譚詠麟 梅艷芳 - 緣份

[liangjian1]

谭咏麟这歌没有张国荣唱得好！

[icyhugs]

The irony of life: Alan and Leslie were described as the worst rival at the peak of their singing career back in the 80s. The 1st few lines of lyrics ..... sigh....

沒有一聲再見　沒有半聲嗟怨 淡淡去但無言　過去終於過去 留下了當初一切　在懷念

[sailorchibimoon1665]

Alan tam looks so young

[ocarol18]

睇親梅姐最後一場演唱會都喊，好非常掛住妳梅姐，

[vincehangout]

miss anita soooo....R.I.P anita..

[fossilz001]

They are amazing!

[a782551321]

哥哥把聲令呀嘛-.-

[creamyiceful]

校长唱得好好笑！！

[lhsd]

當年三劍俠，現在只剩alan.....

[YEN0706]

但我覺得梅姐唱的時候，滿腦子肯定都是gorgor

[xinnews2]

@YEN0706 我也这样想

[YEN0706]

@xinnews2 特別是唱到：你我相隔多麼遠....那年那天可相見.....:­(

[ben065566]

@YEN0706 你愛吃屌喔

[8191217zz]

@YEN0706 這風格跟校長不太搭~ 但我還是覺得不錯的，因為哥哥的逝去。

[canbrain]

Alan的唱功，歌聲也很捧。

但，找不到哥哥和阿姐合唱的味道:'(

[saturday2046hk]

欣賞～阿倫，阿梅，哥哥，都係我好鐘意的歌手～

[gzseyy]

感觉怪异的人其实就系因为对于原唱的印象太深了，加上阿伦并唔想­唱到Leslie咁的（何况珠玉在前）风格，大家权当听唔同风格­的就系了，何必介怀太多以及过于挑剔？

[gzseyy]

其实就是大家听了原唱先入为主罢了，加上演唱会和录音效果显然不­一样，录音一般要严格遵守原曲，而演唱会可以自由发挥大好多。加­上阿伦同哥哥系两种风格，不是非要比较不可的。

[Helgagaist]

this special moment......makes me so sad but was wonderful

[karen3752]

Anita mui so funny and cute

[26565116]

冇野好比較,永遠d歌番唱係冇原唱咁好聽架啦

[jollychippy]

leslie and alan are big different style, even character and songs. leslie is more playboy feel even can hear from his songs (bit lazy n playful feel) so cant be compare, i love both...

[mineko1819]

震呀震, 震甩晒啲深情.. 唱腔似唱緊兒歌多啲..

[KingSleyHoKaHang]

傻啦 我都冇咩型像可以咩野呀 同你差唔多 冇咩分別 

[kwong2469]

無可否認original係好聽多D

[tomli8880508]

無論啱唔啱唱, 唱成點, 呢個片段只會成為回憶...十二月三十日, 我們永遠想念你, ANITA

[MsElla888]

我是校长的歌迷，也觉得这首歌不是很适合校长唱。同校长的整体风­格不太符合。今日是anita逝世7周年，怀念她。

[cheukhanghang]

may?



[carotrice]

这首缘分由谭咏麟唱来实在感觉不对， 无关唱功无关风格， 说不上来的诡异

[MsElla888]

同意你的说法，无关唱功，只是感觉有点奇怪

[jameslo2009]

每個人有每個人的風格！

[wklace]

leslie cheung is way better than alan tam

[monkeybsw]

i really wanna know which event do they refer to about JACKY CHAN ???

[beavertown2006]

Poor Mui Mui.

Still love her.

[winghowwh]

成廿年啦 哥哥黨同校長黨 重要鬥？

認真講句　我同時係哥哥同校長既fans...

但我真心覺得呀麟既歌功係勁過哥哥

呢首歌 呀麟同哥哥各有各味道

我唔會話邊個好d 就算係羅文既聲唱呢首歌 我都會覺得有另類既味道

[LAIMING429]

校長唔想唱到有張國榮風格唱成咁...............­...

.

[LAIMING429]

校長唔想唱到有張國榮風格唱成咁...............­...

[LAIMING429]

校長唔想唱到有張國榮風格

唱到粒世位

[LAIMING429]

校長都唔想唱係阿梅叫到至唱

阿梅找唔到第2個有份量人唱

唱成咁......................

[anw828]

anita so beautiful

u r our superwoman 4ever

[namida401]

懷念Leslie

[ashley090184]

听不懂两位说什么 好着急啊 有没有朋友可以把他们的话写出来呢 谢谢好心人啊

[grandymui]

校長唱法富有濃厚感情...充滿個人特色!

哥哥唱法自然....人歌合一...

無咩好比較.....兩個都係巨星!

[688bobby]

I miss Anita and her onstage charm a lot when watching this video.... She and Alan were good friends then and the remarks she made of him was sooo funny.

This version makes me appreciate the original version all the more.... >_<

[688bobby]

Miss Anita and her onstage charm a lot after watching this video..... The remarks she made of Alan was very very funny. They were good friends.

This version makes me appreciate the original version all the more.... >_<

[HKMESW]

我好細個的時候都以為Lesile係sell樣的...

但大個佐發覺他的唱功很好... 真係sell唱功... 特別係舊歌...

佢把聲好厚...

[HKMESW]

我好細個的時候都以為Lesile係sell樣的...

但大個佐發覺他的唱功很好... 真係sell唱功... 特別係舊歌...

佢把聲好厚...

[3shinji]

哥哥呢......哥哥你係邊........

[FireAllianceNX]

I love that she was trying not to laugh at him.

[TheCHAIRHON]

緣份 hey

[rickliuhk]

都係哥哥+梅姐 呢個組合好d....

校長唱出黎好似怪怪地.......

不過我諗當時梅姐唱呢隻飲歌...一定諗起哥哥....

[lov2xi]

yes

[zx123456able]

譚詠麟 梅艷芳 - 緣份

[holiday258]

校長的確勁

[jrotc1991]

体到梅姐邊唱邊哭喔...一定好掛住哥哥...當時心情！

[TiTiTam]

i love both leslie and alan* coz they r sooooo unique

without one of them, 80's wouldn't be as great as it was!

comparing he vocal, i think alan is better

but leslie's performances were a surprise

no comparison, both of them r gr8!

[neopets915]

阿梅,我永远爱你!!!

[Xplenovo]

永遠支持芳姐愛芳姐....

[01191070]

人生還長遠  何必回首過去 改變現況 夢想將近

[tiencai98053]

校長同Leslie比起來, 雖然校長唱功不錯,但還是Leslie有唱出這首歌的感情

[littlestar0116]

@tiencai98053 I agree that Leslie is better. It isn't differnet style of singing, it's alan without feeling to sing this song.

[littlestar0116]

@tiencai98053 I agree that Leslie is beter. It isn't different style of singing, it's alan without feeling to sing this song.

[falancan]

I always wonder why Mui worked so hard when she was so ill. I dont know if she wanna perform before she die or she wanna make more money for her family. I felt sorry for her when her mum always ask for money(all the time) after she died.

Mui, u are so talented and so much fun.We will always love u!

[winghowwh]

我係哥哥fans...

但我覺得哥哥同校長...

係各有韻味...各有各好...

但論歌功...校長的確勁啲=]

[asd56899]

太棒了好懷念梅姐....永遠懷念你...

[bruceback]

sweet....

[tszhei11]

還要討論alan 同leslie= =

alan當年都53歲......唱功都好難再好啦....

[evelynhaze]

OMG Alan...

I miss leslie so much

[anyway606]

经典...

虽然Leslie 离开了，但梅姐还是找了Alan 来代替她心爱的Leslie 和他一起合唱！支持....毕竟友情是伟大的....

[Slaander]

zkgshit, shutup, she just using the songs to say good bye to her friends, since she knows she don't have much time left.

[dandelionjp]

So many years later.. no matter how many times I watch this video, I cry. Mui-je, so brave, so determined.. shining so brilliantly, so very, very beautiful!! Ahhh Mui-je, I miss you so much!!!!

[Creighla]

anita r.i.p.

[hoppers001]

the man is 58, give him a break.

[zkgshit]

譚詠倫唱到好怪，啲停頓位唔同哂。但個人覺得以佢而家嘅狀態講嘢­好過唱歌。佢近呢幾年唱歌都不復當年！

[ice004004]

「揾哥哥唱alan d 歌, 佢一定唱吾到囉」?

乜你冇聽過哥哥唱alan既幻影同霧之戀咩?

[xlwaiyiplx]

i cried so hard

[kalun888]

你揾哥哥唱alan d 歌, 佢一定唱吾到囉。所以吾好比較啦, 哥哥吾係賣唱功, 但佢離開舞台回來後唱功係進步左。

[banana5201314]

France-Edith Piaf

American-MJ

Chinese HK-Anita Mui

[kakihandsome]

哥哥是無人能及....

[vvv11121]

梅姐, 一早已經警告左李宗盛..

[companyys]

唔明.. 點解.. ?

[happyj122]

romantic song, i love this song

[Darkriders123]

Comparing Leslie's to Alan's voice, Leslie sounded way better! Geez, and soon Alan might need to duck tape his neck or his head will really drop...

[ollik6]

i believe both leslie and alan sing very well, leslie is more artistic, 但校長把聲勁D喎, both are passionate. maybe it's just because leslie sang this first. haha yes head will really drop they are funny

[man165]

maybe it's because you are a Leslie fan...hm

[hazelwai]

i miss her...

she is a real star....

不過呢首歌就好似...

梅姐同哥哥....先可以一齊唱既歌

點都唱唔到個種韻味啦....

[supporthackenalan]

kind of miss ah....mui :(

[tubeloving]

Sorry... but.... Tam's voice just seem to not go with this song. I think its because Leslie's voice is too strongly connected to this song already T_T

[Mamakayi]

wat happened to anitas voice? Did she cry too much?

[coreyduck]

You know wt her voice was affected by the treatment of chemotherapy. T . T so..... everytime i watch the clip from her "last" concert i feel so hurt. She is trying hard to keep the show perfect, make joke around. Actually that is the last chance to see her fans on stage and last perfomance of her life-time. She is a legend send from The God............

[dannytheelf]

看到校长，想起哥哥

[Mamakayi]

When exactly was this??

Must be after Gor-Gors death, wasnt it?!

[anyway606]

yeah , end of the 2003,i think it was Aug ? or Sep.

[kuen0827]

should be nov

[yuenstyle]

其實..

我覺得梅姐唱這首歌時一定很有感觸...

畢竟跟她唱這首歌唱了＋幾年的老朋友

一直只有一個...

但他..

走了...

miss 哥哥＆梅姐

[chowsiumanchowsiuman]

係呀，唉，真的很難過

[anyway606]

有没有资格不是你来评论的，看来你才是没有资格评论的一个！人家­梅姐请他做嘉宾，一定有她原因，难道不出席吗？不懂人情世故..­..

[8191217zz]

@anyway606 請他做嘉賓的原因，應該是一起拍過電影吧!

富貴兵團! 譚詠麟-羅森 梅艷芳-草木蘭 劉德華 - 華英雄!

[po102475]

@8191217zz 佢地幾十年老友....你吾糸吾知牙?

[8191217zz]

@po102475 ...不知道= =我不是香港人唷!

[Heyken17]

its real sad cuz her voice is already deteriorating by then =(

[Fondmemory]

Leslie has a sensitively caring heart and that's why he could sing every song with an overflowing emotion. Furthermore, his sexy voice was in inborn and that's why his love songs can touch the heart of each listener. Nobody could have sing this song better than Leslie and Anita. It's too heartbreaking to watch this performance when knowing that it took place after Leslie has gone and Anita has no choice but to invite Alan Tam to sing the song on behalf of Leslie....... sigh.

[unterdemweiden]

我觉得她找潭是刻意的。她本来完全可以找和张比较类似的李克勤张­志霖等，而她找了一个不论风格还是声音都大相径庭的潭，说明她不­想触景生情。

不过她有点失策，张国荣死了，这首歌就当是绝唱好了，再找别人唱­一次无异画蛇添足。

[unterdemweiden]

是啊，这就是张国荣尴尬的地方。他是以商业化偶像起家的，但是以­艺术家终结。（相反很多学院画家起点是艺术家，终点却是俗媚的投­机骗子）其实这也是现代平民社会唯一成为艺术家的道路，阳春白雪­的独木桥只在贵族时代行得通，只要上流圈子认可就可以了。但是他­很不高兴这样，因为在很多人心目中，他还是和潭争霸的那个张国荣­。

[EsomeE]

你根本不了解張國榮, 你沒資格也不應該去評論

[unterdemweiden]

你又有什么资格评论我了不了解？

如果你自认为也不了解，那你怎么证明我不了解？

如果你自认为了解，那我很感兴趣你是谁？！

按照你的逻辑大家都洗洗睡了算了，

张梅已经死了，他们不可能再开口说

知我者某某某了！

[Fondmemory]

I fully agree with your view. Even though Alan Tam's fans have marked your comment as spam...

In Hong Kong, most people nowadays think that Leslie is a serious artist and has kept on improving himself over the years. Whereas for Alan Tam, his singing is the same as it was decades ago.

[ollik6]

dear fondmemory, I dont think this is true Alan is always improving himself too 佢依家把聲厚過以前, and look at 左麟右李, another success, over the years alan has changed his target to bringing joy to everyone. I just want to say both leslie n alan r real super stars. 各有長短, leslie is more artistic, but alan is more energetic with his voice more powerful

[Fondmemory]

Sorry, I still don't like Alan Tam mainly because of his personality. I don't like fake people. I only admire those who're truly talented and has a heart of gold.

[hengx]

it's her last concert before she passed away...almost everyone she invited came...i think most of them knew it's the last time they could sing with her as she face the final stage of cancer

[Helen7265]

I am not trying to be against Alan - I think Alan is a good singer. But, I like Leslie's version much better because I think Leslie has a softer and sexy voice while Alan's voice is more crispy...

[LlamaLordofScience]

I love this part of the concert, the two of them look so sweet.

[013tvalan]

anita was a great singer although i am not her fan.

[LlamaLordofScience]

I love this song, it's so sad that she passed away not too long after this concert. *sigh*

[starsinajar]

yeahh alan is really good singer...but i love the anita+哥哥's duet ;(

[disastranagant2007]

那時哥哥精神上已經唔係太好....而梅姐係呢個show 之後都差不多...嗚嗚嗚~~

所以先請校長唱....

[xmeddie]

Leslie had gone on April 1st 2003, the concert took place later Autumn. Still, itwas a very touching performance. Anita passed away on 12/30/2003. Sad.

[samson123321681]

可惜那時哥哥已經唔係我地身邊

[Phil28168]

lovely song. a beautiful performance by Alan and the late Anita. thank you for the upload.

[ahlunn2001]

legend, miss her!... but dont be too sad people!,she could be partying having fun playing ma jong with leslie and roman at the moment, could also be with james wong jim too..!

[justinl1991]

Alan Tam is a very good singer, and has sang many good songs. But somethings i think he exagerates to much when he sings. Leslie Cheung sings this song with much more feeling.

[suminexsan]

I totally agreed! Leslie's version is much more touching!

[siuwahchan]

Alan Tam sang this song with Anita, was out of the respect of Leslie, as we all know Anita and Leslie were so close like brother and sister. What was more touching then singing leslie;s song. They were all great performer.

[kleung841]

I would tend to think it was more of Anita's to have Alan singing Leslie's part - after all, only Alan has the reputation to sing that part since Leslie.

[psalm1604]

I think it's Anita's choice. Why not just respect her choice. Leslie is death anyway. Every single has his/her way of singing. It's nothing to do with respect a person or not. I don't think Alan can't sing this song well too.

[lovetwinsfans]

i hope it was gorgor standing there and singing the song with her...

[gingerfarm]

I try to avoid watching this concert again...I get really sad everytime.

This one is sad too...esp thinking that the original singer, Leslie Cheung, isn't even there to sing that with Anita.

[pinksBBQ]

this song is super touching....

[LlamaLordofScience]

everytime when I watch clips of this concert I start to cry. Anita was so wonderful and I loved her very much. I really do miss her and her voice, she's a great singer and should always be remembered

[littledragongirlgirl]

is this in the dvd also and is it the last concert of Mui?

[siuwahchan]

yes, sadly

[supertrouper]

Dear maccalove,

I saw this concert on the VCD. This is a very good song. I also remember that she sang this song called "Song of sunset"(jik yueng jee goh) as her last song of the concert when she was about to leave the stage. It was very touching to see that part and hear the song. If you have the part where she sings "Song of sunset" at this concert, can you post it? It is a big classic song.