林憶蓮 - 枯榮MV

[vocaletainhaha]

good song good lyrics.. :)

[Peff06]

这首歌实在是近期歌坛佳作，sandy 三十年仍在不懈努力，实在让人钦佩！！ 可惜youtube 上这首歌的效果不太好，要听她自己上载的就好的多。

我有一个意见，我觉得她这首歌的MV 不应该自己跳舞，或者跳舞也可以，但MV应该截动态图，然后剪接­进行后期制作，不应该用动态拍摄的方法。

[aesopn12131]

明眼人都睇得出有王菲影子,當然唔係話林憶蓮差,不過呢種風格的­確王菲好早期已經玩得出神入化,印象太深刻

[gdtmr]

Nice song... MV style made reference to World End Girlfriend and Gossip.

[ringrcircle]

好好听

[pepsifanJL]

這麼多年依然專心執著地做著自己喜歡的音樂，很高興香港還有這樣­的歌手存在。Sandy是不老的天后！

[wingwing0404]

苦榮??? ~.~"

勁走勁走勁走...

無聊? 直音你... 

[ranwongzone]

歌词填得好。。曲风就不是我的茶！但是还是最爱忆连！

[kenchish]

很感動! 不能想像一位唱了近30年的歌手還有如此的生命力，仍然每日在挑­戰自己，是藝術家的氣節和膽量。

[stgf1080]

棒棒棒..最強

天后

[jiffcia]

Sandy is super great~ mv is not

[teri2688]

Sandy loves to inject fresh idea n life to her music...we should appreciate or comment this song from Sandy's vocal style, lyrics & music arrangement perspective, else we r just degarding the musician & artiste's efforts by comparing it with so and so. Sandy has been perservered with her music passions all these years despite the number of setbacks & challenges she faced...isn't this the messages Sandy likes to pass on..."Do Not Give Up, Think Out of the Box...Keep Trying & Keep Going"?!!

[ImLai2]

我看見thom yorke的影子

[magyuan]

之前覺得這首歌很哲，看完MMXI，覺得這首歌SEXY到爆

[bonjourmayan]

支持！ 大爱！

[ifatepaul]

其實我認為係王菲+泳兒合唱...

[kelissir]

一聽就知唔係王菲唱，

好多鼻音，令我諗起泳兒

[MrChannel8s]

别说，这个真是像王菲。 林忆莲年纪不小了，这个MTV设计觉得不合适

[tennrainooto]

不嬲都唔覺王菲唱歌真係好好聽 只係覺得 係d人聽佢唱歌唱到好高音就叫好叻...

hk d 歌手無幾多個真係令人覺得 awesome

[greaseonj]

very strange melody and MTV.... its very crystal clear she cant manage it at all...

[ImLai2]

Thom Yorke

[SnoopyATE]

唔好成日話咩扮王菲,請問有冇實際上既對比?認真講,王菲既唱法­唔係得佢一個先至可以咁做。一個pro既歌手係更加應該為左唔同­既歌用唔同既聲音同聲線先叫pro

[worldofakina]

@SnoopyATE 可能有人認為Bjork都扮緊王菲

[thisisthesecondme]

我覺得似tori amos多d ...

[kohjison]

SL 三个字"你好ye!!!!!"難以望懷

[pooncarson]

atv個版本唔知佢唱咩

唔睇字幕都唔知...

[geraldd39]

以為vincy 唱tim

[DasiChesty]

歌好聽,不過唔明MV想表達D咩..

[stgf1080]

超耐聽.

[tanbs1977]

新唱法!忆莲永远最棒!希望早日出专辑!

[wangdienacht]

"驟爾回"的意思是...?(很好奇，但網上搜不到@@)



[PlantaButterfly]

@wangdienacht 驟爾 = 匆匆; 驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲 = 人匆匆出生, 匆匆離去; 出生的時候會哭, 離去的時候沒人在笑

[justinweng]

why feel like got faye wong shadow...If without MV i will thought is 王菲

[stgf1080]

超正

[manmani1996]

一呼一吸　一眨眼睛 年華如同流雲　化作泡影 出生一刻心跳聲 床前彌留時辰去細聽 驟爾來　在哭聲 驟爾回　沒笑聲 滴答滴答光陰過隙 童年俄而成年　秒秒壓逼 一絲一點想記憶 回頭原來搖籃　悄悄褪色 驟爾來　沒珍惜 驟爾回　未歇息 月有虧盈陰晴　輪遞不停 換到功名虛榮　轉眼如幻影 花事哪可敵過一枯一榮 明艷過　磨蝕了　過程 一呼一吸　一眨眼睛 年華如同流雲　化作泡影 出生一刻心跳聲 床前彌留時辰去細聽 驟爾來　在哭聲 驟爾回　沒笑聲 春光秋色　不堪滿足 回頭沿途繁華　哪裡駐足 一章一章演奏曲 如何迷人仍然要結束 驟爾來　但一生 驟爾回　像借宿 月有虧盈陰晴　輪遞不停 換到功名虛榮　轉眼如幻影 花事哪可敵過一枯一榮 明艷過　磨蝕了　過程 

[tosonwong]

因為我阿媽成日睇套你是我的命運所以有留意到呢首歌 很佩服SANDY的唱功依然頂級 從綠水清風開始都係咁正 

[nobita813]

有点像王菲， 不过更像 Tori Amos !!!

很喜欢 ！！！

[deathmoonkiller]

刚开始听还真的觉得像王菲但又不像王菲，后来听介绍才知道是林忆­莲出新歌了~

一看MV就深深被吸引， 发现到或许一些转音真的有王菲的影子，但肯定的是两位都是毋庸置­疑的天后，各有各的特色!

[chumuse]

作曲：常石磊 作詞：喬 星 編曲：常石磊 監製：林憶蓮、常石磊 Mixed By：Kelvin Avon 主唱：林憶蓮 一呼一吸 一眨眼睛 年華如同流雲 化作泡影 出生一刻心跳聲 床前彌留時辰去細聽 驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲 ＊ 滴答滴答光陰過隙 童年我而成年 秒秒壓逼 一絲一點想記憶 回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色 驟爾來 沒珍惜 驟爾回 未歇息＊ 月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停 換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影 花事哪可敵過一枯一榮 明艷過 磨蝕了 過程 春光秋色 不堪滿足 回頭沿途繁華 哪裡駐足 一章一章演奏曲 如何迷人仍然要結束 驟爾來 但一生 驟爾回 暫借宿

[tsepppp]

perfect!!!!!!!!!!

[pigwire]

A quite different from her passed style!

[autumntale100]

Simply Perfect!!

[givemesam]

歌風是有點像tori, 但感覺就完全不同, 我唔會因聽"枯榮"而想起tori 任何一首歌, 至於唱得像faye 的只有一句尾最後的一個高音,(但真的很像),而其它完全是憶蓮­的聲音, 真的很佩服憶蓬廣東話咬字的工力, 唱得很好聽 A++++ 

[lonexo]

i love this song very much~

[KahSing82]

I like Sandy, but one thing I cant stand is this song, the verse sounds exactly like Tori Amos [GOD], n the transition to chorus sounds like [PANCAKE], n the arrangement based more on Tori's LIVE band arrangements....

If she said the song was in spired from Tori its ok, but if she claim its her own new style i will seriously lose my points....the trails r too obvious

[lilithdvs13]

@KahSing82

I thought it sounded very Tori Amos too. Well, to be fair Sandy's been doing this kind of ethereal undercurrenty type of number as far back in the 80s, before Tori even came out in 1992. Also Sandy's vocal in the last verse is more brilliant powerful than any of Tori's usual subdued whispers.

[KahSing82]

@lilithdvs13 No worry, i'm not attacking her, but more of the arrangements, cos if u listen to GOD and also PANCAKE , both in tori amos live, the base of the progression in the arrangements are undeniably similar.

To me, inspiration from one another music style etc is normal, its also a progress of innovation...The only concern is I hope she or the music company dont claim that it's her "own new creation" music style, cos too many chinese singers go n claim without respect n i seriously dislike

[KahSing82]

@lilithdvs13 the main 2 similarity that really obvious are the progression in Piano and also the use of the percussions... :)

[lilithdvs13]

@KahSing82

When I heard the progression I was like, "OMG Liquid Diamond!" Well, at least they didn't go with the obvious and better known choices. Yeah I'm lookin' at ya Faye Wong...

[KahSing82]

@lilithdvs13 lol....yea liquid diamonds also rings in my head too, anyway even Coldplay [speed of sound] samples n inspired their beats from Kate Bush etc, i think sampling n inspirations r okay as long as they admits, which western musicians pays more respect. Just wouldnt like how chinese industry always go over-hardsell saying it's their own originals everytime people catches the trails.

n again, i think sandy is an artist with taste n will not claim it to be totally hers, not like others :)

[ST091102]

Sandy is truly a great singer. Not just a great voice, she performs each song in ways that expresses its true meaning. I cannot think of a Chinese singer that does better than her in the past few decades. Anita Mui was quite good also.

Faye Wong also has a good voice and can sing, but not with the range of emotion and expressiveness.

[kienez]

Sandy, I'm tired of all Taiwan ballads. Please come back to HK Canto Pop. They need you so badly :-) Love you Sandy...

[KelvinWarcraft]

好似王菲 ._. 第一次聽仲如為係王菲唱...

[spikypanda]

@KelvinWarcraft 我同意你所講，真係好似王菲唱腔，唔講真係以為係王菲。。。

[benlau321]

终極地"放縱" 好正~!!!

[jchk00]

好到沒話說！



[sabahiya]

正! 最好去盡啲, 做幾個有 Massive Attack 加 Portishead 嘅 remixes..

[nocridnocrid]

好Tori Amos... 我中意!

[vivien91126]

作曲：常石磊 作詞：喬 星 編曲：常石磊 主唱：林憶蓮 一呼一吸 一眨眼睛 年華如同流雲 化作泡影 出生一刻心跳聲 床前彌留時辰去細聽 驟爾來 在哭聲 驟爾回 沒笑聲 ＊ 滴答滴答光陰過隙 童年我而成年 秒秒壓逼 一絲一點想記憶 回頭原來搖籃 悄悄褪色 驟爾來 沒珍惜 驟爾回 未歇息＊ 月有虧盈陰晴 輪遞不停 換到功名虛榮 轉眼如幻影 花事哪可敵過一枯一榮 明艷過 磨蝕了 過程 ＊

[hypermonster]

thought it's a faye wong's new song when i heard it the first time... ^^

[carkeen]

by far one of the best canto song this year. feels like i'm back to the glorious days of canto pop in the 90s. <3

[anyproductionhk]

i like to say,she is sandy,she is queen,she can do more best,she really want ? dont say anything of her bad ! anyone dont want to be bad ! right ? so support her not a k song singer ! i love herr when i shoot the i loveu song ! the point is i not work for money ! money fuck it !

[kaycharlotte]

我雖然唔係林憶蓮既Fans，但我都幾中意聽呢首歌！歌詞好之餘­，憶蓮仲演繹得好有韻味！！呢首歌絕對聽得過！仲好洗腦:D

[sillyasiantrixr4kidz]

one of the better Canto songs in a long time

[valleybeneaththesea]

Music, art works, photographs, dancing, printing, sculptures......

is a groups of friends linked with the closed relationship in targeting the best presentation, all sharing a bit of inspiration and beated out their sole noise, Sandy is much enjoys her innovative role with her sole feminity.

[endlessrain615]

點解要抄radiohead - lotus flower ?? 香港影視人...才窮 ?

[rusebbb]

@endlessrain615 睇左都唔覺抄姐...Choreography都唔同...仲有­本身想表達的都唔同...拍攝手法都唔同...

[ahTin125]

@endlessrain615 你呢 d 人鐘意咁講, 某程度係想拋書包..

如果你咁都話抄既話, 咁大概所有 "一男一女" 演出既情愛 MV, 全部都係抄?

講野之前用下個大腦, 編個現代舞(i think) 出黎唔代表抄既, 係你唔明佢地想表達咩姐..

[yungbeeee]

@ahTin125 我覺得都唔係拋書包既... 我第一次睇都有d lotus flower既感覺, 大家討論下姐~~唔洗咁偏激~~

不過我都覺得唔係抄既, 咁世界上咁多mv都係跳hip hop, 咁唔係個個都抄跳hip hop嫁嘛~~

btw呢首歌好好聽~~ 但好似都唔太popular, 係唔係因為係亞視播所以咁先!!! 連kkbox都冇... 一係你快d出碟啦蓮姐!!!!!!!!!!!!

[joshiko]

@endlessrain615  coz Lotus is 蓮 in Chinese?

[aromabee]

@endlessrain615 唔可以話抄, 呢種表達方式其實好多人都做過, 如果SANDY係抄RAIDOHEAD, 唔通RADIOHEAD又抄中森明菜? 85年時中森明菜已經用了類似的方式表演. 可以在YOUTBUE 揾中森明菜　ー　Marionette



[aromabee]

中森明菜　BACK DOOR NIGHT ～ マリオネット 也是用這種方式表演.

[xingxing14]

搞咩呀個MV

[leochan0723]

做緊D你唔識，唔曉，唔敢做嘅嘢，友仔。

[happy0u0u]

我想知個mv條友係到做咩?

[jchk00]

如果憶蓮這樣唱也聽不到每一個字，現在的歌手看來要送進集中營勞­改！一字一語，清淅無瑕，可能真的是聽者耳朵有問題！

[lajabo888]

好Brand New Sandy , 好有Tori Amos 曲風......不過香港依家D只愛聽走音歌手既歌同埋唔識欣賞­啦！我就覺得越聽越好聽啦！

[TenA853]

開心舞?!

btw,首歌好型~!

同埋我諗呢個mv亞視遲d都應該會播下既 (純為宣傳套韓劇)

[siulu1212]

其實我第一次聽既時候係一個字都聽唔到...

完全唔知咩黎

[Sit2006]

開頭一聽呢首歌,我分唔出係王菲定林憶蓮唱.......

你閉上眼,腦想起王菲,聽這歌......真的會以為是王菲唱的­......把聲有些位好似王菲.....

林憶蓮同王菲我也支持.....實力才是王道

[Eva01ShI]

彊屍Mode

[garcons79]

Sandy isn't copying Tori Amos" song - GOD, just copying Tori Amos is general. The piano, the beat, the backing vocal... And she sounds a bit like Faye Wong at times...

[halla2004003]

原以為MV裡你是比較安靜的，沒想到有這麼多跳舞的動作，想起古­老民族祭祀那樣，不知您要表達什麼..但歌曲歌詞都非常喜歡，喜­歡你的突破，加油！！

[rchoi99]

I can understand why some posters, myself included, think this absolutely great song by Sandy, sounds like a Tori Amos song. The drum pattern and piano intro is very much a Tori Amos signature, but the similarities end there. Neither 'Spark' or 'God' resembles anything remotely like 枯榮. So to accuse her of copying Tori Amos is just daft.

[Sporty87]

有人說此曲無論在歌曲及MV上也是抄襲 Tori Amos《God》一曲。

個人認為兩曲並沒有太相似的地方，你們認為呢？

[highartfan01]

@Sporty87 剛看了Tori's MV，不覺相似，遑論抄襲！很久沒聽Tori Amos的歌了，還是很Tori的風格！反觀Sandy不同時期­有不同的音樂風格，廿多年還是這麼堅持，很佩服她！

Playing safe is boring & yes, I'm with you always!

[lwp0214]

WILL THERE BE 16:9 VERSION? THANKS!

[MrMatthewchan]

好期待9月演唱會啊

[nnnnaaaazzzziiii]

Good

[dbdawnbobo]

Welcome Back!! I love this song and vedio much. :)

[alvinshcn]

omg, this is what i am talking about!!!! sandy in canto = awesome!!!!

[DarienChen]

EPIC!! EPIC!! :)

[ycccheng]

You are amazing Sandy~~~ Nobody click in to check in here doesn't mean anything at all, you are simply the pride of all HK ppl, along with Danny, Lesile, Roman,家駒and Anita, I am very proud of you, yes, Very Very Much.

[keetoi]

This has to be one of the most stunning MV in recent years. The music and the visual blend in so perfectly. A new direction from my beloved Sandy Lam. I am so so very proud of you! ;)

[valleybeneaththesea]

The visibly Diva picked on the most controversial performance, but only she could riding the experimental dancing into a ridiculously beautiful scenery, honors are given to the talented production as they paralyzed the tradional MTV making, it captured with the most unique and artistic illuminations.

[timmann1972]

在現在香港樂壇，難再找一個像sandy的歌手了。

[709394PP]

Playing safe is boring, yeah!!!

[highartfan01]

試問香港有那個音樂人廿多年來還能不斷帶給我們這麼多驚喜？以她­的條件，如她跟著遊戲規則玩，一定會大紅大紫，但她沒有隨波逐流­，只是默默在做她喜愛的音樂，亦因此她並沒有像其他歌手那樣漸漸­迷失、退出... Sandy，我只想你繼續做你喜愛的音樂，我會一直默默的支持你­！Love this Song, love this MV!

[yn2004]

我看見您在真的活着!

[511730880]

原來ATV個電視劇就系拎左e首歌。。

[kent007tnek]

LOVE..SANDY

[iokuokhk]

驚訝! 憶蓮這個mv, 對一直喜歡她的我, 很驚喜! 回想起93年的天大地大, 被dancer抬橋出場那個現場表演, 或者係91年的再生戀mv, 都給我同樣的感覺. 勁!

[charles0311230]

現今樂壇似乎只有sandy這類少數的歌手可以做出如此有行為藝­術style的mv

無論歌詞,意境,唱功都是現在首屈一指的 可惜會欣賞的人不多..

一名中二14歲學生上

[6110angie]

@charles0311230 你真的才十四歲??!!太難得了!

[charles0311230]

@6110angie 是的 因為我的舅舅是個憶蓮的FAN 因此我是聽她的歌長大的

[manseewa]

SANDY YOU ARE THE BEST .................

[allen1985hk]

曲•詞•歌手完美演繹•MV•憶蓮的肢體語言，優秀脫俗，現今亞­洲樂壇根本無人可比，真正用心為音樂添上靈魂的好歌者。

[yeeroland]

Sandy it's absolutely stunning, so different from what you've done before.

[JLprojects]

Sandy, 我打從87年 [ 憶蓮 ] 大碟, 已經成為你的follower, 真的很高興看到你的新嘗試. 從歌詞中聽得到你現在對生命的感受. 長久追隨你的歌迷如我都經歷不少, 人生又豈止只有愛情呢? 這次的內容在你過去的主打歌中是絕無僅有的. 畢竟你和你的歌迷都長大了. 坦白說, 近年來我的耳朵悄悄地被Shirley Kwan吸引過去, 她09年的 [ 山水 ] 給我很大的感受. 我的心問: 為什麼 Sandy 除了愛情的主題外, 很少在主打中流露其他想法呢? 所以很驚訝這次的新曲. 新唱腔方面, 真的給我觸動神經感受, 憶蓮有膽唱, 我就有膽聽呵! 在這裡希望你keep住勇於嘗試的心, 我期待著你的新大碟和9月的演出. JEFFREY

[highartfan01]

@JLprojects 推介你聽Sandy新的國語歌「柿子」，想必令你更欣賞她！

[JLprojects]

@highartfan01 Thank you, it's pretty good, will she include it in her latest album? I mean a studio version.

[highartfan01]

@JLprojects You're welcome! From SandyFanclub: 日期 : 2011.03.21 有大陸歌迷找到一篇去年8月的報導 指常石磊為憶蓮新碟創作了四首歌 分別是《柿子》、《爱笑了》、《灰》及《不哭的红眼眶》 看來新碟會收錄的曲目有 : 1. 柿子 (常石磊作品) 2. 愛笑了 (常石磊作品) 3. 灰 (常石磊作品) 4. 不哭的红眼眶 (常石磊作品) 5. 閉上了流淚眼 - 不哭的红眼眶粵語版 (常石磊作品) 6. 兩生花 (恭硕良作品) 7. 也許 - 兩生花國語版 (恭硕良作品) 8. 月球人國語版 (恭硕良作品) *蘇打綠作品《寂寞擁擠》未確定是否收錄

[msc07lth]

@highartfan01

兩心花

[JLprojects]

@highartfan01 Thank you for the information! :-)