Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (761)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i fucking love when mariah sing that hight note!!! damn miley!1

  • I love how they all dance the way you would dance to their particular type of music. This must have been fun music to arrange for all those different artists. I'm impressed

  • If Miley didnt sing with all these other singers, the song would've SUCKED!! MILEY ROCKS AND PPL SHOULD GET OVER IT AND LIVE WITH IT!! cuz hatin on her is not gonna change anything!! she's amaizng, and u know it!!

  • @ThaBieberVideos mmmh how old are you?

  • @TheSupershooter does it even matters ?

  • why do people who have not much else to do have to come on here and just slag or dis miley, clearly she is a good singing as she has many records, this song was for charity so think about that not about miley even though she was the best in the song!!!!

  • @mileyno1fan19 are u sersious? she has the lowest range of octaves these singers are way out of her league besides rihanna. you willrealize when you grow up.

  • miley cyrus isnt a singer or a acter, that, what she does is disney shit, that nothign

  • @4counter8 I think that's kerrie Underwood

  • @Ardyia08 what?i dindt aks something

  • @4counter8 sorry i clicked on the wrong person

  • Who is that singer at 0:25?

    and that girl next to Rihanna sounds terrible... She also seems cocky, like, watch I am here with the stars and I'm one of them. Yeah, right.

  • @Veraxxxx no hun that's miley

  • @Veraxxxx

    carrie underwood

  • @Veraxxxx Thats Carrie Underwood

  • by far the best beyonce, carrie underwood,mariah carey and mary j. blige and leona lewis sounded good

  • Thank God Mariah and Mary were here!

  • i like this song bt it does sound like it was made for beyonce and the Rand B queens in mind coz everyone else sounds really bad lol and i love everyone on stage bt its not to good ae

  • im not saying miley ruined it or anything bu her and rhianna should have swithed parts. but it was all reeealllyy good. (:

  • I love fergie!!!

  • fergie ruined this song. SHES NOT BLACK and she sings like she is all gangsta and crap. + she can't sing. its dumb how you become famous just cause you look good.

  • There is an inner gangsta in every one!!

    She is tough ..What did you expect?She is a rapper..

  • @pionette2009 well it might be lame but that dosnt change the situation does it :)? shes still famous :p

  • wtf was miley doing....my hears! ugh! horrible...And I actually like a few of her songs...

  • miley sounds weird

  • lol this song almost brought me to tears i love it because of all the people who pitched in to make it happen go everyone who sung up there

  • Comment removed

  • Ouch. Miley so should not have gotten up there with real singers...

  • You mean Miley and Rihanna..they really didnt do anything but just stand up there and say like 3 lines...to be compeletly honest they both suck at singing live!!

    :(

  • @slapinthebassMAN especially miley, its like SO annoying

  • @Ravenbeaut agreed

  • @Ravenbeaut miley was one of the best singers on the stage she sounded great to me

  • stop hating on miley! maybe shes not the best singer but thats only because shes young

    u dont know what she goes through

    just imagine going through ur teenage life living under a microscope! shes human too!

    like all the secrets you hide from ur parents she couldnt have that because everyone had to know everything and put it all in magazines.

    its hard! youve never been her and u never will so dont act like u know whats going on her life. jeez. some people are so immature these days

  • miley cyrus just killed the song...

  • true

  • @bebeto2011 well, she just sounds like 5 year old...

  • i luv this song!! i like the original recording because what the heck is miley cyrus doing? especially the part w/ rihana?

  • i think everyone wuz real good except miley

  • the only wrong thing in this performance is miley's singing .. she's nothing compared to all these amazing singers!

    dont hate thats my opinion.

  • okaii im only saying dis once....... this is a really really gud video and its for a gud cause not to be juged on singing!!!!! and for all u haters out there some that curtain people shouldn't have been there...... but have any one of u's ever been on stage????? i didnt think sooo u's r just jelious cause these people can sing!!!!!! SSHHAAMMEE...... DON'T JUGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER!!!!! LATERZZZ

  • okaii im gonna say dis once....... have any one of u haters standed up on a stage and sung?????? SSHHAAMMEE... dats wat i thought!!!!!! so how can u say some of them shouldnt be there...... well mabe ur jelious non of u guys can sing!!!!!! have u ever thought of dat!!!!!! DONT JUGE A BOOK BY IT'S COVER!!!!!!! LaTRzzz

  • Beyonce and Mary are the best!

  • i agree=))

    they are really the best...

  • its actually not that great of a harmony, but its nice to listen to it, its like they're singing it in their own styles...i wont change a thing....^___^

  • i lol'd when miley started singing

  • why is ciara up there does she sing.Did i miss her.Please tell me

  • why in the hell is ciara there

  • Fergie, Rihana, and Miley should not have been on this song. I normally like Mley and Fergie but they don't sound good on this song.

  • Ok people are gonna be mad at me for this one, but Im sorry, I am just stating my opinion. I have to first give all of them their props. Not a big fan of Beyonce and Fergie, but they all looked great and sounded wonderful. Thats the props...the bad news is....Miley should not have been in there! She cant sing! Sorry but I was just hearing the song at first then I heard her voice and looked at the video. Other then that, they sounded wonderful!

  • Umm. When Miley Cyrus sang...I started laughing like a maniac.. Hahaha, she seems extremely excited to be there but she's with all the good singers...she can't sing...

  • you cant judge miley by her voice in this song.. her only solo part wasn't even singing. it was more talking.

    i admite she clearly sounded weird but it wasn't even singing.

  • amazingggggggggggg

  • A Fergie levanto todo mundo, nicole desafinou, só as cantoras divas! amei

  • miley is a great singer & I agree you couldnt do any better. everyone always has something to say about her. she always has to do something wrong. i believe she did a great job & it was for a great cause so every1 should go critcize someone else & leave her life & what she decides to do with it alone;; find something better to talk about.

  • just shut up! it doesn't matter if miley sang bad or good or anybody these girls are singing for a cause to fight for women!

  • and fergie sucked!

  • why is everybody criticizing miley? you couldnt do much better.

  • haha, I could. now what?!

  • MILEY IS A GREAT SINGER

  • she sucks ! come on , she have a very normal voice !

  • for real miley is not perfect

  • miley voice is frikkin annoying in this ugh

  • i thought everyone was really good

    but miley sounded really crap

  • the best were Beyonce, Mary J. Blige, Leona Lewis, Keyshia Cole, and Mariah Carey.

    Miley is a terrible "singer" and needs to sit her tired, no-talent ass down.

  • Comment removed

  • miley sucked!

  • Miley was probably there for the younger people and you know how the kids like her and crap like that, you know bring more attention to the cause... or what ever this is, lulz but everyone else was amazing did you see how when fergie started singing everyone rose... or is it just me? :D

  • miley's voice was HORRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ur faceis CXHECK OUT HER OTHER SONGS SHE ISENT USED TO IT

  • oh miley sounds horrible !

  • everbody hates the fact that miley there so they sould cut her out because she scruwing the song!!

  • all of them sound really good.....EXCEPT MILEY!!! WTF IS SHE DOING THERE??????

  • They had the greatest vocalists of all times up and then they ruined it with Miley! why? she does NOT even come close to the talant theyt have!!!

  • why the hell is miley doin in the middle why is she up there, fuck who was the genuis who decided lets put miley cyrus in amongst these amazing female vocalists, dickhead

  • LOLZ she was put next to Beyonce..i mean i have nothing against Miley cyrus but i think she is very lucky to sing next to and on the same stage with Beyonce

  • so true

  • OMG thats amazing! all of em super talented n famous! woahhh..whats miley doin there? im a fan n evrythin but shes not THAT gud to sing with these other singers.

  • Miley's voice must have gone through a MAJOR make-over in the actual single !

  • alll super talented singerss !:]

  • Ronaldo....

    Brilha muito no Corinthians...

  • Everyone says Miley sounds VERY bad, and I agree 100 percent. Bitch sounds terrible!

  • omg. BEYONCÉ IS THE BEST! <3

  • omg... mary j. blige made it so amazing...

    why the heck was miley here?!?! I like her music but I don't think her voice was right for this song... I like Fergie in the end

  • miley just made the song BAD

  • mily and rhianna sounds guuddd

  • Miley's voice is awful!

  • really good song.

    proper talented.

    but why have they left

    natasha, with the one wearing white

    :/

    ?

  • TERRIBLE

  • I LOVE IT! Stop being mean u should appretiate them for trying to raise awareness for cancer they could be doing so meaning other things but they didnt so they deserve respect

  • Oh shut up! even if u're a fan, r u blind 2 d fact dat she sounds terrible, she shud neva hav been on stage wif all those ppl....its bcos she's crap dat u remember that they're singin 4 cancer awareness.

  • why is miley and fergie singing with all these talented people

  • i know rite

  • Miley cyrus sounds horid!

  • datz sound weird...but good try

  • i think it sounds really good.

  • this really workz try it out pretty pwease

    1.say yo name 10 timez

    2.say your mama"z name 5 (x)

    3.say your crushes name 3 timez

    4.then paste this to four other videosif you do your crush will kiss you on the nearest friday!!♥♥But if you read this and did not paste it,then you"ll have bad luck and your daddy gunna lose hiz job ☺☻♥♦♣♠•◘

  • Stop being so pathetic. Miley cyrus is gaining awareness for cancer. She could do a britney spears, and mime EVERYTHING, but she doesnt, shes not fake. So i think she should get a bit of respect to be honest, because she isnt pretending to be someone shes not. She was doing her bit for cancer. Why shouldnt she get some appreciation for that? its unfair.

  • i totally agree with you.

  • Holy crap that sounds terrible!It was pretty bad.Damn man you'd think it sounds better than that!Going live was the wrong way to go!

  • OMG!... wat a diva overload!....

  • i thoguyht miley was better than fergie her voice was all deep

  • love Mariah

  • I love Fergie, Rihanna

  • Comment removed

  • nice spelling skills.

    i believe it should be:

    miley sounds terrible

    OR even better:

    Miley sounds amazing!

  • lol ;D

  • okay first off, its MILEY ,

    and second, shes pretty good,

    shes doing her part ,

    i think she shud get some respect.

  • love miley she has an amazing voice!!

  • Miley ruinded it

  • Love The Song

    Miley Was Great

  • Love this song its for such a good cause think all did well, i actualy enjoy mileys bit i think it complements the song. Look how well leona has done for herself too!

  • The powerful M's Mariah and Mary J Blige

  • miley sucked

  • I saw this when it first came on televison, and my honest thoughts were, Celine and Whitney were safe from anyone taking their crowns, LOL

  • This song was so great it had me in tears

    the first time I heard it. This is a great song and it has a great meaning, Miley Cyrus Part was great she kinda sounded like Rihanna her part was great for her. The gave beyonce the best part. But they all did a great job on this song

  • miley sounds good she made her voice like that on purpose besides this song isn't the only song that determines if shes a good singer listen to her voice at the end 3:08 thats her real voice!!!

  • did u hear her when she sang "the climb" live? she was great.

  • omg cyrus ruined it. somebody else could've sing her part lol

  • miley sounded awful in this but everyone else sounded great!

  • I love that song so much! Miley Cyrus was so good in it! Her voice sounded so pretty! All those people are very talented! That was so amazing how all those amazing singers all are in one song! Miley made it good though! I love Miley Cyrus!!!!!!!!! (forever and always) and you guys who are saying mean stuff about her you need to stop if you don't have something nice to say than don't say anything at all!!!! Miley rocks and has a beautiful person and can sing really good!!!!!!!!

  • Love what the song stand for.

  • great song except miley

  • miley did good. like yall can sing, and if i can hear it anyway. so stfu. all of you.

  • all of these ladies are talented but miley cyrus she good at singing rock songs not pop songs like this lol

  • woah.. miley's voice xD she got an unique voice :|

    but the rest was rlly good!

  • miley just get ur skinny self back 2 disney

  • mileyy kills da songg she sounds lyk a baby!!! take herr off! butt jow her voice sunds betta

  • why do you say miley is a bitch???

    you don´t know her!

    i think it isn´t a good idea that miley sing with so great singers! she isn´t so long in this buisness then the other like ... and for this short time she sings good

  • miley shouldn't have been on that stage. she sounded terrible. hell, even rihanna and fergie sounded better than that bitch.

    the best there were beyonce, mary j, and leona lewis.

  • I Love Miley Cyrus!! Such an awesome singer!!!

    Check out a Hot band from Vancouver BC. Search for "Brandon Paris Band + Say Goodbye"

    <3 Rachel

  • i must say that miley cant sing live and she lucky to sing with the legdens Leona lewis is so beautiful

  • Mary J. Bilge has such a beautiful voice

  • true she suked the rest where awsome

  • i mean now that you all bring mileys talent up its not showing its more of a personality thing..... but is a GOOD PERSONALITY a talent im just saying im very happy she has been blessed with the upgrades of life but she is not a good singer and i think they should have chosen a more dedicated artist/ singer and she cant act but her daddy insist she be famous..... but if sum1 can prove me wrong then bring it on. :) I thought showbiz in stuff was way more complex..... :)

  • it must be said

    i like mileys songs but i don't think she can sing live ...

    x

  • i dont hate Miley cause i dont know her You cant say you hate her cause whe all dont know her But she's not a good singer and its unfair to let her on that stage while there are a lot of talended girls who work there ass of for an opportunity like that . And thats execly what happened at hannah montanna Miley was'nt a good actrice but than she showed up with her father and he wanted to play in hannah montanna but only if Miley gets the part. Its just not fair
  • Thank you you took the words out of my mouth i wish that was me enjoying the moment with the legendary beyonce knowles..... it is my dream to sing with them. i dont get it???? i mean what about us.

  • rihanna beyonce and leona were the best

  • miley ruined the song! she sounded really bad

  • miley done excellent along with the rest of the singers shes as talented as the other girls in her own right, she deserves to be up there with them Xd

  • no..no...Miley Cyrus ruined the song..seriously man i'm not a hater but she broke the song just listen to it

  • STOP HATING ON MILEY PEOPLE! mileys a really goood singer, and the hate is SOO last year. get an update ;) .. miley and rihanna goo well together! and she does belong in the group. she suits the grouup!! maybe they put her bit with rihanna tooo cover rihannas voice because lets face it, shes not the best singer liveee! noo offence too her, just making a point! and not being mean, but not all of them were pitch perfect! except mariah, leona, beyonce and maybe fergie and natasha!! point made.

  • nobody is hating on miley at all but when you have true talent out there in the world no one wants to settle for sum1 who is sucky in many areas when it comes to presenting i can sing and so can everyone that attends my school im over the disney stuff im out there doing my thing and i think we sound a whole lot better in no where in her history have you heard of her singing and winning contest and then she bust out nowhere and is famous cuz of her daddy and thats no lie thats not bringn me down.

  • perfect d+++ yes

  • Oh God, can everyone just shut up about Miley? Why was everyone so MEAN? She's trying. Big deal. She was imitating Rihanna a bit, and her voice stood out because she's younger, and barely hit puberty. As far as I'm concerned, she sings amn better than any other sixteen year old I know. So I don't judge her.

  • i hate miley's voice it sounds horrible, song is nice i like all singers but miley destroy's it

  • Miley Cyrus does not belong in this group of talented women.

  • why hater.

  • She has NO TALENT! She is just some little girl who got lucky.

  • Nikki, Natasha, Leona. rocks

  • miley gotsta go...... but amazing song

  • ya Miley. Miley. NO!!!!!!!!

  • I love this song . because lost good friend . she is mom friend . she dead with cancer . i miss her . but i not going give up with life and dream too .

    R.i.p Sue

  • wow this was kinda cool and weird at the same time. i like how they had all of the coolest female singers of today singing but miley cyrus voice was so out of place she sounded like a little child compared to the other girls and it was weird combinations that made it sound funky

  • hannah montanna better get her achey breaky heart ass outta here. lmao. is that mary/ stacy ann ferguson? is that natsha?. I like miley cyrus but she' s wayy overpaid.

  • i'm sorry but miley cirus can't sing at all....

  • bsides miley's voice is different to the rest she stands out a little more which is why she seems "bad" in this song but i like it - it gives it an extra edge. all of them have an individual voice and don't need to be criticized for it.

  • ok i'm not sure how many of those stars have been affected by cancer but i know for one miley has been her grandpa had it. and my nan does too. cancer will amlost always affect one person in one way or another and that's what this song is about. getting together to stand up to and fight aginst cancer not to see who sings best! those stars are there to sing together and they all did an amazing job! if they wern't going to they wouldn't have been asked to sing!

  • i think Miley verse was cute lol she didn't bother me

  • Miley cannot sing I HATE MILEY CYRUS BEYONCE IS THE BOMB LIKE TICK TICK

  • everyone who great except for miley omg she was sooooo bad she should be up there

  • i agree miley shouldnt have been up there

  • no affense im a fan of miley and all but uhh in this one she was really bad compared to all the soul singers but i still like miley!

  • Leona Lewis and Beyonce are the best in this imo. :)

  • Actually, if you'd like to do the research. The word cancer came from the "father of medicine" Hippocrates. It was used to describe tumors. Though, the first case of cancer was documented from Ancient Egypt. So, it's been around a lot longer than 100 years.

  • it bothers me how everyone wont give miley a break saying she sucks.miley was trying to be extra good cause she was up there singing with legends!!!i know all of u who said miley sucked would have made the crowd barf if u were up there.plus if miley sucked she wouldnt be up there and wouldnt be making disney a billion dollars just in merchandise.

  • Everyones so horrible to miley give her a break shes 16 shes breakin in to the music world and doing amazingly every1 says shes ruinin the song if she did they wudnt hav asked her to do it. Everyone thats slating her singing i would personally love to hear u up there singing with all them. Give her a break.

  • Miley sounded dumb as hell. She is lucky to even been on the stage with all of that talent.

  • agree! she isn't even worthy!

  • i hate rihanna and miley!

    the only good ones are beyonce mariah keyshia cole and mary, why they stand up when fergie sings

  • why did everyone stand up when fergie started singing I mean shes good but theres a whole line up of AMAZING legends on stage.

  • Miley ruined the whole son