I still watch this performance since 2 years ago because it was so amazing I felt her. Felt that she means these lyrics. !! Damn Simon and his arrogance ! She was the full package and they have no idea what they lost
Siobhan is the first ever American Idol to write, record, release, produce and develop her own independent album under her own label and publishing company. Wow, this girl is just 21 years old? What a courage and sense of conviction. Her much awaited album "Moonbaby" is now available on Amazon and Itunes. Support the most talented and most intelligent idol to ever walk on AI stage!!! Listening to her album took me to another dimension :)
did you guys see the girl with peackock earings she is siobhans sister and she is also my boys and girls club staff she sing just as well as siobhan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@EST0KES yeah that would have been cool especially w/ J Lo adn Steven (who is also from Mass.) they or at least would've loved her. but I don't think they can come back once they are actually on the show can they?
I watch this after all this time and have to rate it with one of the best idol performances ever...right up there with adams mad world...absolutely awesome and brings tears to the eyes!
That girl can BLOW! Sorry but that white girl got some crazy soul to her voice, she betta sang. She would give Christina A a run for her money. She reminds me of Kelly Clarkson!
Watch Chrislyn Hamilton singing Think on Australian Idol.
I love Siobhan, but her stylised screaming can become annoying because the rest of her voice is nasal, breathy and really not the strongest. Most of her performances are like Mary Poppins singing the first half, then Robert Plant belting out one or two sustained notes at the end.
i dont think theres another person who can love siobhan magnus as i do thts auditioning for american idol its a new season if one of my faves lose im done watching it
And there we see Simon, not even caring to turn around when she goes behind the judges. What a close-minded, rude jack*ss. I always supported his opinions until season 9. Simply because he and the Idol staff rigged Siobhan's chances should NOT impact her career. At 1:01 , he is being a disrespectful jerk. Screw him AND Kara.
@iBenjafied well all these people can't be wrong... who do U think is better...hopefully it's nto C-0Sux! she was a 1 trick pony! that is all! a copy-cat of Bonnie Rait.
American Idol has gone downhill from the moment Siobhan was eliminated and I'm sure the show will be cursed if not cancelled. I don't see the new judges lasting more than a season.
@alabamabregan I was addicted to this show but now I think I broke that after Siobhan! She is as good as it gets! All natural, all talent, total Awesomeness! AI will never be the same! AI needs to give her an Honorary Idol record deal...then I will watch it again!
she's the most unique of all female singers.... she's noy the diva type an has amazing voice tone............. she's cute and her talent was flawless....... she shud've won.............
Screw Simon and Kara. Simon is such an ***. You have to be a true rude individual not to even look at Siobhan as she passes by. He acts like she's not even performing. Then when Ryan says, "Go give him a hug...Go give Simon a hug...", she is reluctant because she knows what he did to her. She also didn't want to touch that scumbag Kara who can not tell the difference between screaming and excellently high singing.
Her sister is incredibly pissed off, because I know I was, and I knew that those votes went over to that stupid idiot Aaron kid, because Siobhan was never in the Bottom 3. She should have been the winner, but what do you know Teenagers these days voting for their hot looks on this show, duhhh who won? A "cute" guy, i'm sorry but Siobhan was wayy better than him, the judges and stupid Kara just kept throwing in negative comments to her so people wouldn't vote for her. She's the real winner.
Guys, don't not watch Idol because of one season, watch the next few. hope is interesting goes on the show, because without those people Idol is boring as hell without those people Idol is boring as hell
i have no reason to watch american idol because siobhan magnus is gone on that competition.....america is deaf and blind you dont know the real voice..her voice is brilliant,.,
Everyone who wins Idol sucks anyway. Siobhan went out in style with one of her best performances. Lee is a nice guy, but as a singer, he's a joke. Crystal and Siobhan out sang him and everyone else by a mile.
Aaron - Woa, are Americans crazy? Or is America crazy?
Casey - Safe and boring, and guess what? The complete opposite of Siobhan
Mike - He's alright, but... Siobhan is a million times better than him
Crystal and Lee? Let's see.
Anyway, how did all three of them actually get more votes than this wonderful young talented amazing artist who will with no doubt have a sucessful career, and hopefully more than the winner!
Siobhan will be a million nautical miles than the winner of American Idol Season 9!!! She's the best and so what if she got eliminated?!?! Siobhan will be the best Idol for this season!!!
They say the way you depart from Idol will define your post Idol career. Siobhan left the show with class, poise and a strong performance. I cannot find another instance of a contestant walking down from the stage to hug their families after finishing their performance, or saying goodbye to the judges as Siobhan did, it was classy and poignant. It also showed a side of her that most people did not get, that she is a family person who cares about peopl
ust loved it...I miss Siobhan soo much..I stop watching AI for now and will be watching on the forthcoming FINALE:D love Siobhan Magnus...
Im Forever will be a Siobhans True FanI just Love her, I just miss her sooo much and I just Adored her as alwaysLove her and I hope she will have a Successful Career ahead of her and I know she can do it because shes now a STAR Keep doin your Thing Siobhan coz a lot of people and fans will definitely support you in your MUSIC CAREERLove yah:D
shes so awesome she got a career ahead of her a big one i think and americans are idiots and i am one lmao also idk which think performance was better lmao there both awesome
at the first siobhan was unnoticed but when she sang living for the city she became noticeable and the rest of her performance was epic except through the fire!
kk im an enormous Siobhan fan, i was real pissed, but whats all this about the facebook page thing? I doubt people are gonna vote for her on her facebook page, ther either gonna vote from the tv airing or from somewhere else. Seriously, she got voted off (which is retarded) cause it was a huge fluke, bot for a few people looking at her facebook page
hey Guys... do you know the moment Siobhan was out in the show... American IDOL significantly dropped their ratings since 2002. The lowest audience share ever!!! Poor Siobhan she was the best one out there.. I really thought that Americans are rooting for her... but well Americans are IDIOTS!
Idol is paying for their mistake with their crappy ratings. They posted THE WRONG NUMBER on Siobhan's Facebook and people actually voted for Aaron the night Siobhan was eliminated even when Siobhan was never in the Bottom 3. This is not a singing competition anymore.. After 10 Seasons now the judges say they are looking for "Artists". Even Britney Spears can be an artist.
Don't watch American Idol this season if you care about sweet and talented 19 year-old Siobhan. Spread this information!!!
Like many of you, I only watched American Idol this season, because Siobhan caught my attention. I wasn't impressed with any of the other contestants, only she stuck out from the rest. I'm tired of hearing people saying all she did was scream. That's BS. She has an incredible vocal range! She was unique, and true to herself. Apparently Idol didn't like that. Well, she doesn't need them. She got her exposure, now it's on to bigger and better things. Good luck Siobhan!
@mirrorimage98 she has indeed the spirit of a champion and is in peace with herself. She is so bold and original,and so true to herself !. She reminds me as an artist and in versatility the young Barbra Streisand. Though they have different voices they have similar charisma and dramatic sense.
Simon has gone too far. Not looking at her during this, not even wanting to hug her, and being so rude and biased towards her during the entire competition. Screw him; she's the best!
She totally rocked her last performance, had fun with it, shoved it in Simon & Kara's faces ( 0:40 ) that they were wrong, and now she's going to go on and show America (and the world, I'm from Canada :D) what she's got and what they let go of. I love you Siobhan!! And I'm not watching the show until she comes on for the finale, and I'm going to the tour this summer :D
Her beautiful sister looks very disappointed. I'm gonna miss 1:18, it's longer than the first one. She's the only one who dresses fashionably and interacts with the viewers totally.
see the judges should have used the save on TRUE TALENT which is Siobhan. While Mike may sound okay, he does not have a potential to create albums that will fly off the shelves like Siobhan could.
@IanROX22 From my understanding and what I've heard at least, a facebook fan page for Siobhan had listed the wrong number to call, so many that thought they were voting for Siobhan were really calling the number for Aaron.
@SmAshleyK47 I know and its so horrible! AI is definitely rigged. Notice how throughout the season she was trying to be herself rather than fitting the judges ideals of what they wanted her to be. She went to my high school and she has always stood out as a strong independent person. Nothing is gonna change her world and she will be more successful than any of them who are left in the long run.
i got upset seeing she is the one being voted out....personally i go for lee...but watching her perform for the last time makes wonder she could be part of my top 3 with lee,..she make me cry..and totally make me cry when she hug one by one her family member.that was awesome....you got the talent siobhan make it live don't let it die...love the performance think....
I mean.. C'mon... Not fair AT ALL.. I think all the people watch American Idol for Siobhan. I know that I DO. She deserves to STAY NOT LEAVE. She has the BEST Voice I have ever heard. And screw the judges. They Confused her, they DO NOT know what they want from her. Once they want the screaming, the second they don't. You're GREAT. Can't WAIT for your CD :) and well... I think Simon kinda wanted her to stay. duno. Good Luck Anyway :)
@cwgreen89 Absolutely. Broadway is where she belongs. Not polluting the airwaves with her terrible death-shriek. We got Christina Aguilera for that one...
this video inspires me so much... although i am very sad that she was eliminated out, it still makes me happy seeing her smiling and looking so happy even when its her last performance. This shows us that she didn't join American Idol for fame, but because she enjoyed singing. From this, I know that if she carries on with her singing career, i will support Siobhan!
i really cant sleep on that night when siobhan got voted off.. and in the morning still thinking of her... T.T i love you siobhan! you still number one! i wonder why always guys who always left there? though crystal is still there. some voters i think is looking for cute guys rather than voice!
i almost cried when she got voted off. its such crap. i think she is the best one the show so now i really hope that Lee wins ony because crystal just doesnt appeal to me.
Wait, wait, wait! THIS was the performance she got voted off for? She slayed this song!!! This is precisely why I don't like AI; it kills off all the actual talent.
@autumnrose3 Uhm, the contestants can actually choose what song they're going to sing on the night of their elimination, she performed this during the top 20, the song she got voted off for was "Any Man of Mine". America is stupid. She shouldn't have been voted off.
@PigTailCurler Ohh, ok. Like I said, not an AI fan. I don't watch it. My mom does and didn't like Siobhan, and then I saw her in the news because Hanson invited her to come to their 5of5, and I youtubed her to see how she sounded.. I think she sounds fantastic! Oh well... at least now she's free to do what she wants wherever she gets signed, and we'll see a cd sooner.
I think what happened is people thought Siobhan was going to be safe so they decided to vote for someone who was not as popular. Well anyway, she really killed it when she left, when out with a bang, showed people that she didn't deserve to go home. My top two are Lee and Crystal, vote for both!
And BTW Siobhan would NOT want you to stop watching the show just because she got voted off!
i really don't like that note when she says "doctor." it sounds off. it makes sense for her to sing this song. "Think" made her an Idol frontrunner, but IMO, she would have done better if she chose Wicked Games or House of the Rising Sun. It would have been the perfect swan song. Goodbye Siobhan. You were my favorite and my only reason for watching the show.
I don't know if you guys realised but think is actually a song for the judges! Analyse the lyrics that she sang this time... she shorten it a little bit... and she made the note longer... "YOU BETTER THINK"...
@bjchabzroxy You're right :) I did when I saw her... And see how she advance towards them? I think it was for DeGuardi and Cowell rather than Jackson and Ellen.
i've read on some posts days ago that siobhan's facebook account has wrong information on number to vote.. it says 1(866)436-5705 and 11 instead of 06 and 12. they've reported it but still ignored, they dont wonder why siobhan has big chance to be voted off.. wont watch AI this season anymore, the best got voted off..
im actually happy for her to leave the "crystal bowersox show"..! now she's so ready to rock her own stage.. i'll be on the first line to buy your cd..! rock it SIOBHAN!!!!!
Best version of "Think" out there. Even better than Aretha's, Kathrine McPhee's or Kelly Clarkson's. I love you Siobhan! You don't need to win to be successful... Most winners aren't successful: Reuben, Jordan and that white hair dude. You will be the most successful out of everyone this season. The others are just plain and boring.
What the F??American Idol Lost their asset on the show...Siobhan Magnus is the ONLY person we are watching in this show and now that she's gone, WhoElse to watch???
I still watch this performance since 2 years ago because it was so amazing I felt her. Felt that she means these lyrics. !! Damn Simon and his arrogance ! She was the full package and they have no idea what they lost
MAFK93 1 week ago
miss this girl!
homewake 1 week ago
Every time I watch this I feel her. :(
mattimeo02 2 weeks ago
Siobhan is the first ever American Idol to write, record, release, produce and develop her own independent album under her own label and publishing company. Wow, this girl is just 21 years old? What a courage and sense of conviction. Her much awaited album "Moonbaby" is now available on Amazon and Itunes. Support the most talented and most intelligent idol to ever walk on AI stage!!! Listening to her album took me to another dimension :)
onlineconcept 1 month ago
She owned America the two times she sang that song.
alabamabregan 2 months ago
That Top 5 looks so dull without her.
kamilzlotnik 3 months ago
Her sister looked really jealous that Siobhan was on stage.. :/
HollyKalina23 3 months ago in playlist Amazing Singers :)
@HollyKalina23 no no no. She wasn't jealous, she was upset because Siobhan was voted off. She was singing 'THINK" as her farewell song. It was sad.
Jimbojub 3 months ago
@HollyKalina23 no, she loves Siobahn & is 1 of her biggest fans and supporters. she even started her fansite didn't she?
generationaluv 3 months ago
She was the WINNER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
purpleporter 4 months ago
I like Diana DeGarmo singing it better :/
dollar49 5 months ago
AWESOME LADY
blackunicorn9000 6 months ago
did you guys see the girl with peackock earings she is siobhans sister and she is also my boys and girls club staff she sing just as well as siobhan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hannahandkkbffs 6 months ago
awesome awesome
blackunicorn9000 6 months ago
i like her shoes :3 they rock!
silvicurlytop 8 months ago
Damn she shoulda come back this year.
EST0KES 9 months ago
@EST0KES yeah that would have been cool especially w/ J Lo adn Steven (who is also from Mass.) they or at least would've loved her. but I don't think they can come back once they are actually on the show can they?
generationaluv 6 months ago
@generationaluv No, if they make it to the top 24, they can't try out again :(
simpsonsfanatic777 6 months ago
Amazing !!!
AddictKaskus 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Go to my channel and watch her new single :))
phuctran107 9 months ago
She should have won that season!!!!!
magico008 10 months ago 4
I love her hair here. And her sister was cute when she protested the elimination. :D
Kainosielu 10 months ago
Intelligent choice of song;D
weirdgoldilocks 10 months ago
I watch this after all this time and have to rate it with one of the best idol performances ever...right up there with adams mad world...absolutely awesome and brings tears to the eyes!
SpartanLegion300 11 months ago
the fact is.. siobhan magnus is one and only unforgtabble contestant of season 9!
SuperJohnkevin 11 months ago 6
She reminds of Kelly Clarkson both white girls got soul and can BLOW BLOW all day everyday!
kmaur21 11 months ago
1:18 I think is a B5 or C6 thats sick how effortless she did that. Lol she did a Patti here too.
kmaur21 11 months ago
@kmaur21 her range is crazy
bowiehs 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bowiehs Sure is, that girl something else!
kmaur21 11 months ago
@kmaur21 It's a Bb5, incredible!
HighNoteFanatic 11 months ago
She pulled a Lashun Pace Rhodes/ Karen Clark Sheard 1:18 girl been listening to them gospel girls!
kmaur21 11 months ago
Man this girl can BLOW!!!!!!!!!!!!
kmaur21 11 months ago
That girl can BLOW! Sorry but that white girl got some crazy soul to her voice, she betta sang. She would give Christina A a run for her money. She reminds me of Kelly Clarkson!
kmaur21 11 months ago
Watch Chrislyn Hamilton singing Think on Australian Idol.
I love Siobhan, but her stylised screaming can become annoying because the rest of her voice is nasal, breathy and really not the strongest. Most of her performances are like Mary Poppins singing the first half, then Robert Plant belting out one or two sustained notes at the end.
EmilieSagae 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
UPDATE SIOBHAN MAGNUS ON HER OFFICIAL SITE:
smagnus.com
mommasguy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If only Simon was still part of the show.
torkeljen 1 year ago
If only Simon was still part of the show.
torkeljen 1 year ago
glad simon is out in AI
madarm 1 year ago
i dont think theres another person who can love siobhan magnus as i do thts auditioning for american idol its a new season if one of my faves lose im done watching it
BaByV101100 1 year ago
And there we see Simon, not even caring to turn around when she goes behind the judges. What a close-minded, rude jack*ss. I always supported his opinions until season 9. Simply because he and the Idol staff rigged Siobhan's chances should NOT impact her career. At 1:01 , he is being a disrespectful jerk. Screw him AND Kara.
Anyway, Siobhan is AWESOME.
evilportrait 1 year ago 2
@evilportrait I agree totally! I am soo gald he is history now!!! hope all his shows are "utter failures!"
generationaluv 1 year ago
@generationaluv 1:18 betta sing like Aretha! She got that church soul girl can blow!
kmaur21 11 months ago
@kmaur21 yeah, Aretha is the Queen but damn if Siobhan ain't the Princess!
generationaluv 11 months ago 3
Siobhan has such a nice voice. Why people vote her as the bottom? Now she's not in the compeition. ): Siobhan, I felt so sad for you.
KrazieeKelli 1 year ago
Kelly still is the best to me.
zjeemvel 1 year ago
@iBenjafied well all these people can't be wrong... who do U think is better...hopefully it's nto C-0Sux! she was a 1 trick pony! that is all! a copy-cat of Bonnie Rait.
generationaluv 1 year ago
she's the best ! her voice is so amazing... !!!!
gille2303 1 year ago
America did not think about who to vote for
whitesoxbuff 1 year ago
She should have been one of the finalist....:(
mgcustado06 1 year ago
very good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
suziegr 1 year ago
i love siobhan she awsome im her # 1 fan she should have won i love her scream.
fashinrckstr12 1 year ago
i loved siobhan im her # 1 fan she should have one shes awsome siobhan magnus fan forever i love her voice.
fashinrckstr12 1 year ago
to me she was so damn cute and i love the way she was true to herself and a little quirky...lol...but very cute girl!
PrinceTian 1 year ago
American Idol has gone downhill from the moment Siobhan was eliminated and I'm sure the show will be cursed if not cancelled. I don't see the new judges lasting more than a season.
alabamabregan 1 year ago
@alabamabregan I was addicted to this show but now I think I broke that after Siobhan! She is as good as it gets! All natural, all talent, total Awesomeness! AI will never be the same! AI needs to give her an Honorary Idol record deal...then I will watch it again!
generationaluv 1 year ago
I can't watch this video without getting PISSED!!....YOU WERE RIPPED OFF SIOBHAN!!!
rockinstien 1 year ago 6
OMG! I learned how to hit that note by watching her!
Twilightgirl56863 1 year ago
I like her outfit yeah...
but these is the most idiot,and all that can describe my feeling to this
Siobhan's Elimination Fuck
Fuck America
America is idiot!!
mommasguy 1 year ago
Comment removed
mommasguy 1 year ago
i'm gonna cry :'( she deserves to win
judygugu 1 year ago
@judygugu no duh
Twilightgirl56863 1 year ago
I can't imagine how boring it must have been to watch this show after her elimination
qg6ff 1 year ago
@qg6ff Luckly krystal didn't win
Twilightgirl56863 1 year ago
She should've screamed the lyrics of this song to Kara and Simon...
"You better think, think about what you're doing to me!"
They're letting her down for being unique.
koyamagen 1 year ago
As good as it gets!
generationaluv 1 year ago 4
AMAZINGLY AWESOME :D
davidintheworld 1 year ago 3
she's the most unique of all female singers.... she's noy the diva type an has amazing voice tone............. she's cute and her talent was flawless....... she shud've won.............
jeremymoonwalker 1 year ago 4
@jeremymoonwalker I agree
Twilightgirl56863 1 year ago
Would have absolutely loved it if Siobhan did the scream in front of Simon's face. But she's too much of a good person to do that. Love her
LeonChaos18 1 year ago 6
I don't know how anyone can take their eyes off of her! She has it all!
generationaluv 1 year ago 48
@generationaluv totally agreez
blackunicorn9000 6 months ago
how can she leave wow
blackunicorn9000 6 months ago
@blackunicorn9000 yeah, she is so talented and sexy! should've definitely won in 2010!
generationaluv 6 months ago
Very emotional part of the show.
Screw Simon and Kara. Simon is such an ***. You have to be a true rude individual not to even look at Siobhan as she passes by. He acts like she's not even performing. Then when Ryan says, "Go give him a hug...Go give Simon a hug...", she is reluctant because she knows what he did to her. She also didn't want to touch that scumbag Kara who can not tell the difference between screaming and excellently high singing.
Go Siobhan! Make a CD!
evilportrait 1 year ago 13
Her sister is incredibly pissed off, because I know I was, and I knew that those votes went over to that stupid idiot Aaron kid, because Siobhan was never in the Bottom 3. She should have been the winner, but what do you know Teenagers these days voting for their hot looks on this show, duhhh who won? A "cute" guy, i'm sorry but Siobhan was wayy better than him, the judges and stupid Kara just kept throwing in negative comments to her so people wouldn't vote for her. She's the real winner.
yusuckass8 1 year ago 6
siobhan always gets teary-eyed when someone gets eliminated...
when it was her time, she didn't even shed a tear..
she's surely gonna go further than the rest of the season 9's idols.
MrQwerty8969 1 year ago 49
@MrQwerty8969 hell yeahhhh!
OJLuscious 1 year ago
@MrQwerty8969 Did any of the season 9er's go anywhere? ;)
acode909 7 months ago
That fucking NOTE.... chills just erupted down my whole body when she hit that.
athousandstrats 1 year ago 7
Uber Cutey!
generationaluv 1 year ago
Guys, don't not watch Idol because of one season, watch the next few. hope is interesting goes on the show, because without those people Idol is boring as hell without those people Idol is boring as hell
Azelf3 1 year ago
i have no reason to watch american idol because siobhan magnus is gone on that competition.....america is deaf and blind you dont know the real voice..her voice is brilliant,.,
MegaSaydie 1 year ago
Everyone who wins Idol sucks anyway. Siobhan went out in style with one of her best performances. Lee is a nice guy, but as a singer, he's a joke. Crystal and Siobhan out sang him and everyone else by a mile.
mightyolav 1 year ago 4
the top 3 should have been siobhan, lee and crystal.. damn stupid voters!
123jampack 1 year ago
she was spicy. i liked her! and she got prettier and prettier!! she was robbed a couple more weeks..
also i think her high note here was even alot better than her 1st performance
spotzyglitch 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Katharine McPhee sounded way better than Siobhan on this song!
prelevich 1 year ago
@prelevich It's close, but Sio did a better job to me.
shukigkato 1 year ago
This was dumbest move of the whole season. Could any of the others even get CLOSE to hitting that note?
CodeBoy2494 1 year ago
she was my favorite contestant
99vmgirl 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how fitting, her last note on the show sounded like complete and utter crap.
kcmet79 1 year ago
love U Siobhan!!
Pznarf 1 year ago 3
Let's chop it down:
Aaron - Woa, are Americans crazy? Or is America crazy?
Casey - Safe and boring, and guess what? The complete opposite of Siobhan
Mike - He's alright, but... Siobhan is a million times better than him
Crystal and Lee? Let's see.
Anyway, how did all three of them actually get more votes than this wonderful young talented amazing artist who will with no doubt have a sucessful career, and hopefully more than the winner!
Votes and judges? They're useless!
koyamagen 1 year ago 2
@koyamagen I know right?! you have taken the words right out of my mouth!
MsFantasyMaker 1 year ago
Siobhan will be a million nautical miles than the winner of American Idol Season 9!!! She's the best and so what if she got eliminated?!?! Siobhan will be the best Idol for this season!!!
andrayeiscastiel 1 year ago
well i think siobhan could be like adam lambert, he is much successful than the winner kris allen..
and not all the winners get such a fame..
deadkemo 1 year ago
aaron sucks
chiisuchiananderesu 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
They say the way you depart from Idol will define your post Idol career. Siobhan left the show with class, poise and a strong performance. I cannot find another instance of a contestant walking down from the stage to hug their families after finishing their performance, or saying goodbye to the judges as Siobhan did, it was classy and poignant. It also showed a side of her that most people did not get, that she is a family person who cares about peopl
Karnakthemagnificent 1 year ago
Siohban is the real idol!!!!
Loiginer 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ust loved it...I miss Siobhan soo much..I stop watching AI for now and will be watching on the forthcoming FINALE:D love Siobhan Magnus...
Im Forever will be a Siobhans True FanI just Love her, I just miss her sooo much and I just Adored her as alwaysLove her and I hope she will have a Successful Career ahead of her and I know she can do it because shes now a STAR Keep doin your Thing Siobhan coz a lot of people and fans will definitely support you in your MUSIC CAREERLove yah:D
MagnertSiobLex 1 year ago
you better think americans! that's the message of the song!
mawexduque 1 year ago
shes so awesome she got a career ahead of her a big one i think and americans are idiots and i am one lmao also idk which think performance was better lmao there both awesome
irish97993 1 year ago
now that she's not in idol anymore..i swear never to watch that show again...
0707iam 1 year ago
@0707iam i completely agree! she was incredible!
catie369 1 year ago
at the first siobhan was unnoticed but when she sang living for the city she became noticeable and the rest of her performance was epic except through the fire!
jamelandi 1 year ago
@jamelandi sorry i have clicked the thumbs down
justandhumane 1 year ago
kk im an enormous Siobhan fan, i was real pissed, but whats all this about the facebook page thing? I doubt people are gonna vote for her on her facebook page, ther either gonna vote from the tv airing or from somewhere else. Seriously, she got voted off (which is retarded) cause it was a huge fluke, bot for a few people looking at her facebook page
/end rant
IanROX22 1 year ago
hey Guys... do you know the moment Siobhan was out in the show... American IDOL significantly dropped their ratings since 2002. The lowest audience share ever!!! Poor Siobhan she was the best one out there.. I really thought that Americans are rooting for her... but well Americans are IDIOTS!
BreakPics 1 year ago 2
1:19
beaL03151995 1 year ago
Idol is paying for their mistake with their crappy ratings. They posted THE WRONG NUMBER on Siobhan's Facebook and people actually voted for Aaron the night Siobhan was eliminated even when Siobhan was never in the Bottom 3. This is not a singing competition anymore.. After 10 Seasons now the judges say they are looking for "Artists". Even Britney Spears can be an artist.
Don't watch American Idol this season if you care about sweet and talented 19 year-old Siobhan. Spread this information!!!
ParamoreVzla 1 year ago
OMG!!
zegavazquez11 1 year ago
Jaw dropping... I mean, she's the only highlight for the whole show. Without her, the show is ntg...
clccchucky 1 year ago
Like many of you, I only watched American Idol this season, because Siobhan caught my attention. I wasn't impressed with any of the other contestants, only she stuck out from the rest. I'm tired of hearing people saying all she did was scream. That's BS. She has an incredible vocal range! She was unique, and true to herself. Apparently Idol didn't like that. Well, she doesn't need them. She got her exposure, now it's on to bigger and better things. Good luck Siobhan!
Cheryl2979 1 year ago
she has the heart of a champion i swear to god.
i just can't get over how she didn't seem sad,
she seemed more worried about being like "this what you're missin suckas"
than her feelings,
which to me makes her a champion <3
mirrorimage98 1 year ago 7
@mirrorimage98 she has indeed the spirit of a champion and is in peace with herself. She is so bold and original,and so true to herself !. She reminds me as an artist and in versatility the young Barbra Streisand. Though they have different voices they have similar charisma and dramatic sense.
solanjoe 1 year ago
Simon has gone too far. Not looking at her during this, not even wanting to hug her, and being so rude and biased towards her during the entire competition. Screw him; she's the best!
evilportrait 1 year ago
This should have never happened!
She was the only exciting part of the show, other than Crystal, I guess. The show's definitely ruined now.
evilportrait 1 year ago
she's the only contestant who keeps me watching this season of American Idol :-(
3jrik10 1 year ago
now i dont have reason to watch american idol....long live SIOBHAN!!!!
iluvreg4ever 1 year ago 3
She totally rocked her last performance, had fun with it, shoved it in Simon & Kara's faces ( 0:40 ) that they were wrong, and now she's going to go on and show America (and the world, I'm from Canada :D) what she's got and what they let go of. I love you Siobhan!! And I'm not watching the show until she comes on for the finale, and I'm going to the tour this summer :D
MoonInHerEyesx 1 year ago
she's definitely worthy of Top 5 but Crystal is the best female in the competition. Thus she's still there. A Kelly should not be in the top 5.
duhgr8ate1 1 year ago
Her beautiful sister looks very disappointed. I'm gonna miss 1:18, it's longer than the first one. She's the only one who dresses fashionably and interacts with the viewers totally.
tobertz8 1 year ago
God I hOpe they will give siobhan a break becouse she is really good!!!!!!!!!!!!
the first for me is adam lambert
and the second is siobhan magnus!!!!!!!!!!!
BabyCupid100 1 year ago
sign the petition online! look up siobhan petition on google search and the website is petition online.
skilletrulez12 1 year ago
see the judges should have used the save on TRUE TALENT which is Siobhan. While Mike may sound okay, he does not have a potential to create albums that will fly off the shelves like Siobhan could.
MrFab1230 1 year ago
Im a huge Siobhan fan, but whats this all about Aaron Kelly getting some of her votes? Please tell me cause im confused
IanROX22 1 year ago
@IanROX22 From my understanding and what I've heard at least, a facebook fan page for Siobhan had listed the wrong number to call, so many that thought they were voting for Siobhan were really calling the number for Aaron.
SmAshleyK47 1 year ago
@SmAshleyK47 I know and its so horrible! AI is definitely rigged. Notice how throughout the season she was trying to be herself rather than fitting the judges ideals of what they wanted her to be. She went to my high school and she has always stood out as a strong independent person. Nothing is gonna change her world and she will be more successful than any of them who are left in the long run.
Js57690 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sign her petition! it's called "Siobhan Magnus wrong phone number listed" in petitiononline! come on siobhan fans! please!
bjchabzroxy 1 year ago
0:39 and 0:40 (Simon's hand) and the way she screamed "Freedom" in front of him. She DID choose this song for a reason ;)
MAFK93 1 year ago
i got upset seeing she is the one being voted out....personally i go for lee...but watching her perform for the last time makes wonder she could be part of my top 3 with lee,..she make me cry..and totally make me cry when she hug one by one her family member.that was awesome....you got the talent siobhan make it live don't let it die...love the performance think....
vincesanji2009 1 year ago
I mean.. C'mon... Not fair AT ALL.. I think all the people watch American Idol for Siobhan. I know that I DO. She deserves to STAY NOT LEAVE. She has the BEST Voice I have ever heard. And screw the judges. They Confused her, they DO NOT know what they want from her. Once they want the screaming, the second they don't. You're GREAT. Can't WAIT for your CD :) and well... I think Simon kinda wanted her to stay. duno. Good Luck Anyway :)
MAFK93 1 year ago
@cwgreen89 Absolutely. Broadway is where she belongs. Not polluting the airwaves with her terrible death-shriek. We got Christina Aguilera for that one...
Amphed 1 year ago
@Amphed Yeah, we need more autotune pop garbage singers.
Ricearoni80 1 year ago
I echo Simon's comments during her very performance of this song. Parts of it were absolutely horrible.....
She deserved to go down...
Amphed 1 year ago
go siobhan.!you should have win this season.!
blueaddict16 1 year ago
Sign the online petition that aaron kelly got half of siobhan magnus' votes. its unfair.
skilletrulez12 1 year ago
This girl should have won!!!! :-(
shack88fan 1 year ago
its really disappointing to see one of the best of the season go home.
wafumetz21 1 year ago
this video inspires me so much... although i am very sad that she was eliminated out, it still makes me happy seeing her smiling and looking so happy even when its her last performance. This shows us that she didn't join American Idol for fame, but because she enjoyed singing. From this, I know that if she carries on with her singing career, i will support Siobhan!
130esther 1 year ago
1:17 - 1:25 .......nuff said
IanROX22 1 year ago
i really cant sleep on that night when siobhan got voted off.. and in the morning still thinking of her... T.T i love you siobhan! you still number one! i wonder why always guys who always left there? though crystal is still there. some voters i think is looking for cute guys rather than voice!
marsds22 1 year ago 2
America better "think" about how in the hell Siobhan got voted off.....
SmAshleyK47 1 year ago 5
Her scream in this performance was even better than the 1st time. She really gave the audience a good performance in her exit.
AshleyFrancoisC 1 year ago 3
siobhan is awwesome and america didnt know what they have donnee !!!!!!~
GO SIOBHANN !
MAGNUS foREVERR!!!!!!!!!!!~
mIl3y911 1 year ago
@mIl3y911 im super agree with you! Go siobhan Magnus!
marsds22 1 year ago
i almost cried when she got voted off. its such crap. i think she is the best one the show so now i really hope that Lee wins ony because crystal just doesnt appeal to me.
TheGingerAlee 1 year ago 2
@TheGingerAlee Gosh!! We have the exact views this season!! I'm so glad!! :D
waterbender09 1 year ago
Wait, wait, wait! THIS was the performance she got voted off for? She slayed this song!!! This is precisely why I don't like AI; it kills off all the actual talent.
autumnrose3 1 year ago
@autumnrose3 Uhm, the contestants can actually choose what song they're going to sing on the night of their elimination, she performed this during the top 20, the song she got voted off for was "Any Man of Mine". America is stupid. She shouldn't have been voted off.
PigTailCurler 1 year ago 2
@PigTailCurler Ohh, ok. Like I said, not an AI fan. I don't watch it. My mom does and didn't like Siobhan, and then I saw her in the news because Hanson invited her to come to their 5of5, and I youtubed her to see how she sounded.. I think she sounds fantastic! Oh well... at least now she's free to do what she wants wherever she gets signed, and we'll see a cd sooner.
autumnrose3 1 year ago
I think what happened is people thought Siobhan was going to be safe so they decided to vote for someone who was not as popular. Well anyway, she really killed it when she left, when out with a bang, showed people that she didn't deserve to go home. My top two are Lee and Crystal, vote for both!
And BTW Siobhan would NOT want you to stop watching the show just because she got voted off!
GO LEE AND CRYSTAL!!!!!!!
missy5245 1 year ago
See it this way: Finally, SIOBHAN is FREE!!! Now she can do what she wants!
SophomoreSlump236 1 year ago 2
She was my only reason to watch!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheTati83 1 year ago 68
i really don't like that note when she says "doctor." it sounds off. it makes sense for her to sing this song. "Think" made her an Idol frontrunner, but IMO, she would have done better if she chose Wicked Games or House of the Rising Sun. It would have been the perfect swan song. Goodbye Siobhan. You were my favorite and my only reason for watching the show.
lawlessearth 1 year ago
I don't know if you guys realised but think is actually a song for the judges! Analyse the lyrics that she sang this time... she shorten it a little bit... and she made the note longer... "YOU BETTER THINK"...
just trust me mate... analyse the whole song.. :P
bjchabzroxy 1 year ago 2
@bjchabzroxy I totally agree with U!
missy5245 1 year ago
@bjchabzroxy You're right :) I did when I saw her... And see how she advance towards them? I think it was for DeGuardi and Cowell rather than Jackson and Ellen.
MAFK93 1 year ago
siobhan, you know you'll always be the siobonbons' idol. :) you DIDN'T DESERVE TO GO HOME!
who cares? we know you'll be fine in the future. :)
just remember we are right behind you :)
bjchabzroxy 1 year ago 2
bye siobhan. There's no need to watch this show again,,
Chickenfeedzz 1 year ago 2
She sang it even better than the first time. I can only shake my head. It was a pleasure watching her these last couple of months.
ReadR00ster1 1 year ago 2
i've read on some posts days ago that siobhan's facebook account has wrong information on number to vote.. it says 1(866)436-5705 and 11 instead of 06 and 12. they've reported it but still ignored, they dont wonder why siobhan has big chance to be voted off.. wont watch AI this season anymore, the best got voted off..
basch03 1 year ago
I can't belive Siobhan got kicked off thats the only reason I kept watching this sucks!!!
Justine361587 1 year ago
im actually happy for her to leave the "crystal bowersox show"..! now she's so ready to rock her own stage.. i'll be on the first line to buy your cd..! rock it SIOBHAN!!!!!
kokokcrunch 1 year ago 25
nooooooo puedooo creerr que USA no votara por ellaaaaaa, no lo puedo creerrr
luismiguelvm3000 1 year ago
Best version of "Think" out there. Even better than Aretha's, Kathrine McPhee's or Kelly Clarkson's. I love you Siobhan! You don't need to win to be successful... Most winners aren't successful: Reuben, Jordan and that white hair dude. You will be the most successful out of everyone this season. The others are just plain and boring.
TheSportslover2010 1 year ago
siobhan should of won..im so pissed
victorvillegas88 1 year ago 2
What the F??American Idol Lost their asset on the show...Siobhan Magnus is the ONLY person we are watching in this show and now that she's gone, WhoElse to watch???
jhieferzon 1 year ago 4
There's no need to watch this show again.. I bet their ratings are going to go even lower next week
ParamoreVzla 1 year ago 2
Big mistake!!!! Siobhan was the best!!!
StacieRicard 1 year ago 2
she doesnt deserve to be voted off!
shame on you american idol!!!