Supertramp - The Logical Song piano cover

[patrickdrx]

Really nice man! And no blabla! I don't really agree with that man who says you playd a G in that chord instead of a A at 0.58;I used to play the A but I think the G could be the right Harmony!!Anyway,thanks again and keep swinging with the Wurly..Madpat

[eeroneato]

Thanks. I used this for chord voicing for a solo guitar performance.

[armanpour335]

awesome dude, I learnt it from watching u playing it..thanks.

[Bra23we12]

I'm still enjoying this.

A couple of hours for you....years for me.

[nerrawekim]

Very nicely played. And on a real wurly, no less. Love it! :)

[mima14031985]

Thanks to your video. It helped me to learn the song

[MaaThueZinnN]

Oh man, love it !

[wow4411]

You played wonderfully.

Could you play?

SONG OF TRUE LOVERS or

KILLING ME SOFTLY

[Austinagent1]

Love it!

[bridesheadrevisited]

The chord on the right hand at 0:58 should be an Am7♭5 with (A + C + E-flat + G). Otherwise, the song sounds great.

[RapForMeDotCom]

Great job. Love this song, love the way you hammer it out. :)

[paulwwells]

Very nice. I used to own a Fender Rhodes 73 (and a Boss Chorus pedal) and this reminds me exactly what it felt like to play. Thanks for making this video of the real thing.

[HelenaHachechan]

oh i love it!! do you have the partiture???

[Tidiouter]

@Bikerboythousand Really? How do you know? Sounds like a Bb everytime to me.....99.9% sure its a Bb

[Tidiouter]

@Bikerboythousand Oh, my vote is 100% Bb.  Its a B natural in the end of the song

[Bikerboythousand]

@Tidiouter Play what ya like mate. I was just trying to tell you what the sheet music for it shows and if you look at the videos of this song being played you'll see RH plays a B.

[lagocardiel]

Grande maestro....felicitaciones.....­.saludos desde Argentina

[Grounditzelf]

nice piano, nice cover. perfect!

[JuiiceBoxx17]

OMG OMG amazing, i was just expecting like a lame sort of one handed chord with the melody in the right but this is way better

[shelyl]

Perfect cover!!! A friend of mine plays piano and will be happy to find this video.Tx mate, great player.

[karaegr777]

best best best !!!!+++

[Blubbien]

great!

[lewys93]

Excellent!

I've just finished learning this on my Motif XS8, after I found a brilliant Wurly sound on it.

I learnt most of it by ear, but this video was a real help for the parts that I got stuck on, Thanks!

[Tidiouter]

@lewys93 The wurly sounds on my XS8 are amaaazing...the bright wurlitzer with chorus sounds perfect...the natural wurly is great too, but less bark than the other one

[lewys93]

@Tidiouter Yeah, that's exactly what I do. I use the bright Wurly, take the reverb off it and add a little bit of chorus. Sounds a treat!

[euka01]

the rythm isn't so easy at all !!

[lookingatcrap]

nice 200

[dan8852]

fuckin awsome, great job!

[n3nicku]

supertramp need a new pianist?????¿¿¿¿¿¿

very nice guy!

[auggiedoggy]

That's excellent!!! Nothing can beat a real Wurly!!! Super cover!!!

[TheGreatWynd]

Good Job

[Twentepimp]

not impressed

[GreenCardProductions]

Check out my cover of this!

[spudster007]

Beautiful! I just found out about the band Supertramp today and I'm already hooked!

[ScooterandSparky]

I got a great condition 1973 Rhodes 73 I'll trade you for the Wurly ;)

(I don't gig with it anymore and play more wurly tunes than Rhodes these days)

Great playing man....

(a little hint/tip... instead of running it through a MXR, try running it through a POS Guitar Amp w/ a Chorus built in... I did that with my Rhodes to get that vintage 70s "not-so-clean" sound... cheap Peavey will work wonders... plus you can kick in some added saturation to dirty it up a bit ;) )

Awesome job!

[fourminutewarning]

u have the touch

[bherber]

Wow, that's damn good! So that's a Wurlitzer?

[tall32guy]

@bherber Yep! They were most popular in the 70's and early 80's.

[Steven197981]

Nice Wurlitzer.

[enyalid]

Super performance. Kudos to you.

[kellyfortune]

super!

[5595ernst]

Hey!!!

Du machts ja ein Künstwerk --Hört sich auch in GERMANY TOP an

[sergiomng]

very good, however, there are a couple of incorrect notes there.

In the chorus,

First chord there is, as you played it: Eb, then, in the 2nd one, you should be playing these 4 notes (from low to high):

A C Eb G, and you're missing the A.

and in the final part, you played something different too, but it would take me a lot more lines to explain that. If I could write the score here, it would be much easier, but I can't

Anyway, great job, and your keyboard sounds great too.

[nonosse56]

Is this tabbed anywhere ?

If so please be kind enouth to link <3

[tall32guy]

Geez louise! I just came back to this and realized half the comments on here were mine! LOL This should be my last one. :)

[dezsanderson]

great

thanks

dez sanderson

youtube

[pisdon2]

29,000 views because it's the best cover on you tube...thanks for uploading this...I play guitar...but have always wanted to play this,and Goodbye stranger..I'm inspired now to go out and get a keyboard to try and learn these songs...thanks for doing such a great,accurate,detailed job on both songs.. :)

[miggs1964]

Excellent but as I learned to play this quite easily by watching, I think my ear picked up one wrong note. In the second verse in the right hand after you play the inverted Eb, and switch to the inverted Cm, on the Cm I think it sounds more correct to play an A with the right hand thumb, instead of the G. Try it and see if your ear thinks it matches the song more correctly. Everything else seemed spot on. Great Job.

[KarmaSong]

Amazing performance, you've managed to get the feel and tricky syncopation of this superb song: congratulations!

[thehorribles]

Thank you very much Tidi. I am learning this key to key from you!

[WeShotTheMan]

such a nice sound from your keyboard is that a wurlitzer?

[Tidiouter]

@WeShotTheMan yes a wurlitzer 200

[plungerdrum]

@Tidiouter Wow! I'm so happy I've finally found a video with someone playing this on an actual 200A!! Great job!

[Tidiouter]

woah almost 24,000 views....pretty cool..thats a lot of people..thanks all

[newman20072008]

thats cool i was singing to it LOL

[apestocito]

! Fome y monotono !

[marakarock]

te apuesto a que ni conoces la canción apestocito

se nota cuando habla un ignorante

[growtogether]

Amazing man!

[homembom]

Great performance!

[lsisro]

how did you get that sound ?

[tall32guy]

Chorus pedal, the same that you'd use for any other instrument, run through an amp.

[pianogrl697]

I would LOVE to know how to play this one, too - again, no good tutorials on this and this sounds EXACTLY like the real thing!

[Laislaeditorapro]

Excelente!!

Maestro!!

Congratulatios

[sptol]

Brilliant mate just blown me away there Wurlitzer and Yamaha CP70 pianos are so distinctive in sound that cant be emulated where as a Rhodes can the best emulation is the Nord Lead or Electro range anything else doesnt come anywhere near

[glema2007]

HI. good job!! what kind of pedal are you using? i love this song and looking for a Rhodes piano sound. Thanks! Gustavo

[Tidiouter]

Hi!, this is an MXR Stereo chorus pedal. They only make one that looks like that, works pretty well! My wurlitzer is pretty barky as is though, which helped. Didn't really need to cut out the lows and bring the treble up to get that sound, which was pretty fantastic. Good luck.

[Tidiouter]

PS the only way to get a rhodesy sound from this is to play it softly...i want a rhodes.....

[dalekinder]

One of my favorite songs. Great piano Cover.

[Keyboardman88]

Why would you want a Rhodes sound? The song was done with a Whirly and a chorus unit just like it's done here. Dead nuts on.

[xias0mors]

that isnt a piano ..?

[dgrtktschr]

nice pants

[showbizfrank]

I thought it was really good, very impressed

[Sulouminou]

GREAAAT !!

[montypython11111]

does anyone have the sheet music for this??

[tall32guy]

You can probably find it at your local musical instrument store, if not by itself at least (more likely) in a compilation book.

[profdrmuffkopp]

well done!

[xXChaozLordXx]

OMG awesome

[kirktonstreet]

Great job. Sounds brilliant on a wurlizter. Any chance you could do a quick tutorial on this? I think I've got the chords but I can't figure out how you play the little riff at 1:05

[Beatlesfan41]

i really want to learn this song, please can you make a tutorial?

[pianogrl697]

Wow....sounds the ACTUAL song!! AWESOME!! Tutorial please??

[rogerhodgsonfan]

Wow! This is great! I'm trying to learn to play the song on my Dad's ancient Korg M1 keyboard, using note sheets and watching your video carefully. Wonderful inspiration - thanks! :)

[nomestradamus]

Ure close I app the work I can show u how i "really" wrote it but good job keep our music flowin. p.s. love the dancin leg i have the same thing too!

[acciaxxx]

grande! bravo bravo bravo

:)

[jlaw666]

is that a pedal that turns a normal electric piano into a wurlitzer?

[Tidiouter]

no, it is in fact a wurlitzer, I don't think they manufacture pedals like that. Some digital keyboards emulate the real thing, few are good, none come close.

[thebeatles34]

am i an idiot to ask what a wurlitzer is? by the way, perfect cover! i love this song

[tall32guy]

A Wurlitzer is the electric piano he's playing. They were made from the mid 70's to the early 80's.

[tall32guy]

Sorry from the late 60's, til the early 80's. lol

[Skaliwag66]

Actually 1954 was when Wurlitzer Went into production starting with model 100.

[tall32guy]

OK OK i was off by a few years! Sheesh! LOL :-P

[tall32guy]

It's the electric piano he's playing. LOL Wurlitzer makes organs, regular pianos, and for a time made these like what he's playing.

[Tidiouter]

from my high school spanish...you said

You played good but....you played the dry standard form ps webo seco

is that right?

[pollik3]

no, you're wrong xd

he said: " you play good but... teach us how to play it" or "show us how to play it" and webo seco i don't know what does it mean

anyway the idea is that you might film a lesson or tutorial video.

i've seen your videos of supertramp's covers and you are very good at this! congratulations!

[Lampen01]

You're damn good at this ..

Keep on doing that :)

[tall32guy]

Love the chord change and key contrast at 1:28! Always loved those contrasts in music.

[tall32guy]

Did you do this after practicing the sheet music? Or just practiced it a lot "off of ear"?

[Tidiouter]

nah just learned it by ear

[thelemonsong13]

I found myself singing along :p I think you did a damn good job on this song. I'm trying to pick up keyboard playing again.

[colonos82]

very good

[radioman66]

Dude you nailed the sound! By using that audio effects box, you have captured that sound that Rick uses on most of the Breakfast In America Wurlitzer parts.

[tall32guy]

you mean Rodger Hodgson. :)

[radioman66]

Oh I always get those two mixed up. They both play the Wurli so I have to think who is singing because they are usaually the one playing the Wurlitzer. What a great band huh?

[tall32guy]

Where'd you get the Wurlitzer, and was it in great condition or did you have to fix it up ? How much did it run you?

[Tidiouter]

I bought this one for 75 bucks off a lady. It's a 200. It was heavily played, pretty chewed up all over, very soft on the notes, missing the jewel light, but sounded beautiful. I put metal flake car paint on the cover, painted the bottom, buffed up the legs and leg plates, replaced all the caps, replaced the broken reed, and totally cleaned everything out, and regulated it, and tuned it. Put about 200 bucks into it, and tons of time, and may be selling it soon!

[tall32guy]

How much do you think shipping to Washington would be?! LOL!!!

[tortwister]

The sound is as good as the original one. I love the wurlitzer!!

[Tidiouter]

if you can't C#, then you must Bb

[KLAATU2007]

Forgive me, I was wrong. Bass, sequence 1: F (just F, the chord chnages from Fm to Fm7, not the bass, it stays in F. The sequence 2 is just like I told you: bass F, D#, G, G# (4 notes), chords Fm, D#, G# (3 chords). Please, forgive me.

[KLAATU2007]

And in the final part, whwn the bass (left hand) changes from F to D# (for the second time) the chord must follow the bass, I mean, the bass changes form F to D# (both notes in the chord Fm), and whwn the bass changes from D# to G# the chord must follow the bass, I mean, the chord must be G# complete. But be carefull, before the bass play the note G# it must pass by (playing queckly) the note G (bass, left hand, sequence 1: F, D#, sequence 2: F, D#, G, G# (as played in the original record).

[KLAATU2007]

Hello, Tideouter! It"s me again!!! And again you forgot the details!! See, in the part of chorus (...But at night, when all the world"s ASLEEP...), in the second chord, just over the word ASLEEP you must fill in the chord with the note "A". You play 3 different chords with the bass (left hand) in the note "D#", and it's correct. And in the second chord you change only one note (from "A#" to "C"), but you must change 2 notes, A# to C and G to A at the same time to form the second chord. Ok?!

[nickrock23]

i didn't catch the screw up, you did fine. i basically play it the same way. same notes, just some inversions

[patrickayres]

WOW- very nice, i like

[jormanaxl]

muy bien...!! gracias por el video!!

[Tidiouter]

maybe a tutorial...

[THEIllPIANIST]

is it possible music sheet pleeeeaaaase

[CanadianAstronomy]

Absolutely amazing. Very well done and a pleasure to watch!

[wurlytone]

Cool man, good job... 0:55 helped me, I've been playing that part wrong, thanks!

[mima14031985]

Yeah great video! I'm gonna learning this song just right now! Your video will instruct me :D

[princessrori]

fantastic~!

[gdavd]

It sounded so logical, very nice.

[djbelc01]

Good playing. Also, nice MXR Chorus effect.

[PAYPALORVISA]

GREAT VIDEO, you should do a 'how to video'.