Piazza, New York Catcher

[deadzonefan13]

This is a really good rendition! Your voice is perfectly suited for a song like this. Good job! :)

[LoopTheLooop]

I love this song <3

[ShesSoLovely92]

this is really good lianeeeee!!!

i love it xxx

[becca2398]

AAH I love this song!

[gal4twilight]

OMG!! LOL!!! you looked REALLY weird in this! lol I'm not being mean :) sorry :'(

[juttezak]

Not very butchering. I mean, your voice really suits the song. I agree on the guitar, although it's sort of endearing ^^

[nicol1811]

I am a big belle & Sebastian fan and that is a decent effort! well done.

[noxinferius]

very nice!!!! keep up!!!!

[cvvemuri]

All I see are covers by random people

[cvvemuri]

No offense to this singer but why the fuck can't I find the actual song on youtube?

Wtf is up with that!

[mattieiscool78]

maybe try typing piazza, New York catcher original? i dont know just a suggestion.

[romo111213]

@cvvemuri

youtube won't have EVERY song out there :P

[cvvemuri]

lol I didn't expect every song. I'm just amused that a song as popular as this doesn't even have the juno soundtrack video for the original song, or any video with the original song for that matter.

It only has people doing renditions.

[onedayallwillknow]

Please tune your guitar...

[gerbenbiermann]

You do this very lovely, it's a pleasure to listen to. But indeed, tune your guitar. :-)

[caloriequeen]

I don't think you butcher this. It's nice.

[soundslikesushi]

good voice! nice job, though the song is not so easy.

[PratNamedEvans]

i saw this video before watching juno, so at the end when this song came on, i freaked and yealled "LIANNE SANG THIS!!"

[birdsonmywindow]

I love your covers a lot. I think you're amazing and you have no idea how much you inspire me. <3

(Tune your guitar though.)

[mvpsonly500]

Liane are you a nurse?

[patchworkz7]

If those are scrubs they're surgical scrubs...which means she could still be a nurse, but those are usually the scrubs used in surgery. I know only because I work x-ray in surgery.

[mvpsonly500]

I know that but i am a CNA and my uniform is just like that.

[Vampowl]

i love belle and sebastian! and i love every song on the juno soundtrack . have you heard of kimya dawson? she's amazing, i think you'd like her.

[matthewhugheswidnes]

I love how Belle and Sebastien are connecting with their fans by covering their songs. I bet you're really happy. How does it feel for a pretty big band to cover your song?

[kidlat91]

ur cover of this song is my fav only coz i find u attractive n also ur good too.i love this song i wish i can sing this to someone i love.

[UntillDeathComes]

Gah, this song is my lover.

[lilbluehersheykiss]

ooh i love this song!

[Gsv91]

your guitar is out of tune and you strum in a disturbingly stutter way.

concerning your singing you hit the notes FAIRLY well, but your voice is awfully trailing and thin. Yeah I know that this is very hard song to sing with large intervals and so on, but none of the covers posted on youtube are even close to sound as good as the original

[stararmor]

I've basically become obsessed with this song in the last few days, and I've watched a ton of covers of it on here, but yours is still my favorite. Very good job! =D

[JustTeri2K7]

I love this song!

This is a great version!

And you're so pretty!

[Judophile4]

I love this song, I became addicted to it when I discovered it on the Juno soundtrack. I'm so glad someone else loves it too!

[clicheddisaster]

You made me like this song.

Belle and Sebastian are really great.

[Sandwhichperson]

you rocked!!

[JXintheZ]

Awesome!

[balance180]

This is such a great song! And you have a beautiful voice, no butchering here :)

[theoriginalnetsirk]

I thank the Juno soundtrack for leading me to this terrific song and thank you for such a lovely retelling.

[RonandHermioneLOVER]

Amazingness just occured

[squal3469]

You didn't butcher it at all. This is really good.

[nooutwhere]

Ahhh, that's one of my favorite songs.

[canealot]

Belle and Sebastian yeyyy :D your a godess !!!!

[hannahgotahowler]

I love Belle and Sebastian!!

[Keaxx]

I love this song! You did a great job, really.

[forestofaddendums]

I love this song, and you definetely did it justice

[sgtpeppers10]

ahhhh liane i ADORE this song and i adore you.

[HazzaPistheDocsBFF]

I thought It was great, dont think it would be possible for you to butcher a song, you have a beautifull and unique voice and great writing and guitar playing skills!

[wrockforever]

Ah, that was amazing!

[SmileysAreMagical]

that was amazing if u think u did it badly the real version must be i cant think of a word etter than amazing sorry:(:)

[DrunkenBarWench]

I love that song.

[dripduke]

"Liane butchering a song",these words are not in my vocabulary.I once again missed you on Blogtv,I was at work.But this video made up for it.I liked Juno,I should get the soundtrack.

[onebre]

good job, juno music ftw

[definitelyoverrated]

Coolest song ever! You didn't butcher it! Nice to see a new video of you.

[stellawiz]

This is my favourite song in the whole world! And you sing it so pretty!! Wow! That was great!!

[girlsknow]

pretty pretty pretty

[MrCaltec]

Not a bad butchering,:) I'm sure there are a few sharper knives in your arsenal.

[personoftheinternet]

I fell in love with this song the moment i got my hands on the Juno soundtrack (before i actually watched the movie i had all the songs commited to memory).

I like your take in it.

:)

[Frank9067]

Great job on the singing Liane love the song

[CleverestWitch2188]

I love this song too and I don't think you butchered it. Everyone has different takes on songs. I enjoyed yours. :)

You can just tell your not a tenor(ish). LOL. <3

[VicMorrowsGhost]

Hey congrats on winning NaNoWriMo!

[Ilovetoyell3]

this is perfect. songs by bella and sebastian should never be perfect, thats part of the beauty.

[prongsmwpp]

Uhh, butchering? I heard no butchering.

[iamcrookedneighbor]

I love this song...

and ur rendition is great!

ben.

[smashedpineaples]

you look like a nurse

and that was some nice singing

[24skipper07]

loved it...!!! =)

[loser2rocks]

This song is fantastic.

I don't think you butchered it, although I've never heard the original so I wouldn't know :D

And just to bug you: Why are you wearing scrubs? (That you got at a bat mitzfah) :)

[JMtheCONQUERER]

butchered, not

awesome, yes :)

[Matthewcmiel]

hey, I absolutely love you and your videos, but you would sound a lot better if you tuned your guitar a little better. Everything is really flat, and it's not stable. But I totally love this song, and you are awesome!

[lianeandthemusic]

I just watched this again, and everything sounds exactly as it should... assuming I'm not screwing up, which I am, in places.

[Matthewcmiel]

It is also possible that I have overly finicky ears. excessively trained, anal-retentive classical musician who specializes in weird modern music that requires me to hear the slightest intonation flaws. I apologize for critiquing. I truly loved the song. Not that there is any doubt, but Keep playing! You rock!

[disasterpastor45]

Quit walking away from the speakers....you're getting a Doppler Effect. LOL.

[violin118]

this was awesome and not butchered! :D

[animagusprincess]

i knew this song! yay! you didn't butcher it, though, liane :D

[zomghorcrux]

This is my favorite B&S song!

[makepeacenotwar0505]

Really great rendition of this awesome song! Keep up the great work

[Olamario0429]

in no way shape or form have you butchered this song love. lol dont be silly your music and voice are so talented!!

[cycoG]

juno!

[RachaelF27]

I don't think you butchered it, it's really good.

This is one of my favorite songs too.

[robynsaysoyvey]

this is so cute!!

and i totally agree, scrubs are heaven in clothing form.

[TheZombieFlanders]

Never having heard the original 'til a few minutes ago, I say you did s brilliant job.

It's a great song, involving baseball imagery to tell a love story. Brilliant.

[disasterpastor45]

I just never believe what I read as lyrics anymore. It's always about something else, that'd be so far out of bounds.

[bobbyjustbobby1]

nicely done! :)

[PaperStory]

always enjoy hearing your wonderous voice andseeing your prety face<3 keep up the vids dears.

[lianeandthemusic]

Aw, I love yous!

[Aquamariene21]

Explain the scrubs Liane!

[matthewhugheswidnes]

Yes. Explain them.

[lianeandthemusic]

There's no explanation. I am lazy and scrubs are comfortable. So what if I don't actually want to get dressed to make videos?

[sophieeee19]

lovelyyy.

[supersallee89]

i love this cover. i love this song too.

=)

[coolstream1]

i am THOROUGHLY disappointed with the complete lack of FAIL and SUCK in this video... as a depressed emo i thrive on FAILING and SUCKING...

this video does neiher!

bah

:3

[LizzyKatelyn]

I love this song.

It's on Juno isn't it?

I brought the soundtrack and this was on it.

Great work.

[emmasspace]

It is from Juno. It was on my soundtrack. Weird that it wasn't on yours.

[adyrulesthe666]

your awesome liane. good work

[NelliumTheFisherman]

yay! i love this song too! nice job.

and unlike all the other comments on this video, i will not ask why you look like you're wearing scru- damn it.

[mortifiedpenguin9]

"Butcher"? You have a wonderful voice!

[stubs999]

I love this song.

Nice cover :)

[Milllie91]

eek! I love Belle and Sebastion!

[stfukidds]

I was totally just waiting for this video to load and flipping through channels to find a new movie to watch, and guess what's on? Yeah, Juno. Juno FTW. (:

[1awesomenerdfighter]

Are you a nursing assistant now? :) 

ahhhh mannn i miss wearing scrubs.

Lovely song, you did a good job!

[thoroughlymodernally]

i think the scrubs definitely took it to the next level.

<3

[elmo2488]

I've always liked this song, your cover is nice.

To echo everyone else, are the scrubs for your job?

[MarchHatterofWoe]

omgz sweet scrubs, sweet good job Liane!

[nstak36]

I love this song!

I think your cover is perfect. ;-)

[scionofslytherin]

wait...do you have to wear scrubs to work?  weird...

[Fkdls]

LOVE THIS SONG!!!

i too found it from the juno soundtrack :)

[OneWickedGryffindor]

well done!

[tyrannosauruslexxx]

this is absolutely ace :)

[emperessemma]

I bum this song. Well done. =]

(I will admit that i only know it from the juno soundtrack. Lol. )

[seeitscjayy]

i love this song.

[aLynnax]

amazing (:

[LizlikesHPalot]

YESYESYES I LOVE THIS. I LOVE YOU. whya re you so talented!? why are you my friend!? how do i have friends this talented.!?!?!?@#

[CookieTwilight]

Awesome.

I love this song :)