for once bernie does the vocals of a joy division song correctly !! pity he couldnot do likewise with almost every live version of in a lonely place !!
@CardiffBoy1927 pooras this is it isone one of bernies better ceremonys he could try and sing it like on the 7 inch which sounded good with massive processing by hannet or like ian sang it at birmingham,, a few wrong notes dont matter too much though sometimes hes singing in the wrong key, and phrasing wrong, even that could be forgiven IF HE SANG AS THOUGH HE EVEN SLIGHTLY CARED ,AT TIMES HE SOUNDS LIKE HES READING A SHOPPING LIST, STILL GOOD ENOUGH FOR YOU
@birdandthe - Stop being so precious about someone's else's work. Tis is not Wagnerian Opera where a note out of place stinks the place out. This is Post-Punk made by 20the century Mancunians. Bernard is not a singer of any note, nor an especially significant performer. New Order are very much greater than their parts. I'm sure he does care more than you'll every know, or appreciate. And yes, it's good enough for me because I don't have ridiculous expectations like yourself.
for once bernie does the vocals of a joy division song correctly !! pity he couldnot do likewise with almost every live version of in a lonely place !!
birdandthe 11 months ago
@birdandthe - Get a life man ! Since when did you determine what's ''correct'' ?
CardiffBoy1927 3 weeks ago
@CardiffBoy1927 its called an OPINION buy a dictionary and get your ears syringed
birdandthe 3 weeks ago
@birdandthe - Chill Winston, but just to point out there's no such thing as a 'correct' vocal, unless you're afflicted by OCD ?
CardiffBoy1927 3 weeks ago
@CardiffBoy1927 pooras this is it isone one of bernies better ceremonys he could try and sing it like on the 7 inch which sounded good with massive processing by hannet or like ian sang it at birmingham,, a few wrong notes dont matter too much though sometimes hes singing in the wrong key, and phrasing wrong, even that could be forgiven IF HE SANG AS THOUGH HE EVEN SLIGHTLY CARED ,AT TIMES HE SOUNDS LIKE HES READING A SHOPPING LIST, STILL GOOD ENOUGH FOR YOU
birdandthe 3 weeks ago
@birdandthe - Stop being so precious about someone's else's work. Tis is not Wagnerian Opera where a note out of place stinks the place out. This is Post-Punk made by 20the century Mancunians. Bernard is not a singer of any note, nor an especially significant performer. New Order are very much greater than their parts. I'm sure he does care more than you'll every know, or appreciate. And yes, it's good enough for me because I don't have ridiculous expectations like yourself.
CardiffBoy1927 2 weeks ago
Best song ever written
beforethree 1 year ago 12
@beforethree Yes, it is!
greensteph 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
beforethree 1 year ago
This was always one of my favourites by them. And I loved Bernard's hair this way the best. I wish he kept it like this :'(
ButterflyRoseX 1 year ago 5
Hooky's cying, isn't he?(at 3:48)
gabriel94220 1 year ago
@gabriel94220 Do you mean Bernard?
HumanJarv 6 months ago
Tony Wilson on camera in the background too :-)
lagowski 1 year ago
thanks for shear !!!!!!! GREAT PERFORMANCE
alex329 2 years ago
a drip of sweat falls from his lips at 3:18
sheer energy put into this perfomance
slangshotstudios 2 years ago
Thanks for sharing! It's a great performance
themanamp 2 years ago
nevermind, just noticed it is already on here.
bananimalistic 2 years ago
thanks for uploading this one.
what date is "the missing boy" from? any chances of uploading that one too?
bananimalistic 2 years ago
NICE!
mojorama2001 2 years ago