@ub3r2008 Exactly but Geddy REALLY pushed his voice and has always sang loudly with a lot of force. Jon does the opposite which has let his high notes stay intact. The more force you sing with, the more your vocal chords stretch and the more you need to be a vocal care Nazi and since Ged has always been a bass player first his voice has dropped. Oh well they still put on a great show!
Its normal that his voice doesnt exactly the same, he recorded this song nearly 30 years ago, our voice gets deeper when we get older, he just cant hit the high notes he used to back in the days, Geddy lee doesnt have the high pich voice he had back then, not as much at least, but he still has a good voice.
I went to the one in Seattle. I guess Geddy gets tired or somethin after a bit. Cause he sounded a lot more....Cracked?.....I don't know the word....But he sounds A LOT better here considering it was the first show.
This has got to be one of the best rock songs ever. Its so complex yet sounds so good. Hard to believe these 3 guys created it 30yrs ago. I used to think drums and bass playing was for the dummies in the band until I heard these guys. Geddy's voice is not as good as it used to be but he's almost 60. Other than that their all better than ever.
I'll be at the Atlanta show in Sept..Cant wait I have waited 20 yrs for this..American but Grew up in Brazil listening to them and they would never come there because they usually would not play on open stadiums...well they went to Rio a few yrs ago but I was already in the US and no shows around. Now I'm in Afghanistan and will be on leave in Sept to go watch it. OH MAN..got the tickets last week. The wife and I are going...Yesss AWESOME the sound that 3 guys can do do uh? Neil is Da man!
claydogg2006...what row were you in while recording this?? trying to get an idea of how i'll be able to see in the 18th row at allentown this year. was in the 9th row at hershey in 2008 and had a really good view.
Hey guys check out our band Panacea. We are heavily influenced by Rush. Please subscribe and we accept ALL friend requests. We already have a few videos out there.
@77Brainer77 60 wow where you get that?,anyways who in the hell are you to tell me not to complain about Rush? you and your kind can fuck off asswipe stick to hiding on your computer?...coward.I'll say what I want about the band asshole you and no one else has to like but don't tell me about who to complain ok?i'll let you get back to your rockband game..ok shithead
@77Brainer77 WOW HOW LONG IT TAKE YOU TO PUT THAT ONE TOGETHER,BY THWE WAY I WAS A RUSH FAN FOR NEARLY 34 YEARS AND SPENT ALOT OF MONEY AT THEIR SHOWS STILL HAVE CREEM&CIRCUS,MUSIC EXPRESS MAGAZINE ARTICLES AND INTERVIEWS ABOUT RUSH FROM 1976'77'78'79'80,SO THERE'S NOTHING YOU CAN TWELL ME ABOUT RUSH,WHEN DID YOU LISTEN SNAKES,AND ARROWS,OR COUNTERPARTS WHEN THEY FINALLY STARTED TO SELLOUT WITH THEIR BS CDS?
@77Brainer77 NOW,NOW JUST BECAUSE RUSH MAKES MONEY IN AMERICA THERE'S NO NEED FOR THAT,HELL NO YOU DUMB FUCKING HYMIE I DON'T DO NIGGER WEED OR GET HIGH YOU FUCKING RETARD FUCK YOUR ARE PISSED BECAUSE I SET YOU UP YOU FUCKING DUMB ASSHOLE TELL ME YOU ARE ONE OF THE CHIMPS IN THE VIDEO,LMFAO
I wanted to see them in KC last night...but after viewing people's concert footage, I was shocked that mature, older fans, still stand up and even on their sets throughout the concert. Can't we all just sit down and enjoy the show without acting like 17 year old kids. Please!!
was nice being a rush fan for o33years now its time to say see ya rush you are the best american band out there bar none,too bad you gave up touring canada,but maybe its for the best.
@Zivojinovic126 no i wish it were but since they gave up on Canada,and to concentrate on the Central Canada market(Ontario&Quebec,and the Southern US i guess they don't need my money?.anyways with that said Isupported these guys for a very long time,so yes I shall critize them afterall,spent hundreds of dollars at their shows so I have that right
a sickness to it
SuperMegaUberGenius 9 months ago
haha this crowd sucks balls
Sweezelballin 1 year ago
when i was a teen all we had to go by was bootleg shows or the album. this takes me back to when i was cool.
muddack 1 year ago
boot lg video's sucks ass
getalife67 1 year ago
Jon Anderson and Russel Mael are still able to hit the high notes.
GFWspacezilla 1 year ago
@GFWspacezilla Jon Anderson's voice is naturally higher, though both Geddy and Jon are high tenorish.
ub3r2008 1 year ago
@ub3r2008 Exactly but Geddy REALLY pushed his voice and has always sang loudly with a lot of force. Jon does the opposite which has let his high notes stay intact. The more force you sing with, the more your vocal chords stretch and the more you need to be a vocal care Nazi and since Ged has always been a bass player first his voice has dropped. Oh well they still put on a great show!
Annonymus121 1 year ago
@Annonymus121 Ah, that really explains it.
ub3r2008 1 year ago
I'll be seeing them tonight live in Argentina!! Can't wait!
FrankoZappa 1 year ago
what a shitty crowd lol
francky101 1 year ago
Its normal that his voice doesnt exactly the same, he recorded this song nearly 30 years ago, our voice gets deeper when we get older, he just cant hit the high notes he used to back in the days, Geddy lee doesnt have the high pich voice he had back then, not as much at least, but he still has a good voice.
insid3rkill3r 1 year ago
@insid3rkill3r Yeah I agree some of their older songs really don't fit his voice well anymore, red barchetta being on of them imo.
Annonymus121 1 year ago
Was it louder than in the video?
TomShutter4 1 year ago
I went to the one in Seattle. I guess Geddy gets tired or somethin after a bit. Cause he sounded a lot more....Cracked?.....I don't know the word....But he sounds A LOT better here considering it was the first show.
Still none the less, freakin amazing show still.
Chaotix425 1 year ago
This has got to be one of the best rock songs ever. Its so complex yet sounds so good. Hard to believe these 3 guys created it 30yrs ago. I used to think drums and bass playing was for the dummies in the band until I heard these guys. Geddy's voice is not as good as it used to be but he's almost 60. Other than that their all better than ever.
phdgraffiti 1 year ago
I'll be at the Atlanta show in Sept..Cant wait I have waited 20 yrs for this..American but Grew up in Brazil listening to them and they would never come there because they usually would not play on open stadiums...well they went to Rio a few yrs ago but I was already in the US and no shows around. Now I'm in Afghanistan and will be on leave in Sept to go watch it. OH MAN..got the tickets last week. The wife and I are going...Yesss AWESOME the sound that 3 guys can do do uh? Neil is Da man!
zecarioca2 1 year ago 2
@zecarioca2 Nice story, glad you're finally getting your chance. Be safe over there. Hope you enjoy the show.
Javdoc 1 year ago
Seeing them Sunday. Fucking stoked!
Aaronmac404 1 year ago
I'm looking forward to rocking to this tonight at the Rush concert!!!
JulzPlanet 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
CALL LOCAL ROCK FM RADIO STATIONS AND REQUEST Rush SONG "Caravan"!
RUSH1200 1 year ago
apes on the big screen in the beginning of the vid lol
TheMigster87 1 year ago
claydogg2006...what row were you in while recording this?? trying to get an idea of how i'll be able to see in the 18th row at allentown this year. was in the 9th row at hershey in 2008 and had a really good view.
sfservice75 1 year ago
I WAS HERE!!!
Satonica 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Call LOCAL ROCK RADIO STATIONS AND REQUEST "Caravan"!
LAST WEEK #5 ON THE CHARTS...#1....
RUSH1200 1 year ago
holy shit...his voice took a dive after the mid 80s but wtf?! he sounds great in this video!
PeeceSells 1 year ago
i hate all that stupid dancing big al does durning song.. but big als the man
earlymtv 1 year ago
Hey guys check out our band Panacea. We are heavily influenced by Rush. Please subscribe and we accept ALL friend requests. We already have a few videos out there.
PanaceaSJBR 1 year ago
ya get to see these guys at the new york state fair next month! cant wait
stupid173 1 year ago
Brilliant! crowd are very subdued compared to European audiences though. Pretty sure they're into it big time anyway
SixxBitch13 1 year ago
Very good-sized crowd for the concert. Awesome song!
rshcry24 1 year ago
hahahahaha Neil on guitars... Alex on bass and Geddy on drums, I^m sure that they will play very well.
santyrush 1 year ago
should have the user name "no brainer77,no brains no glory
rainsize 1 year ago
@77Brainer77 60 wow where you get that?,anyways who in the hell are you to tell me not to complain about Rush? you and your kind can fuck off asswipe stick to hiding on your computer?...coward.I'll say what I want about the band asshole you and no one else has to like but don't tell me about who to complain ok?i'll let you get back to your rockband game..ok shithead
rainsize 1 year ago
@77Brainer77 WOW HOW LONG IT TAKE YOU TO PUT THAT ONE TOGETHER,BY THWE WAY I WAS A RUSH FAN FOR NEARLY 34 YEARS AND SPENT ALOT OF MONEY AT THEIR SHOWS STILL HAVE CREEM&CIRCUS,MUSIC EXPRESS MAGAZINE ARTICLES AND INTERVIEWS ABOUT RUSH FROM 1976'77'78'79'80,SO THERE'S NOTHING YOU CAN TWELL ME ABOUT RUSH,WHEN DID YOU LISTEN SNAKES,AND ARROWS,OR COUNTERPARTS WHEN THEY FINALLY STARTED TO SELLOUT WITH THEIR BS CDS?
rainsize 1 year ago
@77Brainer77 NOW,NOW JUST BECAUSE RUSH MAKES MONEY IN AMERICA THERE'S NO NEED FOR THAT,HELL NO YOU DUMB FUCKING HYMIE I DON'T DO NIGGER WEED OR GET HIGH YOU FUCKING RETARD FUCK YOUR ARE PISSED BECAUSE I SET YOU UP YOU FUCKING DUMB ASSHOLE TELL ME YOU ARE ONE OF THE CHIMPS IN THE VIDEO,LMFAO
rainsize 1 year ago
BRAINER77,THE MASTER OF THE GENE POOL FUCK HOW DO YOU EXIST? YOU PICE OF DOGSHIT?
rainsize 1 year ago
@rainsize ya spelt "piece" wrong.
bllpg9 1 year ago
@bllpg9 Y'ALL RIGHT ABOUT THAT KEYBOARD ACTS UP
rainsize 1 year ago
@rainsize what the fuck? xD
bllpg9 1 year ago
@77Brainer77 HAHA,MADE YOU BELIEVE SO MUCH FOR BEING BRAINER77 FUCK YER STUPID..LMFAO YOU IDIOT
rainsize 1 year ago
I wanted to see them in KC last night...but after viewing people's concert footage, I was shocked that mature, older fans, still stand up and even on their sets throughout the concert. Can't we all just sit down and enjoy the show without acting like 17 year old kids. Please!!
jeffs1000 1 year ago
@jeffs1000,sorry to hear that what a bunch of imbeciles
rainsize 1 year ago
I still say they are the best American band out there
rainsize 1 year ago
@rainsize what?
faithless1969 1 year ago
best light show i have seen from them. awesome show
CRD26 1 year ago
was nice being a rush fan for o33years now its time to say see ya rush you are the best american band out there bar none,too bad you gave up touring canada,but maybe its for the best.
rainsize 1 year ago
@rainsize What are you talking about? Is that a joke or something. ?
Zivojinovic126 1 year ago
@Zivojinovic126 no i wish it were but since they gave up on Canada,and to concentrate on the Central Canada market(Ontario&Quebec,and the Southern US i guess they don't need my money?.anyways with that said Isupported these guys for a very long time,so yes I shall critize them afterall,spent hundreds of dollars at their shows so I have that right
rainsize 1 year ago
im seeing rush tomorrow nite on the KC date motha trucka
ogdensrule 1 year ago
Excellent sound quality!!
marshjvm 1 year ago