

check out the guys on the discover NI advert at the start! they are called john, shelly and the creatures. the song is called long may you reign and the album is called dinosaur! check them out! they are KICKASS!

[LILPOPSTAR89]

*your

[Gumbasso]

Scarlett is gorgeous and she has this amazing voice too, but Pete... he is really hot :D In fact they look like they make a perfect match ;-)

[hsaka67]

She so fuckn beautiful.In "match point" i was totally in love with her..Why are u married?????????grrr

[Julietteisme]

its kind of offensive for me lol cause everyone i know says i look just like her so when you guys call her an ugly pig, your calling me an ugly pig... yeahhhhhhhhhhhh

[ImDavidBizar]

So talented, and SO FUCKING HOT ajaja, love her.

[bronzjag]

Amy Winehouse without the drugs!

[HanaNoTenjin]

People will settle for someone average and love them like the they breath the air, for all their imperfections, and then go and have the gall to say that, because she isn't their ideal, Scarlett Johansson is just flat out NOT pretty?

Wake up, you petty fucking bastards. She's gorgeous.

[Bongtasia]

mk not for me

[janus70]

Doesn't matter what she looks like (I think she's pretty, but that's just me,) since she can out-sing about every female pop vocalist out there. With a voice like that, she could look like Marlon Brando for all it matters.

[spurtingcocks69]

ahaha what the fuck are you listening to?

[latirouquine]

très bonne decouverte

[hwiley09]

Omg, Scarlett, idk y on Earth you would ever, for any reason, possibly happen to be reading this, but I've always loved your acting and I love your voice, and I think it's great that you're doing something you like. Don't listen to any negative criticism. Just know how awesome you are, and act like you do .^_^.

[marapryds]

she's like a cow,her face is piggy distorted?what's wrong with you guys?are you brainwashed?

[theorhcp]

Fuck ! She's beautiful ! you are brainwashed, look at her face, she so perfect, how can you say that ?!

[Spawnisntdead]

Sure she's beautiful but on this she has a quite swollen face, i don't know why.

[Julyeah]

i dont get it, she's the most overrated person in the world! people, wake up!

[Lyra369]

is she actually pretty?

[Jammsbro1]

Thats for you to decide.

[Mokkadi]

No, she's not pretty.

She's beautiful.

[Wonderwh98]

she's average, any girl her age looks good with a minimum of make up and work out

[THECLAYSTER]

@Wonderwh98

You're crazy, she's so hot.

[spurtingcocks69]

I'D THROW A DICK OR TWO UP YOUR SISTER

[kittylovesmj]

I love her.

[JustForKeanu]

Check out Amandine, a French new star winner 2008..She has a similar voice to Scarlet's.

[adtor111]

Scarlett I love you!!!!!!

She is good in everything she does.

She is wonderful, she is the best, so beautiful, so nice, so lovely....................

Love u Scarlett

[ebrownGandalf]

cool stuff

[jennifereileen]

Love it!

[pollardfan]

she had tom waits material on her last record, i think this stuff suits her better.

[Jennifer009]

fair play at least shes honest and giving it a go

[getoutofmyway01]

she looks sad in the interview.

I'm not a fan of hers, but when I heard this song on a local college radio station, I liked it.

Other than that, I'm sick of her being everywhere but making a decent movie. If she wants to be a "serious" actress, she can still do other projects, sure, but she needs to focus on ACTING more than posing for things like CHANEL or CHRISTIAN DIOR. I know it's good to make money while you can, but she needs to make a decent film... and fast.

[LILPOPSTAR89]

i LIKE her voice! she should make more music!!

she has a very original voice! like nothing we´ve heard from this generation! :)

[ImTalkingJBrooch]

@LILPOPSTAR89 really? I think it's plain.... at least in the two songs I've heard...

[Maxurai2222]

@LILPOPSTAR89 Her voice sounds great on the album, but live it sounds a lot less impressive :P

[memnochyouare]

@LILPOPSTAR89 Get her album, Anywhere I Lay My Head. It's awesome. :)

[badbadruberpig]

@LILPOPSTAR89

r u stupid, she can't sing, the voice is not original and there is a lot

of good music and voices in this generation, ur lilPOPstar what do u know?

stupid!!

[LILPOPSTAR89]

@badbadruberpig You are not worthy of my time, but i was curious too see if you could elaborate on your conclusions.

First of all care to explain you theory of "She can't sing"?

As for my user name(It's hardly relevant to the video/this discussion), for you to judge my Opinion/knowledge based on my user name is not only stupid but it also doesn't put you in the best of lights as far as common sense goes. Anyway if you would bother to do as i proposed above it would be great.

[aussiechic06]

@LILPOPSTAR89 This is why I think she can't sing. My definition of someone who can sing, would be someone who can do accapella and still sound good. Their voice is like multiple instruments, very complex. In my opinion, the timbre of her voice is horrible (esp. in that green grass song). She has the same boring voice throughout the song (simplistic), and uses no falsetto, no head voice, no mixed voice, no whistle register, etc. She does not do any vocal runs, and barely even uses any vibrato.

[aussiechic06]

@LILPOPSTAR89 ... cont'd... Basically, what i'm trying to get at is she doesn't use any musical elements with her voice. No crescendos or decrescendos, no staccato, no legato. You catch my drift? There is nothing special about it. It's boring. Yes, she can stay on key the entire time, but there is no style or finesse to it. The main thing heard by the listener is the musical composition of the song (which is very catchy), not the "singing" itself. A singer's voice could stand alone & be superb.

[LILPOPSTAR89]

@LILPOPSTAR89 *I *She *Unique

[dillinghammatt50]

Great song just bought it. i cant wait to hear the rest..and this is the first time hearing Scarlett Johansson sing. Scarlett and pete are perfect together.. keep up the good music..dont stop

-lovinit

[macks3123]

Lets hear you live. Then we can Make a Decision

[Ellalla]

There is at least on live version of the song Relator on youtube, and she actually sounded quite good. I didnt like her own album, Tom Waits stuff, she sounded HORRIBLE. But this album is nice, I like it.

[ashkissee]

she needs better material

[jenisoutofhermind]

How many computers had to "help" her sing?

[GoldenEraa]

Haha i agree shes shit even with the computers she cant act sing or do anything shes ugly shes only got where she is because of her bra size not because shes talented she lacks talent. Marilyn Monroe wannabe - but Marilyn was something that Johansson isnt - a woman?

[invisiblekiva]

about 10,000 less that have to help Madonna, Britney and the other so-called pop singers. Give credit where credit is due. She can wipe the ass off these other 2 fakers.

[mattmurd0ck]

Her voice sounds like a reincarnation of a 20's recording artist

[whatisatroll]

LOL OMG HURRRRRR DURRRRRR FIRST POST DERP DERP DERP!!!!!!!!11!!1!one!!!1

[swirlygirly1234]

DURRRPPP!!!!!