I can see where you're coming from, but honestly, it's a really basic and common melody. I can't name any off the top of my head but I know I've heard other songs that have a very similar melody. So no, I think Joe Satriani was kind of a douche for sueing them, because they have a completely different sound. I'm not a huge fan of Coldplay but it's ridiculous that people get worked up over something like that.
dude...a couple million that coldplay made off this song? try hundreds of millions of dollars.
you're uneducated, have no musical training, and are clearly lacking any sort of discernment at all. please...take it somewhere else. pathetic and wholly without substance.
I'm sorry that I didn't know the price range this songs profits fell into. And yes I am only in the process of becoming musically educated. My purpose in this video was not to show people that I am an educated music critique (which I am obviously not). I just wanted to show some friends something that I found very interesting (the similarity) between the 2 melodies. Then in reply I wanted to see what they thought about the matter. That's all.
i think viva la vida is better.
Gabbiellao6 2 years ago
I can see where you're coming from, but honestly, it's a really basic and common melody. I can't name any off the top of my head but I know I've heard other songs that have a very similar melody. So no, I think Joe Satriani was kind of a douche for sueing them, because they have a completely different sound. I'm not a huge fan of Coldplay but it's ridiculous that people get worked up over something like that.
SharpieCompulsion 2 years ago
i must agree dylan this is indeed a very interesting topic
rattnroll5150 3 years ago
this was a good video and you said it all, coldplay copy great musicians as joe satriani.
PhilippeMusique 3 years ago
wow ryry this is very interesting
htturtle72 3 years ago
dude this video is awesome and hodore is gay-chris
snwbrder4465 3 years ago
dude...a couple million that coldplay made off this song? try hundreds of millions of dollars.
you're uneducated, have no musical training, and are clearly lacking any sort of discernment at all. please...take it somewhere else. pathetic and wholly without substance.
hodore 3 years ago
I'm sorry that I didn't know the price range this songs profits fell into. And yes I am only in the process of becoming musically educated. My purpose in this video was not to show people that I am an educated music critique (which I am obviously not). I just wanted to show some friends something that I found very interesting (the similarity) between the 2 melodies. Then in reply I wanted to see what they thought about the matter. That's all.
htturtle72 3 years ago
this is my worst video yet.
htturtle72 3 years ago
and you..... are a cock hodore :D
RichieBoi 3 years ago