Good one!! Makes sense to me! The only odd thing about it, maybe, is the goofy lyrics... I would guess that would be because the (presumed) minstrel song character "Johnny Boker" has been completely forgotten and replaced by the mondegreen "jolly poker"...and it's a slippery slope from there!
I just think that singing the same three lines over again would get tiring almost as fast as the hauling!
It's an interesting book if you've never taken a look at it -- it's mostly ballads, but it also has a somewhat different "Haul on the Bowline" used for dragging stone to the construction site of a cathedral in St. John's.
I see what you mean! Then again, some people are content with "1, 2, 3, pull!"! I have a "theory" that chanties got less varied (within a single performance, that is) as the form was transfered from one cultural group and setting to another. The earliest chantying as we know it seems to have been completely incidental and improvised in its verses. It was the custom and aesthetic of African music, I argue. Not saying that is necessarily relevant here, tho.
I'm glad you enjoy listening to these! I get some from books, some from field recordings, some from revival recordings, and some from other singers I've met. This one came from the book I mentioned in the description.
Good one!! Makes sense to me! The only odd thing about it, maybe, is the goofy lyrics... I would guess that would be because the (presumed) minstrel song character "Johnny Boker" has been completely forgotten and replaced by the mondegreen "jolly poker"...and it's a slippery slope from there!
Great addition.
hultonclint 1 year ago
@hultonclint
I just think that singing the same three lines over again would get tiring almost as fast as the hauling!
It's an interesting book if you've never taken a look at it -- it's mostly ballads, but it also has a somewhat different "Haul on the Bowline" used for dragging stone to the construction site of a cathedral in St. John's.
StatenIslandFolkie 1 year ago
@StatenIslandFolkie
I see what you mean! Then again, some people are content with "1, 2, 3, pull!"! I have a "theory" that chanties got less varied (within a single performance, that is) as the form was transfered from one cultural group and setting to another. The earliest chantying as we know it seems to have been completely incidental and improvised in its verses. It was the custom and aesthetic of African music, I argue. Not saying that is necessarily relevant here, tho.
hultonclint 1 year ago
do enjoy listening to these, where do you find the material?
STUTREE 1 year ago
@STUTREE
I'm glad you enjoy listening to these! I get some from books, some from field recordings, some from revival recordings, and some from other singers I've met. This one came from the book I mentioned in the description.
StatenIslandFolkie 1 year ago