As I Lay Dying vs Carnifex

[ElijahJohnCirricione]

Why is As I Lay Dying even going up against Carnifex...

CARNIFEX wins over everything

[Iamtheenemy17]

both.

[annoyingryan1220419]

Carnifex, hands down

[rbcrazyriderrb]

you should compare as i lay dying to all that remains and Carnifex to Suicide silence

[lacedwithliesmusic]

As I Lay Dying doesn't suck in everything forever. So...yeah...

[lacedwithliesmusic]

@GiveInToMetal That's because Carnifex jacked the breakdown from AILD. Durhur

[hashimali72]

Can anyone tell me who is better Annotations Of An Autopsy or Carnifex.

[patrick22014]

Carnifex rapes them!

[00Cyne]

CarnifuX

[xxDISEMBOWLMENTxx]

Nah I'm with carnifex on this one

[crocoshitt]

saw as i lay dying at metalfest.... i was dissapointed. in my opinion they SUCK live, and theyre album stuff is ok i guess, but to be honest any other band there deserved to be the headliner.

[NewEraOfCorruption]

Carnifex's is heavier and deffinately makes me wants to mosh more and kill someone.

But its As I Lay Dying's breakdown and they'll always be the kings of Metal.

Cos they're so original in everything.

[popshotizbeast]

Carnifex, they're way more brutal and their breakdowns are way better. But I also love As I Lay Dying, I own two of their albums.

[kjrody21]

AILD IS MORE SICK

[number660]

Well now theyre touring together so we'll have 2 times the same breakdown in 1 show how amazing!

[joshbeau]

umm... As I Lay Dying, simply because it is their breakdown... not to mention is sounds 20x better than those plagurists anyway...

[daiselol]

as i lay dying.

[keisuke185]

carnifex 

[medusa1312412412]

As i lay dying is MEtalcore Carnefex is Deathcore!!!!!!!!!!

[architects100]

1: as i lay dying

2: as i lay dying

3: as i lay dying

4 :as i lay dying

5:as i lay dying...

999,999: as i lay dying

1,000,000: as i lay dying

1,000,001: carnifex

as i lay dying is X1,000,000 better than carnifex

[TheNextHokage5793]

Carnifex owns.. kool shit tho. i didnt even notice that

[VM38]

carnifex pulls that rhythm off waaay better. Carnifex > As i lay dying.

[Unblacken]

carnifex may be more brutal than as i lay dying but when it comes to austrian death machine...they leave carnifex out to dry

[iheartzombiez]

ever hear stick sitckly

jus sayin

>.>

[planelement]

@iheartzombiez hey,leave Attack attack out of this! lmao:P

[somemetalguy]

neither they both suck!

[lhllfptt]

Haha nice vid, I've noticed the smilarities before but this vid shows they're almost exaclty the same

[jaminjames8]

carnifex doesnt curse that much in there songs anymore. only there album dead in my arms had cursing really. diseased and the poisioned doesnt have much cursing at all.... i think anyway

[Unblacken]

Both bands are awsome christian or not christian :)

[drylung3030150]

metalcore and deathcore riff are like 98% the same. i have noticed alot carnifexs shit "sounds" like other metalcore

[metalmad101]

carnifex

[haemorrhoid1989]

Seeing as a breakdown rarely has more than 1 note played, after the 85626834th one it's sortof difficult to make one which isn't the same as another one...

[GrimAngelLedah]

if your a guitar play, strum along with AILD then with carnifex with the video, carnifex is a LITTLE different, like an offbeat thing, more complicated.

Remember i just said a LITTLE

[DAMINIHOSS]

Fire Riser does have a poing guys..i've been playing guitar for 6 years and have perfect pitch..so i can tell when something is the same..but no matter what..both of these bands kick major asshole! and we know this

[glennjelleen09]

carnifex rules

[glennjelleen09]

Both of theme fuckin awsome from there both genre!!! ^_^

[RecklessIntent91]

yep as i lay dying did write it before carnifex. lol whether they ment to copy that breakdown or not it still kills carnifex's song for me.

[fireriser90]

you people are soooo stupid!!!! AILD wrote that breakdown 3 years before carnifex so shut the fuck up and research before you dis other bands you fucking dipshits

[doggiedreads]

@fireriser90 Actually Gojira wrote that riff in 2001. Check out "Lizard Skin" of their Terra Incognito album.

[QlockworkOrange]

i wouldn't say completely different...they are similar

but i agree with your compromise

[sadeyeskevin]

carnifex son AILD has no fucking change

[sweepxcore]

YOUR ALL WRONG.

as i lay dying EASY

carnifex RIP OFF

[slipknot23589]

CARNIFEX!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­

[Fleischklops90]

Carnifex but AILD kicks ass too

[eatlemonz]

easy CARNIFEX

[MyWhiteAbode]

lol same much?

[joshbeau]

AILD

[Minipunk415]

As I lay dying pwns carnifex

[migmob27]

Carnifex is way more brutal, sorry, but when I'm fighting someone in a parking lot, I'll choose to play Carnifex on the stereo.

[Minipunk415]

Carnifex's sound isn't brutal, it's messy.

[willot747]

As i lay dying easily.

[axionfoo]

CARNIFEX!

obviously

[IllsOfModernMan]

Carnifex!

[rapotstoy]

Впечатление, что одна и та же песня ))

А вообще это попсовый проигрыш, где-то был ещё вроде. Или очень похожий.

[flipdeck1818]

AILD of course.