Added: 2 years ago
From: analeian
Views: 54,911
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (322)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I've seen a lot of episodes (but not all) who is the woman walking away with the Doctor at 1:20, or is that roses back or something? if it's a spoiler just message it to me haha

  • @razrblade0kiss0 is Donna, the 4 season.

  • i think it was kind of cruel to like make out with the human ten and leave the doctor standing their

  • What an amazing video. Molto bene :')

  • @SerenityHatike "Shattered" by Trading Yesterday.

  • What is the name and artist of this song?

  • This video is heart-breaking!!!!!! I cried, really... they're so perfect together.... wonderful job!!!!!!!

  • This is beautiful! So well made!

  • I die a little everytime I watch the Doctor cry over Rose after Bad Wolf Bay.

  • This was one of the first Doctor/Rose fanvids I ever watched and I fell in love with it. Most videos lose their force after a few replays but this one hasn't. Still makes me feel everything I felt for them while I watched those episodes for the first time. Brilliant job.

  • Beautifully done <3 What did you use to edit?

  • Me: *Tears in my eyes*

    YouTube: An error has occured. Please try again later.

    Me: FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU- I'M GONNA GO ALL TIME LORD ON YO ASS, YOUTUBE. *Refreshes madly*

  • Fantastic!

  • ahh brilliant!

  • The Best Doctor Who Video I have Seen Ever, and for a long time. This is totally boss. Like a boss, keep it up and make some more..! XD

  • I've always loved this song, and this is a great video. BBCA is rerunning Series 2 and so the Doctor and Rose are fresh in my mind. Eleven is OK, and I tolerate River, but the show just isn't the same. 

  • Шикарно!Мне безумно, при безумно понравилось)))))) Переданы самые красивые моменты!!! Переходы, огонь- забирает жизнь но в тоже время дает её!)))

  • Beautiful!!!! What song is?

  • @MissPaix shattered (mtt version) by trading yesterday

  • Just Beautiful <3

  • (':

  • @DeathlyMasquerade there's really no short way to describe their...story. You really should watch Doctor Who :-)

  • excellent vid & what a lovely couple!

    I've never watched Doctor Who could anyone tell me in short Doctor/Rose story, if it's not much to ask...?

  • @DeathlyMasquerade You've never watched Doctor Who? You really need to it a brilliant!

  • @DeathlyMasquerade You should definitely watch it. I would start with the reboots (labeled as "Series" instead of "Season." Netflix has them) Be forgiving of the initial effects though (very cheesy in Series 1, though I love it haha). No one thought a DW reboot would take off =]

  • @FallenEmbyr thanks I already downloaded it!

  • Fantastic vid. Really, really, well done. And the song is perfect !

  • I don't hate River and 11/10, I think the actors do a really great job, I just feel like 10 and Rose's love was so much more real, when you contrast the two River and 10/11 just feels kind of superficial considering how shes meant to be the love of his life.

  • @agglebag You have to admit, 11 can be pretty insufferable at times. However, she admits, "Who else am I supposed to fall in love with?" In other words "you drive me insane, but in my book, you're still the most wonderful man in the universe".

  • amazing :)

  • This song works with him and the Master too, in a diferent way.

  • Normally I would say that all the movement would be really distracting, but paired with the song it really fit well together. Wonderful Job!

  • I think the reason their relationship is so sad because he loved her so much he gave her up and gave the one thing he could never have. A normal life. Even 11 feels for rose. Remember when he asks to see someone he didn't hate and it shows rose. That was sad.

  • @EllieRocksAtLife If he had loved rose so much he wouldnt make jokes about helping her with homework =\. i love the 11th doctor but i hate the fact that rose is completly wiped-out as if she was just another companion when the season before, rose played a big part. I also hate the fact that River song out of the blues comes in and BAM! the doctor and her get a relashionship right away while with rose it took time and work and trust. I wish someone else felt that way =\

  • @XsecretXidentityX Yeah I hate river in general.

  • This is my favorite fanvid of them. Splendid job. <33333

  • THIS SONG IS SO PERFECT. I about died when the Doctor left Rose, and I sort of resent River Song- I mean, she's cool, but Rose was the only one for him.

  • @nurey100 Omg I feel the same way!

  • @nurey100 Woohoo! finally someone who doesnt like riversong's relationship with the doctor. I agree 100% rose and doctor was so much better. I hate how river song's relationship was sort of rushed. It makes it fake because the doctor doesnt even know her and yet hes "in love"..or is he really? Im sure i would have liked river song if the relationship hadnt been so instantaneous to give us watched time to get over rose. It was all too rushed and river song is coming off as annoying to me =\

  • @XsecretXidentityX no the doctor only knew her for two series and really only started feeling differently towards her in the second series. I'd rather have river as techinally she has known him all her life and rose met him when she was 19. I'd have river anyday over rose. The dont even think the doctor really liked her that much. of course he'll be upset that she's in a parell world but look how he forgot her as soon as he regenerated. Sorry that's how I feel about it.

  • @nurey100 i agree and i think that rose was the first one he ever fell inlove with even though he never truly said it as the full time lord doctor he did love her and i think he loves her more than river but he had to go on with his life

  • @nurey100 I think Rose is the only one for the tenth doctor, I think River is perfect for the eleventh.

  • so so good, if more people like you did the adds for tv shows and movies i think they'd be watched a heck of a lot more

  • the doctor and rose were the best!

  • This was beautiful. I'm sobbing.

  • I'm watching the classic series from the start and in the first season, there was little emotion, there was just 'danger' and rescue.

    In the new season you see all the emotions, pain, love...

  • Oh lord, this makes me tear up so bad.........................I MISS ROSE AND WANT HER BACK! Geeeze, I was so pissed at moffatt when all Rose got from eleven was 'thanks, give me guilt' he didn't even say her name or anything! Maybe I'm overreacting, but COME ON

  • @SummerRain210 If you loved someone, but couldn't ever be with them, and you could do anything else, you would not want to talk to them. All the pain and memories would flood up.

    I'm not trying to bring up a fight, but it looks to me like he wanted someone he loved, but not Rose...

  • @Dogthebob6 Sure, but he DID say something, he said "give me guilt" he could've just said her name and then no, give me someone else or whatever, that would have been fine, but he didn't. Of course it would have hurt and everything, but it just didn't come across like that. It was as if she was just another one of his companions, and not the woman he had once loved so much that he burned up a sun just to see her. I just want him to say her name once in a blue moon. I don't want to fight either!

  • @SummerRain210 I must admit, the clip was very short. I'm guessing it was just a part of the show Moffat threw in there for the old time fans(ei.Us) but never really looked it over.

    If Davies had accompanied him I beleive it would've been longer, but...

  • @SummerRain210 I agree with you. Rose is completly forgotten and just a companion now. Another time that the 11th doctor mentioned rose was when he made a joke about helping her with homework which made her appear like just another person. I guess the new actor and new writter made a completly different doctor who. I mean i still love doctor who and i love matt smith but the transaction between the 10th with rose to 11th with riversong was NOT smooth at all. It was a whole different show.

  • @XsecretXidentityX when did he say he helped her with her homework??????

  • @DoctorWhoAwsomness It was said in the episode "wedding of river song" when he was talking to dorian

  • @XsecretXidentityX Oh yes!!! That's right!!!! Thanks :-)

  • This vid is EXTREMLEY well edited, I someday hope to be half as great of a vidder as you :)

  • Lol, the song is called shattered!!

    But I love the video <3

  • i want a spin off show of rose and the human doctor. like they did with torch wood and K9

  • I'm glad that Rose got a sort of happy ending... but the Doctor's story just breaks my heart...

  • Beautiful!!!

  • well done, very beautiful

  • God this was deliciously angsty. Much love to analeian ^_^

  • This is such a sad video for such an amazing couple with sad circumstances. Beautiful job and very beautiful video. It was fantastic. Long live Rose Tyler and 10- the best of us all.

  • Fantastic! :D Made me cry :'(

  • I love your video! Where did you get the HD clips from, as I really want to make my own videos like this one. Thanks.

  • I liked Rose, but for me Donna Noble will always be my favourite companion. Rose loved the Doctor, but with Donna it was more. It wasn't just a silly human crush, it was more. Donna was a true friend. She works and fights to find the Doctor again after their first encounter, and doesn't leave. She provides the human side to the moral dilemnas (Pompeii, Doctors Daughter, etc.) She gives up the "perfect life" (turn left), and became the DoctorDonna. He has to wipe her memory before she'll go.

  • @rpottage yea and donna hadnt turned left, doctor would have died and the world would have ended so she didnt give upp perfect life like you claimed

  • @MeisterReaper She and het family were alive and she knew that if she changed things she would die, Rose tells her its not just in that world. She will still die. She gives up her life. You'll notice I used quotations around "perfect life" to illustrate that.

  • @rpottage didnt notice that sorry was very tired when i wrote so i just skimmed it through

  • It would've been awesome if Amy, Rory, and River met Rose.

  • first of all i'm waiting for 11th doctor, fifth season hasnt came in in my country yet, actually ofc i can download it from internet but i want to wait for doctor loyaly, every weeek:)

    And it is just,i had very good time with rose and christopher.. Bad it only lasted 1 season, than chris gone:/ while i was thinking it would never be the same, dacid came, and become a better doctor than chris, more smart, more professional..just more "doctor"..

  • i always deeply missed chris but david was very good too, we had funny and great time, with his smile and serios look :D! Anyway than rose gone,i become sad, afraided of "will it be same", and it did..

    But u know,just my biggest dream when i become 20,i will go there and meet with billie..i will do what ever i need to,and i will meeet that perfect woman,what ever it takes...Anyway,shortly,i really afraid will it be the same when matt smith come in..

  • Cause i had best time,like a dream, with billie and chris.. than it was great and so doctorish with david tennant..but know they all are gone,even donna..i fell so lonely to be honest, hope we will have great time with doctor,and i will accept it, not %100, but at least enough, i hope..

    Just afraid to betray my beatiful billie and chris.. and afraid to this dream will end one day..i dont want to doctor be, gone, one day.. :')

  • i cryed.. :(

    @littlegreenartichoke actually i never think it that way, maybe he wasnt the real doctor,just a copy, but still u think are they happy?And rose loved him like the real doctor? if it is, yeah i tottaly agree with u too, speacially atm cause i'm about to cry again too i guess :')

  • i almost cryed

  • What a beautiful video! :) Ten/Rose was so tragic, and yet their time together was so joyful. Quite the emotional roller-coaster ride for so many people.

  • Thank you for posting this one. It was special

  • The clips are i bit hard to take in, but other then that I love the video. Ten/Rose seem to be the new tragic couple, but I think that's why we watch these video's. So we can see what never was. :)

  • It's called Shattered by Trading Yesterday. It's from one of their unreleased albums and so it's not on iTunes. I had to download it from a website.

  • Ok I cannot find this song and it's driving me crazy! I'd never even heard it before today but I've fallen in love with it! This matches the Doctor and Rose so well. Can I have help finding the song please!!

  • It gives me comfort to know that the human doctor will always live forever with Rose in their own little corner of the parallel world.

  • @littlegreenartichoke Not the same though, because the Human Doctor is the 9th Doctor's personality but with the 10th Doctor's face and body

  • @littlegreenartichoke they were going do this bit were the brown suit doctor gave them the TARDIS seed so they could grow their own TARDIS and fly away together but they cut it because they thought it would lead to a spin off so they didn't do it. I wish they did though. :-)

  • loved it thought it was brilliant, the song was a great choice, really shows how much the two best doctors of the series especially 10 fell in love with rose and her right back.

    again brilliant. fav

  • @nik1987ki this. 9 and 10 were definitely the best doctors, they both had so many different sides and overall alot more depth then what they've done with 11, hes just so...cold, 2 seasons of him and i have no idea who this doctor is. I love amy and rory but its not enough to keep me watching. It makes me think it probably wasn't a good idea to move on to 11; stretching series out 90% of the time kills it. ex; lost, skins, dexter, house, buffy the vampire slayer ect.:(

  • I really dont know why but this couple just really breaks my heart. I'm on season 4 of the show and really the only reason i'm watching is because i really hope rose comes back, even though i know she's not in the current season. its so awful that they arent together

  • @strawberry212221 keep watching you just might be surprised at what you see in season 4

  • @nik1987ki OMG I know!!!! i watched the first episode of the season after i watched this and i literally was jumping up and down :) but its so sad that rose gets the doctor but the doctor doesn't get rose... i cried :(

  • what pogram do you use=

  • It's kind of really hard for me to understand that Rose is gone. I'm currently watching season 3 and I can't accept Martha as his companion although she is really awesome because she's just not Rose.... :'(

  • Okay, THAT broke my heart, and I'm not even really sure why. Well done!

    ~

  • :))))))))))) love love love love love love love love love.

    Did I mention that i loved this video?

  • Wow! Fantastic job!!!

  • a masterpiece

  • This is the most beautifull video i have ever see.I almost cried ty!

  • I miss Rose on Doctor Who so much. She was the best companion! I love this vid. It's absolutely beautiful.

  • wats the song called this vid actually made me like it

  • @iwasinhalowars

    shattered by trading yesterday

  • @sayotlittler thx =D

    

  • @iwasinhalowars

    not a prob^^

  • Beautiful, truly beautiful!

  • I am sobbing, This is a beautiful and heartbreaking video. Well done!

  • i love this ♥ who is the song by? :)

  • @Emmmma2703 It's called Shattered and this version was made by Trading Yesterday ;)

  • @leannelynne thankyou :D

  • @Emmmma2703 YW ;)

  • I LOVE IT SOOO MUCH!! OMGOODNESS! One of the best Doctor/Rose video's I have found in a love time!

  • When he leans in and whispers " I love you " to her I just lost it and started balling T_T Beautiful video and amazing song <3

  • I think I've become overly attached to this relationship. I can't stop, but I'm glad I'm not alone. I love the Doctor and Rose, the show just isn't the same with out her with him. Can you please send me the link!?

  • @jetlaginwis Hahah you surely aren't the only one, I am too. It's one of the best tv relationships I've ever seen. It's perfect.

  • @jetlaginwis Agreed completely. Rose and the Doctor had a bond that I do not think he has ever had so deep with any other companion before. They were more like SoulMates then anyone else was.

  • @jetlaginwis

    I'm overly attached too. someone will start talking about Roses when i'm around them and my thoughts just jump to them and the last scene in Doomsday

  • wow!!!

  • I'm not even a huge Doctor/Rose fan, but this made me cry like a little five year old girl. Gorgeous, and heartbreaking.

  • if you pause at 0:11 , that picture makes me cry for 10, :( Poor guy. I really miss him though.

  • SOOOOO GOOD!!!

  • It's just brillant ! Great job !

  • @dance2live13 The song is Shattered by Trading Yesterday

  • @LeylaKier It's the MTT version of Scattered. There's two versions, one doesn't vocals in this instrumental part.

  • SONG?! Please? Anyone?!

  • oh gosh...what is this song?! I love this video!

  • Oh gosh.

    Beautiful.

  • whats the song called

  • Oh god. Why do I keep watching things that make me cry? So pretty, very interesting way of editing. At times it was a little hard to concentrate on what was going on with all the flashing, but for the most part I thought it made it feel more like memories. So nice job.

    *snif*

  • I first want to say, thank you for not forgetting the 9th doctor. ppl forget that rose first fell in love with the ninth doctor, and continued to love him as he changed. I love this vid.

  • Very good, but please, warm of spoilers! (I don't see 4 season yet...)

  • What's the name of this song?

  • Honestly I'm going to have to take a third option: cry for Ten and feel sorry for Handy. I have this feeling Rose won't settle for him, especially if he's got Donna bits. He's just not the Doctor without the Tardis, and half-human. I kind of liked Rose but I think she was more in love with the adventure and the exotic nature of the Doctor which will be missing from his human version. Plus she'll probably be all pissed off at Ten for leaving her and take it out on Handy. Maybe they'll make it wo

  • @pandagirl42087 *work.

  • It make me cry! I can't stop watching it! it sooo brilliant, sad but brilliant! I love your editing skills! it's just amazing! this video is now one of my favourites!

  • well done plz come see some of mine thanx

  • amazing editing. i love it.

  • Whoa... this is the best Doctor Who music video I have ever seen. This was amazing, thank you.

  • I seriously cannot stop watching this. Seriously. Great song choice too!

    10/10 :)

  • fantastic editing. love this so much. 5 stars (or a thumbs up, whatever :D)

  • 5 peoplemissed the like button O_o shame on them... Awesome vid! wat ya use? sony vegas? :D?

  •  what is this song?

  • wow so good

  • Their relationship really was a emotional and sometimes tragic rollercoater but you still can't deny it's a beautiful one!

    Really liked the vid!

    5/5, fav'd.

  • who r the 4 retards who pressed dislike???

  • This is one of the best Doctor/Rose videos I've seen!

  • Oh wow this is fantastic!

    So sad and so beautiful

  • ...and I'm bawling my eyes out!!! Fabulous! David will ALWAYS be MY Doctor!!!

  • This video is beautiful. I don't think I will get sick of watching this, it is amazingly well done. Thanks for posting it xxx

  • this video make me cry every time I watch it

  • What song is this and who is it by? I love it.

  • amzing :D we need david tennant bak :''(

  • Gorgeous!!!

    really. just simply gorgeous :)

  • Speechless.... Thank You x

  • i love Shattered, I think it's impossible to back a bad video with this song and this one is amazing, favorited Rose and The Doctor forever!

  • This song gets me very time! It is sooo sad and I love Rose and the Doctor I miss them! One of the greatest duos ever!! <3 <3 <3 <3

  • it's amazing

    sorry,but can I download this video anywere?

  • I Really Really love this xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  • this is a master peace , well done i was hart broken when he walked away with donna giving her the gift of a human doctor why can't he have happness. she loved him so , he loved her so as well in my mind rose was his wife he never loved the same afther that faithful day she went away - tears fall- 4ever & always

    Rose / Ten (my doctor & his wife)

  • Love This got a bit tearful tho :P x

  • aaaaahhhh this is my new favorite vid! i love it!

  • What's the clip at 2:27?

  • I love this! so well done, and I love that you used clips from Nine and Ten. amazing job!

  • WOW ! That was so beautiful ! This is probably the best Doctor/Rose video I've ever seen !!!! Wonderful Job !

  • oh dear - my heart, my heart. You are amazing. (L)

  • Shattered - trading yesterday

  • I'm not even done series 2 yet and I don't know what half the scenes are about, yet you still made me almost cry. Amazing editing, I love shattered, and David and Billie and brilliant.

  • wow, your are an amazing editor!

  • i absolutly love this!!

  • r.i.p tenth doctor u will be missed

  • makes me bawl like a baby every time I watch this (it's a good thing though ^^)! Brilliant.

  • Just wanna say: I love this :)

  • wow! This must have taken you days! Weeks even to put together! That was amazing! Can you send me a private message and tell me what program you used? I'd really appreciate it.

  • really good, lots of emotion in it!

    well done.

  • cry for ten :(

    beautifully done