Driving of CARS and usage of TECHNOLOGY "doesn't" constitute biddat.
Biddat in religious discussion STRICTLY means those thing that people do thinking it as act that is going to be rewarded. Biddat by its definition is done out of good faith.
@MrKhanRizwan Taraweeh is not Biddah. Over the years scholars have invented various terms for different types of Namaz, i.e., sunnat mokaddah, sunnat ghair mokaddah, nafl, witar , wajib, qayamullail, taraweeh, Tahajjud. All that we call sunnat are nothing but nawafils that were offered by Prophet PBUH. Taraweeh and witr are just another name for Tahjjud. Before Hazrat Umar suggested people to offer congregational taraweeh or witr, people used to do it in masjid but seperately.
@MrKhanRizwan He probably didn't like the machchli bazar individual prayer was creating because of his neat sense of organisation and reform, he suggested that they pray it under imam. As far as I know Umar himself never prayed his witr in the mosque.
@MrKhanRizwan Such invention of terminology has only created confusion among the people. Now people dont even know that taraweeh, tahajjud and witr are basically the same things.
Aarab of Quran are requirement for people whose mother tongue is not Arabic. When you have facility why not use it.
Rather than labeling something as a biddat (I dont agree with this lady at all but she is entitles to have her opinion) people should make themselves aware of the whole context.
@MrKhanRizwan However I'm strictly against gender segregation. Women should be allowed to pray in the same hall. Those who donot want to do that, can have a seperate room of their own. But you cannot force women to go the secluded hall thinking you are doing a rewarding act.
Saudi Arabia shows the truth of islam. You wear white as a woman, saudi women wear black. Black supposedly makes the woman less desirable. Why are you not covering your face as the home of islam, saudi arabia women do? What a fool you are.
@herself311 Saudi Arabia has the most disgusting political and religious leadership (majority). They are the scums. Btw saudi and irani women are forced to do the Hijab. You should see how they feel free in Europe even if they come for vacations. Such brutal suppression can only result in hypocrisy.
No color is religious. You people are sick.
I know in Pkiastan we have already lost atleast the next generation to fundamentalism. I hopethe generation after the next show some openness of mind.
where there women scolars in the time of the prophet (sas)? could it be that the behaviour between women and men was a little different in the time of the prophet (sas)? and finally: where is proof for this statement? a convert women giving fatwah...masAllah! i suppose this is some type of new moderate islam in america, hm?
What and ignorant person you are. In her time, there was no greater scholar than Hazrat AIsha.
"a convert women giving fatwah..."
what an ignorant statement. All of the sahabas were converts. Before they became muslims they were mushriks. Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman, Talh, Zubari, Khalid bin Walid, Saad bin Abi Waqas....
Help yourself. Read yourself. This outsourced knowledge from the Mullah of the mosque at the corner of the street is taking away your power to think.
@JihadOfTheSoul It is Bid'ah because during the Prophet’s (saw) time the men and women were not separated in the masjid; the women simply prayed in rows behind the men.
@enterthetruth thank u for clearing that up for me. but i still like the wall-and if there was no wall i wouldn't feel comfortable going to masjid. ALLAHU AKBAR may we all serve Him to the best of our abilities
@poshhotcouture How do you "serve allah to the best of your abilities"....? In loving even more people and going towards even more human beings and help them improve their lives...?? Yes?
@poshhotcouture Do you ever wonder why you feel uncomfortable in the presence of men? Its the patriarchical code that has destroyed to the last bit any notion of confidence in women. In our soceities women as old as 21 years have to be accompained by a toddler or brother even if he is 7 years old. Otherwise she is not really allowed to venture far. Your complete thinking has been destroyed.
@poshhotcouture In our houses even the thoughts of women are not of their own. They are of either of father, of husbands or of brothers. Women are not allowed to disagree.
Now don't say that in your family it is not like. Good for you if happen to have such a nice family. I am talking about the general mindset.
LISTEN GUYS THERE WAS NO WALL IN HIS MASJID!!! BUT! LATER AFTER THE PROPHETS DEATH, THE SA'BAHS OF THE PROPHETS HEARD THE WOMENS PLEAD IN HAVING THEIR OWN SECTION IN THE MASJID FOR COMFORT, THE SAHBAS AGREED. ITS NOT BIDAH, BUT ITS NOT SUNNAH, ITS STILL ISLAM THOUGH.
i need proof before believing it is bid'ah. and if it is bid'ah who careS? i like it, i feel more comfortable. i want to take off hijab/niqaab with my sisters, and do my wudu comfortably, and be able to speak freely. and the last thing i do is go to the masjid to see men anyways. i like the wall/curtain and i feel it respects my right to privacy and worship
um...where is the proof that there was no wall? like really...all muslims kno we need a hadith or ayah to back up what we're saying. i follow the sunnah and Allah swt not a random muslim's opinion
@poshhotcouture It is clear from the following hadith that the women simply prayed behind the men and were not separated in a separate room or even concealed by a curtain or partition as is practiced in so many mosques today:
Asma' daughter of Abu Bakr said, I heard the Apostle of God say, "One of you who believes in God and in the Last Day should not raise her head until the men raise their heads lest she should see the private parts of men."(Sunan Abu Dawud, No. 850)
@EnterTheTruth What private parts? Are the men not covered while praying? Is seeing men's backside considered private parts, because, astaghfurillah we Muslim men have such definition in the back and buttocks region. ;-)
@poshhotcouture It has been narrated from Sahl ibn Sa`d's "I saw men having tied the ends of their lower garments around their necks, like children, due to shortage of cloth [because of poverty] and offering their prayers behind Allah's Messenger, Peace be upon him. One of the proclaimers said: O womenfolk, do not lift your heads [from prostration] until men raise theirs [and readjust their garments]." (Muslim,883). Traditionally Women used to pray one row behind the men in the Prophet Mosque.
you can't just call everything a bidd'a without looking at the reason behind it. walls are put up no because of the way the muslim community is. in the prophets time majority of the women covered their faces or at least the whole body except face and hands and the men all lowered their gaze. nowadays women hardly cover their hair let alone the rest of the body and the men stare at every women they see! so obviously walls are needed to stop people sinning in the house of allah
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL Murderer! Jesus Healed/Blessed/ Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY/FREE OF ABUSE/MISERY! Your leaders are killing you! All Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! PLEASE REBEL/ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of ISLAM LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
then let the muslims cover themselves and restrain themselves . this is not done as it should b and u r punished by the law for trying to force it. here in america if u try to stop women from going where they want they call the police and the man goes to jail... like wise so many men have ego and they feel they can do as they wish . i like the wall. when i breast feed my baby i can feel comfortable that no man is looking at me. and if i need to take my khimar off to do wudu i can comfortably
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL Murderer! Jesus Healed/Blessed/ Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY/FREE OF ABUSE/MISERY! Your leaders are killing you! All Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! PLEASE REBEL/ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of these LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
You people that are comparing cameras and AC units to putting up a wall between women and men in the masjid are pathetic to say the least. The bottom line is that The Prophet(SAW) didnt feel the need to do this so he didnt do it!!! Women shouldnt HAVE to stare at wall when they are in the masjid. It is a innovation bottom line because it is something is be REQUIRED and FORCED upon women in the masjid!!! If you make it optional then its not bidah but if you force it upon women then it is!!!
@AhmedAbdullah101 can we also force the women not to look at the men and flirt with them ? to leave the make up at home instead of coming to masjid like models. can we force them to observe proper hijab ? we cant . one place where we as a community r suppossed to feel safe and free from fitnah is now being violated by MODERN SO CALLED MUSLIMS. it is adultery to go out of ur house as women and try to attract attention and they also do this at the masjid saying oh well mayb i will get a husband
@Sunni4lyf Thats pathetic. Are you saying ALL muslim women do these things? Arent you supposed to "lower you gaze" andyway? And would you want a wall up between you and the Imam? And dont try and act like some muslim men dont go to the masjid and look for a wife. Modern SO CALLED MUSLIMS? Is that a insult??? You should check your own deen and ahkida before you make insults and generalizations. And dont try and make muslim women look like they're all attention seekers. Thats just pathetic!!
@AhmedAbdullah101 shhhh u just wanna look at the women =pppppppppp it doesnt matter if not all of them do it if one is doing it thts enuff . n yea we r suppossed to lower our gaze. mayb u live in a perfect community whr everyone does wht theyre suppossed to but i know whts wrong in MY commnty whr I LIVE n we need a wall . ur also pahetic u follow ur desires too much
The difference between the men and women of the Sahabah to todays Muslims is like night and day. The men look too much, but the women dress in an attractive manner that every shape of the body if recognizable!
Correction to the previous reply...I meant to say at the beginning "A woman's Salah..."Anyway brother...I fully understand, that's what I was implying.
@Mujahid777 Who are you to say that women have no need to go to the masjid? In the time of The Prophet(SAW) women always went to the masjid with no problem. People who think like you think are just one of the problems with the Muslim Ummah today. You want to isolate women and oppress them into thinking they have no place in the Masjid. How about you stay home and dont go to the masjid. How about that?
@zaytoon88 Know how many sisters stay home because they are tired of staring at a wall? Let me ask the brothers to try to listen for half an hour to your school teacher or to your imam without seeing them. Lets see your attention span. Let's see you want to know who is lecturing you from the minbar and you have to be sherlock holmes and investigate because you cant see. Prayer messed up bc we arrive late and dont know what step we are on, or there is a sajda and we cant see it. I can go on......
I do not want to judge it already but really she has to be 1 of the 2, a jahila who knows nothing and also does not know she knows nothing, or she tries what her ancestors tried long time ago, and reached nothing, trying to cause fitna from the inside, ad will never happen, because we have the source pure as spoken by Allah, and we have knowledge from people who prove every word they speak out.
this is nothing more then the feminist agenda women believing that their close proximity to men means equality, in fact The order was given for the men and women to seperate themselves in gatherings although the barrier wasn't present the seperation was and the believing women during those times knew this to be the way of the believers even during hajj the women and men seperated themselves not like today. this feminist agenda has no place in our deen
@jihhn so thats not bida, bida is when u think it gives u hasanat, they just do it for discipline, not coz its gives u more reward in ur prayers, u should 1st know the meaning of bida.. and back then there were so few ppl,
y doesnt ur town mosque follow that practice and let men and women pray together then ?
who tells you, you get hassanat by putting wall against believers. Bida means something you add in religion (here we talk about the practice of the second pillar of islam, nothing than that.)
Man and women should pray together,
Man in front and women in back like in the mosque of the prophet.
Our mosques are hollier than the one of the prophet?
Who are you to change rules and segregate women?
It's not the women or the prophet mistake that you cant control yourself.
@jihhn u r a complete idiot, no1 every said u get hasanat for it. Men and women cannot pray together, mosque now r still similar to the mosque times of prophet, only if u ever visit medinah, u would know that there r so many ppl coming and going that u cannot have women behind. by the way prophet also never used utube etc. so y is this not a bidah. no1 is segregating women, i feel ur on some1s payroll.
its also not the shaytans mistake then u cant control urself
@jihhn what argument is shit, u wanna cause a fitna for no reason, i didnt change anything, how can i possibly change when i dont even live in medinah or work there, for the curtains the islam says nothing either,show me where does it say that its not allowed,only what is forbidden in islam is wrong,ur understanding is so childish,and praying behind men is allowed u can pray like that all day long, no1 has a problem, have u ever been to madinah by the way? in my islam muslims dont fight eachther
@Mujahid777 YOUR ISLAM? I'd really like to know who gave you an ownership of Islam. Also you really should watch your mouth when your talking to a Muslimah. Obviously you have no respect for yourself let alone a fellow muslim. And so what you went to Medina. Obviously it didnt do you any good because you like to throw around insults and poke your chest out like your better than someone else. That same pride will lead you to the hellfire if your not careful. Who are you? Check yourself!!!!
@Mujahid777 Also your lame argument about Youtube doesnt hold weight because nobody ever said or tried to imply that Youtube is apart of Islam or Sunnah. So cut it out with that nonsense. Anybody with an ounce of intelligence will easily see right through that shallow argument.
@Mujahid777 Bida is not just about hasanat. Bida is ANY innovation that is brought into Islam and made to be fard or optional that is not apart of the sunnah.
You have to repeat that "you're free" ONLY TO CONVINCE YOURSELF because you don't believe it and nobody believes it. Women in islam are objects. Centuries ago when women like Isabel of Castille, Elisabeth I, Catherine of Russia, etc had absolute power in the west, women were huddled in harems in the muslim world like sex merchandise. In the quran women inherit half, their testimony is worth half of that of a man, 2:282, they can only marry one muslim man, AND THEY CAN BE BETEN, 4:34
you mean shit be upon him hijab shit, you are idiot muslim converter that muslims laghed on you and said that you go to heaven if you follow the pedophile. you are treated as a shit in islam and try to go to arabic countries to see the treatment of the arab men to their women asshole bitchiy muslim covered shit.
if you are a good muslim and you have a daughter in age of 6 then you mustttttttttttt give her to me because muhammed took aesha in age of 6 and I want to do the same
there were a dick to you to fuck you up hijab shit, look at your face you look like a bitch that kiss dicks
fuck all muslim women because you are a symbol for ignorance and terror. If I was a presedent of the USA so all the sht named islam would be thrown out the country
navigator2007 1 you are a dog. how dare you speak dirty about muslim women only because they believe in allah and they obey him and secondly will you speak same about the nuns . veil is ordained by god in bible also in 1 corinthians 11: 6 where paul says women not covering her head should shaven her hair.
Bid'ah only to do with worship, like if someone was to celebrate the birthday of teh Prophet, but with things to do with society, i.e, rectifying it or preventing free-mixing, you can not class these things innovation. The Prophet ordered the women to stick to the edges of the road (to avoid any intermingling even due to the Masjid). It is reported that after this command women walked so closely to the walls of the houses that their clothing would at times be caught in the wall.
If you are going to ask the women of the prohpets household for anything it is best to ask or speak with them from a parda... a covered sheet or wall or barrier of some sort..
not all bida'a is bad, the prophet peace and blessings be upon him said, "Anything that goes against the quran and my sunnah is in hell fire" I don't see how making a wall is in any way an innovation to be spoken about or attacked.
@VIDTHEYID: pliz be professional in ur comment..if have some issues regarding islam..pliz list out ur arguments n points..at least we can settle down and have a good n healthy discussion..i know u can do better than that.. :)
@VITHEYID: pliz be profesional in ur comment..if really dont like islam..bring to us ur points n we can have a healthy discussions n arguments..stop acting like a child..i know u can do better than that.. :)
Some divinely protected verses which have NEVER changed : Mohammad Mo...Mo. from so long ago. The Mad Man of Mecca. The dead diabolos. Mo...Mo, he humped like a hoe, The bad bearded bandit, The Prophet Pedo. Mo...Mo, Qur`an his ego, The desert dwelling dreamer, Of Dante`s Inferno
I would disagree with the speaker she says that anything that comes after the time of the Prophet(saw) is innovation and that all innovation is bad. However the Quran itself was not compiled into a book until after the prophet had passed away. So are we to believe that the Quran is bad and weakens Islam. Innovation can be for good but that is only for scholars to decide. Ordinary people can not just begin to interpret the quran and sunna on their own.
@Muneeb911: Good question. 'Beat' as some translate it is not neccessarily mean to beat the heck out of your wife. Beat could be inform of a word(advice). It could be light beating (by merely) tapping her shoulder to correct her action. A muslim is human being therefore he could beat his wife so bad but that doesnt mean Quran said so. Compare to the West. They not only beat their wives but put gun in their heads. More violence in the west than muslim nation agaisnt women believe it or not.
Please don't take as offence or disrespect on my part from what I wrote before, I am merely stating what I have researched, and I'm not trash talking.
The verse 4:34 (Surah:Verse) specifically states that you can "beat" women but lightly.
I don't think this means that you tap women on the shoulder or advise her.
If you know that women aren't oppressed in Islam, then why made unneccessary comment in the begning to make it look something else? What's your problem with 'tilt'? I really dont understand why you put the comment up in the first place if you are truly a muslim.
@Muneeb911 Oh I see. there is no need to argue with you. Well tilthe is nothing but english word and I see nothing wrong with it. Perhaps you should check ur dictionary for it meaning.Its meaning is not even about gender inequality but bcos you have negative thought about islam is the reason you are confused
@Muneeb911: Go read the Quran with open heart. Nothing wrong with it. Just accept it as it is. If you dont, thats your problem. I knew it was in the Quran. So what your whole point about it?
2@Muneeb911: I dont understand what you meant by "Women are *tilthe* for men". it will be great if you qoute the verse where you found it. However, I suggest you talking about where Quran says " They (women) are your libas (body cover) i:e your mate. So go into your tlthe etc. If this is what you refering to, I wonder why you have problem with that. It simply means husband and wife should cohabitate with one another anything. To enjoy one another anytime etc. It that what you refering to?
3: Yes Quran says men are the maintainance and sustainers over their wives" but u partly qouted the verse to make it look taking advantage of women. The verse is not a privillege for men but responsibilty of men. It's men's duty to provide for their wives & children 100%. It doesnt mean women are men's property. Understand? Dont go out there & start talking trash about Islam after u got this. Although am not a scholar but give the best I can. Salam alaikun(bless u) write me if u have questions
islam is the light and has proved to be the truth. there is proof, all you have to do is look for it from muslims not those non-muslims and false muslims that tell lies and don't nothing about Islam.
Hmraja - Proof, I am certain, is not the word you intend to use. Evidence, maybe. And re-read your statement...there is nothing different about it than any other religious hypothesis out there. 'There's only one true belief, etc etc.' It's hubris and spiteful to those that don't agree.
Actually, orthodox (meaning madhab-based) Islam understands the concept of a 'good' bida. If you're not using the sun direct relation with the horizon or the lenght of a shadow to calculate prayer times i/o a timetable then that's a bida.
ofcourse one needs to be careful and the fiqh discusses constraints, but the conceot is legitimate
They want you at home preferably pregnatnt so you know nothing of his whereabouts, dealings or womanising.
the young muslim males are beying round white girls trying to get their end away because you and you daughters are home you may be lucky , taken a course in computer studies or an office orientated course .
Which you will never use ,but if it keeps you out of his way he will happily let you do that..
They want you at home preferably pregnatnt so you know nothing of his whereabouts, dealings or womanising.
the young muslim males are beying round white girls trying to get their end away because you and you daughters are home you may be lucky , taken a course in computer studies or an office orientated course .
Which you will never use ,but if it keeps you out of his way he will happily let you do that..
During the time of our beloved prophet Rasoolullah (SAW) there wasn't any minara on the mosque, so it doesn't means we all are doing biddah by having the minara on the mosque, objective behind the praying the sallah in the mosque should be pleasing ALLAH (SWT) only. there should be a curtain or seperate room so the sister can feel comfortable.......................................
If there is a God, and I've heard that in Islam God loved you 70 times more than your own mother, if God really loves us than why are even pious people suffering, who have been nothing but "GOOD" people.
Personally, I think religions were made because people at that time had no other choice than believing in a "BEING" powerful that them. They didn't know about Evolution, scientific advances, etc.
They want you at home preferably pregnatnt so you know nothing of his whereabouts, dealings or womanising.
the young muslim males are beying round white girls trying to get their end away because you and you daughters are home you may be lucky , taken a course in computer studies or an office orientated course .
Which you will never use ,but if it keeps you out of his way he will happily let you do that..
Allah says in the Quraan: Do people think that they will be left alone because they say: We believe, and will not be tested.And We indeed tested those who were before them. And Allaah will certainly make (it) known (the truth of) those who are true, and will certainly make (it) known (the falsehood of) those who are liars, (although Allaah knows all that before putting them to test)
And certainly, We shall test you with something of fear, hunger, loss of wealth, lives and fruits, but give glad tidings to As-Saabiroon (the patient).
Who, when afflicted with calamity, say: Truly, to Allaah we belong and truly, to Him we shall return.
They are those on whom are the Salawaat (i.e. who are blessed and will be forgiven) from their Lord, and (they are those who) receive His Mercy, and it is they who are the guided ones
No misfortune or disease befalls a Muslim, no worry or grief or harm or distress not even a thorn that pricks him but Allaah will expiate for some of his sins because of that. (Agreed upon. Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 5641)
Paradise aint cheap..This world is an amusement.There is a hadith something to the effect... This world is a prison for the believers and a heaven for the disbelievers. Look at the eg of all the prophets and how they suffered. The companions of the prophet(saw) too suffered.
As a non Muslim I cannot understand why Muslim men forbid women from entering Mosques or insists that they are in separate rooms. Given that God is neither male nor female why should Muslim women be so excluded from places of worship and often from society generally? Wasn't Mohammed's (PBUH) first wife a businesswoman? Did she wear a burkha?
I understand the mixing of men and women, but when we are praying or when we our listening to the message, I don't see that it is right for us to be cut off. Prophet Mohammad(saw) never handled fitnah with a wall, so why do ppl these days think that they have a better solution than he did.
You say that 'at that time' women wore burkas. This means than the wearing of the burka is a cultural and not a religious thing, as the burka predates Islam, and therefore there is no religious reason for women to be encumbered by this piece of clothing.
And tell the believing women to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things), and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts) and not to show off their adornment except only that which is apparent (like both eyes for necessity to see the way, or outer palms of hands or one eye or dress like veil, gloves, headcover, apron), and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms) and not to reveal their adornment except to their husbands,...
It was narrated from Safiyyah bint Shaybah that Aaishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) used to say: When these words were revealed and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms) they took their izaars (a kind of garment) and tore them from the edges and covered their faces with them.
Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 4481. The following version was narrated by Abu Dawood (4102
This methodoloy of quick decisive classification of things as bida, and hence wrong, is more an indication of the lack of knowledge of both fiqh and the state of our ummah than one of clearer understanding of the rules of shariah or what was general the spirt of the Sunnah of Our Beloved Prophet.
I know Aminah Assilmi to be an inspiration speaker and advocate of Islam and Women's rights, but I don't know her to be an authority in fiqh or matters such as these.
Separation of men and women help facilitate modesty and prevent fitna, which too often occurs of open gatherings. None of this existed in the time of the Prophet. Indeed, the wall seperation did not exist. However, we're not like the people at the time of the Prophet, nor can anyone can claim to have the modesty of those at that time.
Shaykh Zakariyya explains bida that's connoted as bad is that which involves innovation IN deen, not FOR it. Unfortunately, the general meaning of the word has taken, as the exclusive connotation, it's specific reprehensible form. However, under the approval of scholars, many things can help facilitate the practice of our deen. Lines in the rows help us adhere to the command to straighten our rows, libraries helps us compile & preserve knowledge, speakers allow congregations to be facilitated.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
so then, if she had converted she should stick big bomb in her ass and go to the fuckin mosque or shit like that and blow herself out killing more fuckin stupid muslim cunts
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i dont worship anyone, only myself, i dont need Allah, Jesus, Siddharta, none of them, surprised? you can do it too, just buy the blue pills and ure happy all day, no praying, no fooling with prophets, no kneeling anywhere, just get an islamic woman and get ther to please u whilst her husband minds the sheep
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
women and men have equal rights in Islam when Muslim men like u go to heaven Allah will award him 7 virgin girls and since Allah is kind and just and dont discriminates he also is gonna award Muslim girls like ur sisters and mom u a big fat cock for their pussies subhanallah isnot Islam great?
If people felt that way, there wouldn't be anymore Muslims, but behold, the woman in the video voluntarily came to Islam (along with 200 000 converts a year)
Yes, that means she left your 'deviated' lifestyle to engage in one that truly offered her freedom and thought.
what is the word that describes something that comes into existence after the time of the prophet?? BIDAA!!
that proves my statement... time and existence and evolution STOP at the time of that guy called mohammad for islam. all new thoughts and theories and philosophies that come after mohammad are automatically rejected (simply because the quran "got it all" and there can be no more)
that's why, with islam, u r not free to think, to live and to be
all new thoughts and theories don't have anything to do with Islam. if you read the Qur'an we are told to think and ponder over the Universe and learn more about. Only those things that go directly against the religion would be rejected.
innovation in religion - not progress in worldly matters.
you're picking an argument where there isn't one. muslim society innovated algebra, systematic philology, sociology, anthropology, street lighting, public libraries.
you'll no doubt give a mindless response but no need to - you're just plain wrong.
dear sister as a new Muslim girl i just have a question as we know Allah promised Muslim men virgin girls in paradise im wondering as a Muslim girl i also get a chance to have sex with hot virgin guys with their big fat cocks? i hope so cuz i know Allah is great kind and just i hope he dont discriminate against me just bcuz im a girl
This wonderful woman is of Native American heritage like me.
canadianmuslimnproud 2 months ago
This woman is beautiful! Masha Allah! I hope Allah will give me the strength to wear hijab one day.
hijabi2b 2 months ago
Wake Up
There is good and biddah.
Go read your hadith books and your history, and stop thinking like a wahabi
Do you even know that the Harakaat on the Quran that 90% of muslims read was a biddag.. a good biddag, otherwise nobody would know how to read them.
It never happened in prophet's time, yet everyone uses it for reading. Because it is a GREAT BIDDAH
Also, the tarawee prayer of 20.. again another GREAT BIDDAH
You need to WAKE UP!!!
MrKhanRizwan 3 months ago
@MrKhanRizwan
Driving of CARS and usage of TECHNOLOGY "doesn't" constitute biddat.
Biddat in religious discussion STRICTLY means those thing that people do thinking it as act that is going to be rewarded. Biddat by its definition is done out of good faith.
schmezl 3 months ago
@MrKhanRizwan Taraweeh is not Biddah. Over the years scholars have invented various terms for different types of Namaz, i.e., sunnat mokaddah, sunnat ghair mokaddah, nafl, witar , wajib, qayamullail, taraweeh, Tahajjud. All that we call sunnat are nothing but nawafils that were offered by Prophet PBUH. Taraweeh and witr are just another name for Tahjjud. Before Hazrat Umar suggested people to offer congregational taraweeh or witr, people used to do it in masjid but seperately.
schmezl 3 months ago
@MrKhanRizwan He probably didn't like the machchli bazar individual prayer was creating because of his neat sense of organisation and reform, he suggested that they pray it under imam. As far as I know Umar himself never prayed his witr in the mosque.
schmezl 3 months ago
@MrKhanRizwan Such invention of terminology has only created confusion among the people. Now people dont even know that taraweeh, tahajjud and witr are basically the same things.
Aarab of Quran are requirement for people whose mother tongue is not Arabic. When you have facility why not use it.
Rather than labeling something as a biddat (I dont agree with this lady at all but she is entitles to have her opinion) people should make themselves aware of the whole context.
schmezl 3 months ago
@MrKhanRizwan However I'm strictly against gender segregation. Women should be allowed to pray in the same hall. Those who donot want to do that, can have a seperate room of their own. But you cannot force women to go the secluded hall thinking you are doing a rewarding act.
schmezl 3 months ago
Saudi Arabia shows the truth of islam. You wear white as a woman, saudi women wear black. Black supposedly makes the woman less desirable. Why are you not covering your face as the home of islam, saudi arabia women do? What a fool you are.
herself311 3 months ago
@herself311 Saudi Arabia has the most disgusting political and religious leadership (majority). They are the scums. Btw saudi and irani women are forced to do the Hijab. You should see how they feel free in Europe even if they come for vacations. Such brutal suppression can only result in hypocrisy.
No color is religious. You people are sick.
I know in Pkiastan we have already lost atleast the next generation to fundamentalism. I hopethe generation after the next show some openness of mind.
schmezl 3 months ago
where there women scolars in the time of the prophet (sas)? could it be that the behaviour between women and men was a little different in the time of the prophet (sas)? and finally: where is proof for this statement? a convert women giving fatwah...masAllah! i suppose this is some type of new moderate islam in america, hm?
theonlytruthisislam 4 months ago
@theonlytruthisislam
What and ignorant person you are. In her time, there was no greater scholar than Hazrat AIsha.
"a convert women giving fatwah..."
what an ignorant statement. All of the sahabas were converts. Before they became muslims they were mushriks. Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman, Talh, Zubari, Khalid bin Walid, Saad bin Abi Waqas....
Help yourself. Read yourself. This outsourced knowledge from the Mullah of the mosque at the corner of the street is taking away your power to think.
schmezl 3 months ago
@schmezl you only mentioned men..think about it. learn your islam
theonlytruthisislam 2 months ago
No such thing as a good deviation? Really.
Tell me something.. can you read the Quran in its original form, without any of the fata, dama, kasra, and many other things?
Because this was a good innovation.
Tell me, where you here at the time of the prophet, and sahaba? maybe you are also a biddah then.
Tell me, the clothes that you where, was that around?
Was the technology around which created it.. hmm another bad bidaah is it?
Tell me, did you ever sit in a car? another bad biddah is it?
MrKhanRizwan 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrKhanRizwan
Aminah Assilmi is talking about the bidah in the way we worship Allah which is mentioned by prophet (pbuh)
asifmech74 4 months ago
@MrKhanRizwan
are you nuts? do you even know what is meaning of bidaa?
in religious terminology it means an act that is done thinking as a command of religion and for which we find no chain that links it to prophet...
if you think technology and driving car is a bidat, Only Allah can help you.
schmezl 3 months ago
Like. See YouTube "9/11 Don't Get You to Heaven". Will Ferrell and Tina Fey (as Allah) denounce terrorism.
WoodyHook 4 months ago
This woman is ignorant and spreading her ignorance, it is not a bid'ah, by her locig, light bulbs are, microphones are and video recording is too.
Use hikmah and have common sense while learning your deen O Muslims!
JihadOfTheSoul 5 months ago
@JihadOfTheSoul It is Bid'ah because during the Prophet’s (saw) time the men and women were not separated in the masjid; the women simply prayed in rows behind the men.
ByChoiceMuslim 5 months ago
@enterthetruth thank u for clearing that up for me. but i still like the wall-and if there was no wall i wouldn't feel comfortable going to masjid. ALLAHU AKBAR may we all serve Him to the best of our abilities
poshhotcouture 5 months ago 2
@poshhotcouture How do you "serve allah to the best of your abilities"....? In loving even more people and going towards even more human beings and help them improve their lives...?? Yes?
444719abcx 5 months ago
@poshhotcouture Do you ever wonder why you feel uncomfortable in the presence of men? Its the patriarchical code that has destroyed to the last bit any notion of confidence in women. In our soceities women as old as 21 years have to be accompained by a toddler or brother even if he is 7 years old. Otherwise she is not really allowed to venture far. Your complete thinking has been destroyed.
schmezl 3 months ago
@poshhotcouture In our houses even the thoughts of women are not of their own. They are of either of father, of husbands or of brothers. Women are not allowed to disagree.
Now don't say that in your family it is not like. Good for you if happen to have such a nice family. I am talking about the general mindset.
schmezl 3 months ago
@schmezl you're actually retarded.
poshhotcouture 2 months ago
yes. i am a sunni woman and i like our own section. should we be denied our privacy?
poshhotcouture 5 months ago 2
@poshhotcouture nobody is denying you your privacy... but dont try and impose your perception of privacy on others...
schmezl 3 months ago
For those seeking proof, do some research !
ibnlamrini 5 months ago
LISTEN GUYS THERE WAS NO WALL IN HIS MASJID!!! BUT! LATER AFTER THE PROPHETS DEATH, THE SA'BAHS OF THE PROPHETS HEARD THE WOMENS PLEAD IN HAVING THEIR OWN SECTION IN THE MASJID FOR COMFORT, THE SAHBAS AGREED. ITS NOT BIDAH, BUT ITS NOT SUNNAH, ITS STILL ISLAM THOUGH.
thekillerose 6 months ago 2
i need proof before believing it is bid'ah. and if it is bid'ah who careS? i like it, i feel more comfortable. i want to take off hijab/niqaab with my sisters, and do my wudu comfortably, and be able to speak freely. and the last thing i do is go to the masjid to see men anyways. i like the wall/curtain and i feel it respects my right to privacy and worship
poshhotcouture 6 months ago
@ahmedabdullah101 she is right...it is clear that women are encouraged to go to the masjid.
poshhotcouture 6 months ago
um...where is the proof that there was no wall? like really...all muslims kno we need a hadith or ayah to back up what we're saying. i follow the sunnah and Allah swt not a random muslim's opinion
poshhotcouture 6 months ago
@poshhotcouture It is clear from the following hadith that the women simply prayed behind the men and were not separated in a separate room or even concealed by a curtain or partition as is practiced in so many mosques today:
Asma' daughter of Abu Bakr said, I heard the Apostle of God say, "One of you who believes in God and in the Last Day should not raise her head until the men raise their heads lest she should see the private parts of men."(Sunan Abu Dawud, No. 850)
EnterTheTruth 5 months ago
@EnterTheTruth What private parts? Are the men not covered while praying? Is seeing men's backside considered private parts, because, astaghfurillah we Muslim men have such definition in the back and buttocks region. ;-)
ukhawaja 5 months ago
@poshhotcouture It has been narrated from Sahl ibn Sa`d's "I saw men having tied the ends of their lower garments around their necks, like children, due to shortage of cloth [because of poverty] and offering their prayers behind Allah's Messenger, Peace be upon him. One of the proclaimers said: O womenfolk, do not lift your heads [from prostration] until men raise theirs [and readjust their garments]." (Muslim,883). Traditionally Women used to pray one row behind the men in the Prophet Mosque.
ByChoiceMuslim 5 months ago
you can't just call everything a bidd'a without looking at the reason behind it. walls are put up no because of the way the muslim community is. in the prophets time majority of the women covered their faces or at least the whole body except face and hands and the men all lowered their gaze. nowadays women hardly cover their hair let alone the rest of the body and the men stare at every women they see! so obviously walls are needed to stop people sinning in the house of allah
fromAllah2u 6 months ago
The only thing worse than being born a male into islam is being a woman born into islam. islam = CULT
pmoyer50 8 months ago
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL Murderer! Jesus Healed/Blessed/ Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY/FREE OF ABUSE/MISERY! Your leaders are killing you! All Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! PLEASE REBEL/ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of ISLAM LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
tigersforchrist 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Muslims, embrace apostasy and be happier.
ISLAM = CULT, not religion
MUHAMMAD = CONMAN
QURAN = WORK OF FICTION with self-contradictory verses
ALLAH = SATAN IN DISGUISE, not God
TRUE GOD = love, compassion, forgiveness, peace, tolerance, freedom, joy, etc.
ALLAH (Satan in disguise) = hatred, vengence, jealousy, war, intolerance, slavery, misery, oppression, etc.
TRUE GOD = honesty always
ALLAH = TIQIYYA = lies, dishonesty and false promises of 72 houris in any heavenly brothel.
2urita 9 months ago
THANK GOD SOMEONE HAS SPOKEN UP! I HATE WALLS THAT CUT US OFF IT'S WRONG.
greenbutterfly101 9 months ago
then let the muslims cover themselves and restrain themselves . this is not done as it should b and u r punished by the law for trying to force it. here in america if u try to stop women from going where they want they call the police and the man goes to jail... like wise so many men have ego and they feel they can do as they wish . i like the wall. when i breast feed my baby i can feel comfortable that no man is looking at me. and if i need to take my khimar off to do wudu i can comfortably
Sunni4lyf 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL Murderer! Jesus Healed/Blessed/ Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY/FREE OF ABUSE/MISERY! Your leaders are killing you! All Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! PLEASE REBEL/ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of these LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
tigersforchrist 10 months ago
the answer you couldnt find are here on the page census report, help for fighting satan
MrTrilidge 11 months ago
suck
anantsingh666 11 months ago
You people that are comparing cameras and AC units to putting up a wall between women and men in the masjid are pathetic to say the least. The bottom line is that The Prophet(SAW) didnt feel the need to do this so he didnt do it!!! Women shouldnt HAVE to stare at wall when they are in the masjid. It is a innovation bottom line because it is something is be REQUIRED and FORCED upon women in the masjid!!! If you make it optional then its not bidah but if you force it upon women then it is!!!
AhmedAbdullah101 11 months ago
@AhmedAbdullah101 can we also force the women not to look at the men and flirt with them ? to leave the make up at home instead of coming to masjid like models. can we force them to observe proper hijab ? we cant . one place where we as a community r suppossed to feel safe and free from fitnah is now being violated by MODERN SO CALLED MUSLIMS. it is adultery to go out of ur house as women and try to attract attention and they also do this at the masjid saying oh well mayb i will get a husband
Sunni4lyf 10 months ago
@Sunni4lyf Thats pathetic. Are you saying ALL muslim women do these things? Arent you supposed to "lower you gaze" andyway? And would you want a wall up between you and the Imam? And dont try and act like some muslim men dont go to the masjid and look for a wife. Modern SO CALLED MUSLIMS? Is that a insult??? You should check your own deen and ahkida before you make insults and generalizations. And dont try and make muslim women look like they're all attention seekers. Thats just pathetic!!
AhmedAbdullah101 10 months ago
@AhmedAbdullah101 shhhh u just wanna look at the women =pppppppppp it doesnt matter if not all of them do it if one is doing it thts enuff . n yea we r suppossed to lower our gaze. mayb u live in a perfect community whr everyone does wht theyre suppossed to but i know whts wrong in MY commnty whr I LIVE n we need a wall . ur also pahetic u follow ur desires too much
Sunni4lyf 8 months ago
The difference between the men and women of the Sahabah to todays Muslims is like night and day. The men look too much, but the women dress in an attractive manner that every shape of the body if recognizable!
Mujahid1 1 year ago
@Mujahid1
At my local salifi masjid in Birmingham, men and women pray together...there's no segregation.
But I understand what you mean about the inappropriate dress of many muslim women today.
Muslima399 1 year ago
@Muslima399 women can pray in home easier, no real need to go to the mosque in the 1st place
Mujahid777 1 year ago
@Mujahid777
A women prayer is more rewarded & superior if it is done in her home, as that is where the blessings are more heavy and abundant.
But if she wants to pray in the masjid, her husband should allow her. As long as she observes the proper hijab and not perfumed etc...
Muslima399 1 year ago
@Muslima399 but 1st she must know what proper hijab is..
and in todays environment it should be with much caution
Mujahid777 1 year ago
@Mujahid777
Correction to the previous reply...I meant to say at the beginning "A woman's Salah..."Anyway brother...I fully understand, that's what I was implying.
Muslima399 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Mujahid777
1.She has to bring 4 witness to prove a rape otherwise she will be charged with adultery
2.She can not convert or marry to a non Muslim
3.He can marry up to 4 but she can marry only one.
4.Two woman witness= 1 man witness
5.He can say divorce three times and get ride of her but she can not.
6.He can beat a disobedient wife but she can not
7.To re marry a divorced husband, she has to marry another man then he need to divorce her.
8.72 Virgins for men-?
PRIDEISSIN1 1 year ago
@Mujahid777 Who are you to say that women have no need to go to the masjid? In the time of The Prophet(SAW) women always went to the masjid with no problem. People who think like you think are just one of the problems with the Muslim Ummah today. You want to isolate women and oppress them into thinking they have no place in the Masjid. How about you stay home and dont go to the masjid. How about that?
AhmedAbdullah101 10 months ago
love this lade (=
absba9 1 year ago
12 people appear not to be content with the way the Prophet's masjid was set up.
TeacherTudi 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jazak allahu khair
arabcent1 1 year ago
Rest In Peace Sister
ssoo1982 1 year ago
The Validity of Partitions for women in Masjids:
/watch?v=73AD9mLVgiw
zaytoon88 1 year ago
@zaytoon88 Know how many sisters stay home because they are tired of staring at a wall? Let me ask the brothers to try to listen for half an hour to your school teacher or to your imam without seeing them. Lets see your attention span. Let's see you want to know who is lecturing you from the minbar and you have to be sherlock holmes and investigate because you cant see. Prayer messed up bc we arrive late and dont know what step we are on, or there is a sajda and we cant see it. I can go on......
TeacherTudi 1 year ago
LDS anyone? Thumbs up! ^_^
chrstilen5 1 year ago
i think you should learn a lot first!!!
I do not want to judge it already but really she has to be 1 of the 2, a jahila who knows nothing and also does not know she knows nothing, or she tries what her ancestors tried long time ago, and reached nothing, trying to cause fitna from the inside, ad will never happen, because we have the source pure as spoken by Allah, and we have knowledge from people who prove every word they speak out.
zamarino 1 year ago
was there ACs in the prophets mosque at the time of prophet,
lets take out the ACs from there, she cant stand 5 secs..
i feel like slaping her, these r agents who get into muslims to misguide them
Mujahid777 1 year ago
mecca centric is a fitna, this is what happens when agents gets in between muslims and cause fitna,
she is so dumb she doesnt know what bida is, its only when u think its good deed that something beomes a bida,
ask her, was there cameras at the time of prophet? was there
hahaha
this is what happens when westerners teach u islam, she has a long way to go an learn, im sure she cant even read arabic well
Mujahid777 1 year ago
this is nothing more then the feminist agenda women believing that their close proximity to men means equality, in fact The order was given for the men and women to seperate themselves in gatherings although the barrier wasn't present the seperation was and the believing women during those times knew this to be the way of the believers even during hajj the women and men seperated themselves not like today. this feminist agenda has no place in our deen
abdulwalee 1 year ago
which wall is she talking about ??
Mujahid777 1 year ago
@Mujahid777
the wall we use today which is Bida....
Man and women were doing salat in same room and without a Wall.
jihhn 1 year ago
@jihhn so thats not bida, bida is when u think it gives u hasanat, they just do it for discipline, not coz its gives u more reward in ur prayers, u should 1st know the meaning of bida.. and back then there were so few ppl,
y doesnt ur town mosque follow that practice and let men and women pray together then ?
Mujahid777 1 year ago
@Mujahid777
who tells you, you get hassanat by putting wall against believers. Bida means something you add in religion (here we talk about the practice of the second pillar of islam, nothing than that.)
Man and women should pray together,
Man in front and women in back like in the mosque of the prophet.
Our mosques are hollier than the one of the prophet?
Who are you to change rules and segregate women?
It's not the women or the prophet mistake that you cant control yourself.
jihhn 1 year ago
@jihhn u r a complete idiot, no1 every said u get hasanat for it. Men and women cannot pray together, mosque now r still similar to the mosque times of prophet, only if u ever visit medinah, u would know that there r so many ppl coming and going that u cannot have women behind. by the way prophet also never used utube etc. so y is this not a bidah. no1 is segregating women, i feel ur on some1s payroll.
its also not the shaytans mistake then u cant control urself
Mujahid777 1 year ago
@Mujahid777
Dont insulte beacause you dont have any argument.
You are the one who change what is allowed.
For Youtube, islam say's nothing.
For salat yes, islam says what is correct.
And i dont care how paternaliste machist did after the prophet.
What i care is what the prophet did. he allowed women to pray behind him. We must allow that's all.
You can try to find any excuse to segregate the women, but it's only you, it's not islam and they can fight back with men like me...
jihhn 1 year ago
@jihhn what argument is shit, u wanna cause a fitna for no reason, i didnt change anything, how can i possibly change when i dont even live in medinah or work there, for the curtains the islam says nothing either,show me where does it say that its not allowed,only what is forbidden in islam is wrong,ur understanding is so childish,and praying behind men is allowed u can pray like that all day long, no1 has a problem, have u ever been to madinah by the way? in my islam muslims dont fight eachther
Mujahid777 1 year ago
@Mujahid777 YOUR ISLAM? I'd really like to know who gave you an ownership of Islam. Also you really should watch your mouth when your talking to a Muslimah. Obviously you have no respect for yourself let alone a fellow muslim. And so what you went to Medina. Obviously it didnt do you any good because you like to throw around insults and poke your chest out like your better than someone else. That same pride will lead you to the hellfire if your not careful. Who are you? Check yourself!!!!
AhmedAbdullah101 10 months ago
@Mujahid777 Also your lame argument about Youtube doesnt hold weight because nobody ever said or tried to imply that Youtube is apart of Islam or Sunnah. So cut it out with that nonsense. Anybody with an ounce of intelligence will easily see right through that shallow argument.
AhmedAbdullah101 10 months ago
@Mujahid777 Bida is not just about hasanat. Bida is ANY innovation that is brought into Islam and made to be fard or optional that is not apart of the sunnah.
AhmedAbdullah101 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You have to repeat that "you're free" ONLY TO CONVINCE YOURSELF because you don't believe it and nobody believes it. Women in islam are objects. Centuries ago when women like Isabel of Castille, Elisabeth I, Catherine of Russia, etc had absolute power in the west, women were huddled in harems in the muslim world like sex merchandise. In the quran women inherit half, their testimony is worth half of that of a man, 2:282, they can only marry one muslim man, AND THEY CAN BE BETEN, 4:34
DictaduraNo123 1 year ago
you mean shit be upon him hijab shit, you are idiot muslim converter that muslims laghed on you and said that you go to heaven if you follow the pedophile. you are treated as a shit in islam and try to go to arabic countries to see the treatment of the arab men to their women asshole bitchiy muslim covered shit.
if you are a good muslim and you have a daughter in age of 6 then you mustttttttttttt give her to me because muhammed took aesha in age of 6 and I want to do the same
Navigator20071 1 year ago
NO of couse stop trying to bring your fitnah nonsense
2010MujahidBoxing 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fuck Islam. Fuck the prophet pedophile.
MountAnalogue 1 year ago
ameeen
MahyarAkbar 1 year ago
there were a dick to you to fuck you up hijab shit, look at your face you look like a bitch that kiss dicks
fuck all muslim women because you are a symbol for ignorance and terror. If I was a presedent of the USA so all the sht named islam would be thrown out the country
Navigator20071 1 year ago
@Navigator20071
navigator2007 1 you are a dog. how dare you speak dirty about muslim women only because they believe in allah and they obey him and secondly will you speak same about the nuns . veil is ordained by god in bible also in 1 corinthians 11: 6 where paul says women not covering her head should shaven her hair.
sameerahmedify 1 year ago
@Navigator20071
But you are nothing more than an insect....
So you cant do anything. Now tell your mom to learn you respect because she has not done her job .
jihhn 1 year ago
if you want to now about islam
go to mr3izah in youtube it is amaizing chanel
bilsan19 1 year ago
Bid'ah only to do with worship, like if someone was to celebrate the birthday of teh Prophet, but with things to do with society, i.e, rectifying it or preventing free-mixing, you can not class these things innovation. The Prophet ordered the women to stick to the edges of the road (to avoid any intermingling even due to the Masjid). It is reported that after this command women walked so closely to the walls of the houses that their clothing would at times be caught in the wall.
(Aboo Dawood)
jundiyyatullaah 1 year ago
@jundiyyatullaah d
subhanallah
may Allah make us love each other for His sake
12345678channelviews 1 year ago
@jundiyyatullaah
and who says what is worship and what is not ?
jihhn 1 year ago
yes there were division for the protection of ladies..
mmirza00 1 year ago
If you are going to ask the women of the prohpets household for anything it is best to ask or speak with them from a parda... a covered sheet or wall or barrier of some sort..
mmirza00 1 year ago
No ther wasn't, but because of the corruption which exsist today it is needed
abdulwalee 1 year ago
@abdulwalee
No, God now the future and the present.
So if the prophet did not mention any wall, so there is no wall.
With wall there come some other corruptions perhaps and you dont know.
jihhn 1 year ago
she wants to check out the brothers that's what it is
foilmark1 1 year ago
@foilmark1
She's dead now, so let's just watch what we say. =]
jundiyyatullaah 1 year ago
not all bida'a is bad, the prophet peace and blessings be upon him said, "Anything that goes against the quran and my sunnah is in hell fire" I don't see how making a wall is in any way an innovation to be spoken about or attacked.
Billupsj123 1 year ago
@VIDTHEYID: pliz be professional in ur comment..if have some issues regarding islam..pliz list out ur arguments n points..at least we can settle down and have a good n healthy discussion..i know u can do better than that.. :)
sparcoknvb 1 year ago
@VITHEYID: pliz be profesional in ur comment..if really dont like islam..bring to us ur points n we can have a healthy discussions n arguments..stop acting like a child..i know u can do better than that.. :)
sparcoknvb 1 year ago
The wall is innovation.
Mothertahirah 1 year ago
VIDTHEYID 1 year ago
watch"LET THE HIJAB SPEAK"
TheUhud 1 year ago
I would disagree with the speaker she says that anything that comes after the time of the Prophet(saw) is innovation and that all innovation is bad. However the Quran itself was not compiled into a book until after the prophet had passed away. So are we to believe that the Quran is bad and weakens Islam. Innovation can be for good but that is only for scholars to decide. Ordinary people can not just begin to interpret the quran and sunna on their own.
badassmonkeykilla 1 year ago
inna lillahi wa inna lillahi raji'oon. May Allah SWT accept her. AMEEN. She passed away this morning.
TANTHEMAN01 1 year ago 2
Amen, I heard the news. It is sad.
islamonly1 1 year ago 2
Allah yarhama.
JenevaKay 1 year ago
may Allah bless sister aminah , she died like my mother in a car crash.
gulmakai 1 year ago 2
gulmakai, May Allah put her and your mom in heaven inshALLAH.
islamonly1 1 year ago
I am not anti-Islamic but all I wanna say is that how are women equal to men when in the Quran it says:
1. A man is allowed to *beat* women,
2. Women are *tilthe* for men,
3. Men are the maintainers of women
Muneeb911 1 year ago
and not only Islam contains this, all religions do
Muneeb911 1 year ago
@Muneeb911: Good question. 'Beat' as some translate it is not neccessarily mean to beat the heck out of your wife. Beat could be inform of a word(advice). It could be light beating (by merely) tapping her shoulder to correct her action. A muslim is human being therefore he could beat his wife so bad but that doesnt mean Quran said so. Compare to the West. They not only beat their wives but put gun in their heads. More violence in the west than muslim nation agaisnt women believe it or not.
az11z9 1 year ago
Please don't take as offence or disrespect on my part from what I wrote before, I am merely stating what I have researched, and I'm not trash talking.
The verse 4:34 (Surah:Verse) specifically states that you can "beat" women but lightly.
I don't think this means that you tap women on the shoulder or advise her.
It means what it says.
Muneeb911 1 year ago
On the case of the West,
why are you comparing, why not just focus on ur own culture.
I don't know where you got the idea of putting a gun to their head, I have to tell u it may be true for some but thats not the case for all.
And I also wanna say that women aren't oppressed in Islam, I know that I'm not ignorant.
What the Quran says doesn't have to be the same as what is practiced by Muslims.
Muneeb911 1 year ago
If you know that women aren't oppressed in Islam, then why made unneccessary comment in the begning to make it look something else? What's your problem with 'tilt'? I really dont understand why you put the comment up in the first place if you are truly a muslim.
az11z9 1 year ago
"Oppressed" is different from "unequal".
My problem with "tilthe" is that it encourages inequality between the sexes.
And no I'm not a Muslim, religion is a thing of the past.
Muneeb911 1 year ago
@Muneeb911 Oh I see. there is no need to argue with you. Well tilthe is nothing but english word and I see nothing wrong with it. Perhaps you should check ur dictionary for it meaning.Its meaning is not even about gender inequality but bcos you have negative thought about islam is the reason you are confused
az11z9 1 year ago
(sigh) lol I dont have a problem with the word, I have a problem with how its used, and its used to describe women period.
First u didn't believe me when I stated that the word tilth is in the Quran, now ur saying that I have negative thoughts about Islam.
Thats very vague to put it that way, I am not supportive of any religion.
And I'm not confused, either ur not understanding what I'm saying or u don't want to.
Anyways lets stop this argument now.
Not offending u, just letting u know.
Muneeb911 1 year ago
@Muneeb911: Go read the Quran with open heart. Nothing wrong with it. Just accept it as it is. If you dont, thats your problem. I knew it was in the Quran. So what your whole point about it?
az11z9 1 year ago
2@Muneeb911: I dont understand what you meant by "Women are *tilthe* for men". it will be great if you qoute the verse where you found it. However, I suggest you talking about where Quran says " They (women) are your libas (body cover) i:e your mate. So go into your tlthe etc. If this is what you refering to, I wonder why you have problem with that. It simply means husband and wife should cohabitate with one another anything. To enjoy one another anytime etc. It that what you refering to?
az11z9 1 year ago
You asked where I read the word tilth, no i am not refering to what you are saying, ther surah and verse that state this are
Surah Al-Baqara
Verse 223
Read it yourself, from the Quran (in English) you have and you'll find it.
Again I am just stating what the Quran states and I am not intending to offend you or anyone else in anyway whatsoever.
Salaam
Muneeb911 1 year ago
3: Yes Quran says men are the maintainance and sustainers over their wives" but u partly qouted the verse to make it look taking advantage of women. The verse is not a privillege for men but responsibilty of men. It's men's duty to provide for their wives & children 100%. It doesnt mean women are men's property. Understand? Dont go out there & start talking trash about Islam after u got this. Although am not a scholar but give the best I can. Salam alaikun(bless u) write me if u have questions
az11z9 1 year ago
sorry wot is she talking about lol !??
is she tryna say that they should not put walls which get between men and women in mosque !?
786sheerali 1 year ago
islam is the light and has proved to be the truth. there is proof, all you have to do is look for it from muslims not those non-muslims and false muslims that tell lies and don't nothing about Islam.
Hmraja 2 years ago
Hmraja - Proof, I am certain, is not the word you intend to use. Evidence, maybe. And re-read your statement...there is nothing different about it than any other religious hypothesis out there. 'There's only one true belief, etc etc.' It's hubris and spiteful to those that don't agree.
aquatix 2 years ago
Fucking muslim pigs will burn in hell!
irvin4you 2 years ago
this women must be stoning and give sex to her husband when he wants,she must not work and live like slave.
jamalberber200 2 years ago
Actually, orthodox (meaning madhab-based) Islam understands the concept of a 'good' bida. If you're not using the sun direct relation with the horizon or the lenght of a shadow to calculate prayer times i/o a timetable then that's a bida.
ofcourse one needs to be careful and the fiqh discusses constraints, but the conceot is legitimate
786hanif 2 years ago
Wake up muslim women ,you know and I
know your men do not want you in the mosque.
They want you at home preferably pregnatnt so you know nothing of his whereabouts, dealings or womanising.
the young muslim males are beying round white girls trying to get their end away because you and you daughters are home you may be lucky , taken a course in computer studies or an office orientated course .
Which you will never use ,but if it keeps you out of his way he will happily let you do that..
ringworm29 2 years ago
what is SWH ? CANT you fuckers
talk rationally instead of ..pbuh and swh?
jpandyaraja 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wake up muslim women ,you know and I
know your men do not want you in the mosque.
They want you at home preferably pregnatnt so you know nothing of his whereabouts, dealings or womanising.
the young muslim males are beying round white girls trying to get their end away because you and you daughters are home you may be lucky , taken a course in computer studies or an office orientated course .
Which you will never use ,but if it keeps you out of his way he will happily let you do that..
ringworm29 2 years ago
During the time of our beloved prophet Rasoolullah (SAW) there wasn't any minara on the mosque, so it doesn't means we all are doing biddah by having the minara on the mosque, objective behind the praying the sallah in the mosque should be pleasing ALLAH (SWT) only. there should be a curtain or seperate room so the sister can feel comfortable.......................................
Saleem2510 2 years ago
Comment removed
Muneeb911 2 years ago
If there is a God, and I've heard that in Islam God loved you 70 times more than your own mother, if God really loves us than why are even pious people suffering, who have been nothing but "GOOD" people.
Personally, I think religions were made because people at that time had no other choice than believing in a "BEING" powerful that them. They didn't know about Evolution, scientific advances, etc.
They didn't know how to treat Cancer.
No offence to anyone.
:-)
Muneeb911 2 years ago
@ muneeb ..religion is a low IQ mans
drug...despite science people still
believe in bullshit like going to
paradise where 72 Virgins are waiting
etc etc.....how stupid !
jpandyaraja 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wake up muslim women ,you know and I
know your men do not want you in the mosque.
They want you at home preferably pregnatnt so you know nothing of his whereabouts, dealings or womanising.
the young muslim males are beying round white girls trying to get their end away because you and you daughters are home you may be lucky , taken a course in computer studies or an office orientated course .
Which you will never use ,but if it keeps you out of his way he will happily let you do that..
ringworm29 2 years ago
Allah says in the Quraan: Do people think that they will be left alone because they say: We believe, and will not be tested.And We indeed tested those who were before them. And Allaah will certainly make (it) known (the truth of) those who are true, and will certainly make (it) known (the falsehood of) those who are liars, (although Allaah knows all that before putting them to test)
al-Ankaboot 29:2-3
Fi7h 1 year ago
And certainly, We shall test you with something of fear, hunger, loss of wealth, lives and fruits, but give glad tidings to As-Saabiroon (the patient).
Who, when afflicted with calamity, say: Truly, to Allaah we belong and truly, to Him we shall return.
They are those on whom are the Salawaat (i.e. who are blessed and will be forgiven) from their Lord, and (they are those who) receive His Mercy, and it is they who are the guided ones
Fi7h 1 year ago
No misfortune or disease befalls a Muslim, no worry or grief or harm or distress not even a thorn that pricks him but Allaah will expiate for some of his sins because of that. (Agreed upon. Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 5641)
Fi7h 1 year ago
Paradise aint cheap..This world is an amusement.There is a hadith something to the effect... This world is a prison for the believers and a heaven for the disbelievers. Look at the eg of all the prophets and how they suffered. The companions of the prophet(saw) too suffered.
Fi7h 1 year ago
She is right, Mashallah
candlelightmuslimah 2 years ago
As a non Muslim I cannot understand why Muslim men forbid women from entering Mosques or insists that they are in separate rooms. Given that God is neither male nor female why should Muslim women be so excluded from places of worship and often from society generally? Wasn't Mohammed's (PBUH) first wife a businesswoman? Did she wear a burkha?
letstorkbollocks 2 years ago
I understand the mixing of men and women, but when we are praying or when we our listening to the message, I don't see that it is right for us to be cut off. Prophet Mohammad(saw) never handled fitnah with a wall, so why do ppl these days think that they have a better solution than he did.
candlelightmuslimah 2 years ago
let
no the first wife or any women at that time wore a burka. read the hadith for info abt this
hannahr77 2 years ago
You say that 'at that time' women wore burkas. This means than the wearing of the burka is a cultural and not a religious thing, as the burka predates Islam, and therefore there is no religious reason for women to be encumbered by this piece of clothing.
letstorkbollocks 2 years ago
And tell the believing women to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things), and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts) and not to show off their adornment except only that which is apparent (like both eyes for necessity to see the way, or outer palms of hands or one eye or dress like veil, gloves, headcover, apron), and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms) and not to reveal their adornment except to their husbands,...
Fi7h 1 year ago
It was narrated from Safiyyah bint Shaybah that Aaishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) used to say: When these words were revealed and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms) they took their izaars (a kind of garment) and tore them from the edges and covered their faces with them.
Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 4481. The following version was narrated by Abu Dawood (4102
Fi7h 1 year ago
It was narrated that Asma bint Abi Bakr said: We used to cover our faces in front of men
Fi7h 1 year ago
Death to Islam
comotose762 2 years ago
right back at cha....:)
candlelightmuslimah 2 years ago
Bless her
ExMuslimUK 2 years ago
by her definition of bida i hope she got to this event by Camel back becuase cars,airplanes etc are bida
NASER510 2 years ago
wow what is she like the wahabi lord
NASER510 2 years ago
This methodoloy of quick decisive classification of things as bida, and hence wrong, is more an indication of the lack of knowledge of both fiqh and the state of our ummah than one of clearer understanding of the rules of shariah or what was general the spirt of the Sunnah of Our Beloved Prophet.
I know Aminah Assilmi to be an inspiration speaker and advocate of Islam and Women's rights, but I don't know her to be an authority in fiqh or matters such as these.
Synergistik 2 years ago
Separation of men and women help facilitate modesty and prevent fitna, which too often occurs of open gatherings. None of this existed in the time of the Prophet. Indeed, the wall seperation did not exist. However, we're not like the people at the time of the Prophet, nor can anyone can claim to have the modesty of those at that time.
Synergistik 2 years ago
Shaykh Zakariyya explains bida that's connoted as bad is that which involves innovation IN deen, not FOR it. Unfortunately, the general meaning of the word has taken, as the exclusive connotation, it's specific reprehensible form. However, under the approval of scholars, many things can help facilitate the practice of our deen. Lines in the rows help us adhere to the command to straighten our rows, libraries helps us compile & preserve knowledge, speakers allow congregations to be facilitated.
Synergistik 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so then, if she had converted she should stick big bomb in her ass and go to the fuckin mosque or shit like that and blow herself out killing more fuckin stupid muslim cunts
heilm hitler
we are back............hello after 60 years
kreissage1 2 years ago
well not
Ckordobah 2 years ago
what is this american with bed sheet on hear head doing? can't afford a hair dresses? Gosh :D))
fornow100000 2 years ago
It's called a Hijab, or head scarf. Most people know that.
She's an American convert to Islam.... somewhere you'll never get due to your lack of knowleddge and blessings from God.
saleha250 2 years ago
babek right, since ur cock is only a worm, ur woman must wait for paradise,
lunafringe10 2 years ago
I agree with you, this sister misunderstands
JihadOfTheSoul 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont worship anyone, only myself, i dont need Allah, Jesus, Siddharta, none of them, surprised? you can do it too, just buy the blue pills and ure happy all day, no praying, no fooling with prophets, no kneeling anywhere, just get an islamic woman and get ther to please u whilst her husband minds the sheep
lunafringe10 2 years ago
Get a life man!!!
stupidalokabitch 2 years ago
you don't have a lot of ahem...sex do you??
peanuts8 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
women and men have equal rights in Islam when Muslim men like u go to heaven Allah will award him 7 virgin girls and since Allah is kind and just and dont discriminates he also is gonna award Muslim girls like ur sisters and mom u a big fat cock for their pussies subhanallah isnot Islam great?
babek17 2 years ago
islam itself is a deviation from a man's freedom and thought...
manager1111 2 years ago
Prove that statement.
If people felt that way, there wouldn't be anymore Muslims, but behold, the woman in the video voluntarily came to Islam (along with 200 000 converts a year)
Yes, that means she left your 'deviated' lifestyle to engage in one that truly offered her freedom and thought.
saleha250 2 years ago
what is the word that describes something that comes into existence after the time of the prophet?? BIDAA!!
that proves my statement... time and existence and evolution STOP at the time of that guy called mohammad for islam. all new thoughts and theories and philosophies that come after mohammad are automatically rejected (simply because the quran "got it all" and there can be no more)
that's why, with islam, u r not free to think, to live and to be
PS: some people voluntarily commit suicide
manager1111 2 years ago
all new thoughts and theories don't have anything to do with Islam. if you read the Qur'an we are told to think and ponder over the Universe and learn more about. Only those things that go directly against the religion would be rejected.
MatrixOfDynamism 2 years ago
then u dont believe in bid3a?
manager1111 2 years ago
innovation in religion - not progress in worldly matters.
you're picking an argument where there isn't one. muslim society innovated algebra, systematic philology, sociology, anthropology, street lighting, public libraries.
you'll no doubt give a mindless response but no need to - you're just plain wrong.
peace (& go do some research)
786hanif 2 years ago
786
So where are those libraries and streetlights? Surely not in any islamic countries, so what happen?
hannahr77 2 years ago
@hannahr77
are you serious?
research British colonial destruction of Muslim culture and institutions for one answer
786hanif 2 years ago
dear sister as a new Muslim girl i just have a question as we know Allah promised Muslim men virgin girls in paradise im wondering as a Muslim girl i also get a chance to have sex with hot virgin guys with their big fat cocks? i hope so cuz i know Allah is great kind and just i hope he dont discriminate against me just bcuz im a girl
babek17 2 years ago