Anybody talking about the number of titles to compare Brady and Manning has no clue of how to observe a QB. There is a reason why teams try to keep Manning off the field and beat the Defense. It's because Manning is so good. Brady is too, but not like Manning. Try and beat Big Bens defense, or Flacco's defense, which is not happening. The one year Bob Sanders was healthy we won a superbowl, with no prob. Freeney and Mathis help, but Colts need shut down Corners and Safety's and a Ray Lewis
It's simple, if you were scouting not only QB's but any position, would you only pick from the BCS title winning team???? Or would you look around for the best individuals for each position? If this were Golf, or Boxing, then I would agree that one individual decides his own fate.
Well, were I separate them is the ability to read defenses and change plays at the spur of the moment. I haven't seen anything like Manning. Everything else is about equal,cept I think Brady's deep ball is better.
@smoothhoopinal Despite being a New England fan, I agree with you there.Brady does have a problem with tough defenses, at least since I started watching him two years ago. I have not seen them win a Superbowl.
@smoothhoopinal Yea dude, totally agree. I'm a Bucs fan and a UK fan. I saw Peyton rip us apart for 3 years in the SEC, then come back 21 points in 4 and a half minutes on Monday night to beat us. Manning has had a DECENT, not great, defense maybe 4 or 5 years he's been in the league. The guy is an offensive coordinator with mad, old school, pocket passing QB skills. He's the sickest at his position I've ever seen. And I'm not a Colts fan, just a football fan.
@Callmebob137 He has better WRs than Brady??? Brady has or has had Randy Moss, Wes Welker, Rob Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez, Chad Ocho Cinco, and Deion Branch. Manning has had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, and Pierre Garcon. The later two probably would not have as much success as they have without Manning.
@Callmebob137 Hey bud, the only years Brady won a Super Bowls in, 01, 03, and 04, the Pats D was ranked 6th, 1st, and 2nd respectively. When Brady doesn't have a TOP 6 D, he cant win a Superbowl. In 2006, when Peyton won his Super Bowl, the Colts D was ranked 23rd. So you don't know what you are even saying. You give Peyton a top 6 D, he'd have 3, 4 or 5 rings. Learn some facts before you get on here looking like you're gay for Brady and the Pats.
Patron is everything to the colts, he has been MVP 4 times that's twice than Brady and 20,000 yards more than Brady, and the colts can't win without him they have lost 6 games out of 6 without him
@mcalte19 lets b real every team stole signals its not a big deal, and troy brown was never a top receiver come on, manning had harrison, wayne, clark, edge james great offensive line for years along with one of the best pass rushers of the decade with freeney and mathis and other geat players like bob sanders and brackett and a "defensive mastermind" in dungy so as far as talent, manning has had alot more around him, its amazing how many times peyton has choked under pressure
peyton manning is like the only reason the colts offense is good he carries the team and does everything else what does tom brady do through a bad pass and expect randy moss to do an amazing catch
@Lakerzfansince1991 That was also before they were caught stealing signals, had great defenses and in 2001, Troy Brown was a top receiver. He caught over 100 passes. Let's not forget Brady also lost a Super Bowl with a team that was 16-0
yo peyton is the best Qb in the nfl and if u dont like it fuck off because he has heart and setermination he believes in his team and they believe in him yo peyton is my idle and im gonna be just like him one day go #18
@superphil101 And Brady isn't a choker? He went 18-0 in the post season then lost to the Giants in the Super Bowl. If that's not a textbook example of choking, then I don't know what is.
@klenny5688 He's also won three out of four superbowls, and was the MVP for one in which he didnt choke in the final minutes and went down the field to set up the field goal without any timeouts. unlike manning who just threw a pick against the saints to lose the game
and manning has only been playing 2 years longer and tom brady doesnt have the mental capacity to run the entire offense AND individually coach the recievers.
Peyton is the greatest of all time for those reasons.
even though i dont like him hes still number one , yea he lost to drew brees but hes still number one its 1 manning, 2 drew brees 2.5 tom brady (needs to get his shit together) , 3 mcnabb and flacco
@Ozkarftw With the exception of 81, all of Montana's Super Bowl wins came with top 12 defenses.... AND he had the greatest pass catcher of all time, Mr. Jerry Rice. Joe Montana was a great QB, who was part of a great system. Those 2 things worked in his favor to win him 4 rings. I really believe Peyton is a better QB than Montana.
@TheMichaelJoshua totally agree. I feel the same way about Tom Brady (as you said about Montana). I'm a fan of all three QBs, but I believe Brady and Montana are products of phenomenal coaching and general management to build them great teams. The Colts have been in decline since the middle of the last decade, with consistently terrible defense, special teams, and repeated draft blunders. But i don't think anyone's played the QB position as well as Peyton.
best qb in nfl history
redneckgunshooter 1 week ago
Anybody talking about the number of titles to compare Brady and Manning has no clue of how to observe a QB. There is a reason why teams try to keep Manning off the field and beat the Defense. It's because Manning is so good. Brady is too, but not like Manning. Try and beat Big Bens defense, or Flacco's defense, which is not happening. The one year Bob Sanders was healthy we won a superbowl, with no prob. Freeney and Mathis help, but Colts need shut down Corners and Safety's and a Ray Lewis
smoothhoopinal 1 month ago
@smoothhoopinal If title is not a medium for comparison between Brady and Manning, then what is?
theoxusriver 3 weeks ago
@theoxusriver
It's simple, if you were scouting not only QB's but any position, would you only pick from the BCS title winning team???? Or would you look around for the best individuals for each position? If this were Golf, or Boxing, then I would agree that one individual decides his own fate.
smoothhoopinal 3 weeks ago
@smoothhoopinal I was asking about the basis on which you made the claim: "Manning is so good. Brady is too, but not like Manning"
theoxusriver 3 weeks ago
@theoxusriver
Well, were I separate them is the ability to read defenses and change plays at the spur of the moment. I haven't seen anything like Manning. Everything else is about equal,cept I think Brady's deep ball is better.
smoothhoopinal 3 weeks ago
@smoothhoopinal Despite being a New England fan, I agree with you there.Brady does have a problem with tough defenses, at least since I started watching him two years ago. I have not seen them win a Superbowl.
theoxusriver 3 weeks ago
@smoothhoopinal Yea dude, totally agree. I'm a Bucs fan and a UK fan. I saw Peyton rip us apart for 3 years in the SEC, then come back 21 points in 4 and a half minutes on Monday night to beat us. Manning has had a DECENT, not great, defense maybe 4 or 5 years he's been in the league. The guy is an offensive coordinator with mad, old school, pocket passing QB skills. He's the sickest at his position I've ever seen. And I'm not a Colts fan, just a football fan.
TheMichaelJoshua 1 week ago
did anyone catch him slipping?
ikillfun 1 month ago
@callmebob137 dude really? the patriots is STACKED with WR's. he has so many weapons! even his running backs can catch!
alecspu7 1 month ago
can someone say me who the QB is ? because Manning is injury. who is playing for him now?
ModernW4rf3re 3 months ago
this season they suck :(((( 11-0 poor colts >.<
ModernW4rf3re 3 months ago
yeah so much better then brady except he has better WR then brady better D then brady and Less Rings then Brady
Callmebob137 4 months ago
@Callmebob137 He has better WRs than Brady??? Brady has or has had Randy Moss, Wes Welker, Rob Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez, Chad Ocho Cinco, and Deion Branch. Manning has had Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Dallas Clark, and Pierre Garcon. The later two probably would not have as much success as they have without Manning.
twatringer 2 months ago
@Callmebob137 Hey bud, the only years Brady won a Super Bowls in, 01, 03, and 04, the Pats D was ranked 6th, 1st, and 2nd respectively. When Brady doesn't have a TOP 6 D, he cant win a Superbowl. In 2006, when Peyton won his Super Bowl, the Colts D was ranked 23rd. So you don't know what you are even saying. You give Peyton a top 6 D, he'd have 3, 4 or 5 rings. Learn some facts before you get on here looking like you're gay for Brady and the Pats.
TheMichaelJoshua 1 month ago
@TheMichaelJoshua
Yeah, you give Peyton a defense like Big Ben has, and it's a wrap. Maybe even a couple 19-0s
smoothhoopinal 1 month ago
Patron is everything to the colts, he has been MVP 4 times that's twice than Brady and 20,000 yards more than Brady, and the colts can't win without him they have lost 6 games out of 6 without him
ferrariguy490 4 months ago
He looks like a kid on a leash at Disneyland
SD1Chargers 6 months ago 3
@SD1Chargers My candy
lordvoldemort578 5 months ago
@mcalte19 lets b real every team stole signals its not a big deal, and troy brown was never a top receiver come on, manning had harrison, wayne, clark, edge james great offensive line for years along with one of the best pass rushers of the decade with freeney and mathis and other geat players like bob sanders and brackett and a "defensive mastermind" in dungy so as far as talent, manning has had alot more around him, its amazing how many times peyton has choked under pressure
Lakerzfansince1991 6 months ago
hey this was posted on my b day hah
shuffle121000 7 months ago
peyton manning is like the only reason the colts offense is good he carries the team and does everything else what does tom brady do through a bad pass and expect randy moss to do an amazing catch
Strocityy 8 months ago
@Strocityy ummm tom brady won 3 super bowls with troy brown and david givens
Lakerzfansince1991 7 months ago
@Lakerzfansince1991 That was also before they were caught stealing signals, had great defenses and in 2001, Troy Brown was a top receiver. He caught over 100 passes. Let's not forget Brady also lost a Super Bowl with a team that was 16-0
mcalte19 6 months ago
yo peyton is the best Qb in the nfl and if u dont like it fuck off because he has heart and setermination he believes in his team and they believe in him yo peyton is my idle and im gonna be just like him one day go #18
TheChiefs2010 8 months ago
in every madden video game ive played peyton manning is better than tom brady
ethanrogerwilson 11 months ago
@superphil101 yea the patriots havnt done shit in the postseason now that they are not cheating.
chrispuncher1 11 months ago
Brady is a winner. Just look at his regular season record. Manning is a choker, there is no excuse for his poor postseason record.
superphil101 1 year ago
@superphil101 And Brady isn't a choker? He went 18-0 in the post season then lost to the Giants in the Super Bowl. If that's not a textbook example of choking, then I don't know what is.
klenny5688 1 year ago
@klenny5688 He's also won three out of four superbowls, and was the MVP for one in which he didnt choke in the final minutes and went down the field to set up the field goal without any timeouts. unlike manning who just threw a pick against the saints to lose the game
superphil101 1 year ago
@superphil101 They were also caught cheating.
klenny5688 1 year ago
Peyton Manning is the most intelligent and possibly the hardest working QB to play this game... Tom Brady is nowhere near P.Manning's level...
BisQuitos 1 year ago
Tom Brady isn't even half the QB Peyton Manning is... Peyton Manning is the quite possibly the most intelligent QB to play this game...
BisQuitos 1 year ago
Manning: 54,828 yds 399 tds
Brady: 34,744 yds 261 tds
and manning has only been playing 2 years longer and tom brady doesnt have the mental capacity to run the entire offense AND individually coach the recievers.
Peyton is the greatest of all time for those reasons.
Lorraine56838 1 year ago 4
@Lorraine56838 I love it when people say Manning is better than Brady; people who think otherwise are ignorant.
lellinger 1 year ago
Peyton Manning is the best quarterback ever. This is a fact.
AweSomePerSonRockYa 1 year ago 6
@AweSomePerSonRockYa look at the yards lol... tom brady beats him in everything
gopedsrsick 1 year ago
even though i dont like him hes still number one , yea he lost to drew brees but hes still number one its 1 manning, 2 drew brees 2.5 tom brady (needs to get his shit together) , 3 mcnabb and flacco
gtaj03 1 year ago
@gtaj03 might want to rethink that one..
WackAWarrior 1 year ago
no one is better
TheManningBros 2 years ago 27
The best ever? or The Best Ever....? The latter i think
papersoulja27 2 years ago 3
@TheManningBros except tom brady
gopedsrsick 1 year ago
@TheManningBros Except Tommy Brady.
Martena56 11 months ago
@TheManningBros joe montana?
Ozkarftw 2 weeks ago
@Ozkarftw With the exception of 81, all of Montana's Super Bowl wins came with top 12 defenses.... AND he had the greatest pass catcher of all time, Mr. Jerry Rice. Joe Montana was a great QB, who was part of a great system. Those 2 things worked in his favor to win him 4 rings. I really believe Peyton is a better QB than Montana.
TheMichaelJoshua 1 week ago
@TheMichaelJoshua totally agree. I feel the same way about Tom Brady (as you said about Montana). I'm a fan of all three QBs, but I believe Brady and Montana are products of phenomenal coaching and general management to build them great teams. The Colts have been in decline since the middle of the last decade, with consistently terrible defense, special teams, and repeated draft blunders. But i don't think anyone's played the QB position as well as Peyton.
douker 1 week ago
Go Peyton Manning!
McNabb5bobo 2 years ago 17