@MrsMoonshine8 There's only one syllable difference - a search find both versions. Actually "one luminary clock" gets more hits - and makes more sense.
I'd probably better have written "a luminary clock", indeed. But I wanted to show that the "a luminary clock" would fit the sentence more, grammatically, than "o luminary clock": that's why I wrote the rest, for context. And I agree with "one luminary clock"; I wonder how the writer himself thought about it, what his original idea was, etc. He must've had multiple versions of the poem or a part of it, as most writers.
Too beautiful. I enjoyed your analysis link, as well. I'm not put off by analysis, I like considering others' views and interpretations, even those with which I disagree. I remain capable of forming my own. There's little more I wish of a poem than that it lend itself to multiple interpretations and many readings. Perhaps someone to read it aloud to me perfectly? Wish fulfilled. Thank you again.
You have a really beautiful voice that captures the ambiguity between the opposites Frost is playing upon, unstressing where some would have stressed. It's always a pleasure to listen to you. I'm so happy I found your channel.
I love this poem. I've never written, but i've been lurking around your page SpokenVerse - I love the poems.And i'd like to say thank you for putting the time and effort! This one poem in perticular means a lot to me. I'd like to say that interpertations are dangerous things - academics muddle the experience. This is for individuals to sort through and find their own personal meaning.
great poem. im a little wary of the linked analysis. sometimes its nice to be pointed in a suggested direction, and sometimes there is probably only one true interpretation based on the circumstance of the poets then present life. But like the author of the analysis said, this poem is wide open to interpretation from numerous approaches. take it where you want and enjoy it.
Actually I agree. I avoid analysis of poems believing that they are what they are and mean different things to different people. The notes I make are usually just informative, facetious or provocative.
At the same time I know that poems are often inflicted on students who have to turn in something they have written about them...
I thought it was "And further still at an unearthly height, a luminary clock against the sky proclaimed [...]
MrsMoonshine8 5 months ago
@MrsMoonshine8 There's only one syllable difference - a search find both versions. Actually "one luminary clock" gets more hits - and makes more sense.
SpokenVerse 5 months ago
@SpokenVerse
I'd probably better have written "a luminary clock", indeed. But I wanted to show that the "a luminary clock" would fit the sentence more, grammatically, than "o luminary clock": that's why I wrote the rest, for context. And I agree with "one luminary clock"; I wonder how the writer himself thought about it, what his original idea was, etc. He must've had multiple versions of the poem or a part of it, as most writers.
MrsMoonshine8 5 months ago
his voice makes me sleepy (not that it's a bad thing)
Evaspie 6 months ago
antagonising mute might have a heartfelt pity on the boy - but a stage it is.
just a small but momentous fall back to reality
"Go and enjoy yourself",Oh i'll have plenty of company of course, the people i 'chat with' though will wonder,
As for I, I know too well,
no more falling,
this bottomless pit does have an end ,
and here i've gone beyond dreaming
conorbolger12345 10 months ago
frost inspired me to write my first poem: 'Just give him our regards'
A birthday They say,
a 'joyous' occasion that on this day a boy is a man,
his voice will Deepen, his shoulders will Seperate evan more.
A landmark that distances the men from the boys.
The stage is set, the boys,cracking the jokes,havin' the banter, but one stands out,
a man though boy at heart overwhelmed by the attention he hungared for,
that a relief from the (continous next comment)
conorbolger12345 10 months ago
Too beautiful. I enjoyed your analysis link, as well. I'm not put off by analysis, I like considering others' views and interpretations, even those with which I disagree. I remain capable of forming my own. There's little more I wish of a poem than that it lend itself to multiple interpretations and many readings. Perhaps someone to read it aloud to me perfectly? Wish fulfilled. Thank you again.
thissong4you 1 year ago
You have a really beautiful voice that captures the ambiguity between the opposites Frost is playing upon, unstressing where some would have stressed. It's always a pleasure to listen to you. I'm so happy I found your channel.
keytoothed 1 year ago
beautifull combination with Atkinson Grimshaw... placed into my playlist of the artist, thanks
meesterschilders 1 year ago
Thank you. I had better confess that I photoshopped the last painting a little to fit the format.
SpokenVerse 1 year ago
This is beautiful.
ClaireLovesCritters 2 years ago
In the hermit phase of my life (now past) I
walked at night a lot. It felt necessary. When I hear this poem I see those city streets, though I live far from them now. Thank you for posting this.
drivenfool 2 years ago
Nice reading. Love the painting at the end.
gdprosper 2 years ago
I love this poem. I've never written, but i've been lurking around your page SpokenVerse - I love the poems.And i'd like to say thank you for putting the time and effort! This one poem in perticular means a lot to me. I'd like to say that interpertations are dangerous things - academics muddle the experience. This is for individuals to sort through and find their own personal meaning.
KenyanKid417 2 years ago
great poem. im a little wary of the linked analysis. sometimes its nice to be pointed in a suggested direction, and sometimes there is probably only one true interpretation based on the circumstance of the poets then present life. But like the author of the analysis said, this poem is wide open to interpretation from numerous approaches. take it where you want and enjoy it.
bmoneydestroyer 2 years ago
Actually I agree. I avoid analysis of poems believing that they are what they are and mean different things to different people. The notes I make are usually just informative, facetious or provocative.
At the same time I know that poems are often inflicted on students who have to turn in something they have written about them...
SpokenVerse 2 years ago
Excelent poem I love that pic well done thank you
fallbread 2 years ago
THIS IS A GREAT POEM! Thanks for that link with the analysis!
homousios 2 years ago
Great poem. The analysis you linked was useful too. Thanks.
jtbovis 2 years ago
Wow! Great one! I wish I understood it. Going over to the analysis to see what's going on in this poem. Thanks, Spoken.
scifiwritir 2 years ago