Added: 3 years ago
From: CarrieFan4Lyfe
Views: 148,913
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (578)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this sounds like it could be in the lion king or something

  • Thumbs up if you came here because of Colin Morgan and Bradley James when they act like they sing it:)

  • I miss the bagpipe solo.....

  • This should have a million more views!

  • i love this song and love his voice

  • go david!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Just amazing and that voice is like no other. Noone can sing like this guy.  wow, building up to the high notes just took my breath away.

  • Just went and listened to John's version again and its fine but have to admit David owns this now. His voice alone is so much more soultry then John's and he emotion is stronger. I know John is a legend but David owns this now...

  • @sweetcrush4DJA

    Totally. David owns this song like Farnham never did.

  • I'm sure David knows all about John Farnham and David knows exactly what song best suits his voice and he nailed it on this one. Personally I love David singing this better then John. David gives it more emotion and feeling then John but to each their own. There is not a song David covered that he doesn't own now.

  • I'm not saying I hate him or love him, but this guy is really good, better than you haters could probably do. And he has the courage to do what he loves, no matter what anyone says. Personally, I love this song, no matter who sings it. It has a great message, and it should be revived by the youth of today to spread this message throughout the world.

  • John Farnham is an aussie legend. This was originally sung by him with soul and became an aussie anthem. David hasn't really changed up the rhythm or the vocal backings at all. It is like listening to a direct copy. If he knew just how legendary Fanham was, he would never have tried to pull this one off. Just way out of his league and all australians would agree. John's version did have a wicked bagpipe section in it as well which simply sets it apart.

  • Comment removed

  • the original version sang by John Farnham is soooo much better.. no offense

  • :/ this doesn't have the depth or soulfullness John Farnham's original had, but you've gotta give the kid props for trying. It wasn't awful, just lifeless.

  • @maidenfinland You mean improved.

  • AMAZING

    

  • David is just great.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111

  • hot rod! :)

  • What's that?

    Oh you mean..."Transformers"? Was it Hot Rod's theme? He's a character from the cartoons?

    ~Eva

  • Comment removed

  • this guy is my 3rd hero ;p

  • who's your 1st and 2nd? =p

  • i actually ended up seeing david in concert like the day after i wrote that, so now its 1.david 2. justin bieber 3. the undertaker (wwe wrestler) =p

  • @bieberboy316 How DARE you put the undertaker in the same list as beaver boy.

  • OMG i love this!

    hes amazing!

  • check out G4 version

  • I absolutely love this song

  • i have a vocal class and i want to find this karaoke because the original version is to high of a key, but i cant find it this karaoke version anywhere!

  • Wooohooo.. gogogogo Archie

  • gifted

  • correct John does it better but then he was in the business a long time when he recored this... im sure when he first began, he wasnt world class.... David does a fantastic job on a well known song, lets not compare him... lets commend him and let him find his own voice.

  • Well said, I hate people will look past the truly amazingly insprational words of this song, to rather discuss how much john or david perfomed it. This song means too much to be focusing on little things like perpective on who sang it better. Let's jsut be happy that such a young man took it on him to help spread this wonderful message of hope and change.

  • just because people go crazy over ARCHIE...

  • before his first cd came out this was the best song he did

  • DAVID ARCHULATE is amazing and the best

  • Archulate? Lol U mean Archuleta but he is amazing

  • No, its on May!

  • he. is. amazing.

  • wow this is such a cool song...especially sung by him...he has the voice of an angel!!!

  • @MeGhAnShOrTie Have you ever heard an angel?

  • Arrgh - it's hard to do a report on the decline and destruction of the Chinese Manchu dynasty while listening to this upbeat song!

  • hahahahahahahhaa

    i hope you got your report done. :)

  • realy...

    any specific date yet?

  • GO,GO,DAVID ARCHULETA!!!

  • HAHA!! if you blast this song.. then it is sooo AWSOME!

  • Im davids biggest fan ever.. more than anyone else.. HE IS ALL MINE.. tee-hee he did soooo goood on this song:D

  • i love and david ARCHULETA!!!! and this song i cryed when you didnt win you shouldnt won!!! but in my heart you such a winner your #1!!!

  • this is one of my fav songs he did throughout the whole season<3 IM UR NUMBER ONE FAN DAVID

  • This was my fav Archie performince!!!!!! Go Archie!

  • Agree completely GAJ0003. Farnham was a special singer. Too bad he didn't get more play in the states.

  • my family gets so annoyed with me b.cuz I sing this song ALL the time

    lovelovelove this version! <333

    Go David! :D

  • Wrong.

    I love David. And if you don't have anything to say that's in decency.

    DONT SAY IT AT ALL.

    Thanks.

  • i liked david's version better. difference of opinion and music style. its all good though!

  • David did a great job, IMO. So did Heart. John Farnham's was good, but not untouchable.

  • nice song

  • thank you for giving great comments about ramie on disney... you're really nice

  • This is incredible! I can't stop listening to it, and (lucky me!) have had David Archuleta stuck in my head all day! Yay! He is so amazing, I am obsessed with him!

  • I heart Archie!! LUURRRVVVEEEE him!!

  • Look at how cool his songs are. Can`t wait for Album to be released.

  • this is his 2nd best song(that i have heard) his best is crush

  • People lets support Achuleta by buying his new single Crush!

  • Well you should stop and think that they have less than 24 hours to mix these songs. They can't spend days fixing every kink and note like it's a full length album.

  • definetly your the voice of the latter-day saints.were so proud of you!!

  • Wow wow wow. I love this version of this song. This guy has an amazing voice I actually can't get enough!!! GIve us some more more more its great

  • his voice is amazing!

    he doesnt need no editing or anything!

    back off!

  • wow Miley... "like totally" in denial. Listen to the track again sweetheart.

    I'll even tell you what to listen for. Do you remember Cher's "Believe"? That sound is pitch correction turned full on.

    Used more subtly it's harder to hear but it's there. Listen for the notes "snapping" to pitch. 2:06 or anything after.

    The higher he goes, the more help he needs to be stable.

  • i thought 2:06 was pretty good!

    either u need a hearing aid or idk ur just gay

  • Miley, of course it'll sound ok. That's the point. The problems have been "fixed" by a studio engineer. Someone like me.

    But listen a little closer. Listen to the transitions BETWEEN the notes.

    Listen to how it "flips" between the notes just that little bit too quickly. It's subtle but you'll hear it after a while. The "Cher" effect. :)

    Once you manage to hear it, you'll also notice how many other artists use it too.

    Oh, and being gay doesn't usually affect someone's hearing.

  • wow. they have to fit in filming the show, practicing their new song, song selection, practicing where to go when, filming each weeks truck music video...ect ect ect. the only reason they are fixing little parts is because they dont have time to run through the song more than twice. please get a life and stop harrassing teenage girls and the poor boy david. he is a great singer, youre just jealous. have u heard him sing live or in concert. he stole the show! dont criticize 2 make u feel better.

  • Hah. I'm not jealous of him. I just don't think he suited this song.

    Let me paraphrase. "david's the best. leave him alone! (sob)"

    I don't consider it informed discussion on his voice and it gets the scorn it deserves.

    Don't try emotive language on me mate. Harassment indeed.

    Feeling a little sensitive there? Did someone dare to say "the emperor has no clothes"?

  • wow your response definetly proves that your on crack. :D

  • (hackinbogus)

    :wow your response definetly..blah blah

    Another great insight. Sounds like you don't understand the reference.

  • doverbenjamin says: "...and seriously depend upon auto pitch correction..."

    While that is used a lot for the Ashlees and Britneys today (and may very well have been used here with Archie) Archie is great live and they are not--- because Archie can actually sing.

    He performed this song live on "AI" and, while imperfect, was mostly pretty good, and they don't digitally pitch-correct there.

    And I'm a creepy middle-aged guy as opposed to a lovestruck teenage girl. ;)

    Davis ivc

  • Acknowledged. He did it better live than studio.

    I'd rather punch in (re-record) a line than use autopitch. It's rushed work by the producer.

    Oh wait... This is the Simon Cowell money making machine and this is a quick album of covers from a talent show.

    Yep. It'll be rushed out in time to flog on a voice crushing tour schedule.

  • i definetly gave you the idea that he was rushed by my comment. before your were just critizing him and his talent alone. ur gay.

  • (hackinbogus)

    i definetly gave you the idea..blah blah.

    No mate.. You were referring to his (David's) schedule. I was referring to rushed PRODUCTION for economic reasons.

    Every time you post, you further demonstrate that you haven't got a clue what I'm talking about.

  • First things first. "Mate". It's a common expression where I come from and can frequently be sarcasm. It's similar to how a Londoner may call you "my son". Oh wait. That's outside your borders. You won't understand that either.

    And second:- To expand the abbreviation will produce. "have not got a clue". There's no double negative there. The hole is getting deeper. Stop digging... "mate".

  • A. Why aren't you arguing about this on here?

    and B. ur right, there isn't a double negative in have not got a clue... it makes sense!

  • you spelled grammar incorrectly smartass.

  • ^^lol.

    And for a grammar stickler, you seem to have some issues with capitalization and apostrophes.

  • ha. ha. very funny.

    i know that. haha

  • actually, the auto pitch isn't used at 2:06 at all, in fact, its rarely used throughout the song, he had to tone the song down because he didnt have the range of john farnham, who by the way, is far from phenomenal, good...... but not phenomenal.

    David has done a good job of pulling off a cover version of a difficult song to sing, but you're wrong about the auto pitch, very wrong.

    by the way, i dont watch shows like this or anything, i just like the song.

  • That's about as authoritative as "is not!"

    Nice wishful thinking.

    I can clearly hear autopitch. I use it recording people. I know what it sounds like.

    And it gets more heavily used once the key goes up.

  • BTW John Farnham IS phenomenal.

    A powerful, rock high tenor that can still MONSTER out everything in his mid 50's. Not even the great Steve Perry can say that.

    Get footage of the Tom Jones/Farnham tour to see what I'm talking about.

    Another example? "Tina Turner's Version" of Help is actually a COVER of John Farnham's version from 1980. Look it up. Watch Farnham MONSTER it live. Today.

    No matter how nice a kid he is (and he is), let's hear David in 30 years and see who's phenomenal.

  • well cook shouldve won which he did BUT

    Not BY 12 mILLION VOTES ONLY 100 OR LESS

  • well david cook didnt even come out in bossier to sign autographs... and archie did and he was the sweetest! im lucky to have met him.

  • I prefer the grit of Johnny Farnham's version, but this is still a fine rendition, nothing wrong with it.

  • This is my opinion. David Archuleta has a better and more pure voice than David Cook, but Cook's voice has a higher range than Archie's, so Cook can sing more variety of songs than Archuleta. Archie's main focus is ballads and slower songs (except for his new pop song). However, david cook can probably sing almost every song that is given to him. As great Archuleta is, Cook is much more well rounded. I bet Cook can sing ballads pretty well, but I doubt that Archie can sing rock songs that well.

  • this is better then when he sang it live

  • i like cook and archuleta but cook more but they r both AWESOME

  • I love David Archuleta! In my standards Archie won. He got a recording contract about a month and a half ago, and I will go and get his CD the DAY it comes out. This is one of my favorite songs, and Archie does a GREAT job. I really hope this is on his CD! He does the best job. I think it's almost better than the original that John Farnham did! I LOVE YOU DAVID!! I know you're going to go a million and one places in life!

  • hes soooooooooooo sexy!

  • totally sexy!!

  • LOVE HIM!!!! and i loved when he did this! this song is freakin awesome and simons such an ass for dissing him about it!

  • nice job with this. great cover.

    david's voice is AMAZING :]]

    i love this (version of this) song.

  • woow this is awesome =DD i dont remember him singing this..

    i met him today, and i got a hug as well =DD

    dude, i was happy!!

  • Very, Very good! I love the stun and the key change at 3:06. John Farnham is the man but you did a brilliant job!

  • LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!!!! Where did u get the song though?

  • OMG i love this song!!! This is the first time i have heard it but i already know the chorus!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 2nd best studio version song this season. First is We Can Work it Out. Third is Superstar by my favorite Carly.

  • awe i love this song! :]

  • it would be so cool if cook and archuleta got the same amount of votes for the finals

  • I love this song, I can't see why the judges didn't like it.

  • this is one of his best songs

  • archuleta is my 2nd fav idol contestant my first is cook but archuleta shouldnt have lost by 12 million votes

  • yes, because they said Archuleta lost by 12 million votes, alot of peoples I know believe that Amer. Idol was rigged or something...

  • I agree. He should have won

  • american idol is NOT RIGGED!!

  • I never said it was rigged...I'm just saying that a lot of people I know believe that...because you see, Archie have alot cheers on that show that when Ryan said he lost by a millon vote or so...it just sound weird...BUT I NEVER SAID IT WAS RIGGED....!

  • well i liked david a then but i forgot to vote but now i like cook better but both r GREAT

  • i cannot believe he lost by 12 million votes i think its just because a lot of people figured he'd win or maybe the cook fans voted twice

  • it's because more people don't like him then like him

    it suckkkss.

    either that, or idol is rigged.

    HE WON. i know he did haha

  • hm i think it was fair that david cook won. he was the most original person. he turned most of the songs he did into a way that suited his personality. he has an amazing voice and he can sing from rock to an opera song! archie is wonderful too but you cant see him doing a rock song. so i would say its fair that cook won =D i doubt idol is rigged.

  • well i liked cook better but i cant believe that cook won by 12 million votes but i think david a will have the best runner up career...one time i voted for chikezie 100 times

  • oh my gosh chikezie! i loved him! i tried to vote as many times as i could for him too... :)

  • i voted a lot for him but i only voted 22 times the week he got out cuz it was really busy

  • on the finale i voted for archie 350 times. i kid you not. i wanted him to win sooo badly. at least now he doesnt owe idol anything... its all him. love you david!!!

  • this is the only song i really liked from him

    and it is amazing

  • just beautiful

  • He has the voice of a thousands angels!!!!

  • omg i love this and the fact that archie sings it is amazing!

  • I dont care how he sings this song its still amazing. It was stuck in my head after i heard it the first time, i was going archie crazy. I cant believe I didnt watch AI this season of all seasons, I only saw the finale.I MISSED ALL THE ARCHADORABLE MOMENTS!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ONE OF HIS COOLEST RECORDED SONG!!!

  • omgosh..he's an angel.!

  • How did the judges not like this? They say his performances are too gloomy then simon says it is like a Theme Park performance. American Idol is so rigged.

    Archie is the greatest singer to ever grace the idol stage! He is going to destroy Cook in sales. The only people that don't like him are dumb or feel he is a threat to their favorite! He is going to be a superstar wordwide!

  • i completely agree with u thank you for your nice comment:) go archie!

  • i couldnt agree with you more

    [:

  • DUDE UR ABSOLUTELY RIGHT,HOW CUD THE JUDGES NOT LIKE THIS SONG?iT'S SO WELL SUNG BY THE GREATEST SINGER ON IDOL ever-David archuleta!HE IS NOT ONLY GONNA CRUSH COOK BUT MANY OTHER CONTEMPORARY STARS!

  • agreed dude (:

  • i live better the original one.

  • Great voice -- the voice sounds so young like an adolescent!!!

  • :| no thanks, I like the original

  • hhmmm...its ok

    liked it better when guy sebastian sang this song on oz idol

  • can someone please put a karaoke version of this song??

  • loveeeeeeee this song!

    loveeeeeeee david archuleta!

    xox

  • omg!!.. i luv hm!!..

  • his best song! He's great but Im glad D.C won

  • you rock david archuleta

  • i love this soong..:D

    and this singer :]

  • he's so awesomee, and cute. :]

  • I agrre with u!!

  • who doesn't??? :)

  • I thought this was a really cheesy, awkward song but I love Archie's rendition! It's heartfelt and his vocals are ace.

  • I was so mad that David POO Cook won , i think David A should`ve won instead. Some people are dumb for voting for David Cook.

    Oh well , who cares anyway. They are both good but David A is much better .

    Peace <3

  • everyone says this song sucked on american idol but i think it was the best one he sang!! and no simon it IS NOT a theme park song!

  • ya, after watching the idol version countless times, i watched farnham at arias 2003. that's the good stuff

  • love this.

  • OMG!! i <3 HIM!!!

  • This was my favorite among his performances.

  • i love BOTH david archuleta and david cook, but personally, i love david cook more. so you people who think that he did a bad job of singing this song, BACK OFF!!!! i know that everyone has a right to voice their opinion, but don't be harsh or anything like that! david archuleta sang this song in HIS own way, NOT john farnham's way. i agree with daryn3k and david archuleta should NOT be compared!!!!

  • Wolfstryke11... Why are you dumping your dislike for your pathetic existance of being a human being. Please please please do not procreate we do not need anymore people like you out there. This kid has done a fantastic job on this song. He has made it his own so he is not compared to john farnham's version which was also brilliant, and so is the Heart version. Just learn to enjoy the differences that each human bring to this earth as it's not going to be here much longer.

  • he is soooooooooooooooooooo cute.

  • David Cucumber isn't gonna sell well! David Archuleta will!!! I think that the producers weren't honest. Like most of the time I was voting for Archie in the finale, the lines were busy! My Mum made me vote once for cook, and his lines were ALLLLL open. Like everyone at my school hates Cucumber, too. EEEVVVEEERRRYYYOONNEE voted Archie!!! GRRR!! BOO CUCUMBER BUTT!

  • Wow, he actually did a really good job at covering this song.

  • At first i didn't really like it...

    but then i kept on listening and it just got better and better

    i thought both him and cook were talented but was wooting for him all the way!!

    sad he didn't win

    but he has an album for more money so that's good =]

    go archie