Carly Smithson - Without You - American Idol Top 7

[GabbySayese]

thumbs u if you think james durbin is better then carly...... just saying ^___^

[mrpark505]

she looks like Prue Haliwell in "Charmed " :D

[TwisterFlipp95]

Oh, this was much better than James.

[jdanjd57]

Now I appreciate Carly even more since I listened to James' version and I love James completely but Carly did amazing. The more I hear others the more I realize what a fantastic job she did on this song.

[Matshoppahulle]

@jdanjd57 Carly makes a good cover.

Mariah Carey,and Harry Nilson ( US no.1) made it better.

[jdanjd57]

@Matshoppahulle Yes they did, however, Carly did a wonderful job

[takakupo]

Carly Smithson owns this song when it comes to Idol :]

[nikaledesma]

or a song that has too much styling

[nikaledesma]

the problem about this girl is her voice is difficult to complement current songs. but vocally she was best vocalist that season

[kenkenka]

i can still remember back in 2008, after watching this performance, i said what a poor girl chose a wrong song making a disaster.

[elreydelwideox]

KENNN LEEEEE Talibu Dibu Douchooooooooo

[iambarbara]

Ann Wilson sang this song on Magazine album, from 1978.

[starcommand84]

KENNN LEEEEE Talibu dibu Douchoooooo

[Theblackprincess08]

mariah carey is better!

[Withinscars]

Great voice, this song is so hard to sing

[mommasguy]

Mariah Carey's Version is The Best!

[i2l3e4a5n6a]

i wish american idol would have another mariah week

[Ikurun]

@i2l3e4a5n6a I wish American idol would have a no-ballad week. =P

[GinyLiebt0]

she's like kelly's version of without you

[ferror]

carly should be at least in the top 5

[CS2DFANZER]

awesome

[nikkhil3]

Its great :D

[raphee13]

what more worst than leona lewis version..

[timio6436]

Wow she has an extremly deep voice! I dont like her

[cbotten106]

I loved it. Mariah loved it.  Simon...? 2out of3 ain't bad.

[jlakaseyfan]

My fave mariah carey song! Carly was awesome on it!!!!!!! I cant believe she got voted off!!!! It was sooooooo wrong!

[osahju914]

this song didnt get her booted, the week after did, lord knows why?????

[osahju914]

this song is actually a "badfinger" song from 1970, 20 years before mariah did it. harry nillson made it big in 1973, and, 17 years later, mariah did it