Added: 4 years ago
From: imaginary41
Views: 212,931
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (308)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Люблю тебя, Эми!!!

  • essa musica eh muito massa

  • That was the best band-setup ever ..

  • 4:08 go there and pause... just do it

  • @randomGUY843 lol

  • You know even though she was tired or whatever I still love the song. It kind of makes it darker which I like.

  • eva

  • wooaaahh .. 

  • come to indonesia please .. :(

  • @iunka1 I'm an indonesian and I wish she''ll have a tour at jakarta !! XD

  • 3:56 awkward crowd surfing lol

  • Oh...what i wouldnt give to be on stage with her...singing and dancing with such an amzing person <3

  • Rock am Ring HAS EVERYONE WHOS ANYONE

    AVENGED SEVENFOLD, EVANESCENCE

    great stuff

    what other great bands are there?

  • Is it just me or does Amy pretty much always have a cold at concerts?

  • @LadySylvanas101 Maybe she doesn't have good health o:. So she always seems to catch colds. Since she usually travels away from her hometown, so maybe her body can't adjust to the weather? I don't know. OwO

  • :D My Stepmom is her neighbour...argghhargg the Jealousy c:

  • This song gives me the shivers every time I hear it, it's freaking hauntingly beautiful...

  • She moves like Jon Davis from KoRn. lol

  • My fav song by them =)

  • i just had to take my cuz to a talyor swift concert and I WAS SINGGING (with megaphone) THIS AND WAS DRESSED ABOUt like this and was trying to start mosh pit but alas, NO!

  • Germany? holy crap! I was there in 2004! but to bad I came down w/ a cold and couldnt come to the concert. :(

  • @kingdomheartsgirl111 lol amy lee was in Germany too! but she came down with a cold and sung at the concert xD

  • they should of had this as one of their singles

  • i agree

  • so brave to go on stage with an illness. i'm impressed babe. :) ill and yet still has the ability to impress and stun millions!!! thats real talent right there! DO YOU AGREE?!?!?!?!?

  • at 4:07...

  • Problem with Amy is she never can sing the songs on level of studio record.. :-/ Pretty boring like this.. As if she doesn't have the air capacity in lungs or how to describe it... But her records are pretty cool :-)

  • @fxaman She sounds breathless because she's sick

  • @torilutz8 Not really.. I watched their DVD and it was even worse.. :-/

  • @fxaman Well she also is putting forth a lot of energy which is exhausting... it's hard to sing and perform like that at the same time haha but whatever it's an opinion

  • its so awesome at 1:39 when she makes her voice high pitch and then the drummer smiles :P

  • Good singers will try to perfom when ill, great singers kick ass even if they are.

  • She always sounds kinda nazley on stage. But that's understandable since she runs around & sings with so much energy. I LOVE her!!!!!!!!!

  • It's clear she's ill, but the best singer fight through it and try anyway.

    She carried on and it's not the worst while a singers ill.

    could have been worse.

  • its clear she had a slight cold...but shes still the best female rocker ever ive been listening to her sence i was2 or 3

  • this song always sends a shiver down my spine o.0

  • Amy.... is... hmmm (hard to find something to describe her...)... the ONLY singer ever that is better in her Lives, than in the studio!!!!!

  • This performance is not good, It seems Amy needs to take a brearth, Does she sing like this? Always? I never heard this song live better than this. Is awful !!!. This band sucks.

  • @unkperson stfu. amy sings AMAZING. its just she must have bin on stage a LONG time, and shes out of breath, and her voice is wearing! geez!

  • @kittygirl660 maybe what you say is true, but what do you say about Tarja Turunen from Nightwish? She have been on stage long time too, even longer than Amy and she wasn`t out of breath. I don't know what you think about this, but for me... Tarja is better singer than Amy.

  • Lets Rock Awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Troll - someone who responds to a year+ old comment to be a smartass.

  • bahhhhh

  • Evanescence band is the best 

  • wtf.. the crowd sucks ass..if i could be there i would bouncing up and down with her!! 

  • MUITO BACANA CANTA D++ TE AMO EVANESCENCE

  • fuck yea!! im from winnipeg. i cant wait to see them! =D

  • omg...i never expected the double bombo in the drumms...they drive evanescence to a new level of music...this version its much better than the original ^^

  • !!!!!!!!!!!!!

    i love evanecence

    !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • muahaha she still rocks even with a cold >:)

  • MUST. SEE. EVANESCENCE. LIVE!!!

  • @fantasygurl101 TAKE. ME. WITH. YOU!!!

  • @fantasygurl101 TAKE. ME. WITH. YOU!!!

  • @fantasygurl101 I saw them live in October. Ahh.maze.ing.

    

  • why she never screams the" I want to die" part?

    btw... I FUKIN LOVE THIS BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i love her ...

  • dude your can tell this is old because they have the drummer and bass player they have

  • i like We Are The Fallen!

    But this is so good too

  • @Caos0828 c'mon man Evanescence is the best :)

  • Yea, she is fckin awsome and all.......but what is up with her hair and outfit?

  • Comment removed

  • i believe she had a cold? and yet she sings amazing. even when she's sick. that's skill

  • @TrojanTurtle Why do so many Evanscence live performances have these comments saying she had cold ?

  • Everyone says her voice sounds really bad live, IT WAS A COLD!!!! GET WITH IT PEOPLE!!!!!!!! She didn't sound so bad

  • all of this crap about her voice being bad live, it's obvious she had a cold during the show. I have seen them six times she usually sounds really good

  • amy lee 4eva

  • Fuck It!

    She Did Awesome!

    On Top Of Being Interactive She Remained On Time And For the Most Part Hit ALL

    The Notes!

    Fuck Yeah!

  • AND DON'T FUCKING JUDGE HER ON THIS ONE SONG!!! DO YOU KNOW HOW FUCKING HARD IT IS TO EVEN SING TOURNIQUET, MUCH LESS WHILE JUMPING AND GOING AROUND THE STAGE, OVER THE SOUND OF SCREAMING FANS?! GO WATCH HER SINGING MY IMMORTAL LIVE, AND YOU WILL AGREE SHE IS GREAT. BESIDES, THIS WAS CLOSE TO THE END OF THE CONCERT AND THE TOUR, SO HER VOICE WAS TIRED. MAKE SURE YOU UNDERSTAND SHIT BEFORE YOU POST.

  • The reason it doesn't sound quite the same is because she is trying to put the sound of pain into it, instead of making it sound pretty but emotionless.

  • She did sooooo good!!! :D

  • Metallica is gonna rip deese Pussies !!!! lol !! nice song !!!1

  • @coolduderonit can you even type? pfft. typical metallica fan

  • @punkstreetpunk : fuck off Pussy.....

  • @coolduderonit I would, but then you should stop cooyping what I told your mom :O

  • terry ftw

  • i am a huge fan of evanescence but i just think she sounds better in the studio versions....

  • @laura121494

    Obviously, in studio musicians usually run through 20+ takes of the same track.

    If you want to listen to the song, buy the album...If you want to experience the bands emotion, buy a ticket...as simple as it gets. Most bands suck live and have a lot of fuck-ups anyways but they can get away with it as long as they put on one hell of a show.

  • i can relate to this song

  • Chester Bennington Running around Jumping around,but he has no problems to sing or scream at all xD

  • Amazing i cant move only show this video :)

  • Holy crap she looks a bit scary lol

  • i really mis dis song, last june 4, 2010 hahahahahahaha :D

    dba SLR?

  • whats the name of the guitarist with the dreads?

  • @footlesself99 Terry Balsamo

  • Comment removed

  • how can you not love her?

  • era mi grupo favorito pero :/ ya no e sabido nada de ellos ahora es mago de oz

  • For people who think she's so great life. Sometimes maybe, but half of the performances I've seen were quite off key. Listen to " Evanescence Imaginary Rock in Rio " (just search on youtube). It's quite off key.

  • @PowerRedBull For you from someone who thinks she might well be really great live: 1. it's just youtube videos. I've been blown away in concert by singers who on youtube sound average at best; 2. I can't find any flaw in her most recent videos I know (2009), so it seems that she has improved technically in the meantime. And that is the important thing, isn't it? I mean, who cares if 5 years ago she used to screw up?

  • All of her songs give me the chills man Waahhhh

  • Hermosa Amy Lee.

  • WoW she's very tortured ....Still Powerful voice....she's very strong...go go go Amy Lee and EVANESCENCE IS THE BEST:X:X:X:X

  • goosebumps

  • amy's got a beautiful, powerful voice.

  • r u kidding? shes fuking awesum live way better then recorded, live u get to here her rwal n raw voice its so much more powerful

  • WOW,I'm a guy and I would totally wear that dress,she has a kickass taste in both music and dress wear.

  • @nandara2709 fag

  • @themanbearpig Hey man nice comment (two months late),I would ask if your that slow in everything else you do,but that would be a rhetorical question....

  • i saw Amy Lee in my friends kerrang magazine for the first time in ages and she was only rated 17 for this thing

    .. anyway she should of been one of the top 3 !

  • Wow!

  • yea new album comming at the end of this year. Watch on myspace amys vid :)

  • this song is just...wow!!!!

    does anyone know what the hell happened to this best band ever???why dont they play anymore???

  • they are in studio recording their new album, you can sear in youtube the song called "together again" it´s a B-side , and sorry for my bad english ;)

  • she is the best live singer ever. i love her sisging. she knowa how to sing.

  • she's not that great live, but she's still an awesome singer. at least she doesn't lip sing like some of those idiots. she gets into an tries. she deserves props for that. her fans payed to see her give her all and that's what she does. her songs are difficult vocally so to see her struggle is nothing. she's exhausted. at least she tries.

  • Hard Rock is the hardest style of all to sing, anytime you have a wraspy edge it takes its toll on your voice big time. I sing all styles and Hard Rock is by far the hardest. I always thought evanescence was a modern version of Dream Theater..

  • i think this rock am ring is waay better than 2003!

  • Wtf

    Ke feoo kantaa en vivo :S

  • this is one of her weaker live videos....its weird - I know she can sing, and very well, but it seems like 50/50 when shes really good and really...all over the place.

  • agreed. this must have been near the end of a tour, or she was just tired for that show. She is really missing some notes and avoiding others. Either way, I still give the chick props.

  • Sorry If It made no sense...

    What i was TRYING to say in the comment was that in other videos showing her live she sounded awesome but in this one to me she sounded kinda bad.

  • Amy Rocks! She's a real head-banger. You gotta love her.

  • she is deep i like the passion in her song and voice

  • i love the way she moves on the stage she's a great performer

  • every she singing,

    is like a Crying angel lol

  • nice dreads

  • she's fantastic live

  • this is my favorite evanescence song

  • this girl is awesome live. girl can hit some notes. also... HATE lame ass crowds that don't move - get up and MOVE!!!

  • actually, she's a mezzo soprano, so she can't really hit that high of notes.

    In fact, she's sometimes a bit sketchy live. I remember seeing them in Mountianveiw during Family Values and she cracked during The Only One, and the note was something like B2 (second B above middle C), which, on a female voice spectrum isn't that high.

    She sounded amazing most of that concert though :P

  • @lilmizzbloodymary

    The people in the crowd should do only one thing- whatever they like.

  • @lilmizzbloodymary It;s evanescense man! who would ever hit his head in their live? it ain't Marilyn Manson! There is where you can and must get mad! i would ruin the stage if i were in Manson's live but in Evanescense, no! i would just hear the music !

  • I Just Wana Hug Her!!! I LOVE AMY LEE!!!!

  • rastas are fucking horrid

  • Man I wish had half the talent she has. Amazing

  • @dmi4life

    Practise, practise, review yourself honestly andconcentrate on your weaknesses , and practise, practise & practise more

    People often think singing is some ability you have. Yes, for some people. However, it's not like creativity what you can't really 'learn'. Singing is like learning to ride a bicycle. It's just harder, but in theory everyone should be able to learn it

  • @dmi4life No. AMYZING!

  • god damn shes fuckn hot

  • wow. she's amazingggg. i actually like this song better live!!!!

  • Wow....Amy's good live

    Love it

  • do u people know most of their their songs are hard to sing, even for Amy lee when she has to run around and bounced around on stage. It would be quite boring if she just stand still and concentrate on sing the songs well, wouldn't it? It's live and not easy, she has to run aorund and sing at the same time.

  • @zzzthaoster yes I agree I didn't realise how hard the songs were to sing until she sang them! When you jump around your voice does bounce, she puts alot of effort into the performance she even sings when she is ill!

  • @zzzthaoster ur right cuz 2day i was bored so i did a "concert" and it was just whisper and i was TIRED!!! and runnin around didnt make the singin any easier!!!

  • @zzzthaoster I agree! That's why so many singers lip sync! (which Amy doesn't)

  • this is nice.

  • very good!!!!!! I love you Amy and I love Evanescence ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

  • I don't know where she gets her clothes, but she needs to tell me!

  • Ella hace su propia ropa xD...la compra y la remodela

  • Ben Moody and John LeCompt are nothing without Amy...

  • wtf copy cat lol

  • How am i copying? I said the exact opposite which you said implying i disagree with your statement.

  • @blackstones83 surely u can't be serious ben moody was just holding them down... but that's just my op.

  • she sound out of breath but she stil OWNZ!!!!

  • @Kaneevrfld u suck

  • she is truely amazing

  • I like the song but it sounds like she was singing for to long so her voice is cracked But shes trying and it sounds good.

  • SUPER Song.

  • best song eva

  • Amazing x

  • Thats my favorite song ever!I will never forget the emotion I felt when I saw her performing that song here in Brazil in 2007 *.*

  • LOL 4:07 =))

  • i love amy lee so much. her drummer made the song tourniquet. the part I WANT TO DIE is a biit weird but she has an amazing voice live.

  • You mean when she tries to sing "salvation" before the part "I WAN TO DIE"? Cuz obviously she doesn't sing that part.

  • Shes a rocker people. With a voice like hers you are bound to crack with all the movement!

  • It was awesome.

  • Jeezzz I would be screaming sooo loud on how much I love her if I was there.

    XD

  • I was there :D

  • fuck these people. i think she did absolutely amazing! i havent seen one video of evanescence performing live,...and me not liking it. she puts in a lot of effort and i think she really does an excellent job. she knows wut she's doin. ♥amy lee Evanescence forever♥

  • beatiful!!

  • Actually, I think Amy did amazing! You have to remember she's moving around.

  • ahhh I don't know about using computers, except for the obvious stuff like sound quality etc...but I've heard very good live performances. Also, remember that watching it on TV or computer is different from being at the venue, and affects the sound. I'd have to agree that she may have been shitfaced...she said that ever since she was performing as a teenager, she gets REALY nervous.

  • me enkanta sta kancion

    y por supusto soy fanatiko de evanescence

    y en especial de AMY LEE

  • Try singing and rocking to that crowd and see how well you sing. I heard she was shitfaced too, to be avble to handle that big of a crowd aswell..so.

  • i hope i am wrong....